Argentine court declares mistrial in Diego Maradona death case over judicial ethics breach
A court in Argentina has declared a mistrial in the ongoing trial against seven health professionals accused of medical negligence in the 2020 death of soccer legend Diego Maradona.
The ruling followed the recusal of Judge Julieta Makintach, who came under scrutiny after her involvement in a documentary series titled
Divine Justice
, which covers the aftermath of Maradona's death through the current legal proceedings.
Also read:
Was Diego Maradona's death a case of tragic negligence or cold-blooded murder? Disturbing details emerge as court probes how the Argentine football legend died
The prosecutor presented a trailer from the series, alleging that Makintach violated judicial ethics by allowing a film crew to document her actions inside the Buenos Aires courthouse. The teaser included dramatized footage of the judge walking through court halls during closed-door sessions.
Live Events
Makintach resigned from the case on Tuesday, May 27, saying she had 'no choice' but to withdraw. On Thursday, May 29, Judge Maximiliano Savarino stated that Makintach's lack of impartiality had undermined the case and led to the mistrial.
New trial ordered after ethics controversy
The decision voids all progress made since the trial's start on March 11, 2024. A higher court will now assign a new panel of three judges through a lottery system. No new trial date has been set, though the court stated it would occur 'within a reasonable period of time.'
The trial had already conducted 21 hearings, calling on numerous witnesses including medical experts and family members. It was originally expected to conclude by July 2025. The reset now delays the proceedings indefinitely.
Two of Maradona's daughters, Gianinna and Dalma, were present at the courthouse and became emotional upon hearing the decision.
Also read:
Diego Maradona's medical team on trial for homicide, faces 25 years in jail
Medical negligence at center of charges
The seven defendants, including Diego Maradona's primary physician, psychologist, psychiatrist, medical coordinator, and two nurses, face charges of culpable homicide. This Argentine legal classification is similar to involuntary manslaughter and carries a maximum sentence of 25 years.
Prosecutors allege that Maradona's care team failed to monitor and hospitalize him appropriately during his recovery from brain surgery in late 2020. He died of cardiac arrest on November 25, 2020, at age 60, while at a rented home outside Buenos Aires.
Expert testimony in the earlier phase of the trial indicated that Maradona may have suffered for up to 12 hours without sufficient medical supervision.
The defendants deny all charges and argue that Maradona was uncooperative and refused necessary medical treatment.
Public and legal attention continues
The case has received extensive attention across Argentina and globally, given Maradona's prominent legacy in international soccer. Known for leading Argentina to a World Cup victory in 1986, Maradona is considered one of the sport's greatest players.
Also read:
Maradona's final play: Doctor claims home care was 'red card' to recovery in testimony
His personal life, which included struggles with substance abuse, has remained a frequent subject of public interest. The trial's combination of legal, ethical, and personal drama has further amplified its visibility in Argentine media.
Despite the legal setback, the case is expected to resume under a newly assigned judicial panel. Schedules and procedural details will be announced after the court completes its judge selection.
Economic Times WhatsApp channel
)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
3 days ago
- Time of India
Man gets $12,500 in compensation after Google Street View clicks him naked
A man in Argentina has been awarded $12,500 (nearly Rs 11 lakh) in compensation after he was photographed completely naked in his backyard by a Street View car. The man successfully argued in court that his dignity was harmed despite being behind a six-and-a-half-foot wall in a small Argentine town in 2017. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now According to a report by CBS News, the man, who is a police officer, claimed the privacy invasion led to ridicule at his workplace and among his neighbours. The image reportedly showed his bare behind and failed to blur his house number and street name, which were visible online. He initially sued Google in 2019, but a lower court dismissed the case, citing the man's "inappropriate condition" outdoors. However, an appeals panel reversed that decision this month. Google had defended itself by claiming the perimeter wall was not tall enough. What the court said while ordering Google to pay the compensation "This involves an image of a person not captured in a public space, but within the confines of their home, behind a fence taller than the average-sized person. The invasion of blatant,' the court said, favouring the man. Ordering Google to pay out the compensation amount, the court said: 'No one wants to appear exposed to the world as the day they were born." The court also pointed to Google's practice of automatically blurring faces and license plates as an indication that the company recognised its responsibility to prevent harm to third parties. However, in this case, the judges noted that the man's 'entire naked body' was visible and said the image should have been flagged. Replying to this, the company said that 'if you would like us to blur your entire house, car, or body, submit a request using the 'Report a problem' tool.' iQOO Z10R 5G goes on Sale: BEST Budget Phone for Content Creators?
Indian Express
3 days ago
- Indian Express
Google ordered to pay Rs 10.8 lakh to Argentine man after Street View car captures him ‘naked'
A man in Argentina has won a legal battle against Google, which must now pay him roughly Rs 10.8 lakh ($12,500) in damages after a Google Street View car captured and published an image of him completely nude in his backyard. The incident occurred in 2017 in a small Argentine town, where the man—a police officer—was sunbathing behind what he described as a 6-foot-6 wall when the Street View camera snapped the revealing photo. Not only was his bare backside visible online, but the image also showed his house number and street name without any blurring, making him instantly identifiable to neighbours and colleagues. Feeling humiliated and mocked at work, the man took Google to court in 2019. At first, a lower court sided with the tech giant, ruling that he should not have been outside in an 'inappropriate condition'. But this month, an appeals court overturned that verdict, saying the image clearly violated his privacy. 'This involves an image of a person not captured in a public space, but within the confines of their home, behind a fence taller than the average-sized person,' the panel stated. The judges noted that Google's failure to obscure the man's identity stood in stark contrast to its own guidelines, which promise automatic blurring of faces and licence plates to protect individuals' privacy. The court called the breach 'blatant,' emphasising that 'no one wants to appear exposed to the world as the day they were born'. Google argued that the wall surrounding the property was not high enough, but the court was not convinced. It highlighted that the man's 'entire naked body' was visible in the image and should have been flagged under Google's review systems. On its official site, Google notes, 'We have developed cutting-edge face and license plate blurring technology,' and also offers users the option to request blurring of homes, cars, or people via its 'Report a problem' tool. This is not the first time Google has faced legal heat over its Street View programme. Back in 2019, the company agreed to a $13 million settlement over privacy concerns tied to its data collection. And in 2010, it was ordered to pay just $1 in damages to a Pennsylvania couple after trespassing on their property.
NDTV
4 days ago
- NDTV
Man Awarded Rs 11 lakh After Google Street View Car Clicked Him Naked
Google has been forced to pay approximately Rs 10.8 lakh ($12,500) to an Argentine man after he was photographed completely naked in his backyard by a Google Street View car. The man argued in court that his dignity was harmed by the internet giant despite him being behind a 6-foot-6 wall, in a small Argentine town in 2017. The man, a police officer by profession, claimed the invasion exposed him to ridicule at work and among his neighbours, according to a report in CBS News. While his bare behind was splashed on the internet for everyone to see, Google did not even blur his house number and street name, which were clearly visible in the image. He sued Google in 2019, but a lower court initially dismissed the case, faulting the man for being outside in an "inappropriate condition". However, an appeals panel reversed that decision this month. Google, in its defence, claimed that the perimeter wall was not high enough. "This involves an image of a person not captured in a public space, but within the confines of their home, behind a fence taller than the average-sized person," the court observed, adding: "The invasion of blatant." Awarding the sum in compensation, the court said: "No one wants to appear exposed to the world as the day they were born." Google's blurring policy The court also cited Google's policy of automatically blurring faces and license plates as evidence that it was aware of a duty to avoid harm to third parties. However, in this case, the man's "entire naked body" was visible, the judges said, and the image should have been flagged. "We have developed cutting-edge face and license plate blurring technology that is designed to blur identifiable faces and license plates within Google-contributed imagery in Street View," Google's website about its Street View policy states. The company adds that "if you would like us to blur your entire house, car, or body, submit a request using the 'Report a problem' tool."
