Huawei's AI lab denies that one of its Pangu models copied Alibaba's Qwen
Pangu Pro
large language model
has copied elements from an Alibaba model, saying that it was independently developed and trained.
The division, called
Noah Ark Lab
, issued the statement on Saturday, a day after an entity called HonestAGI posted an English-language paper on code-sharing platform Github, saying Huawei's Pangu Pro Moe (Mixture of Experts) model showed "extraordinary correlation" with Alibaba's
Qwen 2.5
14B.
This suggests that Huawei's model was derived through "upcycling" and was not trained from scratch, the paper said, prompting widespread discussion in AI circles online and in Chinese tech-focused media.
The paper added that its findings indicated potential copyright violation, the fabrication of information in technical reports and false claims about Huawei's investment in training the model.
Noah Ark Lab said in its statement that the model was "not based on incremental training of other manufacturers' models" and that it had "made key innovations in architecture design and technical features." It is the first large-scale model built entirely on Huawei's
Ascend chips
, it added.
It also said that its development team had strictly adhered to open-source license requirements for any third-party code used, without elaborating which
open-source models
it took reference from.
Alibaba did not immediately respond to a Reuters request for comment. Reuters was unable to contact HonestAGI or learn who is behind the entity.
The release of Chinese startup
DeepSeek
's open-source model R1 in January this year shocked Silicon Valley with its low cost and sparked intense competition between China's tech giants to offer competitive products.
Qwen 2.5-14B was released in May 2024 and is one of Alibaba's small-sized Qwen 2.5 model family which can be deployed on PC and smartphones.
While Huawei entered the large language model arena early with its original Pangu release in 2021, it has since been perceived as lagging behind rivals. It open-sourced its Pangu Pro Moe models on Chinese developer platform GitCode in late June, seeking to boost the adoption of its AI tech by providing free access to developers.
While Qwen is more consumer-facing and has chatbot services like ChatGPT, Huawei's Pangu models tend to be more used in government as well as the finance and manufacturing sectors.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
What Apple's biggest iPhone supplier Foxconn told Indian government on asking hundreds of Chinese engineers to 'Leave India'
FILE - The Apple logo is displayed at an Apple store, Jan. 3, 2019. (AP Photo/Mary Altaffer, File) Foxconn has asked hundreds of Chinese engineers and technicians to return home from its iPhone factories in India, with the Indian government being informed of the staff withdrawal without being provided specific reasons for the move. More than 300 Chinese workers have left the facilities over the past two months, Bloomberg reported, dealing a significant blow to Apple 's manufacturing expansion in the country. Apple's India manufacturing push faces major setback as Chinese expertise exits The departure of Chinese technical staff will slow down the training of local workforce and the transfer of manufacturing technology from China, likely raising production costs and affecting efficiency on iPhone assembly lines. According to Bloomberg, the timing is particularly challenging as Apple prepares to ramp up production of the new iPhone 17 with its manufacturing partners in India. The move appears linked to Beijing's broader strategy to curb technology transfers and equipment exports to India and Southeast Asia. Earlier this year, Chinese officials verbally encouraged regulatory agencies and local governments to restrict such transfers, potentially aimed at preventing companies from shifting manufacturing away from China. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Esta IA está generando ingresos (Ver más) Finanzas y economía Prueba ahora Undo Foxconn implements contingency measures amid Chinese staff withdrawal To mitigate the impact, Foxconn is replacing departing Chinese staff with Taiwanese and Vietnamese workers while converting machinery to be operated by Indian employees. The company is asking suppliers to retrofit existing machinery that largely runs on Chinese-language software to be used by English-speaking engineers. The Indian government has not seen a major impact on phone production yet, according to a person familiar with the matter. Foxconn is expected to receive the retrofitted machinery in a few months, while the company continues building a new iPhone plant in southern India as part of Apple's plans to manufacture most iPhones for the US market in India by late 2026. Apple CEO Tim Cook has previously praised the skill and expertise of Chinese assembly workers as a key reason for setting up production in China, beyond just cost advantages. The withdrawal of these experienced engineers from India represents a significant setback for Apple's diversification strategy, particularly as the company seeks to reduce its dependence on Chinese manufacturing amid ongoing geopolitical tensions . AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now
Mint
39 minutes ago
- Mint
China warns US of retaliation if tariffs return, as Trump targets 14 nations with new duties: ‘Will respond resolutely'
China warned the Trump administration on Tuesday (July 8) against reigniting trade tensions by reinstating tariffs on Chinese goods starting next month. The warning came in response to President Donald Trump's move to notify trade partners of sharply higher tariffs set to begin August 1, unless new agreements are reached. In a strongly worded commentary published by the People's Daily, the ruling Communist Party's official mouthpiece, Beijing said, 'One conclusion is abundantly clear: dialogue and cooperation are the only correct path.' The article was signed under the pseudonym 'Zhong Sheng', a term used by the publication to signal official views on foreign policy. Trump's plan to restore tariffs—initially delayed in April—could unravel the fragile truce both sides reached in June. China now has until August 12 to strike a deal with the US to avoid the reimposition of duties that were paused following earlier tit-for-tat exchanges. The People's Daily commentary dismissed the looming tariff deadline as a 'so-called 'final deadline'', and hinted at renewed retaliation if Washington moves forward unilaterally. According to the Peterson Institute for International Economics, the current average US tariff on Chinese goods stands at 51.1%, while China imposes an average 32.6% duty on US products—both sides now covering the entirety of bilateral trade. China continues to reject Washington's approach, reiterating its stance that the tariffs amount to economic coercion. The People's Daily stated: 'Practice has proven that only by firmly upholding principled positions can one truly safeguard one's legitimate rights and interests.' The editorial also criticised regional economies—without naming specific countries—for considering deals with the US that reroute supply chains away from China. The move was seen as a threat to Beijing's central role in global trade networks. In a veiled reference to Vietnam, which recently secured a tariff reduction on US exports, the paper warned: 'China firmly opposes any side striking a deal that sacrifices Chinese interests in exchange for tariff concessions.' 'If such a situation arises, China will not accept it and will respond resolutely to protect its legitimate interests.' Vietnam reportedly agreed to a tariff cut from 46% to 20%, with goods transshipped from China to be levied at 40%, prompting strong objections from Beijing. US President Donald Trump on Monday (July 7) sent formal letters to 14 countries, including Japan and South Korea, announcing new tariffs ranging from 25% to 40% on imports, effective August 1. The move marks a renewed push to force new trade deals before an earlier-imposed July 9 deadline. The letters cited 'significant trade deficits' and warned of penalties for any retaliatory tariff hikes, stating such moves would be matched 'on top of the 25%' rate. However, the letters also left room for negotiation, with Trump saying the US would 'perhaps consider an adjustment' if trade barriers are removed. Trump offered these countries a chance to avoid tariffs if their firms build or manufacture products in the US. And, if these nations impose retaliatory tariffs, the US would add that amount to the declared base tariff. Goods transshipped to evade tariffs will be subject to the higher rate. The United States has extended the suspension of its reciprocal tariffs, initially announced on April 2, until August 1, offering temporary relief to Indian exporters and allowing more time for trade negotiations between New Delhi and Washington. The suspension, which was set to expire on July 9, has been extended through an executive order issued by the White House. The order cited 'additional information and recommendations from senior officials,' including updates on the progress of discussions with trading partners, as the basis for the extension. 'In light of this information, it is necessary and appropriate to extend the suspension effectuated by Executive Order 14266 until 12:01 a.m. EDT on August 1, 2025,' the White House said. On April 2, President Trump had announced reciprocal tariffs on several countries, including a 26% duty on Indian goods, but implementation was paused for 90 days to give partners time to negotiate trade deals with the US.
Mint
40 minutes ago
- Mint
India's drone industry grows rapidly but faces critical rare-earth magnet dependency
Sakshi Sadashiv India is swiftly expanding its drone manufacturing ecosystem, driven by increased defence demands, supportive government policies, and a burgeoning startup scene. The motors used in drones are made from rare-earth magnets, typically smaller brushless DC motors. Gift this article India's drone ecosystem is ramping up local manufacturing amid rising defence demand and policy push, and a swelling base of domestic startups. While there's growing domestic capability in airframes, batteries, and software, critical components such as flight controllers, sensors, and motors continue to be largely import-dependent. India's drone ecosystem is ramping up local manufacturing amid rising defence demand and policy push, and a swelling base of domestic startups. While there's growing domestic capability in airframes, batteries, and software, critical components such as flight controllers, sensors, and motors continue to be largely import-dependent. A key vulnerability lies in the reliance on rare earth magnets—essential for high-performance drone motors, which India currently lacks the capacity to produce at scale, industry executives said. With China tightening export controls on these magnets, especially for defence applications, industry executives warn this could become a bottleneck in India's goal of building a fully self-reliant drone manufacturing ecosystem. The motors used in drones are made from rare-earth magnets, typically smaller brushless DC motors. 'There are ongoing efforts to identify alternative options—both in terms of materials and designs—and to determine what can be used in place of Chinese-sourced rare earth magnets," said Sai Pattabiram, founder and MD of Zuppa, a drone-tech startup. Garuda Aerospace invested in the company this year, and it is also backed by MapmyIndia. Government support Currently, India is home to 515 drone-related companies, with 263 focused specifically on component manufacturing. In terms of funding, drone startups secured $108 million in 2024 and have already raised $39 million in 2025, according to Tracxn data. India is also set to roll out a $234 million incentive scheme aimed at boosting domestic production of drones for both civil and defence use, according to aReutersreport. Moreover, the production-linked incentive (PLI) scheme, along with initiatives like the defence ministry's iDEX and Technology Development Fund (TDF), has created a fertile ground for companies to invest in R&D and ramp up manufacturing. Drone companies interviewed by Mint echoed the sentiment that these schemes are not merely financial boosts, but strategic signals that India is committed to building a globally competitive drone ecosystem. Yet, India's reliance on foreign suppliers—particularly for magnets—has emerged as a serious issue. 'In India, most motors used in drones are permanent magnet motors, which rely on rare earth magnets. Unfortunately, there are currently no alternative suppliers for these magnets," said Srihari Mulgund, partner and New-Age Mobility leader, EY-Parthenon. 'There is currently no domestic source for drone-grade magnets in India. We need to start figuring this out, especially given the current situation," he said. With defence applications flagged by foreign suppliers, access to these critical parts becomes even harder. 'If the end use is defence-related, then suppliers—especially from China—won't ship the parts. That's a serious roadblock. You're essentially stuck if the supplier flags your application as defence," Mulgund added. In June, China issued six-month export licenses for select rare-earth materials following trade talks with the US, but continued to block exports of magnets intended for defence use, maintaining restrictions on military-grade components. 'Even automotive companies are struggling to secure these magnets—so how can drone companies expect to fare better?" Mulgund said. Rare-earth alternatives Currently, there is no viable recycling mechanism, and substituting with ferrite magnets or soft magnetic composites is not feasible, he added. These alternatives do not offer the same performance characteristics—such as magnetic strength, weight efficiency, or thermal stability—required for high-end drone applications. Moreover, manufacturers don't stock large inventories. 'Demand is relatively low, as drones aren't high-volume products; much of the production is order-driven. Companies typically receive an order first and then procure parts, operating largely on a just-in-time basis," Mulgund said. Substitutes like ferrite magnets and soft magnetic composites exist but offer significantly lower magnetic strength, making them unsuitable for drones that require compact, high-efficiency components, according to Mulgund. Yet investor appetite is evolving. As localisation deepens and strategic relevance grows, long-term capital is beginning to flow in. Recently, Raphe mPhibr raised $100 million, the largest fundraising effort in India's drone sector to date. However, CEO Vivek Mishra clarified that the funding isn't for a single product but will go toward expanding both R&D and manufacturing capacities—it is not tied to a specific product like drones. Also Read: How new rules may change your app-cab rides The startup started in 2017 with a modest 2,000-square-foot research space. Later, it scaled up to a 100,000 sq ft integrated research and manufacturing facility, which has now expanded to a 650,000 sq ft facility. The company serves over 10 Indian government clients, including the Army, Navy, Air Force, and armed police forces. Mishra said that the company has sold over 400 drones in the past 12 months alone. On the rare earth magnet front, Mishra said the company has been actively working with authorities and advocating for indigenous manufacturing. 'Things have been moving, but they've picked up pace over the last couple of months. We are now setting up local manufacturing for these magnets as well. For a few months, there might be certain problems—but it's solvable," he toldMint. Defence capabilities 'There's growing investment in drone manufacturing in India, but there's no magic bullet—you can't just pump in money and expect startups to suddenly make everything indigenous," said Pushkar Singh, co-founder of investment firm Tremis Capital. 'The government is now focusing on manufacturing simpler, less complex components locally, as making high-precision components requires machining expertise we currently lack." Less complex components—such as frames, casings, or basic assemblies—are easier and quicker to manufacture compared to high-precision components, which demand advanced machining skills, tighter tolerances, and specialised equipment India is still developing. He added that while Indian startups are unlikely to make missiles or tanks, drones represent a strategic sweet spot, especially with rising demand in modern warfare. 'Modern warfare is shifting towards drones. The government wants to reduce dependency and boost exports. Many smaller countries can't afford fighter jets or missiles, but they can afford drones. That creates massive export potential for Indian startups." Mumbai-based IdeaForge says it has already built a fully proprietary autopilot stack—meaning all flight control software and systems have been developed in-house, without using any third-party or open-source code. 'We have written the software for our autopilot from the ground up. The PCB (printed circuit board), which connects and powers key electronic components, is also our own design—and we ensure that microcontrollers (chips that control drone functions), don't come from geographies of concern (countries that may pose security or trade risks)," said Ankit Mehta, co-founder of IdeaForge. He added that, depending on the product, their drones are around 70% indigenously built. US, Europe, Japan, Australia, and India have already begun allocating significant resources to rebuild rare-earth supply chains and reduce their dependence on China. Australia's Lynas Rare Earths has ramped up production, while the US has designated rare earths as critical minerals and is channelling funding into domestic mining and refining. Globally, countries are also investing in recycling technologies to recover rare earths from electronic waste and advancing R&D to develop magnet alternatives and reduce overall rare-earth usage in high-tech applications. Topics You May Be Interested In
