Cold Plunges Are a Scam for Women and Science Just Dropped the Mic on This Freezing Hot Fitness Fad
are popular for muscle recovery, but a Swiss study shows no significant benefits for women. 🩺 Experts warn about potential risks of cold exposure, especially for individuals with heart and respiratory conditions.
warn about potential risks of cold exposure, especially for individuals with heart and respiratory conditions. 🔬 The study highlights the gender gap in sports science, urging for more inclusive and representative research.
in sports science, urging for more inclusive and representative research. 💡 Alternative recovery methods like sleep, hydration, and light activity may be safer and more effective.
The allure of cold plunges has captivated fitness enthusiasts and wellness influencers alike, promoting the idea that submerging oneself in icy water can significantly aid muscle recovery. The global cold plunge tub market reached an astounding $318.63 million in 2023, underscoring its widespread popularity. Yet, a new study from Switzerland challenges these benefits for women. Could it be that the icy hype lacks substance for half the population? No Meaningful Edge in Recovery
The Swiss study took a deep dive into the effects of cold and hot water immersion on muscle recovery in women. Participants were put through a rigorous workout involving multiple sets of drop-jumps designed to induce muscle damage. Post-exercise, they were divided into three groups: cold-water immersion, hot-water immersion, and no immersion. Submerging up to the sternum, participants in the plunge groups underwent this process immediately after exercising and once more two hours later.
Interestingly, while physiological changes such as body temperature variations and muscle oxygenation were noted, these did not translate into improved recovery metrics. Key indicators like soreness, knee extensor swelling, creatine kinase levels, and isometric muscle strength were monitored at intervals following the workout. Results showed no significant differences across the groups, questioning the effectiveness of these popular recovery methods.
Discover the Top Nutrient-Rich Foods that Can Assist in Your Weight Loss Journey Experts Weigh In on Risks and Benefits
Dr. Farah Ahmad from The London General Practice provided insights into the broader implications of cold plunges. While potential benefits such as activating brown adipose tissue and improving insulin sensitivity were acknowledged, the risks could not be overlooked. She highlighted the dangers posed to individuals with pre-existing conditions, noting that sudden cold exposure can lead to rapid heart rate increases and elevated blood pressure, potentially triggering dangerous cardiac events.
Moreover, the sudden shock of cold water might cause hyperventilation, a significant risk for those with respiratory ailments like asthma. Individuals with sensitive skin could also experience adverse reactions. These insights underscore the need for caution and the importance of tailor-fit recovery strategies.
« This brewing habit could silently hurt you »: these common coffee preparation methods directly linked to increased heart disease risk Study Highlights Gender Gap in Sports Science
The Swiss trial stands out for focusing specifically on women, a demographic often overlooked in sports science. Historically, males have dominated studies on training and recovery, leading to a skewed understanding of how these processes work across genders. This study emphasizes the necessity for more inclusive research that considers sex-specific physiological responses and real-world workout contexts.
The researchers advocate for future studies that better represent the female population and address the unique needs and responses women might have to recovery protocols. Such research is crucial for developing effective, gender-sensitive recovery strategies in sports and fitness.
'China Can See the Invisible': Beijing Unveils Handheld Tech That Locates U.S. Stealth Aircraft With Pinpoint Accuracy Smarter Ways to Recover
In light of the study's findings, alternative recovery methods are gaining attention. Dr. Ravina Bhanot of Zonas Fertility advises a holistic approach focusing on fundamental recovery pillars. She emphasizes the importance of quality sleep, adequate hydration, and balanced nutrition, particularly protein intake, to support muscle repair and growth.
Incorporating light activities like walking or yoga, along with occasional massages or heat therapy, can also enhance recovery without the potential risks associated with cold plunges. This comprehensive approach aligns more closely with sustainable wellness practices, offering a safer and potentially more effective path to recovery.
As the conversation around cold plunges and their efficacy continues, one must consider whether the icy allure is truly beneficial or merely a trend. With research unveiling new insights, the question remains: How will future studies shape our understanding of effective recovery strategies for both men and women?
Did you like it? 4.5/5 (21)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
9 hours ago
- France 24
HIV-positive Turkmen man fears deportation, torture
Emir -- whose name has been changed for safety reasons -- fled the ex-Soviet Central Asian country in 2018 for fear of being persecuted for his homosexuality. He then found a job in a territory in Europe that is not internationally recognised. To avoid compromising his safety and that of his relatives back home, AFP has chosen to keep his exact location secret, but was able to interview him in person in July. The 30-year-old said he tested positive for HIV in 2024. He showed the results of medical lab tests, which AFP was able to authenticate, and said he had no access to antiviral treatment. "My condition is getting worse. My body and stomach are hurting, I have pain under my ribs," he said. "I can't sleep anymore, I sleep four or five hours, thinking about my health every day. I don't want to get AIDS," he added in a faint voice. Mortal threat Because of his HIV-positive status, Emir said he had been fired from his job in his current place of residence, lost his income, and now faces deportation to his home country. In Turkmenistan, he said, he would be arrested: "Because of my illness, they will torture me, abuse me, and kill me." Emir is unable to leave the place where he is now because he would have to first return to Turkmenistan to renew his passport, a photograph of which he provided to AFP. Swiss nonprofit Life4me+ sent him six months of antiviral treatment before stopping it due to the exhaustion of their "remaining medication stocks," the organisation's president, Alex Schneider said. Emir then received a few irregular shipments of medication, but for almost four months now he has been without medication. On three occasions, the health authorities in the territory where he is based have refused to provide him with treatment. A local LGBTQ rights group said it was currently unable to provide Emir with the necessary medication for financial and legal reasons. In an email to AFP, it said it had helped find Emir a psychologist who diagnosed him with "severe anxiety and depression symptoms with thoughts of suicide". 'Place forgotten by God' In Turkmenistan, homosexuality is punishable by jail under the criminal code provision prohibiting "sodomy". HIV-positive people, instead of receiving treatment, regularly find themselves imprisoned and tortured, according to several human rights groups. The nonprofits and exiled independent media reported waves of arrests targeting LGBTQ people several times in recent years. People detained as part of the repressions have been reported to disappear into the prison system and held incommunicado. Turkmenistan -- a gas-rich desert country rich officially home to seven million people -- is considered one of the most reclusive in the world. Internet access is severely limited, and no independent nonprofits are allowed to operate there. "It's a place forgotten by God where people suffer terrible things," said Evi Chayka, founder of EQUAL PostOst, a rights group helping LGBTQ people who are victims of repression in the former communist bloc. According to reliable sources familiar with the situation on the ground, speaking on condition of anonymity, the unrecognised territory where Emir is located does not have a "formal asylum framework" which prevents him from being taken into care by international bodies. Stuck in the maze, the young man said he still hopes that someone will find a way to help him. Even if, he added, "thousands of other people are suffering" throughout the world.
France 24
2 days ago
- France 24
'Silent killer': the science of tracing climate deaths in heatwaves
The figure was supposed to "grab some attention" and sound a timely warning in the hope of avoiding more needless deaths, said Friederike Otto, one of the scientists involved in the research. "We are still relatively early in the summer, so this will not have been the last heatwave. There is a lot that people and communities can do to save lives," Otto, a climate scientist at Imperial College London, told AFP. Heat can claim tens of thousands of lives during European summers but it usually takes months, even years, to count the cost of this "silent killer". Otto and colleagues published their partial estimate just a week after temperatures peaked in western Europe. While the underlying methods were not new, the scientists said it was the first study to link heatwave deaths to climate change so soon after the event in question. Early mortality estimates could be misunderstood as official statistics but "from a public health perspective the benefits of providing timely evidence outweigh these risks," Raquel Nunes from the University of Warwick told AFP. "This approach could have transformative potential for both public understanding and policy prioritisation" of heatwaves, said Nunes, an expert on global warming and health who was not involved in the study. - Big deal - Science can show, with increasing speed and confidence, that human-caused climate change is making heatwaves hotter and more frequent. Unlike floods and fires, heat kills quietly, with prolonged exposure causing heat stroke, organ failure, and death. The sick and elderly are particularly vulnerable, but so are younger people exercising or toiling outdoors. But every summer, heat kills and Otto -- a pioneer in the field of attribution science -- started wondering if the message was getting through. "We have done attribution studies of extreme weather events and attribution studies of heatwaves for a decade... but as a society we are not prepared for these heatwaves," she said. "People think it's 30 (degrees Celsius) instead of 27, what's the big deal? And we know it's a big deal." When the mercury started climbing in Europe earlier this summer, scientists tweaked their approach. Joining forces, Imperial College London and the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine chose to spotlight the lethality -- not just the intensity -- of the heat between June 23 and July 2. Combining historic weather and published mortality data, they assessed that climate change made the heatwave between 1C and 4C hotter across 12 cities, depending on location, and that 2,300 people had likely perished. But in a notable first, they estimated that 65 percent of these deaths -- around 1,500 people across cities including London, Paris, and Athens -- would not have occurred in a world without global warming. "That's a much stronger message," said Otto. "It brings it much closer to home what climate change actually means and makes it much more real and human than when you say this heatwave would have been two degrees colder." Underestimated threat The study was just a snapshot of the wider heatwave that hit during western Europe's hottest June on record and sent temperatures soaring to 46C in Spain and Portugal. The true toll was likely much higher, the authors said, noting that heat deaths are widely undercounted. Since then Turkey, Greece and Bulgaria have suffered fresh heatwaves and deadly wildfires. Though breaking new ground, the study has not been subject to peer review, a rigorous assessment process that can take more than a year. Otto said waiting until after summer to publish -- when "no one's talking about heatwaves, no one is thinking about keeping people safe" -- would defeat the purpose. "I think it's especially important, in this context, to get the message out there very quickly." The study had limitations but relied on robust and well-established scientific methodology, several independent experts told AFP. Tailoring this approach to local conditions could help cities better prepare when heatwaves loom, Abhiyant Tiwari, a health and climate expert who worked on India's first-ever heat action plan, told AFP. "I definitely see more such studies coming out in the future," said Tiwari from NRDC India. Otto said India, which experiences tremendously hot summers, was a "prime candidate" and with a template in place it was likely more studies would soon follow.
France 24
4 days ago
- France 24
US plan to destroy contraceptives sparks uproar
The contraceptives are being stored in Belgium and are reportedly planned to be incinerated in France. Both European countries are under pressure to prevent the destruction. What has the US announced? On July 18, British newspaper the Guardian cited two US Congress sources as saying that President Donald Trump's administration planned to destroy $9.7 million worth of contraceptives, which are mostly long-acting such as IUDs and birth control implants. The contraceptives -- intended for some of the world's poorest countries, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa -- are stored in a warehouse in the Belgian city of Geel. They are to be incinerated at the end of July, according to the Guardian report. A US State Department spokesperson told AFP this week that "a preliminary decision was made to destroy certain" birth control products from "terminated Biden-era USAID contracts". Trump's administration dismantled USAID, the country's foreign aid arm, after returning to the White House in January, replacing President Joe Biden. The State Department spokesperson said the destruction will cost $167,000 and "no HIV medications or condoms are being destroyed." Why? The spokesperson pointed AFP to a policy that prohibits providing aid to non-governmental organisations that perform or promote abortions. The Mexico City Policy, which critics call the "global gag rule", was first introduced by President Ronald Reagan in 1984, and has been reinstated under every Republican president since. The Trump administration has also slashed foreign aid, with the Senate this month approving a package that cut around $8 billion in international funding, much of it intended for USAID. Research has estimated that the USAID cuts will lead to the deaths of 14 million people by 2030. Earlier this month, the US also incinerated nearly 500 metric tons of high-nutrition biscuits which were meant to keep malnourished children in Afghanistan and Pakistan alive. Trump has also repeatedly moved to restrict abortion access in the United States, taking credit for the Supreme Court overturning the nationwide right to abortion in 2022. The US State Department also suggested to the Guardian that the contraceptives were nearing the end of their shelf life. However media reports have since said that the products expire between April 2027 and September 2031. What are the alternatives? Belgium's foreign ministry told AFP that it has "initiated diplomatic efforts with the United States embassy in Brussels" about the contraceptives. The government "is exploring all possible avenues to prevent the destruction of these products, including temporary relocation solutions," it added. The international organisation MSI Reproductive Choices said it had offered to "purchase, repackage, and manage logistics at our expense, ensuring the products reach those in need". However this offer was repeatedly rejected, it said in a statement. The International Planned Parenthood Federation (IPPF) made a similar offer at "no cost to the US government" that was also turned down. What are people saying? New Hampshire's Democratic Senator Jeanne Shaheen pointed to the Trump administration's stated goal of reducing government waste, saying the contraceptives plan "is the epitome of waste, fraud and abuse". Shaheen and Democratic Senator Brian Schatz have introduced a bill aiming to prevent further US aid being wasted. The IPPF said the contraceptives plan is "an intentional act of reproductive coercion". Doctors Without Borders called it a "callous waste". MSI advocacy director Sarah Shaw said it was "an ideological assault on reproductive rights, and one that is already harming women". The head of the French Family Planning group, Sarah Durocher, observed that last year France became the first country to enshrine the right to abortion in its constitution. "France has a moral responsibility to act," she said. French Green leader Marine Tondelier signed an open letter calling on President Emmanuel Macron to stop the contraceptives from being destroyed. "Our country cannot be complicit, even indirectly, in retrograde policies," the letter read.
