Vatican Hardens Tone On Israel After Gaza Parish Strike
The strike killed three people in the Holy Family Church in the centre of Gaza City -- prompting condemnation by politicians and by religious leaders of various denominations.
Pope Leo XIV on Sunday slammed the "barbarity" of the war and the blind "use of force", denouncing "the attack by the Israeli army".
It was a change of language after two years of tireless, repetitive calls for peace by the Vatican under former Pope Francis, who died in April.
Francois Mabille, an analyst at France's Geopolitical Observatory of Religion, said the statements represent an increasingly critical view of Israel in the Catholic world.
Beyond growing anger worldwide at the human cost of the Gaza war, he cited "the fact that it's happening on holy ground."
It is leading to "at least a temporary shift in Catholic opinion in general," he told AFP.
On Friday, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called Pope Leo -- who became pontiff in May -- and said his country "deeply regrets" the strike, blaming a "stray missile" and vowing an investigation.
Netanyahu's spokesman said the conversation was "friendly" and that the two men agreed to meet soon.
But on the same day, in an interview with Italian broadcaster Rai 2, the Vatican's second-in-command -- Cardinal Pietro Parolin -- implied the strike may have been intentional.
He called on Israel to publicise the findings of its investigation to find out "if it really was an error, which we can legitimately doubt, or if there was a will to directly attack a Christian church."
The Vatican also sent the cardinal of Jerusalem, Pierbattista Pizzaballa, on a rare visit to Gaza Friday, where he visited the wounded and conducted a mass at the Holy Family Church.
The visit was meant to show that Catholic authorities were determined to stay in Gaza.
"We are not a target. They say it was a mistake, even if everyone here does not believe that is the case," the cardinal told Italian newspaper Corriere della Sera.
Mabille, the analyst, said the Holy See is now also using "more precise vocabulary based on legal categories."
On Sunday, the American-born pope called for the international community to "observe humanitarian law and respect the obligation to protect civilians, as well as the prohibition of collective punishment, the indiscriminate use of force, and the forced displacement of populations."
Mabille said that constituted four fundamental rights under humanitarian law that are being violated by Netanyahu's government.
Some Catholic officials are going much further.
In an interview to Italy's La Stampa newspaper, Cardinal Augusto Paolo Lojudice -- who also serves as a judge at a Vatican tribunal -- said Netanyahu is "not stopping because he is a tyrant pursuing a dark and bloodthirsty plan for power".
Lojudice -- who worked with Leo for several years before was made pope -- accused Israel of "evil without logic" in Gaza.
The Vatican, which since 2015 has recognised the state of Palestine, supports a two-state solution in Israel.
It has also called for a special international status for Jerusalem, with free and safe access to religious sites there.
Already strained ties with Israel degraded further after Israel launched its assault following Hamas's deadly October 7, 2023 attack.
Diverging from the Vatican's official line, Pope Francis questioned whether Israel's heavy handed military response amounted to "genocide" in Gaza.
The current tense diplomatic exchanges also come after a small Christian village in the central occupied West Bank was burnt down in early July and during heightened criticism of Israeli settler attacks. The Cardinal of Jerusalem, Pierbattista Pizzaballa, speaks to a victim of Israeli strikes during a visit to Gaza AFP The damaged facade of the Holy Family Church in Gaza after it was hit by an Israeli strike AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Int'l Business Times
an hour ago
- Int'l Business Times
Brazil Vows To Fight Trump Tariff 'Injustice'
Brazil vowed Thursday to combat US President Donald Trump's tariffs on its exports, saying it intends to lodge appeals if last-ditch negotiations fail. Finance Minister Fernando Haddad said the tariffs announced Wednesday were "more favorable" than expected, with several key export products exempted. Still, there "is a lot of injustice in the measures announced yesterday. Corrections need to be made," he told reporters. Citing a "witch hunt" against his far-right ally Jair Bolsonaro -- Brazil's former president on trial for allegedly plotting a coup -- Trump on Wednesday signed an executive order adding a 40 percent tariff on Brazilian products, bringing total trade duties to 50 percent. The levies affect coffee and meat, two products of which Brazil is the world's top exporter. The order, which takes effect on August 6, listed exemptions for nearly 700 other products including key exports such as planes, orange juice and pulp, Brazil nuts, and some iron, steel and aluminum products. Leftist President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva -- the man Bolsonaro is accused of having sought to topple -- has denounced the tariffs as an attack on the "sovereignty" of South America's largest economy. "The negotiation is not over; it starts today," Vice President Geraldo Alckmin, tapped to oversee talks with Washington, told TV Globo. Alckmin said the new tariff will apply to nearly 36 percent of Brazil's exports to the United States, equal to some $14.5 billion last year. Haddad said he would speak with his American counterpart, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, and "there will be a cycle of negotiations." He did not give a date. "We are starting from a point that is more favorable than one could have imagined, but still far from the finish line," the minister said. If negotiations fail, Haddad said Brasilia would "file appeals with the appropriate authorities, both in the United States and with international bodies." Trump's Brazil tariff is among the highest imposed on US trading partners. Unlike with other countries, the measures against Brazil have been framed in openly political terms, sweeping aside centuries-old trade ties and a surplus that Brasilia put at $284 million last year. "These are harsh measures that will have a real impact on important sectors of the Brazilian economy," Reginaldo Nogueira, an economist with Brazil's IBMEC business school, told AFP. "The exemptions help mitigate some of the pressure on Brazil but primarily protect strategic goods for the American economy," he added. Haddad said the Brazilian government would put in place protection measures for the most affected companies, and noted that "nothing that was decided yesterday cannot be reviewed." Trump's order was based on the Brazilian government's "politically motivated persecution, intimidation, harassment, censorship, and prosecution of (Bolsonaro) and thousands of his supporters," according to the White House. It also cited Brazil's "unusual and extraordinary policies and actions harming US companies, the free speech rights of US persons, US foreign policy, and the US economy," singling out Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes. Moraes is the judge presiding over Bolsonaro's coup trial and has clashed repeatedly with the far-right in Brazil, as well as with tech titan Elon Musk, over the spread of online misinformation. The US Treasury announced financial sanctions on Moraes Wednesday, saying he had "taken it upon himself to be judge and jury in an unlawful witch hunt against US and Brazilian citizens and companies." A Supreme Court source told AFP that Moraes "does not have assets in the United States" where the sanctions would have frozen them.
DW
4 hours ago
- DW
Middle East: Israel risks isolation, German FM says – DW – 07/31/2025
The German foreign minister called the situation in Gaza "beyond imagination" and said Israel needs to show it is not pursuing a policy of expulsion and annexation. Meanwhile, a US special envoy prepares to visit Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul said Thursday that Israel was in danger of becoming isolated, and Berlin was trying to prevent that from happening. "Israel must always find friends, partners and supporters in the international community," he said in Jerusalem. "And that is currently in danger in this situation. If there is one country that has a responsibility to prevent this, then in my view it is Germany." Wadephul also called the humanitarian situation in the Gaza Strip "beyond imagination" and said Israel needed to show it was not enacting a policy of "expulsion" and "annexation" in the Palestinian territory. He also said Israel had a responsibility to allow humanitarian and medical aid into Gaza "quickly, safely and sufficiently to avert mass deaths." Wadephul's comments came after arriving in Israel as part of a two-day trip that will also see him visit the Israeli-occupied West Bank. US Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee and Donald Trump's special envoy Steve Witkoff will inspect an aid distribution center in Gaza on Friday, according to White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt. "Tomorrow, special envoy Witkoff and Ambassador Huckabee will be traveling into Gaza to inspect the current distribution sites and secure a plan to deliver more food, and meet with local Gazans to hear firsthand about this dire situation on the ground," she told reporters in a Thursday briefing. While international politicians often travel to Israel and the occupied West Bank, trips to Gaza are far less frequent. The visit comes after the Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry said 111 Palestinians had died in the territory over the past 24 hours, including 91 people who were seeking aid. Israel said Thursday it had conducted strikes in Lebanon on key Hezbollah infrastructure, where the militant group manufactured and stored missiles. Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz said targets included "Hezbollah's biggest precision missile manufacturing site," and the military said it struck "infrastructure that was used for producing and storing strategic weapons" in the Bekaa Valley in the east of the country, and the south. "Any attempt by the terrorist organization to recover, reestablish or threaten will be met with relentless intensity," Katz added. Lebanon's state-run National News Agency also reported strikes in the Bekaa Valley and the south of the country. Both Katz and the Israeli military said Hezbollah was trying to rebuild its military infrastructure and demanded that the Lebanese army move to disarm the militant group. Earlier on Thursday, Lebanese President Joseph Aoun said that his country was determined to disarm Iran-backed Hezbollah. The United States and more than a dozen of its allies on Thursday said Iran has been trying to murder and kidnap dissidents, journalists and officials in Western countries. "We are united in our opposition to the attempts of Iranian intelligence services to kill, kidnap, and harass people in Europe and North America in clear violation of our sovereignty," the governments of Albania, Austria, Belgium, Canada, the Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Spain, Sweden, the UK and the US said in a statement. The countries said such activities were being carried out in collaboration with international criminal networks. London has said it has halted more than 20 Iranian-linked plots to kidnap or kill individuals in Britain, including UK nationals and others Iran views as threats since early 2022. In October, the Reuters news agency reported that Iran was behind a wave of efforts to assassinate and abduct individuals across Europe and the United States. In March, the UK government said it wanted the Iranian state to register all political influence activities, citing increasingly aggressive behavior by Iran's intelligence services. In a post on the social media platform X, far-right Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir has accused the German government of supporting Nazism. Without providing further context, the right-wing firebrand posted, "80 years after the Holocaust, and Germany is returning to support Nazism." The post was published as German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul landed in Israel for talks with Foreign Minister Gideon Saar, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and President Isaac Herzog. Wadephul said his trip would focus on ensuring that more humanitarian aid reaches people in the Gaza Strip as well as to further iterate German support for a two-state solution to the ongoing conflict. Wadephul has said recognition of a Palestinian state would be the logical end of the process. A key member of Netanyahu's coalition government, Ben-Gvir has said he would leave the government if Israel stops the war in Gaza and has come out in favor of the displacement of Palestinians and expanding Israeli settlements to Gaza. The UK, Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Norway and the Netherlands have imposed sanctions against Ben-Gvir. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video US special envoy Steve Witkoff has arrived in Israel, where he met with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Israeli media reported the meeting would focus on the humanitarian crisis in Gaza and Israeli hostages held by militants, and relations with Iran. The Ynet news portal reported that Witkoff may visit the Gaza Strip, saying he would like to personally look at the work being done by the US and Israeli-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF). There have been reports of Palestinians being killed while lining up for food at GHF distribution sites. The GHF's role in distributing aid has been criticized by several aid organizations, with Amnesty International describing its operations as "illegitimate and inhumane." The United States is imposing sanctions on Palestinian Authority officials and members of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO). The State Department said in a statement that the groups are undermining peace efforts. "It is in our national security interests to impose consequences and hold the PLO and PA accountable for not complying with their commitments and undermining the prospects for peace," the State Department said. The statement did not specify who was being targeted or no longer able to receive visas to travel to the United States. The State Department wrote that the Palestinian Authority is "taking actions to internationalize its conflict with Israel such as through the International Criminal Court (ICC) and International Court of Justice (ICJ)," and accused them of "continuing to support terrorism." The Palestinian Authority is the governing body that has overseen parts of Israeli-occupied West Bank since the 1990s. An open letter signed by over 200 actors, musicians and media personalities has urged German Chancellor Friedrich Merz to take action in response to the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. They acknowledge Merz's increased criticism of the Israeli government in recent days, but urge him to go further, writing "words alone won't save lives." The letter, organized by the group Avaaz, addresses children suffering in Gaza, saying: "More than 17,000 have already been killed. Hundreds of thousands are injured, traumatized, displaced and starving." The signatories urged Merz to stop arms exports to Israel, to support the suspension of the EU-Israel Association Agreement and to demand an immediate ceasefire and access for humanitarian aid. "We too condemn the horrific crimes committed by Hamas in the strongest possible terms. But no crime justifies collectively punishing millions of innocent people in the most brutal manner," the letter states. Actors Daniel Brühl and Heike Makatsch and singers Shirin David and Zartmann are among the stars who have signed the letter. "These steps are deeply in line with European values and would make it unmistakably clear to the Israeli government that even its closest allies can no longer accept the suffering, and that words are not enough," the letter said. Germany approved €326.5 million ($374 million) in arms exports to Israel in 2023, a sharp increase from previous years. In 2024, approvals fell by half amid mounting legal and political pressure. Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul has departed for Israel and the Palestinian territories to hold talks on the worsening situation in Gaza. In a statement ahead of his departure, Wadephul said the trip aims to address the deepening humanitarian crisis in the Gaza Strip, the ongoing threat from Hamas and growing international pressure on Israel. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video "Hamas continues to hold hostages, including German citizens, and is still refusing a ceasefire," Wadephul said. "At the same time, the suffering and deaths in Gaza have reached an unimaginable scale." The German top diplomat called for additional humanitarian aid for people in Gaza. "Only by land can sufficient quantities of aid reach the people," Wadephul said. "I, therefore, urge the Israeli government to allow the UN and international aid organizations safe access and, above all, safe and effective distribution." Wadephul also pointed to increasing international isolation for Israel, citing the recent UN conference in New York and noting that more countries, including some in Europe, are considering recognizing a Palestinian state without waiting for a negotiated peace process. He said the region is at a crossroads, and that Germany, because of its historic responsibility toward Israel, cannot remain passive. As famine-like conditions take hold in Gaza, human rights organizations have criticized plans by Germany and other countries to drop aid in via airlifts. They say this is symbolic politics and inefficient. Read the full story on the criticism levelled at plans to airdrop aid into Gaza. A German delegation, led by Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul is headed to Israel and the occupied West Bank on Thursday for talks with representatives from the Israeli government and the UN. The two-day trip is expected to focus on the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, with Wadephul saying he would push for a ceasefire. "The main goal is definitely a ceasefire," Wadephul told Politico. As for humanitarian aid, he said "the number of victims in the Gaza Strip is too high. We need to ease the suffering of the people there." The visit comes amid increasing international pressure on Israel to end its war, with more and more Western countries pledging to recognize Palestinian statehood. Germany, however, has said it has no short-term plans to recognize a Palestinian state, despite being committed to a two-state solution. Siemtje Möller, the deputy parliamentary leader of the Social Democrats (SPD), is also part of the delegation. The SPD governs in coalition with Wadephul's center-right CDU. In an interview with public broadcaster ARD on Thursday morning, Möller called for "real pressure" to end the suffering in Gaza. She also suggested that Germany could consider recognizing a Palestinian state sooner than expected. "The recognition of a Palestinian state is not a taboo and doesn't necessarily have to come at the end of a [two-state] process," she said before the flight. US special envoy Steve Witkoff is scheduled to leave for Israel as the US looks to address the worsening starvation crisis in Gaza, according to US media reports. The trip comes in the midst of stalled truce talks between Israel and Palestine's Hamas militant group. Witkoff said last week that the US had withdrawn its negotiating delegation from Qatar over what he called a lack of willingness by Hamas to reach a ceasefire. Israel has also pulled its team from the talks. The US, Qatar and Egypt are mediating between Israel and Hamas, who do not talk directly. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video US President Donald Trump has threatened Canada with repercussions for negotiations on a trade deal after it announced its plans to recognize Palestinian statehood. "Wow! Canada has just announced that it is backing statehood for Palestine. That will make it very hard for us to make a Trade Deal with them," Trump said on Truth Social, his social media platform. Trump's statement is set to intensify a trade war between US and Canada, just a day ahead of the August 1 deadline to seal a tariff agreement. If the two countries fail to strike an agreement by the deadline, Canada faces a 35% tariff on goods which are not covered under the US-Mexico-Canada trade pact. On Wednesday, Canada's Prime Minister Mark Carney announced the possibility of recognizing a Palestinian state at the upcoming United Nations General Assembly, scheduled for September. The UK and France have also said over the last week that they would support statehood for Palestine. Canada has joined Britain and France to say that it "intends" to recognize a Palestinian state in September. However, Canada's decision has resulted in threats from US President Donald Trump as a deadline for a trade agreement between the two countries nears. Trump has said that Canada's support for Palestinian statehood would make it difficult for the US to zero-in on an agreement with Canada. Canada will be hit with a 35% tariff on its exports to the US if a deal cannot be reached, the president said. Also, US special envoy Steve Witkoff will reportedly travel to Israel on Thursday in light of the deteriorating humanitarian situation in the Gaza Strip. Stay up-to-date with this blog as we bring you the latest reports, analyses, and explainers on the situation in Gaza.
DW
7 hours ago
- DW
Will Australia's youth social media ban work? – DW – 07/31/2025
Australia will impose a social media blackout for children under 16 to tackle the growing mental health crisis among young people. But will the ban be effective? When Australia's government decided to implement a world-first national youth social media ban, it was pitched as an antidote to a growing mental health crisis. It followed intense debate about the dangers of social media, much articulated in the book, "The Anxious Generation," by Jonathan Haidt. The American social psychologist argues that smartphone-based childhoods and social media are helping to fuel an epidemic of mental illness among teenagers. As the ban was passed in the Australian Parliament in November 2024, one poll revealed overwhelming support among 77% of Australians. The plan to fine TikTok, Facebook, Snapchat, Reddit, X, Instagram and now YouTube, 49.5 million Australian dollars (€27.7 million, $32.3 million) for failing to block young people was supported by 87% of those surveyed. Underage social media users and their parents will not be punished for any violations under the law. Social media companies, including Elon Musk's X, were predictably unimpressed with a ban that many concede will also be difficult to police. "It's entirely likely the ban could see young people pushed to darker corners of the internet where no community guidelines, safety tools, or protections exist," said a TikTok spokesperson when the bill was passed. The Australian social media ban partly seeks to protect young people from the cyberbullying, disinformation and illegal content that has riddled social media platforms. But some experts doubt whether prohibition is an antidote to deteriorating youth mental health. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Marilyn Campbell, a professor in the School of Early Childhood and Inclusive Education at the Queensland University of Technology who writes on cyberbullying, warns that little research establishes a "causal" connection between social media and psychological health. "We know that there's a high correlation between the rise of new technologies and the increase in young people's poorer mental health," she said. "But we don't even know why yet." One 2023 study sampling social media use in 72 countries found "no evidence suggesting that the global penetration of social media is associated with widespread psychological harm." Campbell noted that though populist psychology works like "The Anxious Generation" merely draw a correlation between rising youth anxiety and depression and social media use, they have been heavily hyped in the media. Building on the popularity of these ideas, the government is now pursuing a "nice, simple solution," she told DW. "You don't have to spend any money on it," she said of the ban. "It's not complicated." Researchers at the University of Queensland note that the limited understanding of how social media impacts young people's mental health means that other influences need to be considered, such as rising "social inequity," "climate anxiety" and "gendered violence." Campbell suggested that instead of focusing on social media, governments need to "reform the mental health system," adding that "many more school counselors and school psychologists" would help. "There are lots of things that they could do but that cost money," she added. The Australian government continues to conflate social media use and the psychological struggles of young people. "We know that social media is doing social harm, and my government and this parliament is prepared to take action to protect young Australians," said Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese on Wednesday when announcing that YouTube would be added to the list of banned platforms after initially being excluded. But social media can also be positive for young people, said Campbell. Writing for magazine in January, she noted that young people with autism or who are "exploring their sexual and gender identity" can sometimes more easily identify with peers online than in their physical locality. She added that, like the prohibition of alcohol in the US, a ban just forces the problem underground. Youth also need to be prepared to live in a "technologically-saturated world," the professor told DW. "We are not doing them any favors by saying, well, you can't be in this world until you're 16." To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video The Australian ban will not come into effect until this December. Trials are underway to address the complex task of enforcing the social media blackout. Platforms won't be allowed to compel users to provide government-issued ID or digital identification but must provide "alternative age assurance methods" to confirm the age of social media account holders. One recent study showed that some 80% of people surveyed are concerned about the accuracy of age assurance technologies and potential data privacy breaches. Some 77% of German respondents to a 2024 poll also said they would either "fully" or "somewhat" support an Australia-like social media ban. An even higher percentage, 82%, were "absolutely certain" or "somewhat certain" that social media use is in some way bad for children and teenagers. Several US states are also limiting access to social media, including ensuring greater parental guidance over social media usage. For decades, the US has required tech companies to seek parental consent to access the data of users under 13. Sweden too is looking to ban access to smartphones in schools due to worries about a decline in both mental and physical health. In 2024, US Surgeon General Vivek Murthy suggested that warning labels be added to social media platforms, similar to those on cigarettes and alcohol. This came after a Surgeon General report found some positives with social media use such as "community and connection with others who share identities, abilities and interests," but also "symptoms of depression and anxiety" among adolescents spending 3-plus hours a day on social platforms. Marilyn Campbell reiterated that social media apps should not be banned, but designed to encourage safer interaction with young people. "I think that children need to be educated to live in the digital world," she said.
