Concrete And Cement Additives: U.S. Court Dismisses Antitrust Claims Against Major Concrete Additives Firms, ET Infra
Advt
A U.S. judge in Manhattan on Wednesday dismissed a nationwide antitrust lawsuit accusing six companies that sell the vast majority of concrete and cement additives in the United States and Europe of conspiring to drive up prices.U.S. District Judge Lewis Liman said the "extreme and persistent" price hikes alleged by purchasers were "episodic," and inconsistent with coordinated activity in the estimated $27 billion global market for additives and so-called admixtures."Plaintiffs' allegations fall short of suggesting that the price increases were not the product of normal market forces or that the explanations given were pretextual so as to suggest an antitrust conspiracy," Liman wrote.The defendants include Germany's BASF , Britain's Cinven Group, Italy's Mapei, Ohio-based RPM, France's Saint-Gobain and Switzerland's Sika.According to court papers, they control an estimated 80% to 90% of the $3 billion U.S. market for the additives, which are chemicals added to concrete, cement and mortar to improve the finished products' strength and stability.In his 50-page decision, Liman also said "plus factors" such as mergers, memberships in trade associations, and scrutiny by U.S. and European competition regulators suggested at most that a price-fixing conspiracy was possible, not plausible.Lawyers for the purchasers did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Liman said the purchasers can try to replead most claims. The alleged conspiracy began in 2017.Litigation began after the European Commission in October 2023 conducted surprise inspections, which the purchasers called "dawn raids," at several producers of construction chemicals, on suspicion of possible anticompetitive conduct.The commission said the inspections were a preliminary investigatory step and did not mean it found anticompetitive behavior.In May 2024, the U.S. Department of Justice confirmed a Pennsylvania grand jury had begun probing the concrete and cement additives industry.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Punjab: Saraya Industries got no foreign funds since 2007, says Sukhbir
Jun 29, 2025 08:20 AM IST Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD) president Sukhbir Singh Badal on Saturday dared Punjab chief minister Bhagwant Mann to prove that Saraya Industries, in which party leader Bikram Singh Majithia had an inherited share of 11%, had received even one rupee in foreign funding from 2007. Lashing out at the state government over Majithia's arrest, the SAD chief said the case was registered only because Majithia had been 'exposing' the dispensation over various issues. Sukhbir also challenged the CM to prove the disproportionate assets case, asserting that the entire case was based on a bundle of lies. (HT Photo) The Punjab Vigilance Bureau arrested Majithia on June 25 in a disproportionate assets case allegedly involving laundering of ₹ 540 crore 'drug money'. It was Sukhbir's maiden press conference after the arrest of Majithia. Regarding Saraya Industries Limited, he said, 'The only foreign funding received by Saraya Industries was in March,2006 when it received ₹ 35 crore from United States-based Clearwater Corporation in exchange for 25% shares in the company. Majithia entered politics in 2007.' He also made it clear that all transactions of Saraya Industries were scrutinised and accepted by the Income Tax department. Sukhbir also challenged the CM to prove the disproportionate assets case, asserting that the entire case was based on a bundle of lies. Sukhbir asserted that Mann had pressurised the state DGP to register the case because 'Majithia had been constantly exposing him and his corrupt and immoral cabinet colleagues'. He termed the government action 'vendetta politics'. 'An affidavit which the government had submitted to the Supreme Court in 2023 while appealing for cancellation of Majithia's regular bail and seeking his custodial interrogation in an NDPS Act was used verbatim to register this new case against him. This was done despite the fact that the Supreme Court rejected the affidavit in April this year and refused to overturn the regular bail given to Majithia by the high court or grant the request for custodial interrogation,' Sukhbir said. The SAD chief further said that the apex court even asked the AAP government to complete the probe in two days 'following which it has now taken this new route to engage in political vendetta'. He also condemned the manner in which former DGP Siddharth Chattopadhyaya and ex-deputy director of Enforcement Directorate Niranjan Singh were called by the Vigilance Bureau to share information regarding the drug case. He claimed that his party had conclusive proof of the corrupt activities of the CM and his wife.
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Punjab: Property dealer hacked to death on busy Ludhiana road
A Ludhiana-based property dealer, Kuldeep Singh, 65, was hacked to death on the busy Dhandra Road on Friday night. A video grab of the attack in Ludhiana. The incident, which was captured on video by a passerby and later circulated on social media, shows a man using a sword to hit the victim multiple times, near the Missing Link 2 approach road. Despite the victim's repeated cries for help, no one intervened. Eyewitnesses said the elderly man was screaming in pain while one of the men kept attacking him mercilessly with a sword. Kuldeep was the late Akali Dal MP Jagdev Singh Talwandi's ex-personal assistant. According to the police, the victim left his farmhouse in a car when a group of men in a Maruti Swift car began following him. 'They rear-ended Kuldeep's vehicle. When he stepped out to check the damage, they overpowered him and attacked him with swords until he collapsed. The attackers then fled the spot in their car,' said sub-inspector Avneet Kaur, Sadar police station in-charge. Police believe the murder was pre-planned. 'Kuldeep owned a licensed pistol. It's likely that the attackers were aware of this, and they hit his vehicle intentionally to lure him out of the car,' added the SI. The deceased was settled abroad with his wife and kids. He had returned to India a few days in connection with some property-related issue. Initial investigations suggest that an old property dispute or personal rivalry may be behind the attack. 'He had some past disputes, but no fresh conflict has come to our notice so far. We are exploring all angles,' she said. Police have recovered a video of the incident shot by a passerby. The absence of CCTV cameras near the crime scene is making it difficult for cops to identify the vehicle or the attackers clearly. The police are scanning other surveillance footage from nearby roads and are conducting raids to nab the culprits.
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
PMLA court allows restoration of ₹952-cr property attached by ED
MUMBAI: In an important development, a special PMLA (Prevention of Money Laundering Act) court on June 25 allowed restoration of assets ₹ 952 crore attached by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) in a money laundering case against Infrastructure Leasing & Financial Services Ltd (IL&FS), its group companies, and associated entities. The property - Surat-based plant of Vadraj Cement Limited - would be restored to Nuvoco Vistas Corporation Ltd, which has taken over the defunct company through a resolution process. (Shutterstock) The Mumbai zonal office of the agency initiated investigation under the PML Act against IL&FS and associated entities for their alleged involvement in the generation and laundering of proceeds of crime (POC). During the course of the investigation, it was revealed that Vadraj Cement Limited (formerly ABG Cement Ltd), a group company of ABG, had availed financial assistance from IL&FS Financial Services Ltd (IFIN), which was subsequently declared as a non-performing asset, said agency sources. The investigation established that loans amounting to ₹ 952 crore were obtained fraudulently and were identified as POC, they added. Accordingly, the immovable properties of Vadraj Cement Ltd, comprising its cement plant in Surat, were provisionally attached by ED on January 21, 2020. The attachment was confirmed by the Adjudicating Authority on August 5, 2021. A prosecution complaint or charge sheet in the money laundering case was also filed before the special PMLA court in Mumbai, praying for the confiscation of properties attached as POC. According to ED sources, Punjab National Bank was the major lender to Vadraj Cement Ltd with an admitted claim of ₹ 2,122 crore. The defunct cement company's other major lenders include Union Bank ( ₹ 1,620 crore), Indian Overseas Bank ( ₹ 1,419 crore), Central Bank of India ( ₹ 1,391 crore) and JC Flower ARC ( ₹ 677 crore). Subsequently, M/s Nuvoco Vistas Corporation Ltd, a subsidiary of the Nirma Group and the successful resolution applicant under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC), filed an application before the special PMLA court seeking restoration of the attached property to facilitate implementation of the resolution plan approved by the National Company Law Tribunal, Mumbai, on April 1, 2025. Under the scheme approved by the NCLT, Nuvoco Vistas Corporation Ltd will pay ₹ 1,706 crore to Vadraj Cement's financial creditors in lieu of its acquisition of the defunct company. Considering the intent of the PMLA to restitute or restore the POC to bonafide legitimate claimants, the ED submitted no objection before the special court for the release of property attached to the bonafide legitimate claimants. Based on ED's NOC, the special court on June 25 passed an order to restitute the attached immovable properties to the bonafide claimants - Nuvoco Vistas Corporation Ltd, subject to filing an undertaking to return or restore the property or its value as may be directed in future. The court has also instructed ED to prepare a detailed inventory of the property prior to handing over its possession to the successful resolution applicant.
