Jury discharged due to 'matters beyond my control', judge says
Ms Justice Karen O'Connor today told the jury of five women and seven men in the trial of Joseph Lawlor that she was "very sorry" the trial could not continue, but it would not be appropriate to go into detail about what had happened.
Advertisement
Mr Lawlor (39) pleaded not guilty to murdering dad-of-three Michael Ryan (51) outside the accused man's home in Hampton Wood Way, St Margaret's Road, Finglas, Dublin 11 on June 20th, 2024. His trial began on June 19th.
The jury had been told to expect the prosecution case to close early last week but issues arose that Ms Justice O'Connor told them needed to be dealt with in their absence.
When the jury returned to court on Monday morning, Ms Justice O'Connor told them she had no alternative but to discharge.
Ireland
Court must avoid judiciary being dragged into supe...
Read More
She thanked them for their attentiveness and exempted them from further jury duty for five years.
The trial had heard that Mr Lawlor and Mr Ryan had been drinking together in Mr Lawlor's home. A series of fights between them were captured on CCTV, by neighbours using their telephones and by a Ring doorbell.
The final, fatal encounter occurred shortly after midnight and resulted in Mr Ryan suffering a single stab wound to the neck that severed an artery.
Having discharged the jury, Ms Justice O'Connor put the matter back to July 22nd when a date will be fixed for a second trial.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
6 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Married Cork farmer (60) jailed for rape of man
A married farmer from County Cork was sentenced to a total of 19 years in jail for raping another man twice, but he will serve less than ten years for just one of the offences. Thomas 'Tossy' Nyhan, 60, Crookstown, Co Cork, was sentenced to 11.5 years with the final year suspended, for raping the man, in April 2019. Advertisement Nyhan, who has four children, received a second sentence of 8.5 years for raping the man, in January 2011. The rapes occurred at a location in Limerick, the court heard. As both sentences are to run concurrent to each other, Nyhan will only serve part of the longest sentence. The sentences were backdated to June 23rd last when Nyhan first entered custody. He has no previous convictions. Advertisement Nyhan had contested two counts of anal rape of the victim, but he was unanimously convicted by a jury of both rapes, following an 11-day trial, held at the Central Criminal Court, sitting in Limerick, last May. Ms Justice Mary Ellen Ring had previously lifted reporting restrictions last May allowing Nyhan be named. The judge also directed that the victim was entitled to his anonymity and ordered that he not be identified. The victim told the trial that the rapes were so painful they were like 'barbed wire' inside him. Advertisement The victim wrote in a victim impact statement that, there were "not words strong enough to capture the pain" he had suffered. "He (Nyhan) raped me twice. This was not a moment of confusion. It was cold, calculated and violent – he knew what he was doing – and eight years later he did it again," the man said. "This is what he chose. This is who he is. I trusted him and told him about my trauma and vulnerabilities and he controlled, degraded and violated me in the most horrific way." The man said that Nyhan spoke about his own children during one of the rapes, which the victim described as "twisted and inhumane". Advertisement He said he disclosed the second rape to his GP in 2019, because, he said, he 'could not hold the weight of his abuse any longer". Later he told Gardaí he had also been raped by Nyhan in 2011. The man told how he continues to feel like he is being watched and feels "trapped" by feelings of being "constantly sick with anxiety". 'I am a ghost of the man I used to be. I am broken, alone. I have no one, because my barriers are always up," the man said. "He (Nyhan) is a rapist and that will follow him for the rest of his life and it should." Advertisement The victim encouraged others similarly affected by sexual crimes to seek help and try and bring the perpetrators to justice: 'Please hear this – standing up and speaking out is one of the most hardest things but it is powerful and life-changing.' Previously, the victim asked Ms Justice Ring to impose a sentence on Nyhan that reflected his crimes: 'Let it say this matters – we matter. Please show what I lost matters. What he did Matters.' The man thanked the jury "for listening and for believing me – that has meant more to me than you will ever know". When questioned by Gardaí in May 2019, Nyhan accepted sexual activity had occurred between him and the victim, yet he denied raping him. The prosecution case was presented in court by senior counsel Fionnuala O'Sullivan, barrister Lily Buckley, who were instructed by Aoife O'Halloran, Chief State Solicitor's Office, after an investigation by Gardaí attached to the National Garda Protective Services Bureau, (NGPSB), at Henry Street Garda Station, Limerick City, which deals solely with sexual crimes. During the trial, and under cross-examination by Nyhan's barrister, senior counsel Mark Nicholas, the victim agreed that he had remained in regular contact with Nyhan following the first rape in 2011. The victim described as 'lies', unfounded claims by Nyhan that he had asked the farmer for money for sex and that he had grabbed Nyhan's 'crotch' a number of times and removed his own clothes to have sex with Nyhan. The victim told Mr Nicholas: 'I told him (Nyhan) to stop, I didn't like it.' When asked by the barrister what he was doing when he alleged that Nyhan was removing his trousers and underpants, the victim replied: 'I was just scared, I just froze.' The victim described as 'bullshit' further unfounded claims by Nyhan, put by the barrister, that the victim had been in possession of 'a knife' at the time and that Nyhan 'was afraid' he'd harm himself, and that Nyhan 'pretended to go along' with sex. The victim told the court Nyhan threw him on the bed, and 'thrust' himself into the victim telling him he 'loved' him, despite the victim's pleas 'No'. The victim told the court Nyhan's denials were 'lies'. 'It was like barbed wire ... it was like hell, like something burning you,' the victim said, breaking down in tears. Nyhan's wife, Mary Nyhan, supported her husband to court every day of his trial and throughout the criminal proceedings. Before he was being led away to prison today, members of Nyhan's family cried, roared and hugged him. Judge Ring said evidence accepted by the jury was that, during one of the rapes, Nyhan used a shoelace tied around his own penis in an effort to make it erect as he suffered with erectile dysfunction after he had cancer. 'Nyhan complained it (his penis) wasn't working, and the victim described that he then kissed (the victim's) balls. Nyhan said he would pay him and left €150,' the judge said. "Nyhan then proceeded to masturbate while sitting on the bed and ejaculated onto the floor next to the bed. Nyhan then left. The victim spoke about washing with really cold water and going outside to burn the money.' DNA Swabs taken by forensic Gardaí of a stain at the scene of the 2019 rape matched Nyhan's DNA profile. The judge said Nyhan had told the victim that 'he couldn't have sex' with his wife. 'Nyhan said to the victim if he had sex with him he could go home and have sex with his wife. He then took the victim into a bedroom, took off his pants and had anal intercourse.' Commenting on Nyhan, the judge said: 'He is a man without prior criminal convictions, and to all intents and purposes lived the quiet, hardworking life of a farmer.' Ireland Inmates given almost €550,000 in 'bus money' over... Read More The judge said Nyhan, who was represented by Mark Nicholas SC, Liam Carroll BL, instructed by solicitor Sarah Ryan, had acted in a 'serious and sinister' fashion. 'It is clear that Nyhan knew that the victim had not told anyone of the 2011 rape, and thus he had the confidence to rape again in 2019, assuming that the victim would stay silent again,' the judge said. In mitigation, the judge took into consideration Nyhan's age, no previous convictions, health difficulties and that he has been a hard-working family man. If you have been affected by any of the issues raised in this article, you can call the national 24-hour Rape Crisis Helpline at 1800-77 8888, access text service and webchat options at or visit Rape Crisis Help.
BreakingNews.ie
6 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Convicted killer spent €100k on 'grandiose' renovations to Limerick home, court hears
A convicted killer previously jailed for 'feud-related' offences who has never had a job spent €100,000 carrying out 'grandiose' renovations on his family home in Limerick, a court has heard. A sentencing hearing for Richard Treacy (36) of Downey St, Garryowen, heard on Monday that the house where the defendant lived with his partner and two children was purchased by another in 2014, and various renovation works were carried out over a number of years. Advertisement Lawyers for Treacy today objected to the term 'feud' being used by a prosecuting garda in relation to the defendant's previous convictions. Treacy's defence counsel, Lorcan Connolly SC, suggested the detective garda had gone 'off-piste' and that this was done in an effort to 'colour' the judges' view of his client. He made an application for the three-judge panel to recuse themselves and for another panel to be introduced, but this was rejected by presiding judge Ms Justice Karen O'Connor, who said the judges were 'all very experienced' and were not of the view that there was a problem in them continuing. Treacy previously pleaded guilty that he, between January 1st, 2014 and January 12th, 2021, knowing or being reckless as to whether renovation work carried out at his home address was the proceeds of criminal conduct, did disguise the true source of the property. Advertisement The offence is contrary to section 7 of the Criminal Justice (Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing) Act 2010. Detective Garda Ronan O'Reilly told prosecution counsel Fiona Murphy SC that on June 17th, 2020, gardaí searched the house at Garryowen and found £3,900 of sterling and €4,000 in a sock drawer of the bedroom. Two further quantities of cash were found in a kitchen cupboard. Treacy told gardaí in a voluntary memorandum that another person was the registered owner of the house and that renovation works were carried out on the property. Advertisement He said a family member gave him the €4,000 for an extension on the house. No explanation was given for the sterling, and Treacy said the two quantities, amounting to over €1,000, found in the kitchen were from savings and his dole money. Garda O'Reilly said Social Welfare and Revenue were contacted in relation to Treacy's work history and confirmed there was no record of the accused ever having been employed. There was evidence of some claims that had been attributed to Treacy from a number of court actions. He confirmed to counsel that a guilty plea was entered by Treacy on the first day of the trial, which had been expected to last two weeks, and it was accepted that €100,000 was spent on renovating the house. Advertisement Det Gda O'Reilly said Treacy resides at the property in question with his partner and children. He told the court Treacy has ten previous convictions, including for manslaughter, dangerous driving causing serious harm and violent disorder. Treacy also has previous convictions for careless driving and public order offences. Referencing the violent disorder offence, Det Gda O'Reilly said the defendant and some of his relations got involved in a violent disorder incident 'with a feuding other family in the city'. Regarding the manslaughter conviction, Garda O'Reilly said this was 'another feud-related incident'. He said the deceased was a relation of a high-end criminal in the city. Advertisement Lorcan Connolly SC, for Treacy, said this 'additional information' was unnecessary. He said Treacy's last conviction was nine years ago and highlighted that this coincided with the arrival of his children. In cross-examination, Garda O'Reilly agreed with counsel that the subject matter on the indictment was in relation to the renovation and the works were done over a number of years. He confirmed that no charges were brought in relation to the sums of money found in the house. Mr Connolly said his client resides at the property in question with his partner and two children. He said his client has an active role in his children's upbringing and has been a positive influence in their lives. He asked the court to consider the amount of money involved relative to other cases and to the passage of time involved, spanning a period of some seven years. He said the house was a 'relatively modest' home in a council estate and was not like other cases involving a 'palatial home' overlooking a scenic view. A period of nine years has elapsed in which Treacy has been 'trouble-free', he said. Mr Connolly said he was 'taken aback' by the fact that Det Gda O'Reilly had mentioned the word 'feud' in relation to his client's previous convictions. He said this was done off the garda's 'own bat'. He said prosecuting counsel had 'carefully' led the garda through his evidence, but Det Gda O'Reilly had gone 'off-piste' by mentioning feuds. He suggested the only reason for this was to 'colour' the court's view of his client. He made an application for the three-judge panel to recuse themselves and for another panel to be introduced. Ms Murphy said the evidence and the basis the plea was entered on was that monies had been paid for renovations on a home in the city centre, making it 'grandiose'. She said no evidence has been given in relation to those monies other than in circumstances where Treacy has been on social welfare. She said there was no evidence of him ever earning a living and that, bar some civil claims, there was no explanation for those monies. She said nothing had been said that wasn't true, and Det Gda O'Reilly had simply 'placed context' on Treacy's previous convictions. Ms Murphy said there was no evidence in relation to the plea before the court that linked it to the other matters. Ms Justice O'Connor said the three-judge panel were not prepared to recuse themselves and did not believe it was necessary to do so. She said the panel 'are all very experienced' and were not of the view that there was any problem in continuing. Mr Connolly said one of the key factors when it comes to a money laundering offence is the amount involved. He said this wasn't a 'standard case' where gardaí found €100,000 or €200,000 in a shoebox. He said his client's plea of guilty was valuable to the court and handed in a number of testimonials on Treacy's behalf. Ms Justice O'Connor adjourned the matter to October 20th for finalisation.
BreakingNews.ie
36 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Inmates given almost €550,000 in 'bus money' over past five years after release from prison
Prisoners have been given almost €550,000 in 'bus money' to cover the cost of transport following their release from jail over the past five years, new figures have revealed. The annual amount spent helping inmates get to their desired destinations after leaving prison has more than doubled since 2022 due to rising transport costs and a 25 per cent increase in releases. Advertisement Last year, the Irish Prison Service (IPS) spent €182,121 on bus, train and taxi fares for inmates upon their release from jail. This was a 16 per cent increase from the previous year, and more than double the €87,598 that was spent in 2022. Prisoners receive 'pocket money' of up to €2.20 per day while serving custodial sentences, and can earn an additional €3.50 per week by engaging in work training activities. Nearly €6.8 million in taxpayers' cash was paid to inmates in pocket money over the past two years, while an additional €12.4 million was gifted to them by friends and family on the outside during the same period. There was more than €1.5 million held in back accounts managed by the IPS on behalf of inmates at the beginning of this year, according to records released under the Freedom of Information Act. Advertisement However, if prisoners still need help getting to their desired destination following their release, the IPS can issue a travel voucher, which specifies a destination but not a monetary value. 'Upon release, the [IPS] provides support to assist prisoners in transitioning back into the community,' said a spokesman. 'One aspect of this support is the provision of travel vouchers for those who need assistance reaching their destination. The IPS is billed directly by transport providers, ensuring that 'released individuals can travel without needing to cover the cost upfront, reducing barriers to reintegration," he explained. The spokesman said the increase in the costs associated with post-release transport was likely attributable to price increases by travel providers, and a rise in the number of releases each year. A total of 34,592 prisoners were released during the five years, with the annual number increasing by 26 per cent from 6,438 to 8,113 between 2022 and 2024. The annual amount spent on 'bus money' for prisoners decreased from €78,200 in 2020 to €43,760 the following year due to the Covid-19 pandemic. It increased to €87,598 in 2022 and soared to €156,791 in 2023. Last year, it increased by another 16 per cent to €182,121.
