‘Fishing in the dark': Spain accused of turning a blind eye to illegal fishing in West Africa
Two environmental NGOs, ClientEarth and Oceana, have filed a lawsuit against the Spanish government, alleging failures to investigate and sanction Spanish-flagged vessels suspected of illegal fishing in West African waters.
The lawsuit, filed in Madrid, accuses Spanish authorities of neglecting their obligations under EU law by ignoring vessels that have repeatedly switched off their tracking systems while operating off the coasts of Senegal and Guinea Bissau.
'Fishing in the dark'
At the heart of the legal challenge is the use of Automatic Identification Systems (AIS). This tracking technology is mandatory for all boats over 15 metres in length and supports safety and transparency in the
fishing
industry.
An analysis by the nonprofit Global Fishing Watch revealed that several Spanish-flagged
vessels
appeared to go dark for extended periods between 2020 and 2023. One boat allegedly switched off its AIS for more than a year during that period.
'What puzzles us is why these boats switch off their public identification signals, going 'dark' for such long periods,' Nils Courcy, a lawyer at ClientEarth, said in a statement.
Related
World Wildlife Day: Conservationists say green corridors can help animals thrive in Kenya
India doubles tiger population in a decade: Can other countries learn from its conservation efforts?
The NGOs argue that such activity could mask
illicit
practices that not only threaten marine
biodiversity
but also undermine economies and food security in one of the world's most heavily fished regions.
'This lack of transparency could be linked to fraud,' Courcy added.
In 2023, the NGOs formally requested the Spanish authorities to investigate the AIS anomalies. They claim that
Spain
has refused to do so, prompting the legal action.
Legal loopholes and global consequences
When it comes to legal duties in the globalised fishing industry, the waters are murky.
Spanish authorities claim they lack jurisdiction to act against citizens or companies operating outside EU waters, unless the vessels are blacklisted internationally. The NGOs argue that this position is at odds with
EU law
.
'EU law explicitly prohibits its citizens and companies from engaging or supporting illegal fishing anywhere in the world,' said Ignacio Fresco Vanzini, senior policy advisor at Oceana. 'If they do, Member States must identify and sanction them, regardless of whether these vessels are part of official blacklists.'
Many Spanish companies establish joint ventures with local firms or reflag vessels to countries like Senegal or Guinea Bissau, allowing them to benefit economically from rich West African fishing zones while circumventing EU regulations. Although technically operating under local laws, such vessels are still owned by Spanish entities.
Enforcement
is an even more complex issue.
International law places the responsibility for enforcement on coastal and flag states. But the NGOs believe that when those authorities fail to act, Spain must step in.
Illegal fishing: a broader European problem
The lawsuit comes amid increasing scrutiny of global fishing practices.
ADVERTISEMENT
In February 2025, several NGOs
sued
the French government over its failure to end bottom trawling in marine reserves, arguing that authorities had ignored damaging practices in protected areas.
Senegal, meanwhile, was issued a 'yellow card' warning by the EU in 2024 due to its inability to control illegal fishing activities.
Related
'Blood sport' or 'humane and quick'? Controversial whale slaughter begins in Faroe Islands
Polar bear tracking tech breakthrough could boost conservation as climate heats up
But some countries are upping their efforts to protect their natural habitats.
Finland and Sweden joined forces in 2024 to crack down on
illegal
salmon fishing, while
Portugal
expanded its marine protected areas, giving it the largest such network in Europe.
ADVERTISEMENT
West Africa's coveted fish stocks
The West African coast is one of the most productive
fishing
zones in the world, attracting fleets from China, Russia, Korea and the EU. Remarkably, Spanish vessels account for 73 per cent of the total of foreign industrial fleets that fish here.
Through sustainable
fisheries
partnership agreements (SFPAs), EU vessels can legally fish for surplus stocks in exclusive economic zones in exchange for financial compensation. But these arrangements are now under strain.
The EU's agreement with Senegal, which had allowed EU vessels to target tuna and hake, was not renewed after the country was issued a yellow card. Guinea Bissau's agreement remains intact, permitting EU vessels to fish for
tuna
, shrimp and cephalopods such as squid and octopus. But how
sustainable
it is remains unclear.
Related
'A momentous day for nature': EU approves first-of-its-kind law that could bring back biodiversity
Vietnam's ancient fish sauce making tradition is being threatened by warming seas and overfishing
According to the International Organisation for Migration, income for small-scale West African fishers has decreased by an estimated 40 per cent in recent years. In Senegal, where fishing is indirectly responsible for more than half a million jobs, the fish catch has dwindled by 75 per cent in the last decade.
ADVERTISEMENT
With fish stocks disappearing, local communities are facing risks that range from
food insecurity
to job loss and forced migration.
If ClientEarth and Oceana win their case, Spanish authorities could be compelled to investigate the large grey areas in fishing – and perhaps begin to address these issues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
an hour ago
- France 24
Trump's rollercoaster for Ukrainians: US to send Patriot missiles to Kyiv
03:02 14/07/2025 EU still seeks trade deal, delaying countermeasures after new Trump tariff threat Europe 14/07/2025 Donald Trump says will send US patriot missiles to Ukraine Europe 12/07/2025 Russian drone attack: The goal is to 'terrorise the Ukrainian population' Europe 12/07/2025 Europe needs infrastructure overhaul to tackle summer heatwaves, expert says Europe 11/07/2025 France is Russia's 'main enemy' says head of French army this Friday Europe 11/07/2025 EU orders AI companies to clean up their act, stop using pirated data Europe 11/07/2025 In Lithuania, baby seals have been released into the Baltic Sea Europe 11/07/2025 Zelensky appeals to allies for investment & defense aid in Rome Europe
Euronews
2 hours ago
- Euronews
EU's AI Code ready for companies to sign next week
Member states' formal approval of the Code of Practice for General Purpose AI (GPAI) could come as early as 22 July, paving the way for providers of AI systems to sign up, sources familiar with the matter told Euronews. It will be just days before the entry into force of the AI Act's provisions affecting GPAI systems, on 2 August. The European Commission last week presented the Code, a voluntary set of rules drafted by experts appointed by the EU executive, aiming to help providers of AI models such as ChatGPT and Gemini comply with the AI Act. Companies that sign up are expected to be compliant with the AI Act and are expected to have more legal certainty, others will face more inspections. The Code requires a sign off by EU member states, which are represented in a subgroup of the AI Board, as well as by the Commission's own AI Office. The 27 EU countries are expected to finalise assessment of the Code next week and if the Commission also completes its assessment by then too, the providers can formally sign up. The document, which was supposed to come out in May, faced delays and heavy criticism. Tech giants as well as publishers and rights-holders are concerned that the rules violate the EU's Copyright laws, and restrict innovation. The EU's AI Act, that regulates AI systems according to the risk they pose to society and is coming into force in stages beginning in August last year. Mixed reactions In the meantime, OpenAI, the parent company of ChatGPT, has said it will sign up to the code once its ready. 'The Code of Practice opens the door for Europe to move forward with the EU AI Continent Action Plan that was announced in April—and to build on the impact of AI that is already felt today,' the statement said. The publication drew mixed reactions, with consumer group BEUC and Center for Democracy and Technology (CDT) hesitant about the final version of the code. BEUC Senior Legal Officer, Cláudio Teixeira called the development a 'step in the right direction', but underlined that voluntary initiatives like the Code of Practice 'can be no substitute for binding EU legislation: they must complement and reinforce, not dilute, the law's core protections for consumers.' CDT Europe's Laura Lazaro Cabrera said the final draft 'stops short of requiring their in-depth assessment and mitigation in all cases.' 'The incentive for providers to robustly identify these risks will only be as strong as the AI Office's commitment to enforce a comprehensive, good-faith approach,' she said.
Euronews
2 hours ago
- Euronews
Police detain eight after anti-migrant clashes in southern Spain
Eight people have been detained by police in Spain in connection with violent clashes that erupted between far-right groups, local residents and migrants in a south-eastern town at the weekend, officials said on Monday. Clashes in Torre-Pacheco in the Murcia region happened on Saturday night after a 68-year-old man told Spanish media he had been beaten up earlier in the week by three men of North African origin. That sparked a call by far-right groups to seek retribution on the area's large migrant community, with groups armed with batons reportedly roaming the streets looking for people of foreign origin. The motive for the initial attack on the elderly man was not clear. Among those detained were two people allegedly linked to the attack on the elderly man and several others in relation to the weekend clashes, Mariola Guevara, the central government's representative in Murcia, said on Monday in a post on X. Six Spanish nationals and one North African resident were detained for the assaults, damage and disturbances, Guevara said. The two others detained had helped the perpetrator of the attack on the elderly man, she said. A major police presence was moved into Torre-Pacheco, including more than 75 police officers as well as Civil Guard and riot control units. The town has a population of around 42,000 and about a third of its residents are of foreign origin, according to local government figures. Large numbers of migrants also work in the surrounding area as day labourers in agriculture, a major driver of the regional economy. Local media have reported that some families, mainly of Moroccan origin, have shuttered their businesses and refused to send their children to school. The Civil Guard says it has opened an investigation to identify those responsible for messages circulating on encrypted channels and social media with calls to "hunt down immigrants." Fact-checking platforms such as Verifica RTVE and Newtral confirmed that many of the videos used to justify the violence had been manipulated or were fake. Spain's Minister of Migration, Elma Saiz, said that "Spain is not a country of immigrant hunting," and accused the far-right of fuelling the unrest. And in comments on Monday, Interior Minister Fernando Grande-Marlaska blamed the far-right Vox party and the conservative People's Party for spreading messages that "have served as fuel for this situation." Vox took almost 19% of the vote in the last municipal elections in Torre-Pacheco and on its official X account, posted several messages blaming immigrants of North African origin for the "terror" in the town. Spain's Second Deputy Prime Minister Yolanda Díaz accused the party of "setting the streets on fire with racist speeches" and of "using pain to divide." Vox has denied any responsibility for the riots and demanded a "tough hand against illegal immigration."
