Explained: Why Umpire Wasn't Wrong To Signal Inside Edge On Refusal Of ENG's Appeal
Sri Lanka umpire Kumar Dharmasena has been criticised for signaling inside edge during England's LBW appeal against Sai Sudharsan.
Sri Lanka umpire Kumar Dharmasena came under fire on Thursday when he was seen indicating to the players that there was a clear inside edge when England appealed for an LBW of Sai Sudharsan, prompting fans to question if an on-field umpire is allowed to do the same.
The incident came to light after England pacer Josh Tongue's ball to Sudharsan prompted a minor appeal from the fielders.
It was a full, inswinging ball that struck Sudharsan low on the pad, causing him to lose his balance and drop to his haunches. Dharmasena shook his head as the England cricketers appealed.
While shaking his head, Dharmasena gestured with his fingers as well, indicating to the cricketers that he believed Sudharsan had inside-edged the delivery onto his pad.
Sudharsan had indeed got an inside edge on the ball, sparing him from what appeared to be a straightforward LBW dismissal.
'Why is Sri Lankan umpire Kumar Dharmasena telling the English bowler that it's a clear edge by showing his fingers?" a fan questioned.
'Is Kumar Dharmasena Helping England Bowlers ?? By explaining the reason for denying an appeal 🤔🤔," another fan tweeted on Thursday afternoon.
Is Kumar Dharmasena Helping England Bowlers ??By explaining the reason of Denying an appeal 🤔🤔 #INDvsENG #INDvsENGTest pic.twitter.com/Chu6RitSAq
— Mayank (@mayankcdp) July 31, 2025
It is not uncommon for umpires to explain their reasoning behind a not-out decision to the cricketers on the field. But it gets more controversial when the Decision Review System is available.
This is because when umpires indicate they believe there was an inside edge, it can deter cricketers from opting for a review, saving them from losing one they might have otherwise used.
However, there is nothing in the rules that prevents an umpire from explaining the reasoning behind their decision.
'Either the captain or the two batters may, in respect of a decision relating to an appeal for LBW, question the bowler's end umpire as to whether his/her decision has been made on the basis that the striker made no genuine attempt to play the ball with the bat," Article 32.2.3 of the Test Playing Conditions says.
'Under no other circumstance is any player permitted to query an umpire about any aspect of a decision before deciding on whether or not to request a Player Review," the article adds.
Therefore, the conditions don't prohibit Dharmasena from signalling to the England cricketers that he believed Sudharsan had edged the ball.
It would have been against the rules for the England cricketers to ask Dharmasena whether Sudharsan had hit the ball, something they didn't do.
First Published:
Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
an hour ago
- News18
AC Milan Legend Franco Baresi Undergoes Surgery; Enroute Road To Recovery
Last Updated: AC Milan legend Franco Baresi is recovering well after surgery to remove a pulmonary nodule. The 65-year-old will begin oncological recovery therapy. AC Milan legend Franco Baresi is recovering well after undergoing surgery to remove a pulmonary nodule, the club confirmed in an official statement on Sunday. The former defender and honorary vice president will now begin oncological recovery therapy, which includes immunotherapy. 'It Will Take Me a Little Time to Get Back to Full Strength" The 65-year-old Baresi issued a message to reassure fans following the operation, expressing optimism despite the health setback. 'Dear fans, I just want to let you know that it will take me a little time to get back to full strength," he said in a statement released by the club. The issue was discovered during a routine medical check, and doctors moved quickly to perform the surgery. His recovery will be closely monitored as he begins further treatment in the coming weeks. A True Icon of AC Milan and Italian Football Franco Baresi is one of the most revered figures in the history of AC Milan and Italian football. He spent his entire 20-year professional playing career at San Siro, making over 700 appearances for the Rossoneri and captaining the side for 15 seasons before retiring in 1997. Known for his elegant defending, tactical intelligence, and leadership, Baresi was the anchor of Milan's defense during a golden era for the club—winning six Serie A titles and three European Cups. On the international stage, he was part of Italy's victorious 1982 World Cup squad and later captained the national team to the final of the 1994 tournament in the United States, where the Azzurri fell to Brazil in a dramatic penalty shootout. Since retiring, Baresi has remained closely tied to the club, currently serving as honorary vice president. His legacy continues to influence generations of Milan fans and players, with his No. 6 jersey retired in his honor. view comments Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
News18
an hour ago
- News18
India & England Create History, Level 96-Year-Old Record With 14 300-Plus Totals
Last Updated: India and England posted their 14th 300-plus total in Tests at the Oval, with England needing 57 runs for a series-sealing victory over the visitors. With the run-flow continuing at the Oval in London during the fifth Test of the series between India and England, the two teams posted their 14th 300-plus total, the highest in Tests, levelling a record from the 1928-29 Ashes and going past the 1975-76 series between Australia and the Windies. England went past 300 in their second innings with a boundary from Harry Brook off Akash Deep in the 63rd over, as they looked all set to chase down the target. An epic 195-run partnership off 211 deliveries between Brook and ace batter Joe Root took the wind out of India's sails as England coasted to 317/4 at tea, needing another 57 runs for the series-sealing win against India. India and England scored 300+ runs in all four innings of the first Test at Leeds, in three innings of the second Test in Birmingham and Manchester and in two innings of the third Test at Lord's and the Oval. In the 1928/29 Ashes, England won 4-1 Down Under, one of their best shows ever in the history of the tournament. Wally Hammond scored a whopping 905 runs in the series, at a stunning average of 113.12. Surprisingly, left-arm spinner Jack White finished as the highest wicket-taker in the series. It was the second century of the series for Brook (111 off 98), who displayed special ball striking abilities under extreme pressure. Brook made most of a life given on 19 when Mohammed Siraj stumbled to the boundary ropes after taking his catch off Prasidh Krishna. The three Indian pacers couldn't take much out of the track with a softer ball and the two spinners, Washington Sundar and Ravindra Jadeja, too, proved ineffective, although to be fair to them, they were not given long spells. The new ball is still 14 overs away and the match would be as good as over by then if England continue marching towards their goal. view comments First Published: Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
NDTV
an hour ago
- NDTV
"Let Me Get My Hundred, Then...": Ravi Shastri On How Washington Sundar Responded To Harry Brook
Team India clearly dominated the proceedings on Day 3 of the fifth and final Test against England at The Oval in London. In the first session, Yashasvi Jaiswal and nightwatchman Akash Deep 's 107-run partnership troubled England bowlers. Akash even brought up his maiden half-century before getting dismissed for 66. Later in the day, all-rounders Washington Sundar and Ravindra Jadeja took and hit their respective half-centuries. However, it was Sundar's brilliant and powerful hitting, which included four sixes, that grabbed everyone's attention. On Day 5 of the previous Test, when India were playing for a draw and Jadeja and Sundar had rejected Ben Stokes ' request to declare the innings, in order to bring up their centuries, the English players started sledging the Indian duo. Batter Harry Brook was even heard saying, "If you wanted a hundred, you should have batted like that earlier." Team England received severe criticism for their on-field behaviour and former India coach Ravi Shastri felt that Sundar's carnage with the bat in the fifth Test was a result of the last match's frustration. When Sundar was hitting the England bowlers for sixes, Sky Sports broadcaster Ian Ward, who was commentating with Shastri said, "Harry Brook told him to bat quickly to get his hundred in the last Test." Replying to this, Shastri said, "He is now saying Let me get my hundred and then I will show you." Mohammed Siraj castled Zak Crawley with a brilliant yorker to leave England on 50/1 in 13.5 overs at stumps on day three of fifth Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy Test against India at The Oval. India dominated most of day three's play - Akash Deep hitting an entertaining 66, his first Test fifty and was followed by Yashasvi Jaiswal making 118, his sixth Test century. Jaiswal's knock of 118 came off 164 balls, laced with 14 fours and two sixes, held immense value as it came in front of his parents and elder brother present in the stadium's stands, which also had ODI captain Rohit Sharma seeing the proceedings.
