
Oisín O'Neill: Kieran McGeeney's issue not with rules but constant tweaks
This week saw the contentious 50m penalty for impeding a kickout mark buried before the commencement of the All-Ireland SFC knockout phase.
This, despite earlier assurances in the wake of the league that the rules were set in stone for the rest of 2025, at least.
Central Council voted - by 39 votes to one - to remove the 50m mark and replace with an on-the-spot free.
On Saturday, it was confirmed that the FRC had proposed the abolition of the 50m penalty with immediate effect. Following his side's narrow defeat to Galway in Kingspan Breffni that evening, McGeeney lashed out at the decision to enact changes at a relatively late stage in the championship.
"Some teams tell them to do something, I'd love that direct line," McGeeney said after the game. "Whoever has that direct line into Jim (Gavin) and Eamonn (Fitzmaurice), I would love that."
Following the Cork-Kerry game in Round 2 of the group stage, both managers had criticised the 50m mark, with Jack O'Connor labelling it "ridiculous" and saying it was "going to have to be tidied up."
While McGeeney has a reputation for being hostile to the FRC changes, O'Neill insists it's just the constant tweaking which was proving a headache for managers and players.
"I think Kieran's biggest issue with them is they constantly change. We played half the league and they changed them," O'Neill said, at the launch of the All-Ireland SFC knockout stage.
"They're talking about another change this week. There's four rounds of the championship left!
"I think Kieran has no issue with the rules. It's more just that they're continuously changing.
"As players, that's frustrating because you're working on one thing one week and then it might change."
After five rounds of the league, the FRC introduced a major tweak, with teams now obliged to keep four players in their own half at all times to prevent the roaming goalkeeper functioning as an extra man in attack.
"We probably had to tweak a few things that we've been working on and change certain things that we were trying to work on," O'Neill said. "Such as the mark, you know, you had to hold your hands up after going up and now you're being told you've five steps or whatever."
As to whether he agreed with the kickout mark, O'Neill said it was fine as long as referees allowed players to compete for the ball.
"I think if it's refereed in the spirit that the rules intended, you have to allow a little bit of leeway like for players to compete for the ball, but I think it's a reflection of how well coached you are.
"And we were punished severely by it at the weekend, and it's something that we wouldn't be happy with."
Follow a live blog on the All-Ireland Football Championship on Saturday and Sunday on rte.ie/sport and the RTÉ News app. Listen to updates on Saturday Sport and Sunday Sport on RTÉ Radio 1. Watch highlights on The Saturday Game at 9.15pm and The Sunday Game from 9.30pm on RTÉ2 and RTÉ Player.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Irish Sun
12 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Kerry vs Donegal: Start time, FREE live stream, TV channel for huge GAA All-Ireland football final
ALL eyes will be on Croke Park once again THIS SUNDAY as Kerry face Donegal in a mouthwatering GAA All-Ireland football final! Kerry are the most successful Gaelic football team in the 2 Kerry are hoping to secure a mammoth 39th title Credit: Sportsfile 2 While Donegal look to clinch their first football triumph since 2012 Credit: Sportsfile And the Irish giants are appearing in their third final in four years after beating Tyrone 1-20 to 0-17 in a thrilling semi-final clash. But you could argue that opponents Donegal will be hungrier to win the championship, as their only two title wins were way back in 1992 and 2012. Furthermore, Jim McGuinness' side should have the wind in their sails following a stunning 3-26 to 0-15 semis triumph over Meath. However, Joe Brolly believes Donegal Read more on GAA football When is the GAA All-Ireland football final? The GAA All-Ireland football final between Kerry and Donegal will take place on Saturday, July 27. It is scheduled to get underway at 3.30pm BST / 10.30am ET. Croke Park in Dublin, Ireland is the chosen venue for this iconic match and it can host a whopping 82,300 fans. Armagh won their second title, with a 1–11 to 0–13 win against Galway in the 2024 final. How to watch the GAA All-Ireland football final for FREE The GAA All-Ireland football final will be broadcast LIVE on BBC Two Northern Ireland. Fans can stream the entire action for FREE on BBC iPlayer. It will also be shown on RTE One - instead of the usual RTE Two - in Ireland because of the Women's Euro 2025 final between England and Spain. Coverage is expected to get underway from 2:15pm BST - one hour and 15 minutes before the throw-in. Fans in the US can watch the match through the GAA+ stream or website. Alternatively, SunSport will have coverage of the entire action through our live blog. Who will be the referee? The GAA has announced that Brendan Cawley will officiate this year's All-Ireland football final between Kerry and Donegal. It'll be the Kildare native's first time refereeing Gaelic football's showpiece occasion. Most read in GAA Football The Sarsfields clubman has been on the inter-county officiating circuit since 2019 and is a widely respected figure across the game. His line umpires on the day will be Monaghan's Martin McNally and David Coldrick of Meath, with McNally also set to serve as the standby referee. What kits will be worn? Kerry are set to wear their alternative blue kit in order to avoid a colour clash in this year's All-Ireland football final. Common sense seemed to be ignored for Donegal's semi-final triumph over Meath when both teams lined out in their traditional green and yellow colours. It is the referee's call whether a colour clash is significant enough that one or both of the teams is compelled to wear one of their alternative strips. Ultimately, Paul Faloon did not deem that a necessary step to take. And in fairness many viewers expressed that they had little to no issue distinguishing Donegal players from Kerry counterparts. But it was a problem for some portions of the TV as well as Croke Park audience.


Irish Daily Mirror
42 minutes ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Tipp star had same bizarre preparation for All-Ireland final as World Cup winner
Tipperary goalkeeper Rhys Shelly has revealed the unique preparation he had for the All-Ireland final. Shelly, 24, was an integral part of a Tipp team that defied expectations to go all the way to the final this year and beat hot favourites Cork to lift the Liam MacCarthy Cup. The Moycarkey–Borris clubman is still on cloud nine and doesn't intend on coming down anytime soon. He told Tipp FM: "It's still hard to believe that we do have it [Liam MacCarthy], to be honest. "Talking over there, I said the homecoming will help it settle in. It means everything. "Someone said it to me, doing all the walks beforehand and time it cut to me, I was just smiling. "Just enjoy no point getting too bogged down in things - it's hurling. We're amateurs at the end of the day. If you don't enjoy it, there's no point playing it. "Just enjoying every minute of it." Shelly was understandably nervous ahead of the biggest match of his career last weekend. But the goalkeeper seemingly took inspiration from Italian football great Andrea Pirlo. "The day before is probably the worst for me, the waiting around," Shelly said. "I was playing Ultimate Team on FIFA, the head was kind of gone! I don't know if it was good prep..." Midfield maestro Pirlo revealed in his autobiography that he spent the afternoon playing video games before playing the 2006 World Cup final. Pirlo said: "I spent the afternoon of Sunday, 9 July 2006 in Berlin sleeping and playing the PlayStation. In the evening, I went out and won the World Cup."


Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Darragh Ó Sé on the Kerry team: Profiling the 15 men bidding to win the Kingdom's 39th Sam Maguire
1. Shane Ryan Age : 29 Club : Rathmore Debut : 2019 v Cork Struggled in the early part of the season with the new rules, especially around the kickout. But he has been transformed as the championship heated up. Brilliant against Armagh , very good against Tyrone . Revelling in the new rules now. READ MORE 2. Paul Murphy Age : 33 Club : Rathmore Debut : 2014 v Clare Kerry's Mr Dependable. Found the going a little tough early on against Tyrone but grew into the game. Won't be frightened of a final as he was man of the match against Donegal in 2014. 3. Jason Foley Kerry's Jason Foley blocks down a shot from Eoin McElholm of Tyrone during the All-Ireland SFC semi-final. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho Age : 29 Club : Ballydonoghue Debut : 2018 v Clare Probably Kerry's most under-rated defender. Gets all the tougher jobs because he's fast enough to stay with any forward. The last couple of games against Tyrone and Armagh have been among his best in a Kerry jersey. 4. Dylan Casey Age: 24 Club: Austin Stacks Debut: 2022 v Limerick One of the newer players and still has to convince everyone he's up to it. There's a sense of people waiting for him to be caught out but he hasn't been yet. That ability to prove people wrong is very admirable in my estimation. 5. Brian Ó Beaglaoich Age: 29 Club: An Ghaeltacht Debut: 2016 v Clare Last year was his best in a Kerry jersey and he's raised it even further this year. Brings a raw aggression and puts opposition teams on the back foot. Attacks with purpose from wing back and well able to pop a point. 6. Mike Breen Age: 27 Club: Beaufort Debut: 2021 v Clare Another guy who might feel like he is on probation with some of the supporters. Solid on the ball, rarely makes a mistake but probably still not fully proven. Excellent against Tyrone and a very smart footballer. 7. Gavin White Gavin White's performances have been consistently high-calibre. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho Age: 28 Club: Dr Crokes Debut: 2018 v Clare Playing a captain's role. Has been one of Kerry's best players in Croke Park this year, capping off a brilliant season. Even when Kerry haven't played well this year, he has hardly made a mistake. 8. Seán O'Brien Age: 23 Club: Beaufort Debut: 2024 v Cork Dropped in at the deep end out of necessity because of Kerry's injuries but found his feet and hasn't looked out of place. Similar to Mark O'Shea, he fills in around the middle, fights for kickouts and doesn't try to do too much. 9. Mark O'Shea Age: 27 Club: Dr Crokes Debut: 2025 v Clare Does his job with no fuss and no extravagance. Came in against Cork and settled things down. Has taken his chance with Diarmuid O'Connor out. Brave, tough, knows his limitations. A great team player. 10. Joe O'Connor Age: 25 Club: Austin Stacks Debut: 2022 v Cork Outstanding for Kerry all year, even back as far as the league. Really stood up against Cork in Páirc Uí Chaoimh but reached new heights against Armagh and Tyrone too. O'Connor has caught fire this season and is one of the main inspirations behind Kerry's resurgence. 11. Seán O'Shea Kerry's Seán O'Shea is capable of reeling off several scores if Donegal fail to deal with him. Photograph: Laszlo Geczo/Inpho Age: 27 Club: Kenmare Shamrocks Debut: 2018 v Clare Has had a super year. The highlight was the game against Armagh, where he shot the lights out and showed how dangerous he is if you back off him. Kicks left and right, hardly ever misses a free. Someone Donegal need more than one marker for. 12. Graham O'Sullivan Age: 27 Club: Dromid Pearses Debut: 2019 v Mayo Has spent the year being a bit of a square peg in a round hole at wing forward but you can see him growing into the role. Has an excellent attitude, gets in and wins breaks and forages for the ball in that middle third. Could probably back himself a bit more in front of the posts. 13. David Clifford Age: 26 Club: Fossa Debut: 2018 v Clare What can you say? He's judged on standards way above everybody else. Everyone can see his skill and talent but his attitude is superb as well. You can see he has taken to the new rules and is enjoying everybody knowing how dangerous he is. A player for the ages. 14. Paudie Clifford Paudie Clifford celebrates scoring a point against Tyrone in the All-Irleand semi-final. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho Age: 27 Club: Fossa Debut: 2020 v Cork His injury came at a bad time and it was no coincidence that Kerry's form dipped so badly when he was away. If his brother is Kerry's most important player, he's a close enough second. So clever on the ball. 15. Dylan Geaney Age: 24 Club: Dingle Debut: 2024 v Meath Very smart player, very streetwise. Can be lethal in front of goal and would have been cross with himself for his miss against Tyrone. Has been around for a few years but settled into the team now. Substitutes Potentially, there's a lot of firepower on the Kerry bench. If Paul Geaney and Tom O'Sullivan are fit for the last 20 minutes, they're great additions. Killian Spillane and Tony Brosnan can be a bit hit-and-miss. Evan Looney has been very good in his first year. Management Jack O'Connor, Aodán Mac Gearailt, James Costello, Cian O'Neill. This is Jack's eighth final so there's going to be nothing that surprises him. He knows more than anybody that these chances are so rare and so valuable. By his own admission, this year has been tougher emotionally and mentally than any before. Needs to win this one.