
Movie Review: Nostalgia and gore collide in the new ‘I Know What You Did Last Summer'
'It's 1997 all over again. It's so nostalgic,' says
Freddie Prinze Jr.,
who stars in both, this time around. Responds another returning star,
Jennifer Love Hewitt:
'Nostalgia is overrated.'
That line deserves a big laugh from a so-called 'legacy sequel' that blends old and new to resurrect a franchise long dormant but isn't sure where it sits in 2025. A wink here, an eye-gouging there.
By aping the structure of the original — maddeningly calling itself by its predecessor's name — the new version of 'I Know What You Did Last Summer' is both too tentative a step forward and yet too reliant on the past to fully break free of that gravitational pull.
The new installment follows a group of post-high school friends (Madelyn Cline, Chase Sui Wonders, Jonah Hauer-King, Sarah Pidgeon and Tyriq Withers) who cause a fatal car wreck on July Fourth and swear to keep their involvement a secret. But a year later, someone wants them dead, offering the anniversary warning: 'I know what you did last summer.'
This is a franchise that got a bit lost in the shadow of the
'Scream' dynasty
, but still helped make household names of such Gen X heroes as Prinze, Hewitt,
Sarah Michelle Gellar
and Ryan Phillippe. A relaunch makes sense but it's pretty vapid stuff until the OGs arrive.
In fact, you may find yourself rooting for the killer. The five youngsters who have grown up in Southport, North Carolina — 'the Hamptons of the South' — mostly live lives of nepo privilege, drinking from flasks, driving Volvos, munching on macarons and taking Adderall. One lives on a 156-foot (48-meter) yacht with three decks.
The movie mostly muddles along like a TV special, only coming to life when Prinze and Hewitt arrive, asked by the hunted youngsters for guidance. After all, the duo survived the 1997 attacks. 'Get them before they get you,' Hewitt's Julie advises.
Director Jennifer Kaytin Robinson, who co-wrote the screenplay with Sam Lansky, mixes gruesome stabbings, harpoon impalings and corpses displayed on hooks like fish at the dock with jokes that needle everything from Nicole Kidman's cheesy AMC commercials to our fling with true-crime podcasts.
The filmmakers make half-hearted attempts to explain the ripple effects from trauma but we're not here for generational pain; we're here for the slashy-slashy. There is one dream sequence with a surprise returning OG that's worth the ticket price alone.
The tone is all over the place — whimpering victims one moment, horny the next. The police in Southport are nefarious — in a nod to
'Jaws,'
they cover up the murders for fear of turning off tourism — but there's a 'Scooby-Doo' vibe here (even a mention) that seems less playful than idea-deprived. There are elements of spoof, too, like a vain woman who has just lost someone close in a grisly bloodbath but worries about her skin care.
Look, we hate to break it to you, it's not going to end well for many of this privileged set, as they hunt whoever is hunting them. Coherence is also stabbed a lot because a clear motive for the mass murder is really hard to understand.
No matter: We get the scene when a scared victim with a massive knife sticking out of her back shoots a harpoon gun at the hook killer, and that's why we came in the first place. We also get Hewitt screaming her catchphrase, mocking her attacker: 'What are you waiting for?' Well, what are you waiting for?
'I Know What You Did Last Summer,' a Sony Pictures release in theaters Friday, is rated R for 'bloody horror violence, language throughout, some sexual content and brief drug use.' Running time: 111 minutes. One and a half stars out of four.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Fox News
12 hours ago
- Fox News
Freddie Prinze Jr. reveals the secret behind his 23-year marriage with Sarah Michelle Gellar
Freddie Prinze Jr. reflected on the secret behind his 23-year marriage to actress Sarah Michelle Gellar. During a recent interview with Variety, the 49-year-old actor candidly opened up about how he and Gellar, 48, have kept their relationship strong in Hollywood. "Marriage is hard no matter what business you're in," the "She's All That" star said. "What works for us might not work for everyone else." He continued, "We work at it. I'm not perfect. She's not perfect. We piss each other off, but we respect one another. We were friends first." "Maybe that's the secret? It wasn't just "Oh, she's hot, he's hot — let's hook up," he added. "But I know people who've done it the other way, and their relationships are just as strong as mine." Gellar and Prinze Jr. first met while filming the hit 1997 horror movie "I Know What You Did Last Summer." However, sparks didn't immediately fly between the two. In a 2001 interview with People, Prinze Jr. admitted that the future couple "really didn't dig each other" at first. "Then one day I gave her a ride to the gym," he said. "We talked on the way up, and she was a cool chick." The pair became friends, but their relationship didn't turn romantic until three years later. During a joint interview with People Now in 2020, Gellar and Prinze Jr. explained how they accidentally went on a first date. "We were friends for a very long time. We'd had many dinners before. And we were supposed to go with someone else, and the third person didn't make it out and we decided to still go," the "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" alum recalled. "We were just two people at dinner catching up," Gellar continued. "We had a long car ride and a long dinner and things just happened." Prinze Jr. told the outlet that he completely lost interest in seeing other women after his first date with Gellar. "I didn't go on dates with other girls, nor did I even want to pursue dates with other girls," he said. The couple announced their engagement in 2001 and tied the knot a year later in Mexico when Gellar was 24 and Prinze was 26. Prinze Jr. and Gellar, who also co-starred in 2002's "Scooby-Doo" and the 2004 sequel "Scooby-Doo: Monsters Unleashed," welcomed their first child, daughter Charlotte Grace, in 2009. In 2012, Gellar gave birth to their son, Rocky James. While speaking with Variety, Prinze Jr. explained how he treasured his family life with Gellar and their children. "I just love my kids," he said. "My daughter is away for the summer, and I hate it. I like hanging out with my son — he's really funny. I love my wife, man. I married her for a reason." During a December 2024 interview with Fox News Digital, Gellar weighed in on the key to an enduring union. She also expressed her view that changes in societal values had led to the decline of long-lasting relationships. "I think everything takes work in you, whether it's a friendship or a work relationship or a marriage," the "Dexter: Original Sin" star said. "You have to put the work in," she continued. "And we live in an extremely disposable society now." "Your phone breaks, you don't fix it. You get a new one," Gellar added. "And I think that's a lot of the attitude toward relationships." "And I don't know, maybe separate bathrooms," the actress joked. Prinze Jr. is currently starring in the 2025 version of "I Know What You Did Last Summer," which was released on Friday. The actor reprised his role as Ray Bronson in the legacy sequel to the first movie in the four-part franchise. The couple's former co-star Jennifer Love Hewitt also returned to play the original film's protagonist, Julie James. Hewitt and Prinze Jr. previously reunited in the 1998 sequel "I Still Know What You Did Last Summer." Gellar, whose character Helen Shivers was killed off in the first film, made a cameo appearance in the new installment during a dream sequence. "I Know What You Did Last Summer" was released on June 18.


Buzz Feed
12 hours ago
- Buzz Feed
Gen Z Is Being Weird About Answering The Phone, And Other Things The Internet Talked About This Week
What you're about to read is an issue of the Only Good Internet newsletter, which brings you the funniest, weirdest, and most interesting content from around the internet, no doomscrolling required. Subscribe here and you'll get the web's best stuff in your inbox every week! BuzzFeed Welcome to Only Good Internet, where I give you a little bit of good internet content, as a treat. I want to talk to my fellow millennials for a bit, here (Gen X, you too). Because I came across this tweet this week: …That Gen Z answers the phone and doesn't say anything. Apparently, this is a thing: Zoomers will answer the phone and, instead of saying 'hello,' they'll wait there silently for the person calling to speak first. Now, as a millennial, my first thought was, 'What the f***?' But after reading some replies from Gen Z, it started to make more sense…a lot of them are concerned about spam calls (which, let's be honest, are like 90% of the calls we get these days) and how the bot on the other end is waiting for you to say 'hello' so that it knows there's a real person at this phone number, and it can therefore keep spam-calling you. There were also some concerns from Zoomers about AI stealing your voice with these calls and using it to scam your relatives. Obviously, the only way to fight back is to use a voice changer — you know, like in Scream — to answer your calls. Throw off the bots, terrify your friends, win-win. This is the cutest dang thing I've seen in a while: 'Sir, there's a situation on platform 2!' 'Don't tell me…' u/liberty4now / Via 'Yes, sir, it's a Level 5.' I always like to finish every week by leaving you with a little something that I can't get out of my head. This week, it's all about this thought:


Forbes
13 hours ago
- Forbes
Why ‘Summer I Turned Pretty' Star Was Cut From ‘I Know What You Did Last Summer'
NEW YORK, NEW YORK - JULY 16: Lola Tung attends "The Summer I Turned Pretty" Season 3 New York ... More Launch Event at Refinery Rooftop on July 16, 2025 in New York City. (Photo by) The director of I Know What You Did Last Summer is explaining why The Summer I Turned Pretty star Lola Tung and Nicholas Alexander Chavez of Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story didn't make the final cut of the film. Starring Madelyn Cline, Freddie Prinze Jr. and Jennifer Love Hewitt, I Know What You Did Last Summer is a legacy sequel set nearly 30 years after the 1997 hit slasher movie of the same name. In the film, a group of friends responsible for the accidental death of a motorist covers up the crime, only to be haunted by a demented fisherman wearing a slicker and wielding a giant hook. Tung and Chavez were cast in supporting roles in I Know What You Did Last Summer, which was released in theaters on July 18, but didn't appear in the film's final cut. In a recent interview with People, I Know What You Did Last Summer director Jennifer Kaytin Robinson explained why the scene featuring Tung and Chavez— which was supposed to be featured at the beginning of the film— hit the cutting room floor. "In every movie, it's best laid plans, and then you edit the movie and you put it together and you go, 'I love this in a vacuum. This is a fantastic scene. But it doesn't fit in the movie,'" Robinson told People. Jennifer Kaytin Robinson Praised Lola Tung and Nicholas Alexander Chavez's Performances Jennifer Kaytin Robinson told People that she was impressed with Lola Tung and Nicholas Alexander Chavez's performances in I Know What You Did Last Summer, which made the decision to cut their scene from the film all the more difficult. "It was just one of those situations where it had nothing to do with Lola and Nicholas — they are both so fantastic,' the filmmaker told People. 'I really would love to work with them again. I loved working with them. They did a fabulous job. But in the larger tapestry of the film, it just didn't fit. "It sucks because you don't want to do that to those actors,' Robinson added. 'And it sucks when you love something as a scene, but that scene just doesn't work in the final cut of the film." Rated R, I Know What You Did Last Summer is new in theaters.