
Pao Houa Her Shares HMong Stories Through Photography From San José To Sheboygan
The United States' 'Secret War' in Laos roughly paralleled its war in Vietnam. Both in time frame and purpose. From the early 1960s until 1975, while waging open war against communist backed forces in north Vietnam, a covert war directed by the Central Intelligence Agency was carried out in Laos. Laos shares Vietnam's western border and runs lengthwise about two-thirds down the country.
Similar to Vietnam, Laos was engulfed in a civil war during this period pitting U.S.-backed, right wing, regimes against Soviet-backed, left wing, communists. Unlike in Vietnam, the U.S. and Soviets had signed a treaty in 1962 declaring Laos would maintain its neutrality.
Officially.
Neither superpower was interested in that.
Unofficially.
The Ho Chi Minh Trail led through northern Laos. It funneled Soviet-backed troops, supplies, and support into north Vietnam for use against the South Vietnamese and Americans in Vietnam. The Soviets wanted it to remain open. The Americans wanted it closed.
Without being able to place U.S. troops in Laos, the CIA orchestrated the largest bombing campaign in world history to that point. More bombs dropped from American planes on Laos than were deployed by the Allies in World War II. Laos is not a large nation, relatively speaking. Smaller than Vietnam. About the size of mainland Japan.
The CIA also recruited Indigenous people opposed to the communist forces in Laos to fight on America's behalf. Remember, this period was also a civil war. Primary among these groups were the HMong. Over the course of the 'Secret War,' roughly 30,000 HMong fought on the U.S. 'side.'
Hundreds of thousands of people were killed in Laos on both sides. Hundreds of millions were spent in Laos by both do it.
When the war in Vietnam and the Laotian Civil War were over, and the Soviet supported communists had defeated their American supported adversaries, HMong people, and those who had fought alongside them, became targets of political persecution. Murder.
They fled to refugee camps in Thailand, the next country west.
Then to America, by the thousands.
As with Vietnamese people who supported America and suddenly found themselves political targets after the Fall of Saigon, the United States supported a mass immigration of HMong from Laos.
They came first to California, many settling in the Bay Area. HMong people also wound up in Minneapolis and Saint Paul, MN, and Wisconsin next door, in large numbers. They were initially hosted by church communities. Once the populations gained a foothold, word of mouth among HMong people encouraged more to make their way to these places.
Pao Houa Her is a HMong artist based in Minnesota with simultaneous exhibitions of her art on view at the John Michael Kohler Arts Center in Sheboygan, WI, and the San José Museum of Art in California. Pao Houa Her
Born in Laos in 1982, Her fled with her family in the aftermath of the Laotian Civil War, spending a year in a refugee camp in Thailand before settling in Saint Paul. Her's work explores identity, longing, and belonging in a community culturally defined by an elsewhere.
'Pao Houa Her: The Imaginative Landscape' transports viewers to the jungles of Laos, the agricultural fields of California, the memories of elders, and the dreams of HMong community members across America. The exhibition is the artist's first museum survey, presenting over 50 new and recent photographs and video works both inside the John Michael Kohler Art Center and beyond JMKAC's walls, with installations at public sites and community gathering places around Sheboygan—from roadside billboards to yard signs, restaurants, a brewery, the local HMong Mutual Assistance Association building, and an active courtroom.
The two overlapping presentations–on view in Wisconsin through August 31, 2025, on view in San Jose July 11, 2025, through February 22, 2026–each tailored to their host city, reflect the diverse U.S. contexts in which HMong communities have adapted and built new homelands. The survey marks a major career milestone for Her whose work was featured in the 2022 Whitney Biennial and is currently on view at the Museum of Modern Art.
Sheboygan has long been a vital center for HMong culture and community, home to one of the largest HMong populations per capita in the United States. Wisconsin itself has the third-largest HMong population in the country, with deep connections to the Twin Cities region and California, where the largest U.S. HMong populations reside. 'The Imaginative Landscape' in Sheboygan
"Pao Houa Her: The Imaginative Landscape" installation view at the John Michael Kohler Arts Center, 2025. Pao Houa Her, (from left) 'untitled,' Pictures of Paradise series, 2023–24; lenticular print. 'Kwv Txhiaj in the Valley of Widows,' 2023; single channel video, 24 minutes, looped. Courtesy of the artist and Bockley Gallery. John Michael Kohler Arts Center.
The John Michael Kohler Arts Center presentation begins in the building's entryway with banners bearing images from Her's portrait series Attention (2012-14). The series honors HMong 'Secret War' veterans who fought for the Americans by photographing them in military portrait style. The uniforms they wear have been sourced ad hoc, often purchased online. Remember, the Laotian Civil War and the HMong involvement on behalf of America wasn't a formal, official engagement. There were no proper uniforms in the manner typically understood.
Participating–fighting and dying–on behalf of America in a publicly unsanctioned war has left HMong soldiers doubly disgraced: forced to flee their home country and unrecognized for their service in their new country. Remember. Secret war. The United States government in no way has been interested in acknowledging this happened, let alone honoring the veterans who it enrolled on the ground.
Recognition by the new country, America, for their military service in the old country, Laos, after having fled the old country for the new country, has been a decades long process for HMong soldiers.
In Sheboygan's Deland Park right on Lake Michigan, a national Lao, HMong, and American veterans of the 'Secret War' memorial provides extensive background on the conflict while honoring individuals who fought on behalf of the U.S. Be sure to see it.
JMKAC also displays a series of Her's lenticular photographs–prints in which the image changes as viewers change their viewpoint around it. The photographs are massive, six feet across.
'A few years ago, (Her's) father brought the family to Laos, loaded them up in a passenger van and took them around to sites in the jungle where they hid, when the family, including Pao as a toddler, escaped Laos, places where he remembered: this is an enclave where we hid, or this is where someone died, or even this is where someone was born,' Jodi Throckmorton, John Michael Kohler Arts Center Chief Curator and exhibition curator, told a group of media touring the exhibition in May. 'These landscapes that seem completely overgrown, what does this jungle remember of that time? (Pao was) thinking about how she can really bring people into these images and into the jungle with her.'
The jungle remembers it all. The agony. The fear. So do the people, like Pao's father, who lived it. Even if, like most survivors of war and trauma, they don't wish to constantly relive it.
'(Pao says) it's not something her family talked a lot about,' Throckmorton said. 'There's generations of people here that their families don't talk about this experience of being forced to flee, and what it's like to move to the United States. This work conjures a lot of memories for people.'
Not good ones.
Another of Pao's not good memories is shared through an enormous, wall-sized video paired with a haunting HMong kwv txhiaj , song poetry.
'She's never shown this one before because unbeknownst to her, the videographer had shared with the singers that Pao's husband had very recently, tragically, passed away at a young age,' Throckmorton explained. 'So the singers, what you hear in HMong is them singing from the perspective of Pao and her husband, across life and death. It's an incredibly moving song.' Artwork In A Courtroom
Pao Houa Her, 'untitled,' My Mother's Flowers series, 2016; lightbox. Courtesy of the artist and Bockley Gallery. John Michael Kohler Arts Center
'The Imaginative Landscape' in Sheboygan moves visitors around town, most remarkably to an active courtroom at the Sheboygan County Courthouse where Her shows images from the series After the Fall of HMong Tebchaw (2017). The series of black-and-white photographs reflect on the historic loss of 'tebchaw' (homeland) and a more recent scandal in which a Minnesota HMong man swindled nearly $4 million from elders by claiming he was negotiating government-backed land purchases in Laos to create a HMong country.
Judge Natasha Torry, a JMKAC board member, presides over the courtroom. She welcomed in the artworks.
'I have always been interested in the idea of the court being a community center,' Torry told Forbes.com. 'Originally, I was a municipal court judge, and that's referred to as a community based alternative to the criminal justice system. I've tried to do things like have restorative justice. There was a discussion of (having) this exhibition and they were looking for places that are not typically where you would have art being displayed.'
Torry's candidly dumpy, dingy, dated, wood panel lined courtroom allowed for the placement of contemporary art and the banging of nails into walls which would have been forbidden in one of the ornate ground floor courtrooms.
'I've had HMong people make comments and appreciate it,' Torry said. 'Almost right when it was up, I had a HMong defendant sentenced for something, and they even said, 'Judge, thank you for the art.'' 'The Imaginative Landscape' in San José
Pao Houa Her, 'My grandmother's favorite grandchild – Pao Houa' from 'My grandfather turned into a tiger' series, 2017. Courtesy of the artist and Bockley Gallery.
Her's San José Museum of Art presentation is a more typical museum exhibition weaving together California's agricultural landscapes with the jungles of Laos and Minnesota poppy fields, offering a compelling exploration of migration, labor, and identity. These issues are deeply intertwined with California's history and evolving cultural landscape.
The exhibition includes a series of large-scale light boxes showcasing images of Mount Shasta's landscape in Northern California. This is an area where HMong farmers, drawing upon ancestral knowledge of highland opium cultivation, have adapted their skills to cannabis farming amid the so-called 'Green Rush.' More From Forbes Forbes Ogden Museum Of Southern Art In New Orleans Commemorates 50th Anniversary Of Fall Of Saigon By Chadd Scott Forbes Midwestern Grotto Tradition Celebrated In Sheboygan, Wisconsin By Chadd Scott Forbes San José Museum Of Art Introduces Dedicated Permanent Collection Galleries By Chadd Scott
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
REUTERS NEXT - Singapore must develop deeper relationships with China, US, Europe: home affairs minister
SINGAPORE (Reuters) -In a multipolar world, small countries like Singapore have to develop even deeper relationships with other nations, Singapore's Home Affairs Minister K Shanmugam said on Wednesday. "There are more powers playing the game as it were, as opposed to the time when the Americans held the peace across the world. So that's changing, and in such a context, small countries like us have to develop even deeper relationships," said Shanmugam, pointing to China, the United States and Europe. Shanmugam, who is also coordinating minister for national security, was speaking in an interview at the Reuters NEXT Asia summit in Singapore that covered trade issues as well as domestic concerns such as a fake news law. On trade, Shanmugam said the U.S. was an indispensable nation and its policies impact "every country, allies and non-allies alike", especially for a trade-reliant country like Singapore where external trade is 3 to 4 times its GDP. On Monday, U.S. President Donald Trump sent letters to 14 countries, including allies Japan and South Korea, notifying them of tariffs of 25% to 40% that will kick in from August 1. In the letters, Trump warned that reprisals from countries would draw a like-for-like response. Meanwhile, China threatened to retaliate against nations that strike deals with the U.S. to cut China out of supply chains. Singapore has not received a letter from the Trump administration this round. In April on what Trump called "Liberation Day", Singapore was hit with a 10% baseline tariff, lower than its Southeast Asian neighbours, but high enough to harm the economy said the Singapore government. The trade ministry in April downgraded the nation's GDP forecast for 2025 to 0%-2% growth from 1%-3% after the U.S. announced tariffs. The U.S. had a goods trade surplus of $2.8 billion with Singapore last year, an 84.8% increase over 2023, according to the United States Trade Representative website. The city-state's data, which includes services, showed the U.S. trade surplus with Singapore amounted to $30 billion in 2024. The U.S. accounted for 11% of Singapore's exports in 2024 and about 55% of shipments would be hit with the baseline 10% tariff, estimated the central bank. To view the live broadcast of the World Stage go to the Reuters LIVE page:


New York Post
5 hours ago
- New York Post
FBI launches criminal investigations of John Brennan, James Comey over Trump-Russia probe: DOJ sources
Former CIA Director John Brennan and former FBI Director James Comey are under criminal investigation for potential wrongdoing related to the Trump–Russia probe, including allegedly making false statements to Congress, Justice Department sources told Fox News Digital. CIA Director John Ratcliffe referred evidence of wrongdoing by Brennan to FBI Director Kash Patel for potential prosecution, DOJ sources told Fox News Digital. The sources said that the referral was received and told Fox News Digital that a criminal investigation into Brennan was opened and is underway. DOJ sources declined to provide further details. It is unclear, at this point, if the investigation spans beyond his alleged false statements to Congress. As for Comey, DOJ sources told Fox News Digital that an investigation into the former director is underway, but could not share details of what specifically is being probed. The full scope of the criminal investigations into Brennan and Comey is unclear, but two sources described the FBI's view of the duo's interactions as a 'conspiracy,' which could open up a wide range of potential prosecutorial options. The FBI and CIA declined to comment. 7 James Comey is surrounded by reporters after testifying to the House Judiciary and Oversight and Government Reform committees at the Rayburn House Office Building on Capitol Hill December 07, 2018 in Washington, DC. Getty Images Neither Brennan nor Comey immediately responded to Fox News Digital's request for comment. The Brennan investigation comes after Ratcliffe last week declassified a 'lessons learned' review of the creation of the 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment (ICA). The 2017 ICA alleged Russia sought to influence the 2016 presidential election to help then-candidate Donald Trump. But the review found that the process of the ICA's creation was rushed with 'procedural anomalies,' and that officials diverted from intelligence standards. It also determined that the 'decision by agency heads to include the Steele Dossier in the ICA ran counter to fundamental tradecraft principles and ultimately undermined the credibility of a key judgment.' The dossier — an anti-Trump document filled with unverified and wholly inaccurate claims that was commissioned by Fusion GPS and paid for by Democrat presidential candidate Hillary Clinton's campaign and the DNC — has been widely discredited. Last week's review marks the first time career CIA officials have acknowledged politicization of the process by which the ICA was written, particularly by Obama-era political appointees. Records declassified as part of that review further revealed that Brennan did, in fact, push for the dossier to be included in the 2017 ICA. 7 Former Director of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) John Brennan testifies before the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence on Capitol Hill, May 23, 2017 in Washington, DC. Getty Images Brennan testified to the House Judiciary Committee in May 2023, however, that he did not believe the dossier should be included in that intelligence product. Ratcliffe was not surprised by the review's findings, a source familiar told Fox News Digital, given the director's long history of criticizing Brennan's politicization of intelligence. But Ratcliffe was compelled to refer aspects of Brennan's involvement to the FBI for review of possible criminality, the source said. The source was unable to share the sensitive details of Ratcliffe's criminal referral to the FBI with Fox News Digital, but said that Brennan 'violated the public's trust and should be held accountable for it.' The false statements portion of the probe stems from a newly declassified email sent to Brennan by the former deputy CIA director in December 2016. That message said that including the dossier in the ICA in any capacity jeopardized 'the credibility of the entire paper.' 'Despite these objections, Brennan showed a preference for narrative consistency over analytical soundness,' the new CIA review states. 'When confronted with specific flaws in the Dossier by the two mission center leaders – one with extensive operational experience and the other with a strong analytic background – he appeared more swayed by the Dossier's general conformity with existing theories than by legitimate tradecraft concerns.' The review added: 'Brennan ultimately formalized his position in writing, stating that 'my bottomline is that I believe that the information warrants inclusion in the report.'' 7 US Attorney General Pam Bondi and FBI Director Kash Patel walk to attend a press conference to make an announcement in connection with a child sex abuse enforcement action, in Washington, D.C., U.S., May 7, 2025. REUTERS But Brennan testified the opposite in front of Congress in May 2023. 'The CIA was very much opposed to having any reference or inclusion of the Steele dossier in the Intelligence Community Assessment,' Brennan testified before the House committee, according to the transcript of his deposition reviewed by Fox News Digital. 'And so they sent over a copy of the dossier to say that this was going to be separate from the rest of that assessment.' CIA officials at the time of its creation pushed back against the FBI, which sought to include the dossier, arguing that the dossier should not be included in the assessment, and casting it as simply 'internet rumor.' Ultimately, Steele's reporting was not included in the body of the final ICA prepared for then-President Barack Obama, but instead detailed in this footnote, 'largely at the insistence of FBI's senior leadership,' according to a review by the Justice Department inspector general, and later, the Senate Intelligence Committee. But back in June 2020, Ratcliffe, while serving as director of national intelligence, declassified a footnote of the 2017 ICA, which revealed that the reporting of Trump dossier author Christopher Steele had only 'limited corroboration' regarding whether then-President-elect Trump 'knowingly worked with Russian officials to bolster his chances of beating' Hillary Clinton and other claims. The footnote, also known as 'Annex A' of the 2017 ICA, exclusively obtained by Fox News Digital in June 2020, spanned less than two pages and detailed reporting by Steele, the former British spy who authored the unverified anti-Trump dossier — a document that helped serve as the basis for controversial Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) warrants obtained against former Trump campaign aide Carter Page. 7 FBI Director James Comey (L) and CIA Director John Brennan (R) take their seats flanking National Intelligence Director James Clapper during a Senate Intelligence Committee hearing in Washington, USA on February 9, 2016. Getty Images Steele's reporting, at the time, was commissioned by opposition research firm Fusion GPS and funded by the Clinton campaign and the Democratic National Committee (DNC) through law firm Perkins Coie. The footnote made clear the internal concerns officials had over that document. 'An FBI source (Steele) using both identified and unidentified subsources, volunteered highly politically sensitive information from the summer to the fall of 2016 on Russian influence efforts aimed at the US presidential election,' the annex read. 'We have only limited corroboration of the source's reporting in this case and did not use it to reach the analytic conclusions of the CIA/FBI/NSA assessment.' 'The source collected this information on behalf of private clients and was not compensated for it by the FBI,' it continued. But the annex notes that Steele's reporting was 'not developed by the layered subsource network.' 7 FBI Director Kash Patel speaks during a news conference at the Manassas FBI Field Office, March 27, 2025, in Manassas, VA. AP 'The FBI source caveated that, although similar to previously provided reporting in terms of content, the source was unable to vouch for the additional information's sourcing and accuracy,' the annex states. 'Hence this information is not included in this product.' Justice Department Inspector General Michael Horowitz also reviewed the inclusion of Steele's reporting in the ICA during his review of alleged misconduct related to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, or FISA. His report, released in late 2019, found that there were 'significant inaccuracies and omissions' in FISA warrants for former Trump campaign aide Page. Those warrants relied heavily on Steele's reporting, despite the FBI not having had specific information corroborating allegations against Page that were included in Steele's reporting. Meanwhile, Fox News Digital exclusively reported in October 2020 that Brennan briefed former President Obama and administration officials on intelligence that then-Democrat nominee former Secretary of State Clinton was stirring up a plan to tie Trump to Russia. Ratcliffe, as director of national intelligence, declassified Brennan's handwritten notes memorializing that meeting, which were exclusively obtained by Fox News Digital in October 2020. On July 28, 2016, Brennan briefed Obama on a plan from one of Clinton's campaign foreign policy advisors 'to vilify Donald Trump by stirring up a scandal claiming interference by the Russian security service.' Comey, then-Vice President Joe Biden, former Attorney General Loretta Lynch and former Director of National Intelligence James Clapper were in the Brennan-Obama briefing. After that briefing, the CIA properly forwarded that information through a Counterintelligence Operational Lead (CIOL) to Comey and then-Deputy Assistant Director of Counterintelligence Peter Strzok, with the subject line: 'Crossfire Hurricane.' Fox News Digital exclusively obtained and reported on the CIOL in October 2020, which stated: 'The following information is provided for the exclusive use of your bureau for background investigative action or lead purposes as appropriate.' 7 The logo of the FBI is seen at the Los Angeles Federal Building on June 4, 2025, in Los Angeles. AFP via Getty Images 'Per FBI verbal request, CIA provides the below examples of information the CROSSFIRE HURRICANE fusion cell has gleaned to date,' the memo continued. 'An exchange (REDACTED) discussing US presidential candidate Hillary Clinton's approval of a plan concerning US presidential candidate Donald Trump and Russian hackers hampering US elections as a means of distracting the public from her use of a private email server.' The FBI on July 31, 2016, opened a counterintelligence investigation into whether candidate Trump and members of his campaign were colluding or coordinating with Russia to influence the 2016 campaign. That investigation was referred to inside the bureau as 'Crossfire Hurricane.' Former Special Counsel Robert Mueller was appointed to take over the FBI's original 'Crossfire Hurricane' investigation. After nearly two years, Mueller's investigation, which concluded in March 2019, yielded no evidence of criminal conspiracy or coordination between the Trump campaign and Russian officials during the 2016 presidential election. Shortly after, John Durham was appointed as special counsel to investigate the origins of the 'Crossfire Hurricane' probe. Durham found that the FBI 'failed to act' on a 'clear warning sign' that the bureau was the 'target' of a Clinton-led effort to 'manipulate or influence the law enforcement process for political purposes' ahead of the 2016 presidential election. 'The aforementioned facts reflect a rather startling and inexplicable failure to adequately consider and incorporate the Clinton Plan intelligence into the FBI's investigative decision-making in the Crossfire Hurricane investigation,' Durham's report states. 'Indeed, had the FBI opened the Crossfire Hurricane investigation as an assessment and, in turn, gathered and analyzed data in concert with the information from the Clinton Plan intelligence, it is likely that the information received would have been examined, at a minimum, with a more critical eye,' the report continued. 7 FBI Director James Comey, CIA Director John Brennan and Director of National Intelligence James Clapper attend U.S. President Barack Obama's speech about the NSA at the Justice Department in Washington January 17, 2014. REUTERS Durham, in his report, said the FBI 'failed to act on what should have been—when combined with other incontrovertible facts— a clear warning sign that the FBI might then be the target of an effort to manipulate or influence the law enforcement process for political purposes during the 2016 presidential election.' Meanwhile, the White House wants the Obama-era intelligence officials to be held accountable. 'President Trump was right — again,' White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said in a statement to Fox News Digital. 'Those who engaged in this political scandal must be held accountable for the fraud they committed against President Trump and the lies they told to the American people.'


Fox News
5 hours ago
- Fox News
FBI launches criminal investigations of John Brennan, James Comey: DOJ sources
EXCLUSIVE: Former CIA Director John Brennan and former FBI Director James Comey are under criminal investigation for potential wrongdoing related to the Trump–Russia probe, including allegedly making false statements to Congress, Justice Department sources told Fox News Digital. CIA Director John Ratcliffe referred evidence of wrongdoing by Brennan to FBI Director Kash Patel for potential prosecution, DOJ sources told Fox News Digital. The sources said that the referral was received and told Fox News Digital that a criminal investigation into Brennan was opened and is underway. DOJ sources declined to provide further details. It is unclear, at this point, if the investigation spans beyond his alleged false statements to Congress. As for Comey, DOJ sources told Fox News Digital that an investigation into the former director is underway, but could not share details of what specifically is being probed. The full scope of the criminal investigations into Brennan and Comey is unclear, but two sources described the FBI's view of the duo's interactions as a "conspiracy," which could open up a wide range of potential prosecutorial options. The FBI and CIA declined to comment. Neither Brennan nor Comey immediately responded to Fox News Digital's request for comment. The Brennan investigation comes after Ratcliffe last week declassified a "lessons learned" review of the creation of the 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment (ICA). The 2017 ICA alleged Russia sought to influence the 2016 presidential election to help then-candidate Donald Trump. But the review found that the process of the ICA's creation was rushed with "procedural anomalies," and that officials diverted from intelligence standards. It also determined that the "decision by agency heads to include the Steele Dossier in the ICA ran counter to fundamental tradecraft principles and ultimately undermined the credibility of a key judgment." The dossier — an anti-Trump document filled with unverified and wholly inaccurate claims that was commissioned by Fusion GPS and paid for by Democrat presidential candidate Hillary Clinton's campaign and the DNC — has been widely discredited. Last week's review marks the first time career CIA officials have acknowledged politicization of the process by which the ICA was written, particularly by Obama-era political appointees. Records declassified as part of that review further revealed that Brennan did, in fact, push for the dossier to be included in the 2017 ICA. Brennan testified to the House Judiciary Committee in May 2023, however, that he did not believe the dossier should be included in that intelligence product. Ratcliffe was not surprised by the review's findings, a source familiar told Fox News Digital, given the director's long history of criticizing Brennan's politicization of intelligence. But Ratcliffe was compelled to refer aspects of Brennan's involvement to the FBI for review of possible criminality, the source said. The source was unable to share the sensitive details of Ratcliffe's criminal referral to the FBI with Fox News Digital, but said that Brennan "violated the public's trust and should be held accountable for it." The false statements portion of the probe stems from a newly declassified email sent to Brennan by the former deputy CIA director in December 2016. That message said that including the dossier in the ICA in any capacity jeopardized "the credibility of the entire paper." "Despite these objections, Brennan showed a preference for narrative consistency over analytical soundness," the new CIA review states. "When confronted with specific flaws in the Dossier by the two mission center leaders – one with extensive operational experience and the other with a strong analytic background – he appeared more swayed by the Dossier's general conformity with existing theories than by legitimate tradecraft concerns." The review added: "Brennan ultimately formalized his position in writing, stating that 'my bottomline is that I believe that the information warrants inclusion in the report.'" But Brennan testified the opposite in front of Congress in May 2023. "The CIA was very much opposed to having any reference or inclusion of the Steele dossier in the Intelligence Community Assessment," Brennan testified before the House committee, according to the transcript of his deposition reviewed by Fox News Digital. "And so they sent over a copy of the dossier to say that this was going to be separate from the rest of that assessment." CIA officials at the time of its creation pushed back against the FBI, which sought to include the dossier, arguing that the dossier should not be included in the assessment, and casting it as simply "internet rumor." Ultimately, Steele's reporting was not included in the body of the final ICA prepared for then-President Barack Obama, but instead detailed in this footnote, "largely at the insistence of FBI's senior leadership," according to a review by the Justice Department inspector general, and later, the Senate Intelligence Committee. But back in June 2020, Ratcliffe, while serving as director of national intelligence, declassified a footnote of the 2017 ICA, which revealed that the reporting of Trump dossier author Christopher Steele had only "limited corroboration" regarding whether then-President-elect Trump "knowingly worked with Russian officials to bolster his chances of beating" Hillary Clinton and other claims. The footnote, also known as "Annex A" of the 2017 ICA, exclusively obtained by Fox News Digital in June 2020, spanned less than two pages and detailed reporting by Steele, the former British spy who authored the unverified anti-Trump dossier — a document that helped serve as the basis for controversial Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) warrants obtained against former Trump campaign aide Carter Page. Steele's reporting, at the time, was commissioned by opposition research firm Fusion GPS and funded by the Clinton campaign and the Democratic National Committee (DNC) through law firm Perkins Coie. The footnote made clear the internal concerns officials had over that document. "An FBI source (Steele) using both identified and unidentified subsources, volunteered highly politically sensitive information from the summer to the fall of 2016 on Russian influence efforts aimed at the US presidential election," the annex read. "We have only limited corroboration of the source's reporting in this case and did not use it to reach the analytic conclusions of the CIA/FBI/NSA assessment." "The source collected this information on behalf of private clients and was not compensated for it by the FBI," it continued. But the annex notes that Steele's reporting was "not developed by the layered subsource network." "The FBI source caveated that, although similar to previously provided reporting in terms of content, the source was unable to vouch for the additional information's sourcing and accuracy," the annex states. "Hence this information is not included in this product." Justice Department Inspector General Michael Horowitz also reviewed the inclusion of Steele's reporting in the ICA during his review of alleged misconduct related to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, or FISA. His report, released in late 2019, found that there were "significant inaccuracies and omissions" in FISA warrants for former Trump campaign aide Page. Those warrants relied heavily on Steele's reporting, despite the FBI not having had specific information corroborating allegations against Page that were included in Steele's reporting. Meanwhile, Fox News Digital exclusively reported in October 2020 that Brennan briefed former President Obama and administration officials on intelligence that then-Democrat nominee former Secretary of State Clinton was stirring up a plan to tie Trump to Russia. Ratcliffe, as director of national intelligence, declassified Brennan's handwritten notes memorializing that meeting, which were exclusively obtained by Fox News Digital in October 2020. On July 28, 2016, Brennan briefed Obama on a plan from one of Clinton's campaign foreign policy advisors "to vilify Donald Trump by stirring up a scandal claiming interference by the Russian security service." Comey, then-Vice President Joe Biden, former Attorney General Loretta Lynch and former Director of National Intelligence James Clapper were in the Brennan-Obama briefing. After that briefing, the CIA properly forwarded that information through a Counterintelligence Operational Lead (CIOL) to Comey and then-Deputy Assistant Director of Counterintelligence Peter Strzok, with the subject line: "Crossfire Hurricane." Fox News Digital exclusively obtained and reported on the CIOL in October 2020, which stated: "The following information is provided for the exclusive use of your bureau for background investigative action or lead purposes as appropriate." "Per FBI verbal request, CIA provides the below examples of information the CROSSFIRE HURRICANE fusion cell has gleaned to date," the memo continued. "An exchange (REDACTED) discussing US presidential candidate Hillary Clinton's approval of a plan concerning US presidential candidate Donald Trump and Russian hackers hampering US elections as a means of distracting the public from her use of a private email server." The FBI on July 31, 2016, opened a counterintelligence investigation into whether candidate Trump and members of his campaign were colluding or coordinating with Russia to influence the 2016 campaign. That investigation was referred to inside the bureau as "Crossfire Hurricane." Former Special Counsel Robert Mueller was appointed to take over the FBI's original "Crossfire Hurricane" investigation. After nearly two years, Mueller's investigation, which concluded in March 2019, yielded no evidence of criminal conspiracy or coordination between the Trump campaign and Russian officials during the 2016 presidential election. Shortly after, John Durham was appointed as special counsel to investigate the origins of the "Crossfire Hurricane" probe. Durham found that the FBI "failed to act" on a "clear warning sign" that the bureau was the "target" of a Clinton-led effort to "manipulate or influence the law enforcement process for political purposes" ahead of the 2016 presidential election. "The aforementioned facts reflect a rather startling and inexplicable failure to adequately consider and incorporate the Clinton Plan intelligence into the FBI's investigative decision-making in the Crossfire Hurricane investigation," Durham's report states. "Indeed, had the FBI opened the Crossfire Hurricane investigation as an assessment and, in turn, gathered and analyzed data in concert with the information from the Clinton Plan intelligence, it is likely that the information received would have been examined, at a minimum, with a more critical eye," the report continued. Durham, in his report, said the FBI "failed to act on what should have been—when combined with other incontrovertible facts— a clear warning sign that the FBI might then be the target of an effort to manipulate or influence the law enforcement process for political purposes during the 2016 presidential election." Meanwhile, the White House wants the Obama-era intelligence officials to be held accountable. "President Trump was right — again," White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said in a statement to Fox News Digital. "Those who engaged in this political scandal must be held accountable for the fraud they committed against President Trump and the lies they told to the American people."