Doubt cast on claim of ‘hints' of life on faraway planet
Doubt cast on claim of 'hints' of life on faraway planet
PARIS - When astronomers announced in April they might have discovered the most promising hints of alien life yet on a distant planet, the rare good news raised hopes humanity could soon learn we are not alone in the universe.
But several recent studies looking into the same data have found that there is not enough evidence to support such lofty claims, with one scientist accusing the astronomers of 'jumping the gun'.
The debate revolves around the planet K2-18b, which is 124 light years away in the Leo constellation.
The planet is thought to be the right distance from its star to have liquid water, making it a prime suspect in the search for extraterrestrial life.
In April , astronomers using the James Webb Space Telescope made headlines by announcing they had detected hints of the chemicals dimethyl sulfide (DMS) and dimethyl disulfide (DMDS) on the planet.
These chemicals are only produced by life such as marine algae on Earth, meaning they are considered potential 'biosignatures' indicating life.
The astronomers, led by Cambridge University's Nikku Madhusudhan, expressed caution about the 'hints' of a biosignature, emphasising they were not claiming a definitive discovery.
Their detection had reached a three-sigma level of statistical significance 'which means there is still a three in 1,000 chance of this being a fluke', Dr Madhusudhan said at the time.
Biosignatures 'vanish'
Two of Dr Madhusudhan's former students, Dr Luis Welbanks of Arizona State University and Dr Matthew Nixon of Maryland University, were among the researchers who have since re-analysed the data behind the announcement.
When deploying other statistical models, 'claims of a potential biosignature detection vanish', according to their preprint study published online late in April .
Like the other papers since the April announcement, it has not been peer-reviewed.
In one model, Dr Welbanks and colleagues expanded the number of possible chemicals that could explain the signals detected by Webb to 90 from the original 20.
More than 50 received a 'hit', Dr Welbanks told AFP.
'When you detect everything, did you really detect anything?' he asked.
They are not saying the planet definitely does not have DMS – just that more observations are needed, Dr Welbanks added.
'Arguments are healthy'
Dr Madhusudhan welcomed the robust debate, saying that remaining open to all possibilities is an essential part of the scientific method.
'These sort of arguments are healthy,' he told AFP.
His team even went further, releasing their own preprint study last week that expanded the number of chemicals even further to 650.
The three most 'promising' chemicals they found included DMS but not DMDS – a major part of the team's announcement in April.
The other two chemicals were diethyl sulfide and methyl acrylonitrile, the latter of which is toxic.
Dr Madhusudhan admitted that these little-known chemicals are likely not 'realistic molecules' for a planet like K2-18b.
Dr Welbanks pointed out that 'in the span of a month – with no new data, with no new models, with no new laboratory data – their entire analysis changed'.
'Closest we have ever been'
Telescopes observe such far-off exoplanets when they cross in front of their star, allowing astronomers to analyse how molecules block different wavelengths of light streaming through their atmosphere.
Earlier this week, a paper led by Dr Rafael Luque at the University of Chicago combined Webb's observations of K2-18b in both the near-infrared and mid-infrared wavelengths of light.
It also found 'no statistical significance for DMS or DMDS', the paper said.
An earlier paper by Oxford astrophysicist Jake Taylor using a basic statistical test also found no strong evidence for any biosignatures.
Dr Madhusudhan dismissed the latter paper, saying the simple exercise did not account for observing physical phenomena.
He also stood by his research, saying he was 'just as confident' in the work as he was a month ago.
More data about K2-18b will come in over the next year which should offer a much clearer picture, Dr Madhusudhan added.
Even if the planet does have DMS, it is not a guarantee of life – the chemical has been detected on a lifeless asteroid.
However, many researchers do believe that space telescopes could one day collect enough evidence to identify alien life from afar.
'We are the closest we have ever been' to such a moment, Dr Welbanks said.
'But we have to use the frameworks that are in place and build up (evidence) in a reliable method, rather than using non-standard practices and jumping the gun – as has been done in this particular case,' Dr Nixon added. AFP
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
24-07-2025
- Straits Times
Tides could help predict when huge icebergs break loose: Study
Find out what's new on ST website and app. Iceberg calving is a natural process which balances out the massive amount of snow that falls on Antarctica every year. PARIS – Ocean tides can trigger city-sized icebergs to break off from Antarctic ice shelves, scientists said on July 24, offering a potential way to predict these dramatic events in the future. It is not normally possible to forecast when icebergs break free, or calve, although the timing is important because these behemoths change the shape of ice sheets and affect global sea levels. Yet when a chunk of ice the size of Greater London suddenly broke off the Brunt Ice Shelf in 2023 and started drifting away, glaciologist Oliver Marsh was not surprised. Dr Marsh told AFP he had predicted that a huge iceberg breaking off was 'imminent within the next weeks to months'. The British Antarctic Survey researcher had spent years studying the huge crack that would create the 550sq km iceberg named A81. As Dr Marsh had anticipated, the calving occurred at the peak of spring tide, when there is the biggest difference between the ocean's high and low tide. New research led by Dr Marsh, published in the journal Nature Communications on July 24, used modelling to show that the calving was triggered by the tide, along with high winds and stress on the ice. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Asia Live: People evacuated from border regions amid deadly Thailand-Cambodia clash Asia 11 Thai civilians killed as Thai and Cambodian militaries clash at disputed border: Reports Asia Deadly Thai-Cambodian dispute puts Asean's relevance on the line Singapore Singapore says prolonged suffering of civilians in Gaza is 'unconscionable' Singapore Khatib Camp to make way for housing, with its functions moving to Amoy Quee Camp Singapore First BTO flats in Greater Southern Waterfront, Mount Pleasant to go on sale in October Singapore Mindef to set up new volunteer management unit to grow volunteer pool Singapore Primary 1 registration: 29 schools to conduct ballot in Phase 2B After A81 broke off, Dr Marsh visited the ice shelf to see how open water had replaced what had previously been 'ice as far as you could see'. 'It was sad to see it go, in a way,' he said. A81 is currently drifting up the eastern side of the Antarctica Peninsula towards the Weddell Sea. It remains to be seen whether it will come close to South Georgia island, which is an important breeding ground for penguins, seals and other animals. 'Out of balance' The world's biggest iceberg, A23a, ran aground not too far from South Georgia earlier in 2025 but is not thought to pose a threat to wildlife. Now that A23a is exposed to the waves of the Southern Ocean, its 'days are numbered', Dr Marsh said. He emphasised that iceberg calving is a natural process which balances out the massive amount of snow that falls on Antarctica every year. However, 'now we're out of balance', Dr Marsh added. Antarctica loses ice in two ways – icebergs calving and ice sheets melting. And ice sheets are melting at a rapidly increasing rate as oceans warm due to human-driven climate change, scientists have warned. 'We don't know whether calving rates have gone up' because they happen relatively infrequently, Dr Marsh said. A81 was the second of three mammoth icebergs that have broken free of the Brunt Ice Shelf since 2021. 'We are expecting a very large calving event at some point from this area' in the future, Dr Marsh said. But he could not give a timeframe. 'While we're saying we are a step closer to being able to predict these events... it is still difficult to predict.' AFP
CNA
16-07-2025
- CNA
Astronomers witness birth of solar system for first time
PARIS: Astronomers have, for the first time, observed the earliest stage of planet formation around a distant star, offering fresh insight into how our own solar system may have begun. (Wednesday, July 16) The planetary system is taking shape around HOPS 315, a young star located some 1,300 light years from Earth in the Orion Nebula. HOPS 315 is believed to resemble the Sun in its infancy. PLANETS BORN FROM GAS AND DUST Young stars are typically surrounded by vast rings of gas and dust known as protoplanetary discs, the breeding grounds for new planets. Within these discs, crystalline minerals containing silicon monoxide can clump together, eventually snowballing into kilometre-sized planetesimals. These can go on to become full-fledged planets. In our own solar system, such minerals, the "starter dough" for planets like Earth and Jupiter, are believed to have been trapped inside ancient meteorites. Now, researchers have found similar signs of early planet formation in the disc surrounding HOPS 315. The findings were published in the journal Nature. MINERALS IDENTIFIED BY SPACE AND GROUND TELESCOPES "For the first time, we have identified the earliest moment when planet formation is initiated around a star other than our Sun," said lead study author Melissa McClure of Leiden University in the Netherlands. The James Webb Space Telescope first detected the presence of the minerals. Astronomers then used the European Southern Observatory's ALMA telescope in Chile to pinpoint their location. They found the crystalline minerals clustered in a narrow region of the disc, which bears similarities to the asteroid belt in our own solar system. This discovery could allow scientists to monitor a process that once shaped Earth and its neighbouring planets. "We are seeing a system that looks like what our solar system looked like when it was just beginning to form," said study co-author Merel van 't Hoff of Purdue University in the United States.
Straits Times
02-07-2025
- Straits Times
‘Writing is thinking': Do students who use ChatGPT learn less?
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox A recent study suggests students who use ChatGPT to write essays engage in less critical thinking. PARIS - When Professor Jocelyn Leitzinger had her university students write about times in their lives they had witnessed discrimination, she noticed that a woman named Sally was the victim in many of the stories. 'It was very clear that ChatGPT had decided this is a common woman's name,' said Prof Leitzinger, who teaches an undergraduate class on business and society at the University of Illinois in Chicago. 'They weren't even coming up with their own anecdotal stories about their own lives,' she told AFP. Prof Leitzinger estimated that around half of her 180 students used ChatGPT inappropriately at some point last semester – including when writing about the ethics of artificial intelligence (AI), which she called both 'ironic' and 'mind-boggling'. So she was not surprised by recent research which suggested that students who use ChatGPT to write essays engage in less critical thinking. The preprint study, which has not been peer-reviewed, was shared widely online and clearly struck a chord with some frustrated educators. The team of MIT researchers behind the paper have received more than 3,000 emails from teachers of all stripes since it was published online in June, lead author Nataliya Kosmyna told AFP. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore 3 out of 4 in Singapore cannot identify deepfake content: Cyber Security Agency survey Singapore GrabCab, Singapore's newest taxi operator, hits the roads with over 40 cabs to be rolled out in July Life Star Awards 2025: Xiang Yun and Chen Hanwei are the most decorated actors in show's 30-year history Business Cathay Cineplexes gets demand for $3.4 million in arrears from Jem landlord Asia Dalai Lama says he will have successor after his death Sport FAS introduces 'enhancements' to SPL, with increase in prize money and foreign player quota Singapore 3,800 private candidates in Singapore to take O- and A-level exams in 2025 Singapore Teen admits assaulting cop, fracturing officer's nose 'Soulless' AI essays For the small study, 54 adult students from the greater Boston area were split into three groups. One group used ChatGPT to write 20-minute essays, one used a search engine, and the final group had to make do with only their brains. The researchers used EEG devices to measure the brain activity of the students, and two teachers marked the essays. The ChatGPT users scored significantly worse than the brain-only group on all levels. The EEG showed that different areas of their brains connected to each other less often. And more than 80 per cent of the ChatGPT group could not quote anything from the essay they had just written, compared to around 10 per cent of the other two groups. By the third session, the ChatGPT group appeared to be mostly focused on copying and pasting. The teachers said they could easily spot the 'soulless' ChatGPT essays because they had good grammar and structure but lacked creativity, personality and insight. However Dr Kosmyna pushed back against media reports claiming the paper showed that using ChatGPT made people lazier or more stupid. She pointed to the fourth session, when the brain-only group used ChatGPT to write their essay and displayed even higher levels of neural connectivity. Dr Kosmyna emphasised it was too early to draw conclusions from the study's small sample size but called for more research into how AI tools could be used more carefully to help learning. Dr Ashley Juavinett, a neuroscientist at the University of California San Diego who was not involved in the research, criticised some 'offbase' headlines that wrongly extrapolated from the preprint. 'This paper does not contain enough evidence nor the methodological rigour to make any claims about the neural impact of using LLMs (large language models such as ChatGPT) on our brains,' she told AFP. Thinking outside the bot Prof Leitzinger said the research reflected how she had seen student essays change since ChatGPT was released in 2022, as both spelling errors and authentic insight became less common. Sometimes students do not even change the font when they copy and paste from ChatGPT, she said. But Prof Leitzinger called for empathy for students, saying they can get confused when the use of AI is being encouraged by universities in some classes but is banned in others. The usefulness of new AI tools is sometimes compared to the introduction of calculators, which required educators to change their ways. But Prof Leitzinger worried that students do not need to know anything about a subject before pasting their essay question into ChatGPT, skipping several important steps in the process of learning. A student at a British university in his early 20s who wanted to remain anonymous told AFP he found ChatGPT was a useful tool for compiling lecture notes, searching the internet and generating ideas. 'I think that using ChatGPT to write your work for you is not right because it's not what you're supposed to be at university for,' he said. The problem goes beyond high school and university students. Academic journals are struggling to cope with a massive influx of AI-generated scientific papers. Book publishing is also not immune, with one startup planning to pump out 8,000 AI-written books a year. 'Writing is thinking, thinking is writing, and when we eliminate that process, what does that mean for thinking?' Prof Leitzinger asked. AFP
