Man (46) jailed for taking photographs of his teenage stepdaughter in the shower
The 46-year-old man, who cannot be named to protect the identity of the girl, pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to production of child pornography in that he knowingly produced 11 images of a female child which would be considered child pornography at a Dublin hostel on April 12th, 2018.
Advertisement
Sergeant Brendan Casey told John Griffin BL, prosecuting, that gardaí were called to a hostel in Dublin on April 9th, 2018, because there were concerns about a man with a child.
The child was 16 years old at the time and hostel staff told gardaí that there had been inappropriate contact between the man and the child.
The man was 39 years old at the time and when staff tried to engage in conversation with him, he became protective of the girl and said she was fine. He left the hostel.
Gardaí viewed CCTV footage to assist in identification of the man.
Advertisement
The man and the child moved on to another hostel but ultimately returned to the original hostel and staff contacted gardaí.
Gardaí arrived at the hostel and seized the man's phone where the images were discovered. The photographs had been taken on April 12th, 2018.
Sentencing the man on Thursday Judge Martina Baxter said it was a monumental breach of trust where the man 'took complete advantage of a young person' and that he was the person in control.
The reason given was 'self-serving and I'm satisfied it was for his own gratification' …'and that was exploitation,' said the judge. 'Some pathetic excuse was provided' saying she asked him to take pictures of her to send on to her boyfriend, Judge Baxter noted.
Advertisement
She set a headline sentence of three years. She noted there was a European Arrest Warrant and said gardaí were to be commended for their very thorough investigation.
In mitigation she noted his plea, as the young person who is now 23 was unavailable to give evidence. She also noted he has engaged with the Probation Service and appeared to have genuine insight.
Judge Baxter sentenced him to one year imprisonment and backdated it to February, for time spent in custody.
Sgt Casey told Mr Griffin that a statement was taken from the teenage girl. She said she was originally from a different country. She lived with her mother and stepfather in Ireland.
Advertisement
The man was interviewed three times and admitted taking photographs of his stepdaughter while she was in the shower. He said he had been drunk at the time.
He failed to appear for his trial date on November 9th, 2020, and had fled Ireland. He was later extradited back here and remanded in custody.
The court heard that the relationship had ended with the child's mother and the child had stopped attending school when the relationship broke down.
It was accepted that the photographs had been deleted by the man but retrieved by the gardaí.
Advertisement
It was further accepted that there was no evidence that they had been distributed or shared. Some of the images were duplicates.
Ireland
Woman who reported brother for childhood rape says...
Read More
Defending counsel Anne Marie Lawlor SC handed in documentation to the court outlining the man's dedication to rehabilitation.
Counsel said her client had remorse and shame for his involvement and asked the court to accept that as the teenager is no longer reachable, his plea of guilty was valuable to the prosecution.
Counsel asked the court to take into account that the images had been deleted, that it had been an isolated incident and that he had not distributed the images.
If you have been affected by any of the issues raised in this article, you can call the national 24-hour Rape Crisis Helpline at 1800-77 8888, access text service and webchat options at drcc.ie/services/helpline/ or visit Rape Crisis Help.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
38 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Footballer, journalist, fashionista: whatever French Muslims do, we're treated as the enemy within
Being a Muslim in a country with a long colonial history, which has also had to deal with terrorist attacks carried out in the name of Islam, is an everyday challenge. In January 2015, for example, I was as profoundly shocked as everyone else in France by the massacre of the Charlie Hebdo journalists in Paris. As the country mourned, I was invited by a major radio station to comment, but was first asked, live on air, to 'dissociate' myself from the attackers. I had been critical of Charlie Hebdo's publications in the past, but my comments always fell within the scope of legitimate political debate. Nevertheless, as a Muslim, I was now treated as if I was under suspicion. In order to be tolerated on the airwaves, I had to profess my innocence: state publicly that I had nothing to do with the violence. I couldn't hold back my tears – because, even with a media profile, I was reduced to the most racist perception of my identity. I was strongly defended that night by others who took part in the show, and received much support online, but I couldn't help thinking of the millions of French Muslims who, unlike me, would have no microphone to defend themselves against vile accusations. Some years later I was invited to take part in a TV debate on the thesis: is the white man always guilty. I was expecting a conversation about gender and race. But my opponent, the philosopher Pascal Bruckner, immediately took me to task, claiming that I had used my status 'as a Black, Muslim woman' to incite hatred against Charlie Hebdo. He claimed that I had, in effect, blood on my hands, that my words had 'led to the murder of 12 people at Charlie Hebdo'. I immediately protested, stating as firmly as I could, that I had 'absolutely no responsibility for any terrorist attack'. But Bruckner wouldn't let go. He attacked me for having signed a joint statement in 2011, following a night-time petrol-bomb attack at the Charlie Hebdo premises that caused, fortunately, only material damage. Nothing in the statement – which I did not draft and was co-signed by 20 other academics and activists– had called for hatred or violence. It had been critical of the disproportionate media treatment of the fire at Charlie Hebdo when vandalism of Muslim places of worship featured rarely in the news. Signatories had expressed dismay at the selective nature of French national outrage, highlighting the indifference shown after an arson attack on a Paris building inhabited by Roma people, in which a man died. But Bruckner repeated his accusations in an interview the next day, claiming without any evidence that he had simply 'reminded Rokhaya Diallo of her involvement in political Islam' adding – as if it were a crime – that I had 'criticised Charlie Hebdo by calling them Islamophobic and racist'. I felt I had no option but to file a defamation lawsuit against Bruckner, believing the accusation to be not just outrageous and insulting, but influenced by my origins and my faith. But defending myself was viewed as another provocation. Le Figaro, the leading conservative daily, published a highly offensive article on the eve of the trial, which, without even bothering to interview me, stated: 'Inspired by the Muslim Brotherhood, 'anti-racist' activists like Rokhaya Diallo are multiplying lawsuits to silence critics of Islamism.' Taking legal action as a Muslim woman was framed as a 'jihadist' political plot. This kind of smear tactic is used again and again to discredit any Muslim who calls out Islamophobia. When the footballer Karim Benzema spoke in support of the people of Gaza in October 2023, the then interior minister Gerard Darmanin declared – without a shred of evidence – that the player had 'well-known ties to the Muslim Brotherhood'. In May, a report commissioned by the interior ministry into the Muslim Brotherhood fuelled suspicion of all French Muslims by recycling conspiracy theories around supposed 'infiltration'. The report was as the the socio-anthropologist Hamza Esmili put it, 'intellectually impoverished'. Yet Bruno Retailleau, the current interior minister, used alarmist conspiracy tropes to describe its conclusions, claiming it had identified 'a very clear threat to the republic and to national cohesion' and 'a quiet form of Islamist infiltration whose ultimate goal is to bring all of French society under sharia law'. But even the report stated unequivocally: 'No recent document demonstrates any intent by Muslims of France to establish an Islamic state in France or to enforce sharia law there.' It added that the Brotherhood's members in France today are estimated to number 'between 400 and 1,000 people'. As Esmili argues, French Muslims present a paradox: we are part of every social sphere, yet many of us have not given up our cultural specificities. And that is precisely what we are blamed for – integration without assimilation. This is why the same government can claim it uses the law to fight against Muslim 'separatism' while denouncing the threat of Muslim 'infiltration'. Muslims can't win: we are blamed for being part of the national community and for being outside of it. Thus, no matter what level we reach in the social pecking order, being Muslim always carries the suspicion of association with a radical and dangerous ideology: of being the enemy within. Sign up to This is Europe The most pressing stories and debates for Europeans – from identity to economics to the environment after newsletter promotion So when Léna Situations, a major fashion influencer in France, appeared on the Cannes film festival red carpet wearing a long dress with a headscarf, a senior official in Emmanuel Macron's party suggested on social media that she was practising a form of religious 'infiltration'. As if an outfit was in itself proof of extremism. The influencer never mentioned her religion but it made no difference – her Algerian heritage alone was enough to disqualify her. Even non-Muslims who take a stand against this hostile climate are subjected to similar accusations. Emile Ackermann – a rabbi vocal on Islamophobia – was accused by a self-proclaimed academic 'expert' of being inspired by a 'Brotherist' discourse. Such absurd accusations would be laughable if the situation weren't so volatile, with Islamophobic crime on the increase. Take the case of the hairdresser Hichem Miraoui, killed in June in the south of France, in what investigators are treating as a racially motivated act of domestic terrorism. Miraoui had been the target of racist rhetoric posted on social media by a neighbour who also denounced the French state as 'incapable of protecting us from Muslims'. Yet, the very same state constantly fuels a narrative portraying Muslims as a problem. During the defamation lawsuit I launched against Bruckner, and its appeal, my accuser and his lawyer leaned into these cliches. While the philosopher repeated his accusations and suggested that I was funded by 'foreign powers', his lawyer told the court that, given that Charlie Hebdo's case files amounted to several tonnes of documents, no one could say for sure whether my name was not mentioned in them. Elyamine Settoul, a political scientist and expert on jihadism, testified, however, that terrorists are radicalised through direct contacts and in no way rely on intellectual debates or interventions. And the expert and former Islamic State hostage Nicolas Hénin testified that my name appeared 'neither in the legal proceedings concerning the January 2015 attack, nor in the research conducted on the subject'. He told the court that 'the jihadist sphere holds nothing but contempt' for people like me because of my 'multicultural progressivism, which aligns with none of their religious doctrines'. Bruckner was acquitted in the first instance on the grounds that he had attributed to me only 'purely moral responsibility' and invited me to 'take ownership of the weight of my words and commitments'. The appeal court overturned the initial judgment, recognising the defamatory nature of Bruckner's remarks, yet still acquitted him on the grounds that he had made his statement 'in good faith'. Just like the 'yellow peril' once attributed to east Asians, or the supposed 'cosmopolitanist' trope used about Jews, the image of an allegedly foreign group secretly infiltrating France's circles of influence is once again thriving, in a sadly familiar strain of dangerous racist rhetoric. Rokhaya Diallo is a Guardian Europe columnist
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Criminal justice teacher who put his student, 15, in 'choke hold until he lost consciousness' has lengthy rap sheet
A high school criminal justice teacher and basketball coach at the center of a growing scandal after police say he placed a 15-year-old student in a choke hold owns a lengthy rap sheet, it has been revealed. Devon Murphy, 41, a teacher at Douglas Byrd High School in Fayetteville, North Carolina, has been charged with felony assault by strangulation and misdemeanor child abuse stemming from an alleged attack that took place in March. According to court documents, Murphy 'put his arm around the juvenile victim's neck in a choke hold position until the victim lost consciousness,' inflicting visible swelling on the right side of the student's forehead. 'The defendant unlawfully and willfully, being a person providing care and supervision because of a teacher and student relationship… did inflict physical injury on that child,' the arrest warrant states. Public records reviewed by the Daily Mail show that Murphy has been arrested eight times over the last 16 years, mainly for non-payment of rent. He has amassed more than $5,000 in unpaid debts, and in at least four cases landlords had to take legal action to have him forcibly evicted from their properties - most recently in 2022. Murphy was arrested late last month, four months after the alleged incident took place. He was booked into the Cumberland County Detention Center before being released on $25,000 secured bond. Murphy appeared in court on Friday and is scheduled to return for a disposition hearing on August 20. The arrest warrant details how Murphy allegedly used a choke hold maneuver that rendered the teenager unconscious. The alleged assault happened on school grounds, during the school day. The Fayetteville Police Department has launched a full criminal investigation, and its Youth Services Unit has urged any other potential victims or witnesses to come forward. 'These allegations are concerning and do not reflect the standards we expect of those who serve our students,' the Cumberland County Schools (CCS) district said in a statement. 'The safety of our students and staff remains our top priority.' The charges against Murphy have already shocked parents and staff. It is unclear whether Cumberland County Schools conducted a full background check before hiring Murphy in October 2013, or if his prior arrests were disclosed or considered irrelevant to his employment. In response to the most recent charges, CCS says it immediately suspended Murphy with pay after learning of the allegations. 'As soon as the situation was brought to our attention, we reported it to law enforcement and suspended the employee with pay, pending the outcome of the investigation,' a CCS spokesperson told WCCN. Murphy has served in both middle and high schools since joining the district more than a decade ago. He also worked as head coach of the boys' varsity basketball team at Douglas Byrd High. The school has not commented on whether the student involved in the case was a player on the team or had other personal interactions with Murphy outside of class. There are questions as to why it took police more than four months to arrest Murphy. The alleged assault took place in March, but Murphy wasn't arrested until July 24. The district also has not explained whether Murphy continued teaching or coaching students between March and his late-July arrest. His current employment status is 'suspended with pay.' No motive has been revealed, and neither the victim's identity nor the specific circumstances leading up to the alleged attack have been disclosed publicly due to the juvenile's age. Murphy remains free on bond and has not commented publicly on the charges. Murphy is due back in court on August 20, where he is expected to face a preliminary hearing that could determine whether the case proceeds to trial.
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
The Tesla whistleblower and the cost of taking on Elon Musk
In November 2022, a whistleblower contacted investigative journalist Sönke Iwersen. He could not give his name, he said, but he had access to huge amounts of data about Tesla, his former employer: private phone numbers, social security information, bank statements, documents stamped 'top secret', and much, much more. It could not be real, Iwersen thought – his editor at the German newspaper Handelsblatt agreed. Still, he tells Helen Pidd, they kept digging. It was the start of a years-long investigation into Tesla, and a years-long relationship with the whistleblower, too. Here, he shares what he learned – not only exposing serious safety concerns about Tesla's famed autopilot, but giving a glimpse into the company culture under the leadership of Elon Musk, the world's richest man. 'Narcissism', says Iwersen. His book detailing it all, The Tesla Files, written with fellow journalist Michael Verfürden, is out now.
