Why some think the new ‘Superman' movie is about the war in Gaza
An amateur film critic named Evan gave the new 'Superman' movie five out of five stars. Writing on the Letterboxd platform, they praised the film's 'unique visual identity' and called director and screenwriter James Gunn 'the best comic director.' And they added, 'Very anti-Israel, which is awesome to see from a major studio blockbuster.'
When Evan's capsule review was shared by at least one user on X, it garnered more than 11 million views and 36,000 likes.
Evan isn't the only one to suggest that the new blockbuster carries an implicit — or even explicit — anti-Israel message. Social media has been buzzing with theories that one of the film's major plot points — Superman's mission to stop an invasion of a fictional impoverished country named Jahranpur by the US-backed 'Boravia' — is an allegory for the Israel-Hamas War.
'Feels like a major cultural moment that Israel is quite clearly the bad guy villain country in a big budget Hollywood movie,' wrote the political commentator and frequent Israel critic Krystal Ball on X. 'Going in, I thought it was subtle, but it was not subtle at all.' Such messages were amplified in Arab and progressive media.
On Reddit, some supporters of Israel are critical of Gunn and DC Studios for seeding the film with an anti-Israel message. 'I find it so disrespectful and distressing that a superhero created by two Jewish artists, is now being used to promote anti-Israeli messages to the world,' wrote a poster on r/Israel, a 'subreddit' for supporters of Israel. What followed was a lengthy discussion of Gunn's intentions and whether the film's alleged pro-Palestinian bias is only in the eyes of the beholder.
Gunn has flatly denied that the film is a commentary on Israel or the Palestinians. 'When I wrote this, the Middle Eastern conflict wasn't happening. So I tried to do little things to move it away from that, but it doesn't have anything to do with the Middle East,' Gunn told Comicbook.com.
Gunn said the movie depicts an 'invasion by a much more powerful country run by a despot into a country that's problematic in terms of its political history, but has totally no defense against the other country. It really is fictional.'
Of course, no audience member needs a director's, or anyone else's, permission to interpret a film as they choose. And while the film is hardly a political screed, it has enough politics to keep such debates going. The villain, Lex Luthor, is an Elon Musk-style billionaire and military contractor who hopes to create a sort of technological paradise on the rubble of Jahranpur. Superman, who famously arrived on Earth as a child from the planet Krypton, speaks up for immigrants of all types, including a falafel vendor named Malik Ali who helps Superman during his duel with a pro-Boravian supervillain, which has also been seized upon as evidence that the film is pro-Palestinian.
Boravia itself is clearly depicted as a Slavic country, with its wild-haired leader and his minions speaking in Russian. That might invite comparisons to Russia's invasion of Ukraine, except for reports suggesting that the producers sought to cast 'Middle Easterners' and Southeast Asians as the Jahranpurians. The clash between the two countries — the invaders armed to the teeth, the defenders wielding pitchforks and shovels — is unmistakably a war between a Caucasian West and a brown-skinned East. That suggests to some that the Israeli-Palestinian comparison was intentional, although you could also see a director thinking a clash between white and brown worlds might have more emotional resonance and on-screen coherence than a battle between similar-looking Slavs, and would certainly be more relevant during the George Floyd era in which the script was apparently written.
The climactic battle, when Boravian tanks and troops smash through a fence into a huge crowd of Jahranpurians, does not look like the Israel-Hamas War — or at least the urban war of the past two years. Instead, I was reminded of the 2018–2019 Gaza border protests, when Gazans held weekly demonstrations at the no-man's-land between Israel and Gaza. Those clashes often turned violent; Israel responded with force, claiming that Hamas was using the demonstrations as a cover for attacks on Israel.
'Superman' wouldn't be the first film to provoke outrage — and glee — over what may be unintentional messages. A number of films in recent years have used what many viewers saw as antisemitic tropes, for example: the goblin bankers in the 'Harry Potter' movies, the villain in the Smurfs movies who torments the blue-skinned protagonists, Danny DeVito's Penguin character in 1992's 'Batman Returns.'
There was no evidence that the creators of these movies intended such echoes, but that doesn't mean they don't exist: Pop culture is a constant churn of tropes and archetypes, often drawn from familiar narratives — biblical themes, Homeric epics, Arthurian legend. Superman himself, the creation of Jewish partners Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, is a recapitulation of the Moses story: a gifted child sent by his parents to safety in an alien land, where he becomes a hero. The creators even gave him a Kryptonian name — Kal-El — that not only sounds Hebrew but could be translated as 'God's voice.'
'Superman' the movie leans heavily into the idea, as old as David and Goliath, of a weaker neighbor fending off a powerful foe. If it were made 50 years ago, audiences would no doubt have seen parallels with the Vietnam War, or any of a number of post-colonial struggles. And it is not as if the United States hasn't backed despots, from El Salvador to Nicaragua to the Philippines.
For many viewers, the Israel-Hamas War fits neatly into that paradigm, even as Israel's supporters fiercely deny it. Israel, after all, was invaded by Hamas, not the other way around, while it is Israel that stands isolated among countries that have longed for its destruction. In 'Superman,' the United States appears to back Boravia in part to sell and test sophisticated weapons devised by Luthor, a stand-in for the military-industrial complex; in real life, say Israel's supporters, the United States is Israel's closest friend out of shared democratic values.
'Superman' has gotten mostly positive reviews, in part because it weds the sensibility of Saturday-morning cartoons to some bigger ideas about power and populist politics. I understand why supporters of the Palestinians have enlisted the movie in their cause, and why supporters of Israel resent the comparison or even having to think about the war while watching an escapist summer blockbuster. But if it is any consolation — and I am not sure it is — the real-life war won't be settled in social media threads or by men in tights, but through the actions and decisions of soldiers, politicians, and the people they represent.
The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of JTA or its parent company, 70 Faces Media.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Hill
9 minutes ago
- The Hill
As Hollywood taps into American empathy, conservatives call it a sin
'Superman' isn't the only summer film I've been looking forward to. ' Freakier Friday ' hits theaters on Aug. 8 and I can't wait — and not only because I'm expecting it to be a lot of fun, but because I think our country needs a dose of good-hearted humor, the same way we needed Superman reaffirming the values of 'truth, justice and the American way.' 'Freakier Friday' is a sequel to ' Freaky Friday,' which came out 22 years ago, during President George W. Bush's first term. Honestly, that feels like a lifetime ago. Come to think of it, it's more than half a lifetime ago for me. If you haven't seen 'Freaky Friday,' you should. Jamie Lee Curtis and Lindsay Lohan were brilliant, and it's exciting that they're both back in the movie's starring roles, along with most of the original cast. Fantasy comedy movies, like superhero movies, are about delivering good times, not political messages. At the same time, movies and television shows and other kinds of storytelling succeed by tapping into common experiences and our shared hopes and aspirations. The best of them can make us think and laugh at the same time. That was the genius of shows like ' All in the Family,' created by my organization's founder, Norman Lear. 'Freaky Friday' was essentially about empathy — seeing the world through someone else's eyes in order to better understand their thoughts, feelings and actions. In this case, it was about a mother and teenage daughter who were often at odds before a bit of mystical magic swapped their identities and bodies, literally forcing them to experience the world as the other does. The movie succeeded in being both funny and thought-provoking, silly and moving on a basic human level. In promotional materials for 'Freakier Friday,' Curtis and Lohan tell us that the identity swaps and complications in the new movie are even more complicated — freakier all the way around. That feels appropriate, because things in our country are certainly freakier now than they were 22 years ago — and not in a good or fun way. It's impossible to say what aspect of President Donald Trump's MAGA movement is most horrific, but it could very well be its hostility to empathy. The policies of the Trump administration require the systemic suppression of empathy. How else could you support taking health care away from people who are barely making ends meet so you can shovel more money into the bulging pockets of billionaires? How else could you be so delighted about brutally abducting people who have raised families and contributed to their communities for decades that you turn the operations into music videos? How else would you take such joy in the hopelessness of people kidnapped and sent to concentration camps that you pose for photos and sell merchandise celebrating their suffering? It's disturbing to me as a Christian that so many conservative Christians, who make up a big part of Trump's base, are along for the ride. I understand that people have widely differing interpretations of how their faith informs their political opinions. I understand that people of integrity can disagree on what policies will create the best outcomes. What I don't understand is how so many Christians in the MAGA movement not only accept the Trump administration's cruelty as a necessary evil, but seem to actually revel in it. I imagine that many Americans instinctively feel revulsion when witnessing official lawlessness and brutality. They feel empathy for the suffering of struggling and disrupted families. In other words, they feel empathy. That's not useful to Team Trump, so they tell their followers to reject those empathetic impulses. That's how we get the sickening spectacle of right-wing influencers warning against ' toxic empathy ' and MAGA-minded preachers declaring that empathy is a 'sin ' — a sin! That's a hard sell for this Christian. I see empathy at the core of the golden rule, and of the commandment to love our neighbors as we love ourselves. I love the reaction I've seen appear on church message boards and hand-drawn protest signs: 'If empathy is a sin, sin boldly.' That's the kind of joyful defiance we need more of these dispiriting days. We also need humor and good company to keep us going. That's why I'm looking forward to laughing along with a crowd watching Freakier Friday. See you in the theater.


Gizmodo
9 minutes ago
- Gizmodo
‘Fantastic Four' Steps Toward a Solid Box Office Start
Fantastic Four: First Steps came to a theater near you this weekend, and its opening numbers are looking good. Per the Hollywood Reporter, Marvel's latest earned $218 million worldwide in its first three days. While it's slightly behind expectations and the similarly solid $220 million global opening of Superman two weeks prior, this is already more than the 2015 Fantastic movie made in its theatrical run. Of its current take, $118 million came from domestic audiences, where it outperformed initial projections. According to THR, this has been one of Marvel's best domestic openings in years. Of the three MCU movies hitting in 2025, Fantastic Four had some of the biggest momentum behind it. Not only is it the first movie starring these characters since the aforementioned 2015 film, it's distinctly different from previous MCU movies as the first to take place entirely in a separate universe. Add onto that its collective star power and glowing pre-release impressions, and it seems to have generally stuck the landing with critics and audiences alike. Meanwhile, Superman's totals increased to $502.7 million this weekend, making another $44.7 million between domestic and international markets. Jurassic World Rebirth is now at $718.4 million after making an additional $13 million in North America. Previous World movies have made a lot of money and been some of the best-grossing films of their respective years, and it looks like Rebirth will be keeping that tradition alive. Genre-wise, next weekend is free, though Paramount's been putting a lot of weight behind its Naked Gun reboot starring Liam Neeson. (Which you might've gotten a trailer or ad for ahead of Fantastic Four.) The following week on August 8 sees two family movies, albeit in different forms: on one end is the nostalgia sequel Freakier Friday, and on the opposite end is Weapons, a horror movie about missing kids. Maybe one of those can pair with Fantastic as well as Superman does? Want more io9 news? Check out when to expect the latest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what's next for the DC Universe on film and TV, and everything you need to know about the future of Doctor Who.


Newsweek
2 hours ago
- Newsweek
Fortnite Super Showdown Live Event Announced – When and How to Play
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Entertainment gossip and news from Newsweek's network of contributors Fortnite's latest Live Event has been announced for this weekend as Chapter 6 Season 3 reaches its final week. Live Events are story events in Fortnite that run for a very limited time. During this time, you can log into Fortnite to play an exclusive event that expounds on the plot of the current season, which right now is all about Superheroes. With Superman and Robin at the forefront alongside a host of original superhero characters, this Live Event will see them taking on a strange threat, likely unleashed by the villain of this season, Daigo – another original Fortnite character. As for what you'll get to do in the event remains to be seen, but these frequently have unique game mechanics to offer. Superman hovering over a battlefield littered with superheroes looking up at something shadowing over them from off-screen. Superman hovering over a battlefield littered with superheroes looking up at something shadowing over them from off-screen. Epic Games The event is set to start on August 2, 2025 at 2:30pm ET/11:30am PT/7:30pm BST. To join in with this event, all you need to do is log into Fortnite and join the game shortly before the start time. Entry for the event is set to start at 2pm ET/11am PT/7pm BST, so you'll have plenty of time to get a spot to experience the event first-hand. These events normally make big changes to the Fortnite map, which is why it's interesting that this season still has one week left following the event, as the season is scheduled to end on August 7. Whether this turns out to just be part one of a two-part event or something special will occur remains to be seen, but if you want to find out, you'll have to be there.