Senator seeks tourism ousters amid racism, sexism complaints
Fevella (R, Ewa Beach ), said, 'There is a toxic and hostile work environment at HTA. Because of the efforts to sweep this matter under the rug, I am calling for the resignations of James Toki oka, director of the (Department of Business, Economic Development and Tourism ), and Issac Choy, HTA's acting chief administrative officer.'
The news conference followed a sign-waving in front of the state Capitol, which was attended by about a dozen people, and was a follow-up to a request that Fevella made Thursday to state Attorney General Anne E. Lopez to investigate complaints that Choy allegedly had referred to an HTA contractor, the Council for Native Hawaiian Advancement, as 'dumb Hawaiians ' and also was alleged to have 'demeaned and belittled ' female HTA board members.
Fevella also alleged that a hostile workplace contributed to the recent resignations of several HTA employees who were Native Hawaiian, including Daniel Naho 'op 'i, former interim HTA president, who resigned from HTA on March 21. Other recent resignations by Native Hawaiian staff have included Maka Casson-Fisher, HTA brand manager ; 'Iwalani Kaho 'ohanohano, HTA senior brand manger ;
Ilihia Gionson, HTA public affairs officer ; and most recently Kalani Ka 'ana 'ana, HTA chief stewardship officer and interim public affairs officer, whose resignation was effective Friday.
Choy responded to the Honolulu Star-Advertiser in an email Monday saying, 'I deny Senator Fevella's false allegations. The Attorney General will investigate these matters, and I have been advised to reserve specific responses for the investigation.'
Choy, a former state tax director and lawmaker who was elected to five terms in the House of Representatives serving the Manoa district from 2008 through 2018, joined HTA in 2023. For more than a year, he said, he has worked with staff, the Department of the Attorney General, other public bodies and the Legislature to report and resolve violations or suspected violations of law, rule or regulations and contracts executed by HTA.
'To protect against retaliation, the Attorney General's office has acknowledged my staff and me as whistleblowers, ' he said. 'It is unfortunate that the recent allegations appear to be in retaliation for the work done by me and the staff of the HTA Finance-Procurement Section.'
When queried about the attorney general's involvement or Choy's designation as a 'whistleblower, ' Toni Schwartz, spokesperson for the Department of the Attorney General, said in an email Monday, 'The Department of the Attorney General will not make statements on the existence or status of possible pending investigations.'
Makana McClellan, Green's director of communications, said in an email, 'The Governor has directed Attorney General Lopez and DHRD Director Hashimoto to thoroughly investigate these allegations, determine the facts and identify any appropriate next steps.'
HTA board Chair Todd Apo said the board also is waiting for the attorney general's guidance.
State Sen. Lynn DeCoite (D, Hana-East and Upcountry Maui-Molokai-Lanai-Kahoolawe ), chair of the Senate Committee on Energy, Economic Development and Tourism, told the Star-Advertiser in a phone interview Monday, 'HTA is in the paper every week. We've had many challenges with them. I'm not going to second-guess what people are saying. I want accuracy and I want facts.'
DeCoite added, 'I've known Issac Choy for years and worked with him on countless numbers of bills as a female, and I've never felt him to be sexist, and as a Hawaiian I've never felt him to be racist towards me or when around other Hawaiians.'
House Majority Leader Sean Quinlan (D, Waialua-Haleiwa-Punaluu ) said, 'The AG's Office is going to look into the situation, and I think it's really premature to call for anyone's resignation based off of allegations, which may or may not be true.'
Choy said, 'I believe that the results of the AG investigation will confirm that the work done by me and the HTA Finance and Procurement staff has been and will continue to be in the best interests of HTA and the state and not racially discriminatory in any way.'
However, Tyler Gomes, administrator of the Council for Native Hawaiian Advancement's Kilohana, filed a complaint Nov. 25 alleging that Choy called Gomes and the rest of the CNHA team 'dumb Hawaiians ' during an August 2023 meeting, and afterward embarked on a pattern of behavior that was 'race-based in its inequity.'
Tokioka said Friday in an email that CNHA officials were not present at the August 2023 meeting but that he was there and that he had heard Choy use derogatory language during a conversation about CNHA with other HTA staff members.
He said that he placed a written warning in Choy's personnel file in October 2024 after learning that Naho 'opi 'i, who was also present when the remark was made, had not taken further action. He said Choy apologized to staff, and the matter was considered resolved.
But Hinaleimoana Wong-Kalu, community leader and CNHA ambassador, who was at Fevella's action Monday, said, 'For too many years, Kanaka of Hawaii have allowed elephants in the room to multiply exponentially in both overt and covert ways—negatively impacting our existence in our homeland.'
During the news conference, Fevella alleged that Choy also had made unresolved racist and sexist remarks to two Native Hawaiian female board members and had threatened staff. He said DBEDT's human resources was aware of complaints, but alleged that Tokioka protected Choy because they were friends.
Tokioka told the Star-Advertiser in an email Monday, 'After allegations were made, the DBEDT human resources officer met with former interim HTA President &CEO Daniel Naho 'opi 'i on a number of occasions regarding the complaints. Mr. Naho 'opi 'i stated in numerous meetings with Deputy Attorney General John Cole present that he would address the allegations but did not follow up with VP of Finance Isaac Choy or anyone else.'
Naho 'opi 'i told the Star-Advertiser on Saturday that a key reason he left HTA was that he was prevented from effectively addressing numerous complaints involving Choy, including two formal complaints from HTA board members, two complaints from HTA contractors, one formal complaint from an HTA employee and multiple other informal employee complaints.
Naho 'opi 'i said he felt threatened because Tokioka had tried to discipline him, unsuccessfully, after Naho 'opi 'i represented the HTA board's position on a bill in 2024 that was not aligned with DBEDT's position.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time Magazine
09-07-2025
- Time Magazine
'Shark Whisperer' Villainizes Native Hawaiians Like Me
I only found out about the new Netflix documentary Shark Whisperer because my social media notifications exploded. I had been tagged in posts by people calling me anti-shark and anti-environment. I was confused, until I watched the film. There I was, portrayed as the antagonist. I served as Chair of Hawaii's House Committee on Ocean, Marine Resources and Hawaiian Affairs, the body featured in the documentary for holding hearings on shark protection legislation. What the film doesn't show is that I was one the earliest and strongest champions of the bill that banned shark fishing. I called for a hearing when others hesitated. I moved the bill to a vote despite resistance from House leadership. I worked hard to secure the support needed to pass it. But in the documentary, Native Hawaiians like myself—lawmakers, kūpuna (elders), and local researchers—are reduced to obstacles. We are either tokenized or vilified, while a single outsider (in this case, social media activist Ocean Ramsey) is framed as the story's savior. This isn't just a misrepresentation. It reflects a deeper pattern in the way mainstream documentaries often frame their stories: who is cast as the subject, and who is cast as the object. Whose knowledge is celebrated, and whose is pushed aside. I grew up freediving off the coast of Maui, spearfishing for fish and heʻe (octopus), and encountering manō (sharks) regularly. These weren't adrenaline-fueled stunts. They were sacred moments. In our tradition, the shark is not something to be humanized or monetized. It is our aumākua, a family guardian. We do not stalk them, name them, or treat them like pets. We show respect. We let the manō come to us. Later as a young lawmaker representing my community, I began to see how depleted our waters had become. Fish stocks were declining, coral was dying, and ocean commercialization was pushing native species to the edge. I didn't take on shark protection because it was politically easy. It wasn't. Many commercial fishermen opposed it. Colleagues warned me not to push it. But I moved forward anyway because the ocean raised me. I owed it that much. Shark Whisperer claims to honor marine life, but it often confuses reverence with control. It reduces wild, sacred beings to characters in a human-centered story, mistaking closeness for connection. But in our culture, true respect often means keeping a sacred distance. Not everything powerful needs to be tamed. Every creature holds its own essence and role in the web of life, whether or not it reflects us. To honor them is to let go of the need to dominate or display, and simply let them be. That's what makes the film's focus on Ramsey so troubling. Not just because it elevates her as the lone protector of Hawaii's sharks, but because it blurs the line between advocacy and appropriation. In a recent Instagram post, Ramsey referenced the honor of receiving ʻuhi, a sacred tattoo ceremony traditionally reserved for Native Hawaiians. She described it as a 'symbol of her kuleana and heritage', claiming a cultural lineage that simply isn't hers. Beyond this, her academic background is unclear. Her origin is often vague. What is clear is that she lacks the trust of the local community. Many advocates believe her involvement actually delayed the passage of the shark protection law. Her presence casted doubt on the credibility of the broader coalition. And some supporters hesitated to show up, concerned their advocacy would be associated with what many saw as her disrespect toward Native Hawaiians and local fishers. And now, with an even larger platform, her example risks being imitated. And if others will mimic her tactics, our voices, the ones rooted in generations of lived experience and cultural knowledge, may be drowned out. The truth is, Kānaka Maoli (Native Hawaiian) ocean protectors have been doing this work for generations. They've done it with fewer followers, without sponsorships or stunts, and without turning our aumākua into content or cash. Our true Kahu Manō (shark whisperers) may never get a documentary deal or millions of views, but they carry the knowledge that sustains life in our waters and our communities. They are who we turn to. They are who we trust. Netflix had the opportunity to center their voices. Instead, it followed a formula weʻve seen many times before. In The White Helmets, Western filmmakers crafted a humanitarian narrative in Syria that largely erased local organizing and failed to contextualize the complex geopolitical forces involved. In The Rescue, Thai cave divers were spotlighted over the Indigenous local volunteers who led much of the initial effort. And in The Ivory Game, African anti-poaching leaders were overshadowed by European conservationists with camera crews and sponsorships. These films may have had good intentions, but they reflect a pattern: the white outsider as savior, the local or Indigenous people as backdrop or obstacle. This kind of framing doesn't just distort the truth, it disempowers communities. It reinforces a system in which those closest to the harm are furthest from the platform, and those furthest from the culture are handed the microphone. But it doesn't have to be that way. Good allyship begins with humility. It means showing up in solidarity, not for visibility. It means knowing when to speak, and when to step back and amplify those with lived experience and ancestral ties—especially when the work involves sacred beings, sacred practices, and sacred places. We're not asking to be centered in every story. We're asking not to be erased from our own. We are not the villain. And neither is the manō.
Washington Post
04-07-2025
- Washington Post
US military's attempt to retain strategic land for training runs into Native Hawaiian opposition
HONOLULU — A high-altitude plateau on the Big Island is the only place in Hawaii where thousands of ground forces can practice firing live munitions. It's also a place many Native Hawaiians consider the spiritual heart of the island. The U.S. military wants to keep training at this spot, called Pohakuloa, so it's ready to quickly send troops to Asia and the Pacific. Its importance to the U.S. is only growing as China becomes more assertive, particularly regarding Taiwan.
Skift
24-06-2025
- Skift
Hawaii Seeks Overhaul of Tourism Authority
Hawaii Governor Josh Green appears to be cleaning house at the state's tourism authority after calling it a "hot mess." An overhaul gives the state the chance to pioneer a new tourism model. State lawmakers slammed Hawaii Tourism Authority (HTA) for poor financial management and effectiveness Monday, and Governor Josh Green will reportedly ask all board members to resign by July 1. 'Governor Green plans on asking for courtesy resignations from the entire board," said a statement for his office, according to Hawaii News Now. "Because the responsibilities of the board have changed to an advisory role, he feels it best to start with a clean slate." Green signed legislation May 31 that stripped the HTA's board of its policy and management authority, reclassifying it as an advisory body. 'Well, it's a hot mess over there,' Green said on Hawaii News Now Sunrise following the bill's passage. 'I'm going to put in some advisors that are going to be a lot more thoughtful about how we proceed.' HTA's board no longer controls day-to-day operations. The restructuring places the agency's CEO role under direct gubernatorial oversight, a significant departure from the typical U.S. destination marketing organization model. The governor's office did not respond to two requests for comment from Skift. HTA's longtime director of planning and interim CEO, Caroline Anderson, told Skift earlier this month that the new legislation creates 'a direct reporting relationship between HTA's President and CEO and the Governor,' which she sees as an opportunity to "enhance the impact and responsiveness of Hawaii's tourism efforts." Under Pressure, Underperforming During a six-hour legislative hearing Monday, some Hawaii lawmakers proposed moving the authority into one or two existing government agencies as a way to restructure state's oversight of tourism. Another proposal was to adopt the recommendations of a third-party governance study released a year ago by Better Destinations, a consultancy, that called for replacing the HTA with a private, independent nonprofit "destination stewardship organization." State lawmakers have previously criticized HTA for failing to pivot from a visitor growth model to one focused on managing tourism's impact. The state in May became the first in the nation to approve a so-called 'green fee' on visitors, applying to hotel stays, cruise ship cabins, and short-term rentals. The measure is expected to raise about $100 million annually, with revenue supporting disaster preparedness and climate change mitigation. Hawaii's tourism sector continues to lag behind pre-pandemic levels. The downturn was compounded by the 2023 wildfires in Maui, one of the deadliest disasters in U.S. history, and confusion among travelers, many of whom believed the island was closed to visitors. In an interview with Skift last year, Green framed 2025 as a year for 'deployment' of resources to support tourism recovery.
