Ofcom still isn't sure what a woman is
Incredibly, Ofcom's answer was 'no'. Indeed, it described GB News's view that the word 'woman' should be defined in reference to biological sex – and that it was acceptable to refer to athletes by their biological pronouns – as 'dogmatic propositions'. Such editorial judgments, it said, 'require nuanced decision-making'.
So, to be clear, the regulator thinks the view that man-made carbon emissions are causing global warming is so scientifically robust that broadcasters are under no obligation to present alternative opinions, but the notion that sex is binary, immutable and biological is so contentious that if GB News interviews some heretic who thinks trans women aren't women it has to interview someone alongside them who thinks they are. Presumably, that means if the channel interviews, say, Sharron Davies on why women should not have to compete against trans-identifying men in swimming competitions, it should also feature a bloke with a beard who identifies as a woman making the opposite case. Oh, and if a GB News presenter refers to said bloke as 'he/him' rather than 'she/her', he could complain to Ofcom and it would likely be upheld.
We're through the looking-glass in which television viewers are expected to believe six impossible things before breakfast. This decision is bizarre, not least because, among scientists, the claim that carbon emissions have caused the average global temperature to rise over the past 150 years is far from 'settled'. Ofcom's decision may have been influenced by the infamous 2013 paper which claimed 97 per cent of climate scientists agree that 'climate change is real, man-made and dangerous', to quote Barack Obama. But that paper itself is highly contested, with an army of climate sceptics lining up to debunk it.
My go-to document to disprove the 'settled science' claim is the World Climate Declaration, signed by almost 2,000 scientists, which points out that natural as well as anthropogenic factors cause warming, the growth in average global temperatures is slower than predicted by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, that CO2 is not a pollutant but essential to life on Earth, and that global warming is not causing more intense hurricanes, floods, droughts, etc. In short, the notion of a 'climate emergency' is bunkum.
I'm not arguing for putting the trans debate in the same 'settled' basket as climate change, although I admire GB News's chutzpah for suggesting it. But if either is to be regarded as beyond debate, surely it's the biological reality of sex? Until about ten minutes ago, that really was a settled issue among scientists. Now we're told it needs to be handled with kid gloves.
I suppose we should be grateful that Ofcom has at least moved away from the position its chief executive took five years ago when the regulator was a Stonewall Diversity Champion. In a discussion with the SNP MP John Nicholson, Dame Melanie Dawes agreed that it was 'extremely inappropriate' for the BBC to 'balance' the arguments of trans activists with the views of gender-critical charities like the LGB Alliance. She affirmed that for the BBC to feature 'anti-trans' voices when discussing sex- and gender–based issues was no more appropriate than including 'anti-gay' voices in a documentary about homosexuals. 'I can only agree with you,' she told Nicholson.
It seems extraordinary that the head of Ofcom should have once regarded an organisation like the LGB Alliance as beyond the pale. I imagine that's because she never left her metropolitan echo chamber, where such views are rarely challenged. But that's all the more reason for broadcasters to feature people on both sides of such debates instead of regarding one side as 'settled'. I hope Ofcom reflects on its absurd response to GB News and issues a new guidance note restoring the obligation to be impartial when discussing issues like net zero.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
20 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Donald Trump claims another victory in war on transgender athletes after Penn's Lia Thomas U-turn
President Donald Trump 's continued war to prevent transgender athletes from competing in women's sports has taken another turn in his favor just days after the University of Pennsylvania announced they'd rescind Lia Thomas' records. Earlier in the week, the Ivy League school announced they'd strip the titles, wins, and records that Thomas - a trans woman - held for the school. Now, the Supreme Court agreed to hear a case over state restrictions on which school sports transgender students are allowed to compete in. The Court will be reviewing cases in lower courts which ruled in favor of trans athletes in Idaho and West Virginia and overturned state bans on transgender people competing. Arguments will be heard in the fall. Just weeks ago, the Supreme Court upheld a ban on gender-affirming care for transgender youth stemming from a case in Tennessee. The DOE announced Tuesday that Penn is adopting strict definitions for male and female competitors under White House guidelines, adding that the school will ban trans athletes from women's competitions and erase Thomas from the school's record books. Furthermore, swimmers impacted by Thomas' inclusion in women's NCAA competitions will receive a personal apology from Penn and be retroactively awarded records and titles. However, Penn has added a note at the bottom of the webpage for the records of their women's swimming team which reads: 'NOTE: Competing under eligibility rules in effect at the time, Lia Thomas set program records in the 100, 200 and 500 freestyle during the 2021-22 season'. The Ivy League institution's decision comes after the Trump administration suspended $175 million in federal funding to Penn – money that had been earmarked and funded through the Defense Department and the Department of Health and Human Services. 'Penn remains committed to fostering a community that is welcoming, inclusive, and open to all students, faculty, and staff,' University of Pennsylvania president J. Larry Jameson said in a statement. 'I share this commitment, just as I remain dedicated to preserving and advancing the University's vital and enduring mission. We have now brought to a close an investigation that, if unresolved, could have had significant and lasting implications for the University of Pennsylvania.' Thomas won a national title as a woman in the 500 free while tying for fifth in the 200 free at the 2022 NCAA Finals with Kentucky swimmer Riley Gaines, who has since become the face of the movement to ban trans athletes from female sports. The NCAA previously allowed each sports to govern transgender inclusion, generally deferring to national governing bodies or International Olympic criteria. The fate of Thomas' NCAA is now in question. It was under that pervious NCAA structure that Thomas was allowed to compete despite originally swimming as a man before receiving hormone replace therapy. Donald Trump and Riley Gaines are pictured together at a CPAC Convention in Dallas Transgender woman Lia Thomas (L) of the University of Pennsylvania stands on the podium after winning the 500-yard freestyle as other medalists in March of 2022 She returned as a woman in 2021 after meeting the NCAA's hormone requirements at the time. Since then, the NCAA has changed its policy to conform with Trump's February 5 executive order aiming to ban transgender athletes from girls and women's sports. Gaines was among the first to issue a statement on the ruling Tuesday. 'From day one, President Trump and [Education] Secretary [Linda] McMahon made it clear that protecting women and girls is a top priority—and today's agreement with UPenn is proof of that commitment in action.' 'This Administration isn't just talking about women's equality, but instead actively defending it. I hope this sends a clear message to educational institutions: you can no longer disregard women's civil rights. And to every female athlete, know this: your dignity, safety, and fairness matter, and our nation's leaders will not stop fighting for them.' The NCAA changed its policy on February 6 after Trump signed an executive order on banning transgender athletes from girls' and women's sports. Thomas was banned from competing in elite women's races ahead of the Olympics by The Court of Arbitration for Sport panel, which ruled that she was ineligible to challenge World Aquatics policy on trans athletes. Now, according to the statement released by the Department of Education, Thomas' records at Penn are being expunged as well. The nationwide battle over the participation of transgender girls on girls sports teams has played out at both the state and federal levels as Republicans have leveraged the issue as a fight for athletic fairness for women and girls. More than two dozen states have enacted laws barring transgender women and girls from participating in certain sports competitions. Some policies have been blocked in court. At the federal level, the Trump administration has filed lawsuits and launched investigations over state and school policies that have allowed transgender athletes to compete freely. Separately, Senate Democrats in March blocked a Republican push for a national ban. President Trump also has acted aggressively in other areas involving transgender people, including removing transgender troops from military service. In May, the Supreme Court allowed the ouster of transgender service members to proceed, reversing lower courts that had blocked it. A recent poll by The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research found that about 7 in 10 U.S. adults think transgender female athletes should not be allowed to participate in girls and women´s sports at the high school, college or professional level. That view was shared by about 9 in 10 Republicans and roughly half of Democrats.
NBC News
an hour ago
- NBC News
Essence Fest leads a summer of events for Black entrepreneurs galvanized by economic uncertainty
In a year when the U.S. consumer has been weighed down by economic uncertainty, geopolitical tensions and inflation, Black entrepreneurs are eager to get to the Essence Festival of Culture to connect with their core customers. 'Essence Fest is like my Black Friday,' said Rochelle Ivory, owner of beauty brand On the Edge Baby Hair. 'It is my biggest sales weekend of the year. It's where I make all the capital I reinvest in my business.' Essence Fest kicks off on Friday, with roughly 500,000 people attending the event in New Orleans. It generates around $1 billion in economic activity, according to organizers. 'It's the cannot-miss event for us,' said Brittney Adams, owner of eyewear brand Focus and Frame. She said this year Essence Fest is even more important because she's seen Black consumers pulling back on spending. 'I would say the uncertainty of just the economic and political climate — that's giving people a little bit of hesitancy. Should they save the money? Should they buy the things they want?' Adams said. Ivory said her sales are down roughly 30% year over year, but she's hopeful people come to New Orleans looking to spend their time and money in the festival marketplace. 'This could make or break some of us,' she said. 'It's one of the few places where Black women, Black founders can really come together and be seen.' The Global Black Economic Forum aims to bring visibility and create solutions for Black business owners at Essence Fest. This year speakers include Supreme Court Justice Ketanji Brown-Jackson and Maryland Gov. Wes Moore. Last year, then-Vice President Kamala Harris spoke. 'We intentionally curate a space that allows leaders to preserve, build and reimagine how we can collectively increase economic opportunity to thrive,' said Alphonso David, CEO of the GBEF. Second half shift While many Black Americans express economic anxiety, the data is less clear. In the first quarter of this year, according to Federal Reserve data, the median weekly salary for Black workers was $1,192 a 5% increase year over year. Black unemployment stood at 6% in the most recent jobs report, a historically low number, but still higher than the national average of 4.2%. However, the data doesn't appear to fully reflect the sentiment for many Black Americans who are concerned about the political, cultural and economic shifts that have taken place since President Donald Trump's election. 'Never let a good crisis go to waste,' said John Hope Bryant, founder and CEO of Operation Hope, one of the nation's largest non-profits focused on financial education and empowerment. Bryant said he sees the concerns of Black Americans as an opportunity in the second half of 2025. 'This president has done something that hasn't been done since the 1960s, which is unify Black America. Wealth was created in the early 20 th century because Blacks were forced to work together. But instead of Black Lives Matter, let's make Black capitalist matter,' he said. Pastor Jamal Bryant of New Birth Missionary Baptist Church has galvanized Black consumers with an organized boycott of Target that began in February in response to the retailer's decision to roll back diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives. Bryant said he is in discussions with Target but is ready to organize a longer-term boycott if the retailer does not fulfill the promises it made to the Black community after the killing of George Floyd. He is urging Black Americans to use the estimated $2.1 trillion dollars in spending power forecast by 2026 to drive economic and political change. 'I would dare say that 'pocketbook protests' are a revolutionary activity,' said Bryant. 'I think we have to be very selective in light of the 'Big Ugly Bill' that just passed and how it will adversely affect our community,' he said, referencing Trump's megabill that passed through Congress this week. Celebrate and educate Invest Fest, an event that blends commerce and culture created by financially focused media company Earn Your Leisure kicks off in Atlanta in August. Co-CEOs Rashad Bilal and Troy Millings said the event will remain focused on financial literacy, but this year they are emphasizing the urgent need for education and entrepreneurship in technology. 'It's definitely now or never, the time is now,' said Bilal. 'The important thing this year is the way technology is going to disrupt a lot of career paths and the businesses, and we have to prepare for that, which is why AI is at the forefront of the conversation, crypto is at the forefront of the conversations, real estate as always and entrepreneurship,' said Millings. New this year is a partnership with venture capital firm Open Opportunity and a pitch competition where an entrepreneur can win $125,000 in funding to scale their business. 'We need more businesses that can reach $100 million valuation to a $1 billion valuation, get on the stock market. The pathway to that 9 times out of 10 is technology,' Bilal said. The National Black MBA Association Conference in Houston in September will have a similar tone. The event is known for its career fair where the nation's largest companies recruit as well as for networking and vibrant social activities. This year, interim CEO Orlando Ashford is working to establish artificial intelligence education and financial literacy as pillars of the event. 'Doing business as usual is not an option,' Ashford told CNBC. 'AI is something I literally refer to as a tsunami of change that's on its way. All of us will be forced to pivot in some ways as it relates to AI. Those of us that are out in front, that embrace it and leverage it actually can turn it into a tremendous and powerful opportunity. Those that wait and ignore it will be overtaken by the wave.'
Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Inside the torture camp where Trump accidentally deported dad to be abused
On arrival, a prison officer told Kilmar Abrego Garcia: "Welcome to CECOT. Whoever enters here doesn't leave." Remember Kilmar Abrego Garcia? The Salvadoran father of a 5-year-old disabled child that the Trump administration sent to a torture prison in El Salvador by mistake and (initially) refused to bring back? Well, he's back in the US, facing charges of migrant smuggling - to which he has pleaded not guilty and which a magistrate has found to be based on "insufficient evidence". He's still in custody - after his lawyers warned that he is at risk of being captured and deported again by ICE if he's let out on bail. But he's filed a complaint against the government, outlining in extreme detail how he was beaten and subjected to torture while being held at Salvadoran mega-gulag CECOT. In the court document are a lengthy list of horrific abuses suffered by Garcia - and many other people wrongly imprisoned in the "prison." Here's a recap of the case - and some of the "highlights" of Garcia's legal complaint. Who is Kilmar Abrego Garcia - and why was he deported? Kilmar Abrego Garcia is a dad from Maryland, who was rounded up by ICE and rendered to the CECOT torture prison in El Salvador, despite having no criminal record, a 'do not deport' order on his file and government lawyers admitting he'd been wrongly deported. Even after the Supreme Court told the administration they should really bring him back and give him at least a day in court, they steadfastly refused. Garcia, who is married to a US citizen has no criminal record in the US. And after fleeing gang threats in El Salvador to the US in 2011, aged 16, he was granted protected legal status known as "withholding of removal" from a judge who found he would be targeted by gangs if he was deported back. But the White House has variously claimed he's a member of the MS-13 gang, a people smuggler, and is guilty of "monstrous crimes against humanity." And Trump himself claimed a manifestly photoshopped image of Garcia's hands was evidence of gang membership. Garcia, like many Americans, has tattooed knuckles - a marijuana leaf on his index finger, then a smiley face with crossed out eyes, a cross and a skull on his pinkie. Trump was pictured holding a photograph handily marked up to point out that marijuana starts with an M and smiley starts with an it gets a bit confusing. The cross, which one could imagine standing for a T at a push, is marked up as standing for a digit 1, with the skull for no adequately explained reason standing for a 3. This is, of course, nonsense. But what would be even more nonsense is if someone thought the "MS-13" text overlaid clumsily on top to "illustrate" the translation, was actually part of the tattoo. Which Trump apparently did. What is CECOT? CECOT is the biggest and most notorious "mega prison" in El Salvador Salvadorian mega prisons are notoriously brutal. In fact, the US State Department's travel advisory for El Salvador includes a stern warning about "harsh" prison conditions, without access to due process. It reads: 'Overcrowding constitutes a serious threat to prisoners' health and lives. In many facilities, provisions for sanitation, potable water, ventilation, temperature control, and lighting are inadequate or nonexistent.' Nayib Bukele, the President of El Salvador, has been very close to Trump since his re-election. Bukele has been exceptionally successful at reducing the crime rate in El Salvador, mainly through a brutal crackdown on gang membership. He increased prison sentences for gang members from 3-5 years to 20-30 years and reduced the age of criminal responsibility from 16 to 12. He launched a nationwide crackdown, arresting and detaining some 85,000 people over the course of three years. Many of them are held in CECOT, which is said to have capacity to hold as many as 40,000. Human rights groups have raised concerns that the arrests were largely arbitrary, and had little to do with gang violence - suggesting Bukele had used them to consolidate his own power and to target critics of his Presidency. Many arrests were based on the suspect's appearance, tattoos or location. Human Rights Watch said the government's policy had been "first arrest, then tweet, and investigate later". On the other hand, in El Salvador he and his crackdown is incredibly popular with those who haven't been arrested and thrown in the gulag. El Salvador currently has the highest incarceration rate of any country in the world. In 2019, when he was trying to get the legislature to sign off funding for his crackdown, he called for his supporters to surround the Assembly building and ordered 40 soldiers into the meeting to coerce legislators into approving it. Opposition politicians have described this as a "self-coup" - a term regular readers of our Trump roundups will be familiar with. Get Donald Trump updates straight to your WhatsApp! As the world attempts to keep up with Trump's antics, the Mirror has launched its very own US Politics WhatsApp community where you'll get all the latest news from across the pond. We'll send you the latest breaking updates and exclusives all directly to your phone. Users must download or already have WhatsApp on their phones to join in. All you have to do to join is click on this link, select 'Join Chat' and you're in! We may also send you stories from other titles across the Reach group. We will also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose Exit group. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. Here's what Kilmar Abrego Garcia says happened to him in CECOT The legal complaint says Garcia "was subjected to severe mistreatment upon arrival at CECOT, including but not limited to severe beatings, severe sleep deprivation, inadequate nutrition, and psychological torture.." "Upon arrival at CECOT, the detainees were greeted by a prison official who stated, "Welcome to CECOT. Whoever enters here doesn't leave." Plaintiff Abrego Garcia was then forced to strip, issued prison clothing and subjected to physical abuse including being kicked in the legs with boots and struck on his head and arms to make him change clothes faster. His head was shaved with a zero razor and he was frogmarched to cell 15, being struck with wooden batons along the way..." "In Cell 15, Plaintiff Abrego Garcia and 20 other Salvadorans were forced to kneel from approximately 9:00 PM to 6:00 AM, with guards striking anyone who fell from exhaustion. During this time, Plaintiff Abrego Garcia was denied bathroom access and soiled himself…" "After approximately one week at CECOT, prison director Osiris Luna and other officials separated the 21 Salvadorans who had arrived together. Twelve individuals with visible gang-related tattoos were removed to another cell, while Plaintiff Abrego Garcia remained with eight others who, like him, upon information and belief had no gang affiliations or tattoos." And this one's the kicker, given how much Trump himself wailed about Garcia having MS-13 tattoos on his hands... "As reflected by his segregation, the Salvadoran authorities recognised that Plaintiff Abrego Garcia was not affiliated with any gang, and at round this time, prison officials explicitly acknowledged that Plaintiff Abrego Garcia's tattoos were not gang-related, telling him "your tattoos are fine."
