logo
Murder and kidnapping, rampant at Delhi pumps, as authorities impose a car ban

Murder and kidnapping, rampant at Delhi pumps, as authorities impose a car ban

India Today18 hours ago
Rajesh was out with his beloved Senorita, not a flamenco dancer, but his trusted diesel car, on an ordinary weekday morning. Like many mornings before, he pulled into a Delhi fuel pump to top up. But what happened next was anything but ordinary. Two men in Khaki wardis approached him and, without preamble, asked him to hand over Senorita. Utterly bewildered, Rajesh mustered the courage to ask why. The answer came in the form of a blunt statement that the cameras had detected that his Senorita was over 10 years old and had lost the right to live. Senorita, Rajesh's beloved diesel car was bought with his hard-earned money. The 7-year EMI term had only just ended a few years ago, finally bringing him financial relief.advertisementThis wasn't a random act of coercion. It was enforcement in action. An act of legalised injustice which feels like theft in broad daylight is, on paper, perfectly lawful. In what can be called state-sponsored swindling, vehicles are being taken from their owners under the guise of environmental compliance.There are hundreds of people like Rajesh on Delhi's streets today, whose prized possessions are being confiscated by authorities. The situation has become so dire that people have started selling off their expensive cars at throwaway prices just to avoid a total loss.
Delhi's crackdown on "end-of-life vehicles." not death but the presumed end by the authorities, those older than 10 years for diesels and 15 for petrol has reached fuel stations, where surveillance cameras now scan number plates and automatically flag non-compliant vehicles. Owners like Rajesh are then denied fuel, sometimes even coerced into surrendering their vehicles on the spot.advertisementThis Draconian measure, aimed at curbing air pollution, has instead ignited a firestorm of criticism for its heavy-handed enforcement and lack of empathy. Owners of well-maintained vehicles, many still in pristine condition, are being forced to surrender their prized possessions or sell them at throwaway prices to avoid total loss. The policy's blanket approach, ignoring roadworthiness or valid Pollution Under Control (PUC) certificates is absurd and anti-middle class.With Delhi consistently ranking amongst the world's most polluted cities, the government has scrambled for solutions, often at the expense of its citizens. But targeting older vehicles alone, without addressing larger pollution sources, is unlikely to bring any meaningful or lasting improvement in air quality.What was meant to be a green initiative now feels like a forced scrapping drive. While environmental concerns are valid, the implementation has lacked empathy and foresight. There are no clear rehabilitation measures for affected vehicle owners; no compensation, no government support, and certainly no transition period.Instead of enough incentives to switch to cleaner alternatives or retrofitting options, Delhi has chosen the stick over the carrot. The intention may be clean air, but the road taken is leaving behind a trail of resentment, ruined finances, and abandoned dreams.advertisementSocial media platforms, particularly X, have become a place for venting frustration, with vehicle owners like Ratan Dhillon highlighting the plight of lakhs of affected vehicle owners.
Ratan Dhillon's tweet is a passionate critique of Delhi's vehicle ban policy, particularly its blanket treatment of older vehicles as polluters, regardless of their actual condition. In his post, Dhillon showcases his father's 16-year-old Mercedes E280 V6, proudly noting that it still performs exceptionally well, with every feature functioning flawlessly. He argues that it's more reliable and still cleaner than many modern vehicles that often break down. However, despite its excellent condition, he laments that he's now forced to label it 'vintage scrap' because of India's strict age-based vehicle laws. His tweet expresses deep frustration that decisions are being made without regard for automotive value, engineering quality, or environmental nuance. Dhillon ends with a challenge to the government, asking them to prove that his car is polluting. He asserts they won't be able to, but they'll still penalise him under the current system, underscoring what he sees as an irrational and unfair policy.
advertisementAnother X user criticised the move, calling it a case of 'selective sacrifice' disguised as environmental reform. Highlighting the unequal burden of the policy, the user pointed out that while gig workers, small business owners, and middle-class families are left stranded. Despite having valid Pollution Under Control (PUC) certificate, many vehicles are now deemed illegal purely based on age raising questions about whether the government is truly targeting emissions, or merely targeting the poor. The post ends with a scathing rhetorical question: 'Are we banning emissions or just the poor?"For now, the capital's fuel stations are the new battleground, where machines are judged not by their emissions, but by their birthdays. For now, stories like Rajesh's, where dreams built on hard-earned money are crushed overnight, continue to fuel a cry for fairness and reason.Subscribe to Auto Today Magazine- EndsMust Watch
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Delhi government urges CAQM to put fuel ban on overage vehicles on hold
Delhi government urges CAQM to put fuel ban on overage vehicles on hold

Time of India

time11 hours ago

  • Time of India

Delhi government urges CAQM to put fuel ban on overage vehicles on hold

The Delhi government has written to the Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM), requesting an immediate suspension of the fuel ban on end-of-life (EOL) vehicles, citing significant technological and operational challenges in its implementation. At a press conference on Thursday, Delhi Environment Minister Manjinder Singh Sirsa said there is growing public discontent over the ban, which came into effect on July 1, and asserted that the government stands with the affected vehicle owners. 'We are trying to ensure that vehicles are not banned purely based on age, but rather on the pollution they cause,' he said. Under the current regulation, fuel stations in Delhi are barred from supplying fuel to diesel vehicles older than 10 years and petrol vehicles older than 15 years that have been deregistered and are not legally permitted on roads, following court orders. Sirsa said the Delhi government is exploring alternatives to this policy and has formally communicated its inability to implement CAQM's directive, citing ongoing issues with the Automatic Number Plate Recognition (ANPR) system installed at fuel stations. A plea to CAQM In his letter to the CAQM chairperson, Sirsa stated, 'There are critical operational and infrastructural challenges that make it unfeasible to implement this order at this juncture.' He added that due to these technological inconsistencies and a lack of integration with NCR states, the system may even prove counterproductive. The minister pointed out that although ANPR cameras have been installed at most petrol pumps, the system faces several glitches, including issues with camera placement, sensor and speaker malfunctions, and difficulty identifying vehicles without High Security Registration Plates (HSRP). Additionally, he noted the lack of coordination with databases from neighbouring NCR cities such as Gurugram, Faridabad, and Ghaziabad — areas from where owners of overage vehicles can still procure fuel without restriction. 'The fuel ban in Delhi alone will not serve its intended purpose unless implemented uniformly across the entire NCR,' he said. Sirsa highlighted that the ANPR system in these neighbouring regions is not yet functional, which could allow banned vehicles to bypass restrictions by refueling outside Delhi. Several pollution control measures The minister also detailed several pollution control measures initiated by the Delhi government, including a stricter Pollution Under Control (PUC) certification regime, particularly for vehicles from outside Delhi. He said a system is being developed to notify owners of aging vehicles 2-3 months in advance via SMS to help them prepare for the transition. 'We strongly urge the Commission to pause the implementation of Direction No. 89 until the ANPR system is fully integrated across the NCR,' Sirsa wrote. He further criticised the previous AAP-led administration for not challenging the EOL vehicle ban in court or before the National Green Tribunal. 'This enforcement could have been avoided had timely intervention been taken,' he said. Since the fuel ban took effect, Delhi's transport department and traffic police have begun impounding EOL vehicles found at fuel stations.

Delhi banning 10-year-old cars is mindless coercion
Delhi banning 10-year-old cars is mindless coercion

India Today

time16 hours ago

  • India Today

Delhi banning 10-year-old cars is mindless coercion

Delhi's latest pollution control policy denying fuel to diesel vehicles over 10 years old and petrol vehicles over 15 years old, is a coercive measure that doesn't make sense. The entire focus here is on the age of the vehicle and not how much it has run or how it has been maintained. The measure by the Delhi government disincentivises proper upkeep of vehicles that makes them less polluting. This also cheats people who paid road tax for 15 years but can get to drive their vehicles for just 10 who breathe air worse than cigarette smoke, endure scorching temperatures that can melt roads, and navigate a slew of challenges just by the virtue of being born in the national capital, are now facing this heavy-handed pollution control policy, enforced through Automatic Number Plate Recognition (ANPR) cameras at 350 fuel stations, has sparked widespread criticism within days of its implementation from all sections. This Orwellian law, reminiscent of a surveillance state, imposes hefty fines of Rs 10,000 for four-wheelers and Rs 5,000 for two-wheelers, with the threat of vehicle impoundment or scrapping. Fuel station owners also face severe legal repercussions for non-compliance. While Delhi has grappled with severe air pollution since the 1990s, banning nearly a crore vehicles from the roads is counterproductive for several reasons. Here's why this move by the Delhi government is mindless coercion.1. WILL GOVT RETURN 5 YEARS' TAX TO DIESEL VEHICLE OWNERS?advertisementDiesel vehicle owners in India pay road tax for a 15-year vehicle lifespan. But Delhi's policy says the vehicles cannot be used after just 10 years. This discrepancy is making lakhs of vehicle owners question the new law and its Sareen, senior fellow at Observer Research Foundation (ORF), wrote on X on Wednesday, 'Single most stupid rule. Scrap a polluting vehicle even if it's 1 year old; allow a non polluting vehicle even if it's 20 years old. Enforce pollution norms strictly. But scrapping vehicles just on age of vehicle is a brainless thing to do. Since it's NGT dictated no one wants to challenge this foolishness (sic).'The bigger question is, will the government refund five years' worth of road tax to diesel vehicle owners affected by the 10-year ban? And if so, how and when?2. SCRAPPING WELL-MAINTAINED VEHICLES WITH VALID PUCThe blanket ban disregards the condition of the vehicles and penalises even those with valid Pollution Under Control (PUC) subjects the decades-old PUC certificate system to scrutiny. Many on social media said that if a valid PUC is of no relevance and only the vehicle's age determines the emission levels, then the pollution-check certificate system should be Deepty Jain, assistant professor at the Transportation Research and Injury Prevention Centre, IIT Delhi, told The Times of India that a vehicle's tailpipe emissions depend on its age, make, model, kilometres driven, and overall fitness, highlighting that maintenance can significantly influence emission levels beyond just the vehicle's X user, Abhay Anand said, "Bravo Delhi govt! Ban 10-yr-old cars with PUCs, ignore the absurdity, keep taxing us silly, and leave the middle class broke with no compensation. Nothing screams "pollution fix" like forcing loans for shiny new rides while luxury SUVs guzzle fuel. Pure genius! (sic)".3. FIRST WORLD POLICY IN THIRD-WORLD INFRASTRUCTUREDelhi's stringent vehicle ban mirrors policies in developed nations but ignores our infrastructural Delhi, roads and flyovers built by the government crumble in far lesser time than the end-of-life time that the government is putting on the cars. Its focus should be on better and sturdier infrastructure.A host of issues are likely to arise soon, including whether public transport can accommodate those affected by the vehicle ban, whether adequate scrapping infrastructure exists for millions of cars, and whether scrapping itself will contribute to push is very well towards e-vehicles (EVs), which lack supportive infrastructure. Several housing societies in NCR have been reported as denying permission to install charging points for vehicle ban, thus, seemingly burdens not only citizens but also the city's already strained facilities.4. DELHI GOVERNMENT GOING FOR SOFT TARGET?Delhi's new policy on banning "old" vehicles is seemingly a soft target, and conveniently sidesteps other factors that contribute to the air pollution crisis that require a larger political dust, which even the Supreme Court flagged, and construction dust are not monitored or addressed. In winters, Delhi becomes a gas chamber because of stubble burning in neighbouring states. Addressing these factors requires political will. It seems the Delhi government has chosen to act tough on vehicles – a move that will impact the middle class, which is a soft target.5. PRIVATE CARS SMALL PART OF POLLUTION POOLVehicular emissions, while significant, aren't Delhi's only source of air pollution. Also, private vehicles are a smaller part of the polluting to a 2024 Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) study, motor vehicles accounted for 51.5% of local PM2.5 emissions in Delhi between October 12 to November 3, 2024. Of this, two- and three-wheelers accounted 50%, and heavy-duty vehicles make up 30%, while private cars contribute around 20%.advertisementBut there are regional sources like stubble burning, which contribute up to 38% of the total PM2.5 on peak days. Then there is road dust, too, which makes up 3.6–4.1% of local PM2.5 pollution in early winter (October–November). However, a 2015 study by IIT Kanpur found it can contribute up to 38% of PM2.5 over a full year, especially in dry also reportedly contributes 6.7–7.9% to the air on private vehicles, hence, diverts attention from these broader air pollution new law may seem well-intentioned to many, but clearly overlooks practical realities and broader pollution sources.- EndsMust Watch

Murder and kidnapping, rampant at Delhi pumps, as authorities impose a car ban
Murder and kidnapping, rampant at Delhi pumps, as authorities impose a car ban

India Today

time18 hours ago

  • India Today

Murder and kidnapping, rampant at Delhi pumps, as authorities impose a car ban

Rajesh was out with his beloved Senorita, not a flamenco dancer, but his trusted diesel car, on an ordinary weekday morning. Like many mornings before, he pulled into a Delhi fuel pump to top up. But what happened next was anything but ordinary. Two men in Khaki wardis approached him and, without preamble, asked him to hand over Senorita. Utterly bewildered, Rajesh mustered the courage to ask why. The answer came in the form of a blunt statement that the cameras had detected that his Senorita was over 10 years old and had lost the right to live. Senorita, Rajesh's beloved diesel car was bought with his hard-earned money. The 7-year EMI term had only just ended a few years ago, finally bringing him financial wasn't a random act of coercion. It was enforcement in action. An act of legalised injustice which feels like theft in broad daylight is, on paper, perfectly lawful. In what can be called state-sponsored swindling, vehicles are being taken from their owners under the guise of environmental are hundreds of people like Rajesh on Delhi's streets today, whose prized possessions are being confiscated by authorities. The situation has become so dire that people have started selling off their expensive cars at throwaway prices just to avoid a total loss. Delhi's crackdown on "end-of-life vehicles." not death but the presumed end by the authorities, those older than 10 years for diesels and 15 for petrol has reached fuel stations, where surveillance cameras now scan number plates and automatically flag non-compliant vehicles. Owners like Rajesh are then denied fuel, sometimes even coerced into surrendering their vehicles on the Draconian measure, aimed at curbing air pollution, has instead ignited a firestorm of criticism for its heavy-handed enforcement and lack of empathy. Owners of well-maintained vehicles, many still in pristine condition, are being forced to surrender their prized possessions or sell them at throwaway prices to avoid total loss. The policy's blanket approach, ignoring roadworthiness or valid Pollution Under Control (PUC) certificates is absurd and anti-middle Delhi consistently ranking amongst the world's most polluted cities, the government has scrambled for solutions, often at the expense of its citizens. But targeting older vehicles alone, without addressing larger pollution sources, is unlikely to bring any meaningful or lasting improvement in air was meant to be a green initiative now feels like a forced scrapping drive. While environmental concerns are valid, the implementation has lacked empathy and foresight. There are no clear rehabilitation measures for affected vehicle owners; no compensation, no government support, and certainly no transition of enough incentives to switch to cleaner alternatives or retrofitting options, Delhi has chosen the stick over the carrot. The intention may be clean air, but the road taken is leaving behind a trail of resentment, ruined finances, and abandoned media platforms, particularly X, have become a place for venting frustration, with vehicle owners like Ratan Dhillon highlighting the plight of lakhs of affected vehicle owners. Ratan Dhillon's tweet is a passionate critique of Delhi's vehicle ban policy, particularly its blanket treatment of older vehicles as polluters, regardless of their actual condition. In his post, Dhillon showcases his father's 16-year-old Mercedes E280 V6, proudly noting that it still performs exceptionally well, with every feature functioning flawlessly. He argues that it's more reliable and still cleaner than many modern vehicles that often break down. However, despite its excellent condition, he laments that he's now forced to label it 'vintage scrap' because of India's strict age-based vehicle laws. His tweet expresses deep frustration that decisions are being made without regard for automotive value, engineering quality, or environmental nuance. Dhillon ends with a challenge to the government, asking them to prove that his car is polluting. He asserts they won't be able to, but they'll still penalise him under the current system, underscoring what he sees as an irrational and unfair policy. advertisementAnother X user criticised the move, calling it a case of 'selective sacrifice' disguised as environmental reform. Highlighting the unequal burden of the policy, the user pointed out that while gig workers, small business owners, and middle-class families are left stranded. Despite having valid Pollution Under Control (PUC) certificate, many vehicles are now deemed illegal purely based on age raising questions about whether the government is truly targeting emissions, or merely targeting the poor. The post ends with a scathing rhetorical question: 'Are we banning emissions or just the poor?"For now, the capital's fuel stations are the new battleground, where machines are judged not by their emissions, but by their birthdays. For now, stories like Rajesh's, where dreams built on hard-earned money are crushed overnight, continue to fuel a cry for fairness and to Auto Today Magazine- EndsMust Watch

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store