Controversy erupts over decision to hold repeat exams before declaration of results
Teachers from polytechnic colleges across the State have raised serious concerns over the move, calling it 'unprecedented.' They asked why the department was conducting supplementary exams even before announcing the results of regular exams, suggesting a possible manipulation to favour certain students.
Dr. Shino P. Jose, a teacher in the higher education sector, said such a move was unheard of. 'This is the first time that an exam board is re-conducting exams for failed students without declaring who has failed. It clearly indicates an effort to protect their own people,' he added.
The circular issued by the office of the Joint Controller of Examinations on June 2 has intensified suspicions, with critics saying that the move deviated from standard examination protocols and compromised the transparency of the evaluation process.
'Rather than officially announcing the results, identifying those who failed, and then scheduling a supplementary exam, the department appears to be identifying them unofficially and giving them a second chance before the public is even informed of the results,' Dr. Shino said. He urged the Controller of Examinations to provide a transparent explanation for the circular and safeguard academic integrity.
Meanwhile, the silence of other teachers within the Directorate on the issue has added to the scepticism. Stakeholders are demanding accountability and transparency to uphold the credibility of the State's technical education system. However, Joint Controller of Technical Examinations V.V. Ray defended the decision, stating it was implemented following a government order.
'Based on the directorate's recommendation, the government permitted repeat exams for students who failed or were absent in the institution-level theory examination under the Revision 21 syllabus in the State's polytechnic colleges, Mr. Ray said.
He added that the institution-level exams, introduced as part of curriculum reforms, aim to empower the institutions and mirror the academic model of autonomous colleges.
'During inspections, it was observed that government colleges followed strict evaluation, while self-financing institutions were more lenient. To ensure fairness, a second chance was given to affected students,' he clarified.
Mr. Ray also said that the question papers were prepared and evaluated by teachers across institutions—whether government, aided, or self-financing—and that marks were later consolidated in the official mark list.
Dr. Shino, however, dismissed the justification, stating that institutional autonomy cannot be equated with the University Grants Commission-recognised autonomous college status. He pointed out that no polytechnic in Kerala qualifies for such autonomy, and only a small number of colleges in the State hold official autonomous status.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
JNU to hold separate entrance test for two PhD programmes outside UGC-NET; check details here
(JNU) has announced that it will independently conduct the Jawaharlal Nehru University Entrance Examination (JNUEE) for admissions to two specific PhD programmes — Korean Studies and Cinema Studies, for the academic year 2025–26. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now These two disciplines are not currently included under the University Grants Commission's National Eligibility Test (UGC-NET), which is otherwise the standard route for doctoral admissions. The decision to hold a separate entrance test was taken by the respective schools within the university, not the central administration. For all other PhD programmes, JNU will continue to use UGC-NET scores as the basis for admission. The move to conduct JNUEE for the two courses comes in light of the fact that no specific UGC-NET subjects exist for either Korean Studies or Cinema Studies. Protests and hunger strike continue over demand for full JNUEE restoration Meanwhile, tensions continue to simmer on campus as presses for a wider reinstatement of JNUEE across all PhD programmes. The students' union has been staging an indefinite hunger strike, now entering its sixth consecutive day. Their core demand is the restoration of the traditional JNUEE format for all doctoral admissions, not just the two programmes in question. The protest began last Thursday, following the release of the official PhD admission schedule for the upcoming academic year. A scheduled meeting with the university's vice chancellor, which was expected to address student concerns, was postponed without explanation on Tuesday, further fuelling discontent. As of now, there is no official word from the administration on whether the demand for a full reinstatement of JNUEE will be considered.
Indian Express
21 hours ago
- Indian Express
Bombay HC directs Maharashtra archaeology body to preserve ancient rock art sites in Konkan region, utilise funds of Rs 4.32 crore
The Bombay High Court Wednesday ordered the Maharashtra director of archaeology and museums to take required steps to protect and preserve ancient rock art petroglyphs or geoglyphs found in the Konkan region. The court also directed that the sanctioned funds to the tune of Rs 4.32 crore be utilised for preservation, conservation, development and management of these carvings or engravings on rock surfaces. A division bench of Chief Justice Alok Aradhe and Sandeep V Marne disposed of a PIL that raised concerns that a proposed mega oil refinery in the Barsu-Solgaon area in Ratnagiri district may end up harming the rock art. However, it granted liberty to the petitioners to give suggestions on the maintenance of the petroglyphs and to suggest any additional sites for preservation beyond the seventeen listed by the authorities. The PIL was filed by three people, including two residents of Barsu and Goval villages in the Ratnagiri district, where residents and activists had staged protests against the oil refinery project last year. The Indian Express in December 2022 reported that conservationists and archaeologists, including members of an expert team from the Central government, had raised concerns, stating that the refinery would damage the petroglyphs and could be relocated 5-10 km away from the present site. The petitioners, through senior advocate Gayatri Singh and advocate Hamza Lakdawala, sought preservation and protection of petroglyph sites in Maharashtra. They also sought direction to the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) to initiate necessary proceedings under the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958, to protect the geoglyphs included in the UNESCO World Heritage tentative list. The assistant director of the state Directorate of Archaeology and Museums filed an affidavit, in reply to the PIL, stated that it submitted a proposal to the ASI in July 2021 for inclusion of nine petroglyph sites in Maharashtra, including Kasheli, Rundhetali, Devache Gothane, Barsu, Devihasol, Jambhrun and Ukshi in Ratnagiri district, and Kudopi in Sindhudurg district, along with Fansaimal in Goa, in the UNESCO World Heritage category. The Directorate added that the final nomination dossier was submitted to the UNESCO World Heritage Centre, Paris, through the ASI in January 2024. The affidavit further stated that on May 25, 2023, the Directorate sent a letter to the CEO of the Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation (MIDC) for excluding the Devache Gothane and Barasu petroglyph sites from the oil refinery project. The affidavit added that based on the Directorate's request, the MIDC took a 'positive action' and informed it in July 2023 about the exclusion of Devache Gothane and Barasu petroglyph sites land parcels from the proposed land acquisition for the project. The Directorate further stated that it proposed to the Maharashtar state cultural affairs ministry for conservation, development and management of seventeen petroglyph sites, including Bhagavatinagar, Chave, Deud, Ukshi Pochri, Ukshi, Niwali Gawadewadi, Kapadgaon, Umare, Kolambe, Kasheli, Wadi Rundhe, Devi Hasol, Solgaon, Devache Gothane, Goval and Barasu (petroglyph No. 1) and Barasu (petroglyph No. 2). Furthermore, the state government granted administrative approval for Rs 4.32 cror e for the conservation of petroglyph sites in Ratnagiri and Sindhudurg. The bench, in view of the stand taken by the state government and the Directorate, ordered authorities to preserve the identified petroglyph sites.
Time of India
2 days ago
- Time of India
Junk NFS system in teachers' hiring, says min
Lucknow: Taking a stand against the 'Not Found Suitable' (NFS) system used to reject candidates for teaching posts, minister of state for social welfare Asim Arun met with minister for higher education Yogendra Upadhyay on Tuesday to demand the elimination of this system. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Arun stated that the NFS system was prevalent in the recruitment process of teachers in higher educational institutions in Uttar Pradesh and was patently unfair. He alleged that a large number of qualified candidates were declared NFS without clear reasons, often resulting in talented candidates from reserved categories being eliminated during selection. "Currently, many teaching positions in reserved categories are vacant in the state, and due to the opaque NFS system, these positions are not being filled," Arun said. In his representation to the minister, Arun provided three suggestions to do away with the NFS system. He suggested that the use of NFS should be limited and clear reasons for invoking it should be provided. Additionally, the guidelines of the University Grants Commission (UGC) and the National Education Policy (NEP-2020) for the selection of teachers should be clearly followed. He also suggested that the academic scores, research work, written exam, and interview scores of every candidate should be recorded to maintain transparency. Furthermore, he recommended that a video-recorded demo class be made mandatory for each candidate, along with the interview, to make the selection process verifiable.
