Government has ‘systematically smashed' disability laws for children, teen campaigner tells Oireachtas
An AON is carried out to identify if a child, children or young person has a disability, and is designed to identify their health needs as well as service requirements.
Once the HSE receives an application, there is a legal requirement for the AON to be completed within six months.
On the possibility of changes to the laws being in train, Cara said she would "vigorously resist any negative change" to the six-month timeframe, saying she believed it would cause "further permanent damage to children".
The total number of applications overdue for completion at the end of March 2025 stood at 15,296, an 8% rise on the end of 2024.
Throughout the first quarter of this year, just 7% of assessments were completed within the timeframes set out in the Disability Act 2005 and accompanying regulations.
The HSE said that demand for AONs continues to outstrip system capacity, despite increases in activity and commissions from private assessors.
The health service anticipates that by the end of the year there could be as many as 24,796 AONs due for completion.
Opposition parties including Sinn Féin, Labour, Social Democrats, People Before Profit-Solidarity, Independent Ireland and Aontu have supported Cara's campaign.
Last month she staged a 50-hour protest outside Leinster House.
She was initially motivated to pursue her advocacy because her two brothers have autism and severe/profound intellectual disabilities.
Speaking at Committee, Cara said: "My own story is very simple, I have two brothers Neil, 12, and John, eight, who are autistic and severely and profoundly intellectually disabled.
"They were both failed dramatically by the state in relation to assessments and services, and Neil remains in an inappropriate school place.
"Our story is the story of so many thousands of other families. I cannot do anything to change the permanent damage caused to Neil and John, but I can advocate to stop damage being done to autistic children in the future."
She said Taoiseach Micheal Martin and the wider Government are breaking the law over the delivery of AONs.
"Three different taoisigh have made promises to me to fix this issue, and all have dramatically failed."
She added: "Let me explain how they're breaking the law. The Disability Act of 2005, an Act created by this House, states that an assessment of need must be carried out within six months, full-stop.
"That six-month timeframe is there because every single person knows that early intervention is the key.
"It's also generally accepted that when early intervention doesn't occur, that damage is caused to children with disabilities. It's a no-brainer."
Cara said she was shocked that Mr Martin would not declare a national emergency over the matter.
She said the Taoiseach should also set up a taskforce to address the matter, and increase financing for "Cara's Fund".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Sinn Fein leader attends public meeting on Irish neutrality in Wexford
Gorey Guardian Today at 03:00 Sinn Féin party leader Mary Lou McDonald recently attended a public meeting held in Wexford. The meeting was organised by Wicklow Wexford TD Fionntán Ó Súilleabháin at a public meeting in the Loch Garman Arms Hotel in Gorey. Deputy Ó Súilleabháin said that Ireland's participation in European military structures would 'put a nail in the coffin of Irish neutrality'. He referred to the recent 'Eire' sign which was unearthed at Cahore Point in Wexford as an important project which directly presents the history of neutrality present in Ireland. 'It was done so that the German Luftwaffee would see that the bomber planes were not over Britain, but rather a neutral state. So, this is timely,' he said. He further said the removal of the triple lock requirement is something that Irish people do not want as shown in opinion polls. 'Would anyone here want to have their son or daughter fight (and possibly die) for Ursula Von der Leyen?' he said. Deputy Ó Súilleabháin added that people must rally around the matter. He said: 'we need to rally around this issue and point out that it's also a core part of republican and internationalist principles on which the struggle for independence was based on. 'It's a fight that we must win, all of us - SF and non-SF-democrats. We all need to come together and co-operate in a broader front as the alternative is the unthinkable and is not a legacy that any of us can leave for our children or our children's children.' Earlier that day, Mary Lou McDonald visited and cut the ribbon on Deputy Fionntán Ó Súilleabháin's new office which is located opposite the Theatre Hall. The office opened at the beginning of the year. 'We were delighted to have Mary Lou McDonald down to officially open the office, it was a lovely evening and we're having great success with the office,' Deputy Ó Súilleabháin added.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Root of All Evil by Cormac Moore: An insightful guide to how the Border came to be where it is
The Root of All Evil: The Irish Boundary Commission Author : Cormac Moore ISBN-13 : 978-1788551779 Publisher : Irish Academic Press Guideline Price : €19.99 Arriving from Belfast at my in-laws' house in Warrenpoint, overlooking Carlingford Lough and therefore the Border, I invariably receive a text message saying: 'welcome to Ireland' (a bizarre experience to northerners who thought they had been there all along). Sometimes a second message appears, a moment later, welcoming me back to the UK. These messages from mobile providers usually have exclamation marks and other excitable punctuation to alert travellers to changes in contractual terms as a result of a border drawn quickly and often arbitrarily a century ago. Understanding why the Border exists has generated a universe of narrative history covering the Ulster Plantation onwards, but as Cormac Moore's crisp and insightful new book The Root of All Evil shows, understanding how diplomatic manoeuvring and bureaucratic inertia created and sustained the Border is essential too. The Boundary Commission is a critical part of that story. The commission has its centenary this year, and it is oddly fitting that it will pass with minimal commemoration. It was an anticlimactic coda to a revolutionary decade. But it was supposed to be a big deal, and was certainly understood as being so by the signatories who agreed its fatally vague terms in article 12 of the 1921 Treaty. READ MORE The principle of 'temporary exclusion' from Home Rule for Ulster was conceded by John Redmond before the first World War. Fast forward through revolution and the Government of Ireland Act of 1920 later created two devolved entities: Northern and Southern Ireland. By the time of the Treaty talks only the first of these was functioning per the terms of the Act, with James Craig ensconced as prime minister and determined to turn Northern Ireland into 'a new impregnable pale'. But the treaty talks were not just between the imperial British government and the 26 counties, but all of Ireland – represented by the plenipotentiaries of the provisional government. Knowing the North would be an area of contention, the British split the Sinn Féin delegation by seeking secret agreement from Arthur Griffith (technically the lead Irish participant) that his delegation would, if pressed, accept continued exclusion of the six counties on the basis that a commission would be appointed to determine the wishes of local inhabitants and adjust the Border. The Machiavellian Lloyd George appears to have given private assurances (or intimations) to Griffith that the commission would transfer vast swathes of the nationalist North, and at a minimum Tyrone and Fermanagh, into the South. These assurances were either lies or artfully constructed so as to be overinterpreted. However, it was not Griffith alone, but the entire Irish delegation who agreed the obviously flawed (from a nationalist perspective) article 12, which qualified the commitment to local wishes being respected by adding the crucial words: 'so far as may be compatible with economic and geographic conditions'. Moore's book expertly explains how these 11 words served to 'nullify' the entire claimed purpose of the commission – to respect the wishes of local inhabitants. The maximum claim prepared by the Free State officials in the North Eastern Boundary Bureau would have moved the Border as far north as my hometown of Downpatrick in east Down. Not only did that not happen, but no major areas of Tyrone or Fermanagh were transferred, nor were Derry or Newry. As Moore's book shows, the fallout from the commission reinforced the Border rather than adjusting or undermining it. And if Griffith gets blamed for his naivety, it pales when set against the 'appalling ineptitude' of Eoin MacNeill , the Free State appointee to the commission. Of the three-man commission, MacNeill was working alongside a South African judge, ostensibly impartial but in reality steeped in imperial influence, and Joseph Fisher, Belfast publisher of the unionist Northern Whig newspaper. [ Micheál Martin talks about Cormac Moore's book The Root of All Evil Opens in new window ] Whereas Fisher constantly and strategically leaked inner deliberations of the commission to the unionist government and ultimately the press, MacNeill treated his role with chaste propriety, believing himself not to be 'a representative of a Government nor ... an advocate for a particular point of view'. In fact, MacNeill was literally a representative of the Free State government, and was chosen because his northern nationalist background would better enable him to articulate their views. His failure to competently perform either of these tasks culminated in his agreeing a boundary with minimal changes, and then resigning in ignominy when the recommendations were leaked to a newspaper to the humiliation of WT Cosgrave's government. The report itself then was buried for half a century. Moore's book succeeds because he tells a story that is both very particular, with close reading of archive material and chronological detail but also, to use the cliche, mindful of the big picture. It wasn't just the mistakes of Griffith or MacNeill, or the canniness of Lloyd George, or the obduracy of Craig, that shaped the Boundary Commission. It was 'facts on the ground', including the construction of Silent Valley reservoir in the Mournes as a source of Belfast's water, and therefore an 'economic circumstance' allowing the wishes of south Down residents to move into the Free State to be overridden. But there was also the erection of customs posts by a Free State government desperate to demonstrate its newly won fiscal independence, and in doing so 'unwittingly aiding' the unionist northern government in creating a sense of permanency around the Border. As we consider the future of the Border in Ireland, and indeed an Ireland without a border, this book is a useful guide to some of how we got here and how we might avoid some of the same mistakes again.
Irish Examiner
10 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Irish Examiner view: Delays to colonoscopy tests could be a matter of life or death
This week, we learned that thousands of people have been waiting far too long for vital cancer testing procedures, a problem which seems to be getting worse. Some 2,764 people have waited between 29 and 60 days for an urgent colonoscopy between January and May this year. According to the guidelines issued by the HSE, those with symptoms of bowel cancer should be seen within 28 days. That means some people have been waiting for over twice as long as the recommended time period for this vital intervention. To make matters worse, that number appears to be increasing, as 3,623 people were waiting longer than the recommended timeframe in 2024. The Irish Cancer Society pointed out that in 2017, no patient in Ireland had to wait longer than 28 days for an urgent colonoscopy, yet if the current trend continues through 2025, more than 6,500 people will not be seen within the 28-day period. The society's description of this development as a shocking deterioration in service, which is putting lives at risk, cannot be contradicted. This may seem at first glance yet another health service fiasco, one in a long line of similar disasters. But bowel cancer is a particular challenge. It is the second most common cancer in men, the third most common cancer in women, and the third leading cause of cancer death in Ireland. The Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) said this months screening from the age of 50 was likely to be effective in terms of reducing deaths from colorectal cancer. However, plans for earlier screening are meaningless if that screening cannot be carried out. The long waiting times for colonoscopies which were revealed this week are a disheartening reminder that even established processes can break down, given the deterioration in waiting times between 2017 and the present. Strategies conceived with the best of intentions count for little if they cannot be put into practice. Failings of a justice system The man responsible for the killing of Irish soldier Private Seán Rooney was sentenced to death at a military tribunal in Beirut, Lebanon, this week. According to Lebanese media reports, Mohammad Ayyad was sentenced to death and fined 100m Lebanese pounds, or approximately €970. The remains of Irish UN peacekeeping soldier Seán Rooney arriving at Casement Aerodrome, Baldonnell, Co Dublin, in December 2022. Pte Rooney, from Newtowncunningham, Co Donegal, was killed on active service when his convoy came under attack in Lebanon. Another defendant was sentenced to three months, while yet another received one month: They were both fined as well. Ayyad was not in court for the sentencing however, while local media have reported that Lebanon has not carried out an execution in decades — so he is likely to receive a prison sentence instead. Pt Rooney, of Newtowncunningham, Donegal, was killed when a UN peacekeeping force was targeted in an attack on their vehicle in at Al-Aqbiya, Lebanon, in December 2022. He was 24 years old. Those responsible have received light sentences, with the exception of one individual who remains at large in the country and did not even have to attend the sentencing. Concerns have been raised repeatedly about the progress of this case, and the verdicts issued this week show the validity of those concerns. A justice system in which a killer does not even have to be present in court when sentenced to death hardly seems fit for purpose. The Rooney family, which has already had to deal with the trauma of losing a loved one, has been badly let down by that justice system. Taoiseach Micheál Martin weighed in on the matter yesterday when saying that the case had taken too long and that some of the sentences issued were unduly lenient. It should also be pointed out, perhaps, that earlier this year the Taoiseach also said: 'Hezbollah are responsible, in my view, for the murder of Seán Rooney.' Some armchair activists might bear that in mind when signalling their advocacy for certain groups. Pt Rooney made the ultimate sacrifice for peace and his family deserve the support of all. What's your view on this issue? You can tell us here New Garda commissioner The next Garda commissioner was announced on Tuesday, with Justin Kelly — who was appointed deputy commissioner for security, strategy, and governance in October 2024 — taking over from the outgoing commissioner, Drew Harris. Justice minister Jim O'Callaghan, incoming Garda commissioner Justin Kelly, Taoiseach Micheál Martin, and current Garda Commissioner Drew Harris, at Government Buildings in Dublin as Mr Kelly was announced as the next Garda commissioner. Picture: Liam McBurney/PA The process was far from straightforward, given the reticence of some senior officers to apply for the post because of pension implications. At one point, it was even suggested that those pension implications might mean only applicants outside Ireland would apply for the position. This is not to cast aspersions on such applicants, but at this fraught time in Irish life, it is surely preferable to have someone at the helm of the national police force who is already familiar with the particular challenges facing An Garda Síochána. That is certainly true of Mr Kelly, to judge by his policing background, which includes stints as assistant commissioner with responsibility for serious and organised crime, as well as detective chief superintendent in the Garda counter-terrorism unit. The rise of the far right, the ongoing threat of drugs gangs, the operation of rogue states in Ireland, the shadow cast by cybercrime — these are all challenges requiring urgent attention. Morale and standards within the force will also be scrutinised. Mr Kelly's appointment coincided with reports of a former garda being jailed for seven years for impersonating a colleague online, and inciting men to come to her home and rape her. The new commissioner's in-tray is already full. Best wishes to him. Read More Irish Examiner view: State must be ready to step in
