logo
Projects in Great Nicobar Islands have strategic importance. The government, thus, must address transparency concerns

Projects in Great Nicobar Islands have strategic importance. The government, thus, must address transparency concerns

Indian Express09-07-2025
In the past five years, the government has taken steps to develop the Andaman and Nicobar Islands as a bulwark of security to the east of the country's peninsular area and as a crucial node for safeguarding India's interests in the Indo-Pacific. The project involves revamping airfields and jetties and building logistics and storage facilities, a base for military personnel, and a robust surveillance infrastructure. It also involves a massive infrastructure upgrade on Great Nicobar Island — an International Container Transshipment Terminal, a greenfield international airport, a township, and a gas and solar-based power plant spread. Given that the rapid enhancement of the capabilities of China's People's Liberation Army Navy has greatly increased the strategic importance of the Bay of Bengal in the past two decades, Delhi's infrastructure push and the building of a strong military deterrence at Great Nicobar hasn't come a day too late. However, the island's ecological sensitivity has made the challenge more complex. Civil society activists and wildlife conservationists have alleged that the infrastructure upgrade will harm the region's indigenous communities, including the largely uncontacted Shompen people, it will have negative spinoffs for coral reefs and marine systems and pose a threat to endangered species, including the terrestrial Nicobar megapode bird and leatherback turtles. In 2023, the National Green Tribunal (NGT) directed the Ministry of Environment to constitute a high-powered committee (HPC) to revisit the environmental clearances to the Great Nicobar project. On Monday, even as the ministry submitted the panel's report to an NGT bench, there was little indication that a resolution to the impasse was at hand.
The HPC has reportedly concluded that the environmental clearances accorded to the project 'adhered to statutory provisions'. The government has, however, not made the panel's report public. Keeping information classified is, of course, necessary at times in matters involving strategic affairs. But in an ecologically fragile region with a vulnerable local population, a project to create a formidable maritime bastion requires engagement with all sections of society. The government's insistence on secrecy will do more harm than good, especially because the lack of transparency around due procedures was a major sticking point with civil society activists. The government has reportedly also wielded the RTI Act's provisions on security and strategic concerns to deny right to information requests about environmental clearances. In March, it used an equally unconvincing argument — the matter is sub judice — to evade a Rajya Sabha question on the red flags raised by the NGT and National Commission for Scheduled Tribes about the project's impact on local communities. Two months later, Union Minister of Tribal Affairs Jual Oram said that the government was examining the concerns raised by tribal communities, but again refused to divulge details. The Andaman and Nicobar Islands Integrated Development Corporation Limited, which is in charge of the infrastructure development activities, claims that its wildlife conservation plan (WCP) is derived from a framework developed by scientists at the Salim Ali Centre for Ornithology. But the WCP, too, is not in the public domain.
Delhi has taken more than 70 years to recognise the strategic importance of the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. It now needs to set the record right on transparency — a project of national importance cannot be clouded with misgivings.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Transport & environment depts studying ban on overage vehicles, to submit report
Transport & environment depts studying ban on overage vehicles, to submit report

Time of India

time3 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Transport & environment depts studying ban on overage vehicles, to submit report

Delhi govt asked its transport and environment departments to study the current guidelines on end-of-life vehicles, enforcement against overaged vehicles and the reaction of the public and stakeholders to the action. Govt will also assess the removal of vehicles so far and the impact of this on air quality levels, officials said on Thursday. One official added, "Govt may then file a review petition on the policy in the Supreme Court based on the findings and reports submitted by the two departments." Environment minister Manjinder Singh Sirsa said, "The environment and transport departments are studying, separately, the guidelines, their impact on the public and the benefits and consequences on ground and air quality levels. Once they complete their studies and submit the report, govt will take further decisions on filing a petition in the court." The departments will also mention the other measures they took in the last five months to curb air pollution in the city and their results, said a govt official. A 2014 order of the National Green Tribunal also prohibits the parking of vehicles aged over 15 years in public places. Following the NGT and Supreme Court's order, in 2021-22, the transport department began de-registering petrol and diesel vehicles that had completed, respectively, 15 years and 10 years of life. Then in 2023, the transport department launched an enforcement drive against these overaged vehicles found parked in public places or running on the roads. However, several vehicle owners moved court, following which govt was asked to come up with proper guidelines to handle ELVs in Delhi. The current govt relaunched the enforcement drive in July and banned provision of fuel to ELVs, both cars, trucks and bikes. However, after facing public heat the drive was halted on grounds of "critical operational and infrastructural challenges". Sirsa also wrote to pollution watchdog Commission for Air Quality Management pleading the city authorities could not accommodate the panel's imposition of the anti-ELV measure. After this, lieutenant governor VK Saxena wrote to CM Rekha Gupta, asking Delhi govt to seek a review petition before the apex court against its 2018 order restricting petrol vehicles beyond 15 years and diesel vehicles beyond 10 years from plying in Delhi-NCR. "How can a vehicle banned as unfit in Delhi run lawfully in other cities? This is against equal treatment," LG queried in the letter. Citing equality and socio-economic reasons, Saxena underlined that such rules should be proportionate, non-arbitrary and not solely based on a rigid age-based classification. He also said that the ban should be put on hold unless it was implemented across NCR. He sought a comprehensive air pollution mitigation plan within three months. Talking on similar lines, Gupta said, "Just as we requested CAQM to review its decision on overage vehicles, we will approach the Supreme Court to give us a detailed overview of our preparation in the fight against pollution, and we will let the court know of public grievances. We will fight for the rights of people.">

Cooperative dept role key in implementation
Cooperative dept role key in implementation

Hans India

time2 hours ago

  • Hans India

Cooperative dept role key in implementation

Rajamahendravaram: The Cooperative Department has a crucial role to play in effectively implementing the Right to Information (RTI) Act, said East Godavari District Cooperative Officer M Venkataramana. Addressing a district-level awareness programme on the RTI Act, organised at the Aryapuram Urban Cooperative Bank's conference hall, he noted the significance of cooperative societies as grassroots institutions that work closely with the public. Venkataramana urged Public Information Officers (PIOs) to be fully aware of key provisions such as Section 7, which mandates timely responses to RTI applications, and Section 19, which deals with the appeal process. He warned that delays or denial of information could lead to penalties and disciplinary action under Section 20. District Cooperative Audit Officer M Jagannatha Reddy stressed the importance of a transparent and timely information system and said staff should be well-versed with the Act to serve the public more efficiently. Divisional Cooperative Officer M Kanakadurgareddy explained the exemptions under Section 8 of the RTI Act, which prohibit the disclosure of information related to national security, strategic interests, trade secrets, or personal privacy. Ramadas Cooperative Training College Principal Srinivas explained that as per Section 20, officials could be fined ₹250 per day for delays in providing information, with a maximum penalty of ₹25,000. He also underlined the mandatory disclosure of information related to corruption and human rights violations. The awareness session was attended by PIOs, appellate officers, and supporting staff from various cooperative institutions across the district.

Stop building statue of Gond king, restore Dal Sagar lake in Seoni: NGT
Stop building statue of Gond king, restore Dal Sagar lake in Seoni: NGT

Time of India

time8 hours ago

  • Time of India

Stop building statue of Gond king, restore Dal Sagar lake in Seoni: NGT

Bhopal: Taking the municipal council of Seoni town in MP to task for planning to construct a statue of Gond King Dalpat Shah on an island located in the midst of a lake constructed by the king, and further planning the construction of a foot overbridge (FOB) to let people reach the statue, the Bhopal-based central zone bench of the National Green Tribunal (NGT) said that while Dalpat Shah built the lake for the welfare of human beings and all living creatures, the municipal council was 'destroying' it by installing his statue inside the lake and further constructing an FOB for people to easily reach there. The green watchdog ordered the Seoni municipal council to dismantle the slab and columns laid for the construction of the FOB and restore the lake to its original position at its own cost. It also asked the MP Pollution Control Board (MPPCB) to recover compensation from the municipal council, Seoni, according to the law. Hearing a petition filed by Navendu Mishra, a resident of Seoni town, against construction in the lake, the tribunal said, "It is for the parties to consider and reconsider the philosophy adopted by Gond King Raja Dalpat Shah. The philosophy behind the construction of this water body was making necessary provisions for future generations and provision for drinking water as well as for agricultural purposes to the civilians and general public. It was constructed not only for human beings but all living creatures. The pious philosophy should be taken into account, and it is the duty of the litigating parties to fulfil the desire of Gond King Raja Dalpat Shah. It was not desired that the nature of the water body or the lake should be curtailed or damaged, and it was never intended that his statue be installed there." The tribunal, comprising Judicial Member Sheo Kumar Singh and Expert Member Dr A Senthal Vel, further said, "In case it was in the mind of Gond King Raja Dalpat Shah, he might have installed the statue as he was the king, and there was nobody to prevent him. But the spiritual philosophy and the duty towards humanity inspired him to do the spiritual and pious work. It is the duty of the litigants to maintain the philosophy and to promote the philosophy of Gond King Raja Dalpat Shah and not to damage his philosophy by making any construction for their convenience. " The tribunal members further said that in any case, they can't pass any order against the wetland rules and further that illegality cannot be legalised by any judicial order. If anything is legally wrong, then it cannot be justified to be morally correct. The order further said that in view of the above discussion and analysis of the report submitted by the joint committee constituted by the NGT to look into the matter and the members of the SEIAA and the CPCB, the district administration Seoni shall ensure strict compliance with section 4 of the Wetland Rules and ensure that there will not be any encroachment on the wetland, construction activities, discharge of untreated water, or dumping of garbage/solid waste/plastic waste in the lake. The constructions raised during the pendency of this application and those already raised previously in violation of section 4 of the wetland rules must be demolished immediately at the cost of the municipal council. The municipal council, Seoni, shall prepare a detailed time-bound action plan for the restoration of the site that shall be examined by the MPPCB and approved by the MP State Wetland Authority. The State PCB is directed to realise the environmental compensation according to rules, and the amount of compensation must be utilised for the improvement of the lake under the supervision of the Wetland Authority and local administration headed by the Collector. A time-targeted action plan shall be prepared and submitted to the Regional Office, MPPCB Seoni, regarding the demolition of pillars and other civil structures constructed inside the lake. The guidelines on Environment Management of Construction & Demolition (C&D) Waste, 2017, issued by the Central Pollution Control Board, may be adopted and applied. The tribunal said that signboards and caution boards should be installed at suitable places regarding restricted zones. Immediate actions shall be taken by the municipal council, Seoni, for performing cleaning of the lake, and its boundary should be identified, demarcated, and fenced to restrain any unauthorised dumping of solid/plastic waste. The NGT also asked for the removal of weeds in a scientific manner in Dal Sagar Lake, and a catchment area study shall be carried out for the identification of natural inlet drains of the lake to restore water in the lake. A groundwater study, including an assessment of present water quality and the groundwater table around the lake, should be carried out by engaging an expert agency. To compensate for the plants/trees felled during the construction work, the plantation of native plant species shall be carried out around the lake and at the central island. Bioremediation and restoration of the lake bed to improve the water carrying and holding capacity of the lake should be undertaken. Effective measures shall be taken by the local body to expedite the establishment of sewerage network connections and the construction and operation of STPs proposed under the Amrut 2.0 Scheme in the city within a definite time frame. The tribunal asked the MPPCB to monitor and submit a report in four months to the registrar, National Green Tribunal, central zone bench, Bhopal. It also asked the registrar, NGT, to send a copy of the order to the Principal Secretary, Department of Environment, Member Secretary, State MPPCB, Bhopal, Wetland Authority, Bhopal, Collector, Seoni, and CEO, Seoni municipal council for information and necessary action.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store