Couple awarded £500,000 after 17-storey tower made it hard for them to read
Stephen and Jennifer Powell complained that the Arbor tower, part of the £2,000,000,000 Bankside Yards development on London's South Bank 'substantially' reduced the natural light getting to their 6th-floor apartment in the designer Bankside Lofts.
Bankside Yards is eventually set to consist of eight towers, some of them set to be 50 storeys high, but Arbor is the first and only building completed so far.
Before the tower was completed, though, developers ran into issues when the Powells and their neighbour Kevin Cooper sued to protect their rights of light.
The lawsuit threatened the £35,000,000 tower with potential demolition – but High Court Justice Fancourt refused an injunction, ruling that £200,000,000 would be wasted if the tower was demolished and rebuilt.
The Justice did find the couple's flat was 'substantially' affected by the natural light being blocked, and ordered the co-developer of the offices, Ludgate House Ltd, to pay the Powells £500,000 in damages, plus £350,000 to Mr Cooper.
The judge said that parts of the two flats had been left with levels of light 'insufficient for the ordinary use and enjoyment of those rooms.'
'I also conclude that there will, as a result, be a substantial adverse impact on the ordinary use and enjoyment of those flats,' he added.
Ludgate House Ltd had fought the claims, insisting that the tower doesn't block enough light from the neighbouring trio's £1,000,000-plus flats to give the owners a valid claim.
Lawyers said the couple could solve the issue by turning a light on while reading, adding: 'The room is a bedroom and any reading in bed would be done with the aid of artificial light.' More Trending
The judge awarded damages, saying the loss of light was 'principal' to the use and enjoyment of the flats.
He added: 'The reduced use and enjoyment value may have some impact on the market value.
'Mr Cooper and Mr Powell both stressed that they did not want money, they wanted their light, so that they could enjoy fully the advantages that their flats offered. Despite the loss of light, the flats remain useable, attractive and valuable, but less enjoyable in terms of their good light.'
The court previously heard the Powells have lived in their 6th-floor flat in the yellow ochre Bankside Lofts building on the south bank of the river for over 20 years, having moved in in 2002. Property finance professional Mr Cooper bought his 7th-floor flat in 2021.
Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@metro.co.uk.
For more stories like this, check our news page.
MORE: 'A real nuisance' – Londoners have their say on the city's e-bike boom
MORE: Woman screamed 'Oh my god' after man was stabbed to death outside Casino
MORE: Hope Rowe jailed for life for stabbing woman to death at child's party in east London
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Metro
10 hours ago
- Metro
McDonald's branch bans children from new adults-only area during weekdays
A McDonald's branch in Greater Manchester has become the first in the UK to introduce a dedicated 'business zone' – and anyone under 16 isn't welcome. The Whitefield restaurant has cordoned off part of its seating area for adults only on weekdays, reserving the space specifically for remote workers and laptop users looking for a quiet environment to get things done. The new set up is designed to cater to customers who want a calmer experience, allowing people to send emails, take video calls or even hold meetings in McDonald's without the usual background noise. The area is also available to pre-book by companies for group business meetings, although space isn't guaranteed. A notice spotted in the restaurant reads: 'On weekdays this area is reserved for business/laptop users and adults over 16. 'If you're lucky enough to look under 16, we reserve the right to ask you to use an alternative area of the restaurant.' McDonald's confirmed that the new quiet zone is only available at the Whitefield branch and is not a company-wide initiative. Simon Toft, who owns and operates the restaurant, said: 'Customer experience in my restaurant is incredibly important to me, and my team and I work hard to make sure everyone has a great time when visiting Whitefield McDonald's. 'After listening to customer feedback, we've introduced a dedicated Business Area on weekdays for anyone ages 16 and over who wants a quieter space to work or study. 'We want the restaurant to be a space that works for everyone—whether you're bringing the kids to enjoy the Play Place or looking for a calm spot to focus, we're proud to offer spaces that suit everyone as part of our commitment to being a good neighbour in our local community.' It's not the first time McDonald's has introduced measures to keep its younger customers in check. Some UK branches – including one in Wrexham, North Wales – play classical music in the evenings to deter rowdy teenagers from hanging around for hours inside. More Trending The chain has also experimented with turning off WiFi to ward off teenagers and antisocial behaviour. McDonald's restaurants seems to be a spot that many young people gravitate to after a certain time. It has decent-priced food, shelter, and a bathroom – what more could you want? While many young people are perfectly well-behaved, many branches seem keen to head off disruption before it starts. View More » So, if you're after a double cheeseburger and a bit of peace and quiet, you might want to give the Manchester branch a chance. Do you have a story to share? Get in touch by emailing MetroLifestyleTeam@ MORE: Man charged with murder after boy, 15, killed in e-bike crash in Middleton MORE: Bus roof torn off after it crashed into bridge leaving passenger fighting for life in Eccles MORE: Italian Oasis fans recreate iconic Manchester street Renaissance photo Your free newsletter guide to the best London has on offer, from drinks deals to restaurant reviews.
Daily Mirror
14 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Man Utd dealt huge problem by Alexander Isak transfer bombshell as 'contact made'
Alexander Isak's desire to look for a new club came as a huge shock for Newcastle United fans, but it may also have a rippling effect for Manchester United Alexander Isak's potential departure from Newcastle United could jeopardise Manchester United's pursuit of RB Leipzig striker Benjamin Sesko. Despite securing the services of Matheus Cunha in early June and recently finalising the signing of Bryan Mbeumo, United are still on the hunt for attacking reinforcements. After Viktor Gyokeres rejected a reunion with Ruben Amorim to join Arsenal, the Red Devils' focus has reportedly shifted to Sesko. With the north Londoners close to sealing a deal for Gyokeres, United seemed to have had a clear path to the towering Slovenian forward. However, if Newcastle offload Isak, who has been linked with Liverpool and Saudi Arabian outfit Al Hilal after informing Eddie Howe's side that he would like to explore an exit from St James' Park, the Magpies will be expected to move for Sesko. This could spell trouble for United, who have already missed out on many striking targets this summer. According to The Athletic, Newcastle are considering a move for Sesko, who boasts a record of 27 goals and seven assists in 64 Bundesliga outings for Leipzig. The Daily Mail have also claimed that Newcastle have approached Leipzig about the possibility of signing Sesko, who could command a fee in the region of £60m to £70m. With Isak seemingly looking for an exit, Newcastle might decide to capitalise on what could potentially be a Premier League record transfer fee for a player. If this happens, they will likely speed up their chase for another prolific goal-scorer and Sesko seems to fit the bill. Given that the Magpies are competing in the Champions League this season, United may struggle to lure Sesko to Old Trafford. Furthermore, having already splashed out around £132.5m on Mbeumo and Cunha, United will probably need to offload players before they can make a serious offer, while Newcastle could have ample funds to spend if Isak's departure is accelerated. After netting only 44 goals in the Premier League last season, United are still in dire need of a lethal striker. Cunha and Mbeumo are both sharp finishers, with 35 goals and 14 assists between them for their respective clubs last year. Unfortunately for Amorim, neither are traditional centre forwards, which United have been searching for this summer. The Red Devils have already missed out on Delap, Gyokeres and, most recently, Hugo Ekitike, who secured a £79m move to Liverpool this week. United reportedly held discussions with the representatives of Chelsea forward Nicolas Jackson, who is now thought to carry an £80m price tag. It's now understood a bid for the Senegal international from the Red Devils is unexpected. French outlet Foot Mercato also reported that Paris Saint-Germain's Randal Kolo Muani, who spent last season on loan at Juventus, is another potential target for United. However, Sesko could be the preferred choice for United. German media suggests he carries a price tag of around £60m - £12m less than what United shelled out to Atalanta for Rasmus Hojlund in 2023 - making the 22-year-old an attractive prospect. United still have Hojlund and Joshua Zirkzee in their squad, but neither have proven they can lead the attack. The loan move of Marcus Rashford to Barcelona has freed up space and about £12m in wages, but United will still need to generate funds first before they can entertain bidding for another forward. Resolving the futures of Antony, Alejandro Garnacho and Jadon Sancho, who the club are openly willing to sale, will likely be top of Amorim's agenda, especially now Newcastle are putting pressure on them in the race for Sesko.
Metro
2 days ago
- Metro
How foreign tourists are charged 50% more in Paris than French customers
Americans holidaying in Paris are being charged an extra 50% more that French customers. Newspaper Le Parisien sent out one of their reporters dressed like a tourist from the USA as well as one of their local employees to a cafe near the Eiffel Tower. Both sat down and ordered the same dish – a lasagna, a Coke and water – but given drastically different prices when given the check. The obviously 'French' customer was charged €6.50 for their soft drink and given a carafe of water for free. But the 'American' was charged €9.50 for a large coke which was only half a litre. They were also made to spend €6 on bottled water with no offer of a carafe. The pair moved to a different establishment to test the tipping policy. The 'French' customer had a 10% service charge included, but the 'American' was told it 'isn't included'. When he agreed to add a 10% tip, the waiter discreetly raised it to 15%. Franck Trouet of the hotel and restaurant umbrella group GHR said: 'It's a disgrace to the profession. You can't even call these people waiters. 'You should know that in France, water and bread are free. One can refuse a bottle of water. The tip is to express thanks for the service if one is very satisfied. Above all, it is not compulsory. This is not the United States'. Parisian restaurants and bars were also found to be cheating tourists out of wine last month. A sommelier posing as a tourist ordered a glass of Chablis costing around €9, but instead was served the cheapest €5 sauvignon on the menu – and was still charged the higher amount. Wine merchant Marina Giuberti said: 'It's a pity for the customer and for the image of the wine appellation, for the winemaker and for the restaurant owners who do a good job.' Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: New £17 travel charge comes into force across popular Greek islands MORE: Lonely Planet founder reveals the Greek island tourists haven't destroyed yet MORE: Sunbed Wars 2025: Worst UK offenders revealed as mum-of-six sparks fury
