Oisín O'Neill: Kieran McGeeney's issue not with rules but constant tweaks
This week saw the contentious 50m penalty for impeding a kickout mark buried before the commencement of the All-Ireland SFC knockout phase.
This, despite earlier assurances in the wake of the league that the rules were set in stone for the rest of 2025, at least.
Central Council voted - by 39 votes to one - to remove the 50m mark and replace with an on-the-spot free.
On Saturday, it was confirmed that the FRC had proposed the abolition of the 50m penalty with immediate effect. Following his side's narrow defeat to Galway in Kingspan Breffni that evening, McGeeney lashed out at the decision to enact changes at a relatively late stage in the championship.
"Some teams tell them to do something, I'd love that direct line," McGeeney said after the game. "Whoever has that direct line into Jim (Gavin) and Eamonn (Fitzmaurice), I would love that."
Following the Cork-Kerry game in Round 2 of the group stage, both managers had criticised the 50m mark, with Jack O'Connor labelling it "ridiculous" and saying it was "going to have to be tidied up."
While McGeeney has a reputation for being hostile to the FRC changes, O'Neill insists it's just the constant tweaking which was proving a headache for managers and players.
"I think Kieran's biggest issue with them is they constantly change. We played half the league and they changed them," O'Neill said, at the launch of the All-Ireland SFC knockout stage.
"They're talking about another change this week. There's four rounds of the championship left!
"I think Kieran has no issue with the rules. It's more just that they're continuously changing.
"As players, that's frustrating because you're working on one thing one week and then it might change."
After five rounds of the league, the FRC introduced a major tweak, with teams now obliged to keep four players in their own half at all times to prevent the roaming goalkeeper functioning as an extra man in attack.
"We probably had to tweak a few things that we've been working on and change certain things that we were trying to work on," O'Neill said. "Such as the mark, you know, you had to hold your hands up after going up and now you're being told you've five steps or whatever."
As to whether he agreed with the kickout mark, O'Neill said it was fine as long as referees allowed players to compete for the ball.
"I think if it's refereed in the spirit that the rules intended, you have to allow a little bit of leeway like for players to compete for the ball, but I think it's a reflection of how well coached you are.
"And we were punished severely by it at the weekend, and it's something that we wouldn't be happy with."
Follow a live blog on the All-Ireland Football Championship on Saturday and Sunday on rte.ie/sport and the RTÉ News app. Listen to updates on Saturday Sport and Sunday Sport on RTÉ Radio 1. Watch highlights on The Saturday Game at 9.15pm and The Sunday Game from 9.30pm on RTÉ2 and RTÉ Player.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Paula Hynes: The championship of dreams - and it's not the hurling
Life certainly is a rollercoaster and we always try to do our best and ride the ups and downs. It was all systems go in preparing for the YMA National Finals. However, I also had a hospital appointment looming, which weighed heavily on both my shoulders and Pete's. I spent the Saturday of the All-Ireland hurling final in the Mater Private in Cork for a procedure; the staff, nurses and consultants in there are phenomenal, and thankfully, a huge weight was lifted from our shoulders. The work never stops, so there was no time on Sunday to watch the Cork hurlers in action. It was a case of ensuring the full team of heifers were clipped and washed and all the gear and feed was packed so we were ready for the trip to Kilkenny. With seven heifers travelling, Robert Shannon arrived in our yard at lunchtime on Monday to collect four of our heifers, as Pete had the three bigger heifers and gear on our trailer; it is true peace of mind knowing Robert was taking them and they would arrive safely. The crew arrived in Kilkenny to vet inspections, got washed and fed, and the team stand ready, before bedtime with two hectic days of showing ahead. With the Cork YMA team working hard on Tuesday morning, the day kicked off with the individual and team clipping competitions. Cattle fitter Paul Murphy was judging, a highly experienced clipper and with the competitors clipping against the clock, the pressure was on. Stephen Shannon and Gearoid Long flew the Cork flag high, winning the team clipping competition, and then Becky followed the success, claiming the Individual title. It was a win that meant so much to Becky, as she has clipped so many animals, but had never clipped by herself in public or in competition. Showmanship time at National finals is always a lot of pressure with so many top-class handlers and even busier with us having six of our heifers being part of the Cork team. Anna Stable was officiating as showmanship judge, a highly accomplished HYB handler over the years, and she has also judged showmanship at the highest level. Cork handlers started off the novice classes with great success, and then Georgie followed up with a second place in the Junior showmanship. She had the misfortune that her calf got stubborn and would not walk, but we were so proud to see her battle on and hold her nerve to get such a high placing in a big class. Becky chose Rouge as her heifer for the senior showmanship, finishing in second place with fellow Cork handler Sarah Shannon in third place. Cork handler Kevin Smith took our Crushable Sapphire heifer for the mature showmanship class and added another win for the Cork team. Sapphire is the heifer Becky used for the clipping competition earlier in the day, a heifer we took to Expo in April, where Georgie won the Junior showmanship and also placed second in her heifer class. She hadn't been out at a show since April, as the decision was made then to put her away for the clipping competition. The grand finale for day one was the showmanship championship. Anna Stable selected her final five and finally tapped out Manus Murphy from the Carlow Kilkenny club as champion handler, Becky claimed reserve champion handler with Kevin Smith taking honourable mention. Cork may have faltered in the hurling, but they certainly made up for it in the showmanship, with Cork YMA lifting the perpetual cup for the best team of handlers. Day two Day two of the National Finals was an early start at 5.30am as we had six heifers to show. Fed, washed and on the show line for 7am as the task ahead was to keep them eating and line them up in turn at the clipping crate for Richard Jones, who was topping and prepping for us. Richard has been an integral part of the team here for some time. Torben Melbaum from Germany, officiating as judge, has vast experience in Holstein genetics globally and has also coached at European Young Breeders in Battice. Kalani was first in the ring for the colourbreed junior calf and claimed top spot. Jones Holsteins took the win in the intermediate colourbreed class and then Kalani, full sister to Khaleesi, won the senior colourbreed class. The first championship of the day and Jones Victorious Cola was tapped out as Colourbreed champion, with Kalani standing as Reserve champion and Khaleesi taking Honourable mention. Moving on to the Holstein classes, which are always big classes at Nationals, Georgie showed Acorn into sixth place in the Intermediate calf class. Becky was straight into the next class to take fifth place with Jagerbomb in the Senior calf class and then handed Jagerbomb to Pete as she was showing Rouge straight away in the Summer Yearling class. From the moment she walked into the ring, she knew Torben liked Rouge, and she was right as Rouge won the class and the judge commented that she was an easy winner of the class. A brief chance to get Rouge a drink and grab one herself before the Red and White holstein championship, Torben selected four heifers for his final line-up and eventually tapped out Rouge as Red and White champion, a momentous show for us and still one more roll of the dice ahead as Rouge was also eligible as class winner for the overall heifer championship. The hottest Holstien championship of the season, with 14 heifers in the ring, the judge cast his eye across each heifer as they entered the ring, made his final comments and tapped forward five heifers for his final line-up, Rouge amongst the final five and as the crowd clapped. Torben circled his final line-up and then ran down to high five Becky with Rouge as his overall champion heifer of the show, Jones Holsteins claimed Reserve and Honourable went to the two Caught A Vibe heifers which are full sisters. A championship we had only dreamed of winning had now become a reality. We are so grateful to all the team who have played a part, Richard, who is always by our side, Pauric, who had been at the qualifier with us and all who help manage and keep the heifers healthy and fit at home. It means so much to us seeing Rouge achieve success, she is backed by a world-class pedigree, her dam Duckett Ranger 1132 was scored VG87 just last week having produced almost 15,000kg in her first lactation. A full sister to Duckett Ranger was max score VG89 on the same day and the grand dam SSI Doc Have Not ET or simply Doc as she is known globally, the $1.925 million cow, was classified EX94 as a four-year-old with an EX96 mammary and is a proven transmitter. Rouge has made another step on her journey. There is a long road with plenty of hard work, but hopefully we will take her to the next stage of being a great cow.
The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Kilkenny GAA Chairman speaks out about ‘extreme frustration' over scoreboard error in Tipperary defeat
THE Kilkenny GAA chairman PJ Kenny has spoken out on Noel McGrath's ghost point against the Cats. In Advertisement 3 It was McGrath's 70th minute shot that caused the controversy 3 Kilkenny have failed to reach the All-Ireland final for the second year in-a-row 3 PJ Kenny has been the Kilkenny GAA chairman for a number of years now McGrath had taken a shot from near the Cusack stand sideline which was However, the Croke Park scoreboard operator had added the wide as a point to Tipp on the in-stadium scoreboard, extending their supposed lead from two points to three points which With four minutes of added time left to play after the incident the Cats had been shooting for goals rather than points due to believing they were three points down when they were in fact trailing by just two points. There had been radio silence from the Kilkenny county board and players following the match until yesterday when Kenny appeared on local radio station Advertisement Read more on GAA Speaking three weeks after the incident, the Kilkenny chairman said: 'There was communication that evening after the match. "There was extreme frustration from the players, management, and county board, and all the fans, as well, who paid to go to the match. 'There was deep frustration, we were in talks with Croke Park from the very start of that evening. We knew it was never going to a replay. There's no rule that allows for that, and we were told that fairly straightaway. 'We talked to them, but we didn't want it broadcast all over the front pages. We did talk to Croke Park regularly on the Sunday and Monday and we looked for an explanation." Advertisement Most read in GAA Football Kenny - who was ratified as chairperson back in January - hadn't pushed the issue to the media yet as he did not want to kick up a fuss before the All-Ireland final. A media meltdown would have taken away from the occasion between Cork and Tipperary and that was something Kenny did not want to do. David Clifford's son adorably hijacks RTE interview after dad dominates All-Ireland final Kenny added: 'We were also conscious as well that Tipperary and Cork were in the All-Ireland final and there was no point in taking away from their day. 'There was nothing to be gained from it that way, but we were in talks, Croke Park took full responsibility, they wrote a letter which we actually read out at the county board meeting the Monday after. Advertisement 'They took full responsibility and issued an apology, particularly they felt for the players and management. "They are the people who put in the most effort, so it wasn't an easy time. There's nothing we could do. They said they are putting procedures in place. 'All I can say is Tipperary won the All-Ireland and they were well worthy. Congratulations to them. It was disappointing for us, but there's nothing much we can do now.' Kenny suggested a change to the rules and also promised to put pressure on the GAA in the future to ensure an incident like this does not occur again in the future. Advertisement 'In Croke Park, there is about six people on the sideline there, the referee's report had the score in at 4-20 to 0-30 and we were sent on a copy of that, so immediately that's the score you go by. 'Just human error was basically the cause; whoever was on the scoreboard put up that extra point. 'Maybe I think when you have HawkEye you should be able to link it all in and be able to check for scores straight away, I don't know how they can't stop play. 'They say they're looking at procedures and we will enquire about them going forward, we won't just let that go. We need to so that it won't happen again, because it is was a very stressful time.' Advertisement 'When you're a player and you're chasing a lead, it does affect your decision-making. 'The players were kept in touch. Credit to the players, they didn't go out on the media either, looking to make a story either. They are the most important people in this.'
RTÉ News
3 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Shelbourne striker Kate Mooney wins monthly award after run of goals
Shelbourne forward Kate Mooney has been named as the SSE Airtricity Women's Premier Division Player of the Month for June and July. The Dubliner is leading the Golden Boot race with 12 goals that have helped to keep Eoin Wearen's team just three points behind champions Athlone Town at the top of the table. Mooney was in brilliant form across the last two months, which was highlighted by her brace in the win away to Peamount United and her hat-trick in the victory against Sligo Rovers. The 26-year-old has certainly found her groove in front of goal but her overall play has made her stand out and it's what her team-mates will be quick to point to when lavishing praise on her. Mooney, though, feels that she is performing well because The Reds are performing well together. "It is all about the team. I have worked very hard individually this season and I am reaping the awards at the moment and the hard work is paying off," said Mooney. "Every game we're growing as a team; we're learning a lot about each other. We've had a few injuries at the moment so we're having to battle that and find different ways of playing against different opposition. It's only going to make us better. "Eoin Wearen has pulled me aside a few times this year if I haven't been scoring for a few games and he says 'Kate, you're starting for many more reasons than just your goalscoring'. "I work very hard, track back, win a lot of balls, win a lot of headers and I feel I'm always a threat but if I can help make someone else score to win the game then that's even better. "I think we know each other so well as a team so we know what each individual needs. That is hugely important. I set my target to score three goals every five games and I've been okay at achieving it but honestly I'd have liked to score more and provided more assists as I know I have a lot more in me, but sometimes I have to play the other side of my game to help the team." Mooney becomes the eighth different Shelbourne player to win this monthly award and was voted ahead of Athlone Town defender Kayleigh Shine and DLR Waves forward Michelle Doonan. She is currently awaiting news on an injury sustained in the All-Ireland Cup defeat to Bohemians last Saturday.
