The Rhetoric of Social Justice Ignores the Need for it
The Union government's recent announcement to conduct a caste census signals an intent to better understand India's complex social stratification, aiming to craft targeted welfare policies for the marginalised communities, particularly the Other Backward Classes. Though the democratic discourse is infatuated with the agenda of social justice there is a visible gap between rhetoric and reality. The continued marginalisation of the Scheduled Castes and Tribes from the sphere of power and privileges, raise questions about the commitment of the state and the political elites to bring transformative change in their lives.
The Indian constitution lays a robust framework for uplifting SCs and STs through three key pillars:
protection from social humiliation and exploitation with provisions like the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, ensuring that their social dignity and civic rights are safeguarded,
equitable representation through reservations in state institutions that allows these groups to avail themselves crucial positions of power and privileges in governance,
and last, advancing economic empowerment via dedicated budgetary provisions and policy initiatives.
Policy measures like the special component plan for SCs and STs in the state budget were introduced to ensure financial assistance for the economic empowerment of these sections. However, implementation has been inconsistent on all three fronts, often with token value, leaving large sections of these communities outside the ambit of social justice policies.
Persistent social injustices
Despite substantive legal safeguards like the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, caste-based discrimination persists.
The National Crime Records Bureau recorded 57,582 cases of atrocities against SCs and 10,062 against STs in 2022, reflecting deep-rooted systemic oppression and the limit of the state machinery to curb the menace. From rural areas, where Dalit people face violence for minor assertions of dignity, to urban centres, where discrimination in housing and employment is rampant, caste continues to shape access to opportunities.
Such incidents are witnessed even in the arena of state institutions like universities (the institutional murder of Rohith Vemula) and legislative bodies (which see little discussion on the issues of caste-based violence). This underscores the failure of the governing classes to enforce protective measures effectively.
Reservation: A partial success
The reservation policy, designed to ensure SC and ST representation in state institutions, has seen uneven progress.
While lower-level posts (Group C and D) in public sector units like railways and banks are often filled, senior positions remain largely inaccessible to marginalised groups even now. Especially in higher education, leadership roles such as vice-chancellors and professors are predominantly occupied by unreserved categories, highlighting structural barriers.
Similarly, in the higher judiciary, SC and ST representation among judges and key functionaries is negligible, undermining the promise of equitable participation. The downsizing of public sector units has further eroded opportunities for reserved posts, exacerbating their economic exclusion. The positions of power and privileges in major state institutions are dominated by the social elites.
Further, the political class and civil society have failed to engage in crucial deliberation to make private economy more inclusive with the increased participation Dalit and Adivasis. They mostly survive as the precarious labour class, distanced from the entitlements and privileges enjoyed by the middle-class.
Economic marginalisation
One of the major objectives of the special component plan for SCs and STs is to provide income generating assets and skill so as to enable the marginalised social groups to have a sustained economic upliftment. It intends to advance composite economic development programmes to elevate their class position. Even such a significant initiative has often been reduced to a symbolic gesture today. Exclusive funds meant for SC and ST welfare are frequently underutilised or diverted, with successive governments failing to prioritise these allocations for a substantive welfare of these groups.
Under the current Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)-led government, this trend has continued, with flagship schemes for the general welfare of all (like the Jan Dhan Yojana) overshadowing the targeted welfare schemes and policies meant for marginalised groups. There are negligible initiatives to examine the precarious economic conditions of Dalits and introduce effective public policies and schemes for their empowerment and mobility.
Beyond political rhetoric of social justice
As social justice becomes a rallying cry in electoral politics, its transformative potential remains limited without concrete action.
The constitutional framework, though robust, requires rigorous implementation through executive accountability and policy innovation. Political parties must move beyond populist rhetoric and prioritise social justice as a core governance agenda. While the ruling dispensation under the BJP has often pledged to uphold the ideals of social justice, its decade-long tenure has seen a steady rise in caste-based violence and a dilution of policies aimed at SC and ST upliftment. Though at the symbolic level it offered prominent political gestures (like naming Draupadi Murmu the president of India), there is an absence of new initiatives to enhance their representation in public and private sectors.
The growing political rhetoric on social justice shall complement with substantive executive orders and fair implementation of policies. However, the governing elites hardly felt any moral pressure to perform under constitutional directives. Further, within the democratic polity, the Dalit-Adivasi claims for social justice and inclusivity have weakened or relegated to negligible space. Their movements are quelled and not allowed to flourish. Without a popular movement and mobilisation of Dalit, Adivasi and Bahujan groups, political elites would always hesitate to execute effective programmes for their welfare. The growing marginalisation of Dalits and Adivasis from the national discourse has allowed the traditional elites to dominate decision-making process and to neglect the social justice agenda.
The future
The national political discourse shall revolve around the welfare, security and advancement of the Dalit, Adivasi and Bahujan communities, ensuring their equitable participation in positions of power and privileges. The BJP and the Congress offer a visible space to the idea of social justice in their political manifestos, but overtly hesitate to ensure its appropriate implementation. To actualise the potentials of a social justice agenda, India needs a governing class that is sensitive and committed to the welfare of the marginalised social groups in a substantive manner.
Further, there is a crucial need to amplify the Dalit and Adivasi voices for social justice, enabling new movements to drive national discourse for policy reforms.
Finally, the social justice discourse needs to move beyond the claim for representation in public institutions and democratic polity. It needs to examine other spheres of power and privileges (like market economy, cultural industry, sports establishments, and so on) which are overtly dominated by the conventional ruling classes. The social justice agenda needs to be applicable to a broader arena of power to make it more diverse and representative through the participation of Dalit, Adivasi and Bahujan groups.
Harish S. Wankhede is Assistant Professor, Center for Political Studies, School of Social Sciences, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Indian Express
11 minutes ago
- Indian Express
India's first outreach to Syria after Assad fall: MEA official meets ministers in Damascus
In its first official outreach to the new dispensation in Syria since the fall of the Assad regime last year, India has sent a senior official to Damascus to meet with ministers in the transitional government led by Ahmed Hussein al-Sharaa. An Indian delegation led by M Suresh Kumar, Joint Secretary in charge of West Asia and North Africa Department at the Ministry of External Affairs, met Syrian Minister of Foreign Affairs and Expatriates, Asaad Al-Shaibani on Monday, according to Syrian news agency SANA. Kumar was earlier India's charge d'affaires at the Indian High Commission in Islamabad, Pakistan. 'Talks during the meeting dealt with issues of mutual concern and ways of enhancing relations between the two countries in the interests of both peoples,' SANA reported, quoting a Syrian Foreign ministry statement. The Indian delegation also held discussions with Syrian Health Minister Musab Al-Ali on Monday. Sources said the focus of the dialogue was on enhancing collaboration in health care, particularly in 'pharmaceutical manufacturing and medical training'. Both sides also deliberated on the implementation of a 'scholarship program for Syrian students' and the development of a 'specialised engineering cooperation initiative tailored for Syrian government employees'. According to SANA, Al-Ali emphasised Syria's keenness to build a lasting partnership with India in the pharmaceutical and healthcare sectors and noted it would strengthen the country's national health system and improve the availability of essential medicines. Kumar reaffirmed New Delhi's commitment to support Syria through funding specialised training programs for Syrian professionals. He also said India would continue coordinating the training of Syrian doctors at Indian institutions while fostering deeper collaboration in nursing, pharmaceuticals and drug exports. India had strong and robust ties with the Assad regime — led primarily by Hafez al-Assad and then his son Bashar al-Assad — for more than five decades until last December, when al-Sharaa led a rebel coalition to overthrow the Bashar al-Assad regime and took over as the country's leader. According to officials, India has been monitoring the situation after the departure of Bashar al-Assad on 8 December 2024. In the immediate aftermath of the political change in Syria, India carried out the evacuation of 77 Indian nationals from Syria on 10-11 December 2024. On December 9, India had called for a 'peaceful and inclusive Syrian-led political process' which respects the interests and aspirations of all sections of Syrian society. It was India's first statement since Bashar al-Assad's fall. 'We hope that the new constitution, due to be drafted, takes into account the interests of all the sections of the Syrian society,' an Indian official said. Syria adopted a new interim constitution on March 13. The country is expected to hold its first parliamentary election under the al-Sharaa administration in September. Shubhajit Roy, Diplomatic Editor at The Indian Express, has been a journalist for more than 25 years now. Roy joined The Indian Express in October 2003 and has been reporting on foreign affairs for more than 17 years now. Based in Delhi, he has also led the National government and political bureau at The Indian Express in Delhi — a team of reporters who cover the national government and politics for the newspaper. He has got the Ramnath Goenka Journalism award for Excellence in Journalism '2016. He got this award for his coverage of the Holey Bakery attack in Dhaka and its aftermath. He also got the IIMCAA Award for the Journalist of the Year, 2022, (Jury's special mention) for his coverage of the fall of Kabul in August 2021 — he was one of the few Indian journalists in Kabul and the only mainstream newspaper to have covered the Taliban's capture of power in mid-August, 2021. ... Read More


Deccan Herald
13 minutes ago
- Deccan Herald
Renowned economist, House of Lords peer Meghnad Desai dies at 85
Anguished by the passing away of Shri Meghnad Desai Ji, a distinguished thinker, writer and economist. He always remained connected to India and Indian culture. He also played a role in deepening India-UK ties. Will fondly recall our discussions, where he shared his valuable…


India.com
13 minutes ago
- India.com
Microsoft Ditches Russia-Linked Nayara: EU Sanctions Slam Indian Oil Giant Into Crisis, Rediff Rushed In
New Delhi: A storm is brewing in India's oil sector. The trigger? A fresh wave of European Union (E.U.) sanctions aimed at isolating Russia's oil economy. But this time, the fallout is not in Moscow; it is at a high-capacity refinery in Gujarat, where Nayara Energy, backed by Russian oil giant Rosneft, is suddenly cut off from its digital backbone. Microsoft has abruptly suspended its services to Nayara, leaving thousands of employees locked out of their familiar digital workspace. No Outlook. No Teams. No warning. By Tuesday last week, the shutdown was complete, according to sources quoted by Reuters. The sanctions had found their latest and most unexpected target. To keep communication going, Nayara scrambled for a backup. The company turned to an old Indian internet brand now offering enterprise email services. Based in Mumbai, Rediff has stepped in to provide an internal messaging system. But there is a catch. It cannot touch any of the data previously stored on Microsoft's cloud. As a result, years of archives gone dark for now. Caught off guard, Nayara on Monday dragged Microsoft to the Delhi High Court, challenging what it calls a 'unilateral' and 'legally unjustified' decision. The refinery is pushing back, not only in court, but in public. 'This action has been taken unilaterally, without prior notice, consultation or recourse and under the guise of compliance. Such moves signal a worrying trend of global corporations extending foreign legal frameworks into jurisdictions where they have no applicability,' Nayara said in a statement. Microsoft is headquartered in the United States. The E.U. sanctions, Nayara pointed out, apply only in Europe, not in America or India. Still, the tech giant chose to pull out. And this is where things get messier. Capable of processing 20 million tonnes a year, Nayara's Vadinar refinery is one of India's top importers of Russian crude. It handles about 8% of India's refining output and fuels nearly 7% of the national retail network with over 6,750 filling stations. The company is also expanding into petrochemicals, aiming for 8% of India's polypropylene capacity. Until now, Nayara had been seen as a key player helping India balance its energy needs with discounted Russian oil, especially after the war in Ukraine began. But things are shifting. Bloomberg reports say oil firms and shippers are beginning to keep their distance. Exporting refined products or importing crude has started becoming more complicated. Nayara has become the first Indian oil company directly impacted by the EU's newest sanctions. The refinery insists it follows Indian law to the letter. 'We remain in continuous dialogue with Indian authorities to ensure complete transparency and accountability,' the company stated. New Delhi is not happy either. India has pushed back against what it calls unilateral restrictions. Responding to the latest sanctions, the Ministry of External Affairs did not mince words. 'India does not subscribe to any unilateral sanction measures. The Government of India considers the provision of energy security a paramount importance to meet the basic needs of its citizens. We would stress that there should be no double standards, especially when it comes to energy trade,' said MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal. On July 19, the E.U. tightened the price cap on Russian oil from $60 to $46.7 per barrel, squeezing already thin margins. The ripple effects are now being felt in Indian boardrooms and courtrooms alike. What happens next could redefine how India's energy partnerships evolve and how far corporate compliance with foreign sanctions can go, even within sovereign borders.