Almost 30,000 community service orders breached in 11 years, figures show
Almost 30,000 breaches of community sentences have been recorded over 11 years, data obtained by the Scottish Conservatives shows.
Of those who breached community payback orders (CPOs), 8,078 resulted in the offender being handed another community sentence while 7,956 led to a custodial sentence being imposed.
The Tories said the freedom of information data showed 'the SNP's soft-touch justice system in action'.
Figures showed 29,544 breaches of CPOs between 2012-13 and 2023-24.
Justice Secretary Angela Constance has recently spoken of the need to 'shift the balance from custody to justice in the community' as part of measures to deal with prison overcrowding.
Earlier this year, Constance announced there would be an independent review into sentencing and penal policy in Scotland.
The Conservatives have called for more stringent sanctions for offenders who violate CPOs.
Sharon Dowey MSP said: 'These shocking figures are yet more evidence of the SNP's soft-touch justice system in action.
'Given the increased use of community payback orders, the very least the public expect is for offenders to carry out the sentence imposed on them.
'Where there has been a breach, offenders should be properly punished rather than let off the hook. It defies belief that so many are simply having another CPO issued.'
She added: 'It sends a clear message to criminals that there are no consequences for failing to pay their dues, which makes a mockery of the justice system.
'These figures are yet another example of John Swinney's Government pandering to criminals and betraying victims.'
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'Community payback orders are a flexible and robust disposal, with a consistently lower reconviction rate compared to short prison sentences.
'That's why the budget for 2025-26 includes an additional £11m in support for community justice services and ongoing work to further enable a shift away from the use of custody.
'Where a CPO has been breached, it is up to the independent courts to decide the most appropriate outcome based on all of the circumstances of the case.
'Ultimately, this may include the imposition of a custodial sentence'.
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Guardian
22 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
Streeting confident about welfare vote amid criticism of ‘two-tier' Pip plans
Wes Streeting said the changes 'have put us in a much better position' and give 'peace of mind' to those currently in receipt of personal independence payments. The Government's original welfare package had restricted eligibility for Pip, but in a climbdown to stave off a backbench rebellion, the changes will now only apply to new applicants. Mr Streeting said this was not unusual for such a transition. 'When things change and evolve as you bring in new systems, it does change sometimes from group to group, student finance being an example,' he told the BBC's Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg programme. He said 'we've got to listen' when asked if further concessions could be made on Pip. Unite general secretary Sharon Graham has called for the Government to start from scratch on the Bill and said the latest plans were 'divisive and sinister'. 'Creating a two-tier system where younger disabled people and those who become disabled in the future will be disadvantaged and denied access to work and education, is morally wrong,' she said. Disabled Labour MP Olivia Blake said the proposed changes had been 'plucked from the air'. 'This could form an unethical two-tier system that treats two people with the exact same injury or illness differently,' she told The Guardian. The Health Secretary told Sky News's Sunday Morning With Trevor Phillips that the changes 'have put us in a much better position'. 'As a result of the changes, it means anyone watching this morning who's in receipt of personal independence payments now has the peace of mind of knowing that their situation is protected,' he said. Labour MP Louise Haigh meanwhile said she planned to back the Welfare Bill next week but needed to see the full detail of the new plans on Monday. The former Cabinet minister also said it was a moment for the Government to 'reset'. 'I think this is a moment and an opportunity to reset the Government's relationship with the British public and to move forward, to adopt a different approach to our economic policy and our political strategy,' she told the BBC. On Saturday, the Prime Minister told the Welsh Labour conference the 'broken' welfare system must be fixed 'in a Labour way'. The original plans restricted eligibility for Pip and cut the health-related element of universal credit Existing recipients were to be given a 13-week phase-out period of financial support in an earlier move that was seen as a bid to head off opposition. Now, the changes to Pip will be implemented in November 2026 and apply to new claimants only, while all existing recipients of the health element of universal credit will have their incomes protected in real terms. The concessions on Pip alone protect some 370,000 people currently receiving the allowance who were to lose out after reassessment. Ministers had hoped the reforms would get more people back into work and save up to £5 billion a year, but the concessions left Chancellor Rachel Reeves needing to find money elsewhere and point to possible tax rises in the autumn.
The National
27 minutes ago
- The National
Scottish Labour MP not 'proud' of Keir Starmer's first year in charge
Brian Leishman, MP for Alloa and Grangemouth, told the BBC Sunday Show that his 'gut reaction' was there were enough backbench rebels to force Number 10 into changing its decision on welfare reforms. Last week, Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall to MPs wrote to MPs setting out the UK Government's 'concessions' after more than 120 rebels signed an amendment that would essentially kill the welfare bill. Those who currently receive Personal Independence Payments (PIP), or the health element of Universal Credit (UC), will continue to do so. READ MORE: Inside the SNP's political strategy ahead of 2026 Scottish election However, planned cuts will still hit future claimants from November next year. It means anyone who does not score four or more points in one of the activities assessed for the PIP daily living component will not receive it if they apply after November 2026. Labour ministers seemed confident they had staved off a rebellion, with a vote due on the legislation in the Commons on Tuesday. The SNP have urged the rebels to 'stand firm' and refuse to back down to the concessions ahead of the vote. Meanwhile, Leishman told the BBC: 'I think it's fair to say that some have been placated by the compromises and concessions, as they're called, but there is still a healthy amount of us, a big cohort of MPs who feel that this should be withdrawn.' (Image: BBC) Asked if he thinks the welfare reforms will pass, the MP said: 'I'd say that behind the scenes, there's conversations being had all the time…some sort of prediction from me, but my gut reaction would be that there is enough of us to make the Government think again.' Leishman was pressed on if he thought the UK Government's position on changing disability benefits was right or wrong, or if the system should stay the way it is. 'No, it does need to change,' Leishman said. 'These proposals, this is not the change that we need. 'What we have seen over the last decade and a half has been chronic austerity that has really impoverished some of the most vulnerable people in the country, it's been politics and policy by design to make people poorer. READ MORE: Police 'examining' Kneecap and Bob Vylan Glastonbury performances 'The notion that we solve these austere cuts with more cuts, that's frankly ridiculous.' Asked if he was proud of Labour's first year in office, Leishman said simply: 'No.' When pressed on why, he said: 'Because I don't think we have tackled…let me just say, let me embellish that, we have done things in our first year that only a Labour Government will ever do. The Employment Rights Bill, a phenomenal piece of legislation, generational improvement for workers, absolutely fantastic.' He said that over 400 of his constituents had benefited from the restoration of miners workers pension scheme, adding: 'Those are two policies only a Labour Government will ever do, have we done enough of those types of things? 'For me, no, that's my job to make sure we do them more often.' It was then put to Leishman that he thought the Government had got more things wrong than right. 'I think that's only fair to say. I'm going to be open and honest with you, I'm not from a political background,' he said. 'We've got to do better, of that there's no doubt.' Leishman also revealed he had never had a conversation with Starmer, bar exchanges at FMQs, having only met him three times at Downing Street. Asked if the PM listens enough to his party, Leishman said: 'No, I think that's quite clear.'
Glasgow Times
37 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Streeting confident about welfare vote amid criticism of ‘two-tier' Pip plans
Wes Streeting said the changes 'have put us in a much better position' and give 'peace of mind' to those currently in receipt of personal independence payments. The Government's original welfare package had restricted eligibility for Pip, but in a climbdown to stave off a backbench rebellion, the changes will now only apply to new applicants. Mr Streeting said this was not unusual for such a transition. 'When things change and evolve as you bring in new systems, it does change sometimes from group to group, student finance being an example,' he told the BBC's Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg programme. He said 'we've got to listen' when asked if further concessions could be made on Pip. Unite general secretary Sharon Graham has called for the Government to start from scratch on the Bill and said the latest plans were 'divisive and sinister'. 'Creating a two-tier system where younger disabled people and those who become disabled in the future will be disadvantaged and denied access to work and education, is morally wrong,' she said. Disabled Labour MP Olivia Blake said the proposed changes had been 'plucked from the air'. 'This could form an unethical two-tier system that treats two people with the exact same injury or illness differently,' she told The Guardian. Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer has said the 'broken' welfare system must be fixed 'in a Labour way' (Paul Currie/PA) The Health Secretary told Sky News's Sunday Morning With Trevor Phillips that the changes 'have put us in a much better position'. 'As a result of the changes, it means anyone watching this morning who's in receipt of personal independence payments now has the peace of mind of knowing that their situation is protected,' he said. Labour MP Louise Haigh meanwhile said she planned to back the Welfare Bill next week but needed to see the full detail of the new plans on Monday. The former Cabinet minister also said it was a moment for the Government to 'reset'. 'I think this is a moment and an opportunity to reset the Government's relationship with the British public and to move forward, to adopt a different approach to our economic policy and our political strategy,' she told the BBC. On Saturday, the Prime Minister told the Welsh Labour conference the 'broken' welfare system must be fixed 'in a Labour way'. The original plans restricted eligibility for Pip and cut the health-related element of universal credit Existing recipients were to be given a 13-week phase-out period of financial support in an earlier move that was seen as a bid to head off opposition. Now, the changes to Pip will be implemented in November 2026 and apply to new claimants only, while all existing recipients of the health element of universal credit will have their incomes protected in real terms. The concessions on Pip alone protect some 370,000 people currently receiving the allowance who were to lose out after reassessment. Ministers had hoped the reforms would get more people back into work and save up to £5 billion a year, but the concessions left Chancellor Rachel Reeves needing to find money elsewhere and point to possible tax rises in the autumn.
