Councillors could have given support over proposed ward closure
Members of Cumberland Council's health overview and scrutiny committee were given a progress report from Cumbria, Northumbria, Tyne and Wear NHS Foundation Trust at Allerdale House in Workington on Thursday (July 18).
In October 2024 it was reported that North-East and North Cumbria Integrated Care Board (ICB) announced that it was considering closing an adult mental health ward.
Yewdale Ward, part of West Cumberland Hospital, was deemed too isolated from other mental health services and no longer fit for purpose, as it was a mixed sex ward.
Councillor Carni McCarron-Holmes (Maryport North, Labour) said the matter was brought before scrutiny too late and it would have been better if they had been 'kept in the loop' sooner. She added: 'I feel very sad about this and the community feels sad about this.'
She said she hoped the situation worked out for the best but added: 'Because I will coming back to you.'
Ramona Duguid, the chief operating officer with the trust, said there had not been a focus on mental health or disabilities and added: 'We do need to change that. We want to work together.'
Councillor Martin Harris (Dearham and Broughton, Labour) asked what demand there was on the service and James Duncan, the trust's chief executive, it was 16 at any one time and it had remained constant over the years.
He said that, if it was created as two wards, with eight male beds and eight female beds, it would be too difficult to staff.
Councillor Jeanette Forster (Hillcrest and Hensingham, Labour) said she was not convinced by the new Hope Haven facility, which is due to open later this year, but accepted that Yewdale was not fit for purpose. She added: 'We will just have to go with it and see how it pans out.'
Councillor John Mallinson (Houghton and Irthington, Conservative) said lessons had to be learned from what had happened but added that they would support the trust.
Cllr McCarron-Holmes proposed that they write to the ICB highlighting that they were not involved sooner and the whole process could have been handled better.
Councillor Helen Davison (Belah, Green Party) said it should be formalised with a letter and there should be proper engagement 'right from the start'.
When it was put to the vote members agreed that they should write a letter to the ICB raising their concerns.
According to the report in January 2025 the trust updated the committee on the position and next steps in relation to changes to service provision in west Cumbria. This included the development and investment in community and crisis services, Hope Haven, as well as the proposed changes to adult inpatient care, which had been subject to public engagement since November 2024.
In April 2025 the board of directors reviewed the final Strategic Case for Change and:
Approved that the engagement process completed on the proposals has been robust with the local community and staff;
Agreed the case for change proposal for the re-provision of services from Yewdale Ward to Carlton Clinic in Carlisle;
Agreed that further consultation on the proposals was not required.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
4 hours ago
- Forbes
The New Majority Of Students Spotlights Mental Health And Basic Needs
Basic Needs paper sign Many people think of college students as young adults living on campus and focused on developmental concerns, such as establishing new friends, feeling homesick, and academic pressure. Indeed, many campus support services are designed to fit these perceptions. For example, a 2024 report on outlined how many campus counseling centers were traditionally designed to treat developmental stress. However, because more students are now entering college with significant clinical concerns, new models of campus counseling are needed in the field of college mental health. Likewise, to better promote student wellbeing on a national scale, there needs to be a shift in the mainstream perceptions about who college students are and what their needs might be. The New Majority Of College Students According to a report last month on non-traditional students are the new majority of learners within higher education. Highlights from this report indicated that 40.2% of college students were older than 22, 39.1% had children, and 69.3% had jobs. Furthermore, a 2025 report by Inside Higher Ed outlined a national survey of student basic needs from 91 institutions across 16 states. This survey was conducted by The Hope Center for Student Basic Needs, which is a research action center that guides policies and helps colleges and universities address basic needs insecurities on campuses. The survey found that 59% of students experienced at least one form of basic need insecurity, such as food or housing, and that this number increased to 73% when the definition of basic needs included mental health care, childcare, transportation or internet and technology access. Dr. Sara Abelson is The Senior Director of Training and Education at The Hope Center and a faculty member at Temple University. According to Abelson, there's a significant association between mental health challenges and basic needs. She stated, 'It's important to acknowledge that mental health is also a basic need, and one that is impacted by other basic needs.' According to Abelson, many students who lack essential resources become stressed and anxious, which can trigger mental health challenges like depression. Conversely, mental health symptoms can hinder a student's abilities to secure basic needs. Basic Needs For The New Majority Of College Students Rising tuition costs pose significant challenges for many college students, but it's important to note that many schools cannot randomly decide how much tuition will cost. A 2015 report on outlined various factors that determine how much a school's tuition will cost. Some of these factors include annual changes in the general consumer price index, if the state collects sales or income taxes, instructional expenditures, and how much discretionary spending a state legislature has. Furthermore, many schools are making attempts to curb the rise in tuition costs. For example, according to another 2025 report by Inside Higher Ed, tuition discounts are at an all-time high amongst private schools. According to Abelson, many students in the new majority face multiple financial barriers. She said, 'It's not just the cost of college that is increasing but living costs across the board.' In addition to inflation, a 2025 report by outlined changes to federal funding support for college students. Furthermore, many non-traditional students have lingering financial and family obligations. As Abelson pointed out, 'They are working. They are caregiving. They are commuting. And far too many are struggling to afford food, housing, transportation, and mental health care while trying to graduate into a world increasingly stacked against them.' The Importance Of Addressing Students' Basic Needs Basic needs insecurities are related to poor academic outcomes, such as lower GPAs, credit achievement, completion rates, and retention rates. Some might argue that students should not enroll in college unless their basic needs are already met; however, Abelson argued that meeting students' basic needs benefits society because it reduces the number of individuals on public benefits and/or involved in the community health care system. She stated, 'Most students with college degrees also break cycles of poverty and become healthier residents.' Furthermore, Abelson argued that the infrastructure of higher education can improve the efficiency and utilization of established government assistance programs. She stated that many individuals who are eligible for public benefits do not know how to access services, but that college campuses can serve as navigation hubs, even for community members, to address this gap. In addition, she reported that informed policies, such as allowing college enrollment to meet the work requirements in public benefits programs, can increase the utilization of dedicated government funding. Abelson's comments were consistent with the report on which argued that the infrastructure of higher education can be a low-cost service delivery model for mental health in America. Colleges and universities can partner with The Hope Center to collect data and develop systematic ways to address basic need insecurities on their campuses. A 2025 report on The Hope Center's website outlined how these partnerships can work. Abelson argued that since many students face multiple types of basic needs insecurities, schools need to prioritize holistic approaches while addressing the mental health and basic needs of students. She commented, 'Mental health challenges do not exist in isolation; any solutions must address the close link between mental and behavioral health challenges and financial or material basic needs insecurity.'
CBS News
5 hours ago
- CBS News
Maryland therapist worries less LGTBQ+ youth will seek help with 988 changes in effect
It's been nearly two weeks since the 988 dedicated lifeline for LGBTQ+ youth discontinued, and a Maryland therapist is worried about the long-term impact this will have. When the Trump administration announced in June that the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline dedicated to these youth would end, advocates warned it would have life-threatening implications. It was better known as the Press 3 option. For at least one therapist, she said the impacts could lead to these youth hesitating to get help. The Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, or SAMHSA, said the 988's dedicated LGBTQ+ youth lifeline ended because the funding for it had been exhausted. The agency stressed these youth would still be able to get help if they still called 988. However, Xiomara Arrieta, a therapist with ThriveWorks, said she heard these youth feel like they're losing representation in this support. "Some people don't have that availability of people in the community who they can look up living their truth," Arrieta said. Arrieta adds that losing the lifeline takes away the ability for these youth to talk to someone who may fully understand their problems. "With the way gender is affirmed or not important for people to kind of come in and get it — as opposed to explaining the genre or how someone is presenting and why they are," Arrieta said. Earlier this month, WJZ reported local advocates were preparing to step up to fill the gap. One of them is the Pride Center of Maryland. Its CEO, Cleo Manago, said he wasn't surprised when he first heard about this lifeline ending. In response, Manago said they were bolstering youth programming and other suicide prevention resources, as well as creating a suicide warm line. "[A suicide warm line] means that there'll be live people to speak to about any suicide concerns or ideations [during traditional work hours]," Manago said. "For the rest of the time, there will be a recording that will alert people where they can call, where they can go." Behavioral Health System Baltimore stressed that the Central Maryland 988 helpline is still going to provide dedicated support for LGBTQ+ youth. The 988 Central Maryland helpline gets about 4,500 calls a month.
Washington Post
8 hours ago
- Washington Post
NIH cuts spotlight a hidden crisis facing patients with experimental brain implants
Carol Seeger finally escaped her debilitating depression with an experimental treatment that placed electrodes in her brain and a pacemaker-like device in her chest. But when its batteries stopped working, insurance wouldn't pay to fix the problem and she sank back into a dangerous darkness. She worried for her life, asking herself: 'Why am I putting myself through this?'
