AFL concedes to Ross Lyon as Alix Tauru ban changed under ‘exceptional circumstances'
Tauru was given a four-week ban at the VFL tribunal for rough conduct and it was upheld after the Saints appealed.
But with byes at the start and end of Tauru's four-week sanction, the 18-year-old was set to be ineligible to play football for six weeks.
Lyon compared the penalty for St Kilda's first round draft pick to that of Richmond's Noah Balta, who was suspended for four matches as a result of the off-field incident that led to him being charged with assault.
'We're incredibly disappointed, I am really frustrated, it's a broken system,' Lyon said on Wednesday.
'If you think the penalty is four weeks, that's OK, but they know we've got a bye and then at the end of that there's another bye.
'How the tribunal doesn't take into consideration that it's six weeks; Noah Balta got four weeks' stand-down for an assault off the field, with respect.
'We've got a kid that concussed a player, it's a six-week penalty, there's just no consideration — as Paul Roos would say: 'common sense is commonly uncommon'.'
In a win for St Kilda, common sense has eventually prevailed and Tauru will be available to return sooner.
AFL football boss Laura Kane approved a change to Tauru's ban under exceptional circumstances, 7NEWS Melbourne's Mitch Cleary revealed on Thursday night.
The suspension can now start this weekend with Sandringham's practice match against a Tasmanian representative team.
Tauru will now be available in Round 12 of the AFL season and Round 10 of the VFL campaign.
St Kilda are in the midst of a debate about their VFL future with an increasingly likelihood of a split from Sandringham.
In the same press conference where he teed off about Taura's ban, Lyon said AFL clubs would be better off running their own breakaway competition than fielding teams in the VFL.
'No wonder AFL clubs talk about, 'Let's have a breakaway group from a 22-team competition and just have four or five clubs that play each other',' he said.
'It's not worth the risk and there's no recompense or consideration or adjustment for the reality of a misaligned fixture of a feeder competition to the AFL, so I am absolutely filthy.
'What I would like is for common sense to prevail here for a young player.
'We talk about mental health ... the kid has been suspended for four and he'll miss six, how do you reckon his mental health is going at the minute? And mine.'
Mixed-team practice matches were commonplace during COVID when teams were based in hubs.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
7NEWS
12 minutes ago
- 7NEWS
Extraordinary vision emerges of Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera partying on Ross Lyon's shoulders after historic St Kilda win
Extraordinary footage has emerged of St Kilda hero Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera partying on coach Ross Lyon's shoulders after his all-star turn on Sunday. The 22-year-old wrote himself into Saints folklore with the final two goals to seal the biggest three-quarter-time comeback — from 46 points down — in VFL/ AFL history. Wanganeen-Milera's soaring mark over Demons forward Bayley Fritsch to set up the game-equalling goal even prompted an emotional reaction of disbelief from usually solemn Lyon. Lyon kept the celebrations going at a raucous post-match function on Sunday night. Vision emerged on Monday showing the coach lifting Wanganeen-Milera onto his shoulders, egged on by everyone else in the room. Wanganeen-Milera's performance brought increased calls for the Saints to pay up to keep him from requesting a trade home to South Australia at the end of the season. St Kilda teammate Hunter Clark wants the star to stay 'forever' but says there will be no hard feelings if he decides to leave. Clark, who also produced some important moments late against Melbourne, was in awe at what Wanganeen-Milera achieved. 'He's obviously got a really big decision, and he'll do what's best for himself, and there'll be no hard feelings either way,' Clark told AAP. 'Obviously we'd love him to stay forever; he's going to be, if he's not already, up there for one of the best players in the competition. 'He's only 22 so I think his future is going to be so bright and he deserves everything that comes his way.' Wanganeen-Milera was drafted with pick No.11 out of Glenelg in 2021, playing 82 games for the Saints so far. St Kilda have also thrown a big contract in front of him as arguably the key player in the club's rebuild and bid for an elusive second premiership. Wanganeen-Milera, who had a game-high 34 disposals alongside his match-winning four goals, was in doubt to play against the Demons due to a stye in his eye. The club doctor called Lyon early on Sunday morning to let him know his best player was in doubt, but Wanganeen-Milera reassured his coach he would be fine. The Saints superstar led his side out of the greatest three-quarter time deficit in history. 'He's an absolute freak,' Clark said of his teammate's skill. 'But he's such a good man. 'The way he plays, almost you'd expect him to just be this real out there character, like he probably has every right to just strut around. 'But he's the most humble bloke you'll come across. 'He's an absolute freak of a talent, but he works as hard as anyone. It's not all just what you see on the field. 'He's absolute star, and I think he's made for those moments.' After just their second win since the start of May, St Kilda can take confidence out of their Marvel miracle into 2026. 'If we can just finish the year strong, just keep getting experience into everyone and keep growing,' Clark said. 'Then just get to work over the summer. It's not just going to happen in a day. 'I see a lot of the teams over the last few years, it can take five or six years until you have gone through s**t, until you get there.'
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Young the ‘point of difference' to Freo's flag tilt
Hayden Young has been labelled Fremantle's 'point of difference' in the Dockers' flag tilt following a blistering return from injury over the past fortnight. Young secured his first Glendinning-Allan Medal despite being subbed off early in the fourth quarter against West Coast after a commanding display with 23 touches, seven clearances and three goals in a derby domination. Channel Seven commentator Kate McCarthy said it was imperative the Dockers keep the left-footer fit, if they are to go deep into September and their hopes of winning a maiden premiership. 'Purely for what they have through the midfield, they have Andrew Brayshaw and (Caleb) Serong with Luke Jackson running through, but he (Young) is a genuine point of difference for them,' she said on 'He had a really important fourth quarter last week as the sub with 11 disposals and just continued on with that momentum, he's been their most important player. 'Keeping him on the park is an absolute must if you're Fremantle because he is key to your team going deep into September and maybe onto their first flag.' Young has managed just six games this year after undergoing surgery on a hamstring injury he picked up in their round eight loss to St Kilda, having missed the start of the year with a similar injury. Hayden Young & Justin Longmuir pose for a photo after the match. Credit: Janelle St Pierre/AFL Photos / Getty Images Given his history, the Dockers have been managing his return to the AFL level, including acting as the sub against Collingwood, with coach Justin Longmuir warning there is still more to come as he works his way back to full fitness. 'It was a good build from last week and should set him up well for next week. I thought he was clean, I thought he found space, and I thought he finished well. He was sharp,' Longmuir said post-game. 'We've missed his ball use at times this year. He's a welcome addition. He gives us another big body around there as well, which helps Andy and Caleb and the other mids. We've missed that as well. 'I thought our stoppage work went to a level it hasn't seen for a while today. I'm sure Youngy had an impact on that. Of course, that excites me.'
Courier-Mail
2 hours ago
- Courier-Mail
AFL 2025: Melbourne Demons cop huge whack after St Kilda melt down in record-breaking loss
Don't miss out on the headlines from AFL. Followed categories will be added to My News. Melbourne's leaders have been called out for their dying seconds 'panic' in the historic six-point loss to the Saints on Sunday. When Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera kicked a goal to level scores with just eight seconds to play, the Demons coughed up a 6-6-6 infringement free kick in the middle of the ground. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1. And what followed was pure chaos as Melbourne's players took off, only to be called back, before that man Wanganeen-Milera bobbed up again to kick the winning goal in a stunning 15.6 (96) to 13.12 (90) victory. 'There was a rush of blood to defend long and deep,' AFL great Dermott Brereton said. 'It was panic stations.' In all the confusion, Max Gawn, Jack Viney and Kysaiah Pickett all returned to the middle of the ground in a move that ultimately proved costly as Wanganeen-Milera streaked forward, marked inside 50 and nailed the matchwinner. It created history for the Saints, with the biggest three-quarter time comeback ever, from 46 points down. The Demons' confusion was clear in the dying seconds of St Kilda's historic win. Umpire Nick Brown asked for the field to be reset before paying a free kick to Rowan Marshall. Picture: Michael Klein Two-time premiership Roo David King labelled the Dees' dying seconds brain fade as a 'cardinal sin'. 'Name me the leaders at Melbourne. They're all there. They've got (Christian) Petracca, Gawn, you've got (Christian) Salem behind the footy, (Tom) McDonald. They're everywhere there. They should have understood this situation,' King said on Fox Footy's First Crack. 'They should have understood the 6-6-6. Instead of getting confused here … why is Max back in the middle? 'I just spoke with (ex-AFL umpire) Ray Chamberlain, he said there is no rule that says Max has to go back in and reset. He should be the loose man. 'What the hell is Viney doing in the middle of the wing when his opponent has gone to the left edge to charge forward? 'So, as the fourth midfielder comes in no one is communicating. No one knows who's got who. 'Viney is thinking, 'I've got to get back to Wanganeen-Milera'. I'm assuming that's what he's thinking because he's not going with (Saint Anthony) Caminiti, who charges to the left. 'He clearly doesn't get there, he doesn't surge, now he doesn't know what he's doing and the rest of the Melbourne backs are all here. 'Why is Bowey out there? If he's all the way out there that's fine. Stay there. Coach Simon Goodwin on the sidelines. Arms were out all over the centre square ahead of the final play of St Kilda's historic win. 'He turns to correct and he's not organising Viney. He should be saying to Viney, 'Come back' … Bowey turns and he's not even facing the play. 'I don't understand how they've capitulated so poorly in the space of 30 seconds. 'They haven't assessed the situation. 'They haven't assessed the likely danger zones and they've allowed Wanganeen-Milera to charge unopposed into that dangerous area through a lack of understanding of what's going to happen and a lack of communication. 'This is on them and the details matter. This comes back to coaching, I don't care what anyone says. 'It comes back to learnt habits, learnt skills at training … They should have known these things. This is their profession. 'I'm disappointed with Melbourne because this is a game they played really well for three quarters and have just lost their minds. 'It's the dumbest thing I've seen this year. 'Viney standing, wrong side of his opponent 30 metres (away), giving a tall – a targeted player – he can contested mark this guy Caminiti, allowing him to go inside 50 unopposed is just a cardinal sin.' Goodwin was seen looking bemused on the bench while their footy head of development Mark Williams was still counting players when the ball was handed back to Saints big man Rowan Marshall – who nailed the kick to Wanganeen-Milera. 'Pickett and Petracca didn't have to be at the circle,' Fox Footy's Leigh Montagna said. 'They could have been all the way back just inside the square because they knew it was St Kilda's free kick. 'Simon Goodwin was coaching from the bench … he wasn't giving instructions to his players at all. He was standing there watching. Demons head of development Mark Williams was spotted counting players. 'If you're on the bench, that's one of the advantages you have as a coach is to be able to yell out to your players in that situation. 'Jack Viney, his vice-captain, would have been 40 metres away from him.' Speaking after the one-goal loss, Goodwin described the defeat as 'unacceptable'. 'We won't shy away from it at all. We won't sugar-coat it,' he said. 'We'll just own it and do something about it and make sure it never happens again. 'Today is unacceptable. For all the good that was in the day, that last quarter was so far off.' Originally published as 'Dumbest thing seen': Dees' huge whack after St Kilda melt down
