Nadine Doherty: Vikki Wall being held to a 'different standard' by refereeing calls
Speaking to RTÉ's Game On, Doherty highlighted Wall's sin-binning in Meath's 0-07 to 0-04 win over Kildare and felt the decision was harsh on the 27-year-old, with the yellow card incurred in the 44th minute when she was adjudged to have fouled Claire Sullivan.
"The biggest talking point in that game was Vikki Wall's sin-bin. It wasn't a sin-bin for me," said Doherty.
"I just felt that Vikki had the ball, she was at full pace which is a lot of pace but that's her strength, so she can't be punished for that.
"And the Kildare player came across her, very clearly put two hands up to Vikki's chest. Vikki saw this late, turned her shoulder to protect herself as you would and straight away I knew she'd get a sin-bin, and you could see she was dumbfounded, as was everybody."
Doherty feels that has not been an isolated occurrence and feels the player has been incurring more on-field punishment than has been warranted by the way she plays the game.
"It just angers me to be honest because she's one of our top players," she said.
"Look, Vikki is attritional, she has a lot of pace. Does she commit fouls? Of course she does.
"But I just feel she's held to a higher standard. Not even a higher standard but a different standard when it comes to the majority of referees in this country.
"I just think she's one of our top players, who has come home from AFL. She could easily have stayed out there (in Australia) for a year.
"She has come home, back into that Meath team, she's upping the standard of our game and I just don't understand how week after week these calls are made against her."
While she viewed Wall's sin-binning as "simply a bad call", Doherty did distinguish that from the wider issue of the charging rule in women's football.
"I just think the charge rule is outdated. I don't know why it's in our game. Is it to keep our game and I put this in inverted commas, a 'non-contact sport' game?
"The game isn't non-contact. It's full-contact, it's a physical game. I don't see the point of (the charge rule) because it actually puts refs in positions where sometimes I feel they don't actually know what the right call is. They might argue that.
"Because it's such split-second tackles, it's all in the moment. But I just think at the weekend that Vikki was punished and shouldn't have been and I just think over the last few years, she's held to a different standard in that regard.
"And teams also play into that. You can see it. When Vikki has the ball and she's at full tilt, teams play into it and sometimes that's the only way they can stop her is to draw a charge."
Follow a live blog on the All-Ireland Football Championship on Saturday and Sunday on rte.ie/sport and the RTÉ News app. Listen to updates on Saturday Sport and Sunday Sport on RTÉ Radio 1. Watch highlights on The Saturday Game at 9.15pm and The Sunday Game from 9.30pm on RTÉ2 and RTÉ Player.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
25 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Lions v Australia live updates: Tourists look for 3-0 series win in Sydney
2 minutes ago Australia have also made changes after their fightback came up short last weekend. Taniela Tupou is back at tighthead to add some power. It will be needed given Rob Valetini, so impressive in Melbourne, is once again injured. Nic White starts at scrumhalf in his last international before retirement. Will Skelton stays in but it remains to be seen how long he'll last given he was called ashore after 47 minutes last time out. TEAM SHEET 🦘 Tune in on — Wallabies (@wallabies) 4 minutes ago Let's start with the teams, because that's all we care about as Lions onlookers, right? How many blokes from my country are involved? With Ireland, the answer is nine in the starting XV. The two changes (from an Irish perspective) are James Ryan starting at secondrow after his impressive bench cameo last week, while James Lowe is replaced on the wing by Blair Kinghorn. Our team for Saturday's third Test in Sydney! 🦁 — British & Irish Lions (@lionsofficial) 9 minutes ago For the last time this summer, it's time to say good morning and welcome you all to live coverage of the Lions vs Australia. With the series decided, Andy Farrell and co are in Sydney for the final game of this tour. The Lions want a series sweep, Australia are trying to salvage some pride. Well, pride on the series scoreboard after their sensational first half performance last week showed at least some backbone. Nathan here to guide you through what's what as we build up to kick-off at 11am Irish time.
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
‘It still gives you goosebumps' – Orla Byrne hoping Meath LGFA rekindle ‘special feeling' from famous All-Ireland final
ORLA BYRNE cannot help but think about Meath's amazing 2021 breakthrough as the Royals prepare for another TG4 All-Ireland SFC final against Leinster rivals Dublin. It is almost four years since the game took place but former Meath star Byrne admits she still gets 'goosebumps' whenever she recalls how the counties' ladies won their first senior crown. Advertisement 2 Meat beat Dublin in the 2021 All-Ireland final Credit: Piaras Ó Mídheach/Sportsfile 2 Former player Orla Byrne is hoping they can rekindle that feeling Credit: Sam Barnes/Sportsfile Given they had only secured a national intermediate title in the previous season, they were big underdogs heading into a top-tier showpiece clash with the five-in-a-row-chasing Dubs at Yet with Byrne playing a pivotal role at right half-forward, Eamonn Murray's charges pulled out all the stops to claim a magnificent 1-11 to 0-12 victory. Meath's renewal of acquaintances with the Jackies in tomorrow's Brendan Martin Cup decider at She beamed: 'Every time I think of it, it still gives you goosebumps. Advertisement Read More on LGFA 'You still nearly get emotional thinking about that day and what we achieved. I think it was because we were such underdogs. We had come up from intermediate the previous year. 'No one had really given us a chance. We thought we had proved ourselves as to what we were capable of but there was still a lot of doubts heading into the final. 'When I think back to those final few seconds and the hooter going off in Croke Park when we beat 'I'd love to experience it again, it was a special feeling and one I'll never forget. Advertisement Most read in GAA Football 'We all have such special memories from that time. I'm hoping the girls will be able to experience that again now on Sunday.' That historic 2021 win was made all the better for Byrne by the presence of her sister Kate on the Royals' panel for the game. 'Aged like milk on a windowsill in July' - Watch BBC's GAA pundits ALL predict Donegal to beat Kerry The gifted siblings from Duleek/Bellewstown had experienced some difficult days early in their Meath careers so it was extra sweet when they eventually reached the top of the ladies football ladder. Orla added: 'There is only a year and a half between myself and Kate so we would have played a lot of underage football together as well. We played most of our careers together with Meath. Advertisement 'It was really special that myself and Kate got to experience good days in the last couple of years of our career playing with Meath, got to enjoy the success after putting in the years of disappointment. 'Every year committing again and again, even though it was tough and we weren't getting much joy out of it, it was really nice to finally be able to say we achieved the ultimate dream of playing in Croke Park initially and then obviously winning an All-Ireland in Croke Park.' STEPPING BACK After appearing off the bench in a NFL Division 1 final victory over But in the wake of those successes, she opted to bring her inter-county journey to an end. Advertisement Although a career break from her job as a primary school teacher at Réalt na Mara GNS in Donacarney came further down the line — she is due to make a return to that post in September — Byrne acknowledged that a number of factors came into play when she decided to step back from Meath duty. She said: 'After 2021, I just didn't feel ready to go because it had been such a successful year and a year that I really enjoyed. I said I'd give it one more year. 'After the 2022 season, it was in the back of my head, 'Will I give it another go?' 'I was very much on the fence for a couple of months right into pre-season . I think the time was right. It was probably a mixture of reasons. Just mainly I had put so much of my life into playing with Meath, had put a lot of stuff in my own personal life to the side. Advertisement 'It is only probably when you step away and you come out from it that you realise how much time you can give to other things. 'I left in 2022, I went back to teaching and then took my career break the following year. I'm happy and I feel like it was the right time for me to step away.' ON EDGE While Byrne acknowledged it was a big change when she transitioned from being a Meath player to a supporter, she likes being able to relax more as a spectator. Still, she will be anxious for her former team-mates and the side's newer additions to get over the line in Croker tomorrow. Advertisement The Royals have already faced Dublin at HQ in 2025. The Leinster final on May 11 was held there as part of a double bill with the men's decider between Louth and Meath. Shane McCormack's outfit fell to a 2-13 to 1-12 defeat after leading for large stretches of the game. But even though there was a sense that it was one that got away, Byrne believes Meath showed that day they are more than a match for the Sky Blues. She added: 'I know the girls were quite disappointed. I definitely think they felt they left it behind. They were dominating most of that game and I do feel like after that game, they know they have the beating of Dublin. 'They're well capable of doing it. Just hopefully they can bring it all on the day and put in the performance they'll need to beat them.' Advertisement
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Dublin boss Paul Casey admits Meath ‘caught us on the hop' in famous All-Ireland final but won't be ‘motivating factor'
PAUL CASEY insists that the failure of Dublin's five-in-a-row bid will not serve as an added incentive to prevent another Royal coronation tomorrow. Having occupied the throne for four years on the spin, the Dubs were odds-on favourites to prevail when they met Meath in the 2021 All-Ireland ladies SFC final. 3 Meath made history by winning the 2021 All-Ireland Credit: Brendan Moran/Sportsfile 3 It ended Dublin's quest for five in a row Credit: Brendan Moran/Sportsfile 3 Paul Casey insisted that won't motivate them in this weekend's final Credit: Piaras Ó Mídheach/Sportsfile Yet just nine months after they sealed promotion to the senior ranks, the Royals caused a seismic upset to claim the Brendan Martin Cup. The neighbours will contest the After serving on the backroom ticket, the pair were promoted last December following Mick Bohan's decision to step down. Reflecting on 2021, Casey said: 'Meath very much came out of nowhere, having won the intermediate and having won Division 2. Read More on LGFA 'We hadn't the luxury of playing them even in the Leinster Championship that year because of the Covid restrictions, so they very much, I suppose if you like, possibly caught us on the hop. 'It was just that unfamiliarity. They were a team that obviously improved massively. 'When they beat 'We were a team that was only used to winning matches then. But I think the defeats we've had over the years — that year, the following year to Most read in GAA Football After Meath successfully defended their All-Ireland title, Dublin returned to the summit in 2023. They are now hotly fancied to regain the game's ultimate prize by seeing off Meath for the FOURTH time this year. The Dubs were victorious when the sides met in the National League, before coming out on top again when they crossed paths twice in the Leinster Championship. 'Aged like milk on a windowsill in July' - Watch BBC's GAA pundits ALL predict Donegal to beat Kerry Casey continued: 'I don't think 2021 will be any motivating factor. 'When you come to All-Ireland final day, you want to win the game. 'Meath will be the exact same. I'm sure they're not looking back and saying they have to get revenge for the Leinster final. You're playing on the biggest day of the year — you're going out to try and win the game. That's motivation enough for any team.' Dublin's aggregate margin of victory in their three meetings with Meath in 2025 was 27 points. However, Casey knows that Shane McCormack's side will be on a high after ousting All-Ireland champions He said: 'They're definitely a team that has improved an awful lot as the Championship has gone on. That's what happens — the longer you stay in the Championship, obviously fitness-levels increase, you're beginning to peak fitness-wise. 'But we see ourselves as the same — that we're improving as the championship goes on. 'We're expecting a massive, massive battle from them. They've some excellent players. They're not a one, two or three-person team. They have fantastic players all over the pitch. 'We know from 2021 when they came here and beat us in the All-Ireland final that they won't fear playing Dublin on the biggest day of the year.' Casey was a member of the panel when Dublin won the Sam Maguire in 2011. The seven-time Leinster SFC winner called time on his playing career at the end of the following season. Speaking at HQ ahead of tomorrow's All-Ireland final, he added: 'There's going to be a good crowd here on Sunday and it's only right the girls get to experience that. 'What I've seen over my years involved with the girls, and obviously playing myself, is the commitment and the lengths they will go to to better themselves and make sure they're in their absolute peak physical condition. 'They've brought the game to a new level. They put in the exact same effort as any men's team.'
