logo
Sean Combs Trial Alternate Juror ‘Believed' Cassie and Jane, but ‘Intent' Was Issue

Sean Combs Trial Alternate Juror ‘Believed' Cassie and Jane, but ‘Intent' Was Issue

Yahoo18 hours ago
When Sean Combs was acquitted of two sex trafficking charges after harrowing testimony from R&B singer Casandra 'Cassie' Ventura and a more recent ex-girlfriend who testified under the pseudonym Jane, some surmised the jury simply didn't believe the women. But there's another possible explanation, experts and an alternate juror who sat through the seven-week trial tell Rolling Stone. The verdict may have hinged on jurors' appraisal of Combs' 'intent.'
It's possible jurors believed that either Cassie or Jane, or both, felt coerced by Combs into at least one commercial sex act with a male escort, but that still wasn't enough for a conviction on sex trafficking. Jurors were required to find that Combs intended to commit sex trafficking, or at least that he recklessly disregarded how his actions might compel someone into sex trafficking, U.S. District Judge Arun Subramanian said in his instructions.
More from Rolling Stone
Sean Combs' Sentencing Set for October
Sean Combs Alternate Juror Speaks Out
Beating RICO Charges Doesn't Make Diddy a Hero
It's a high bar to clear, especially with the element of reasonable doubt, the juror and experts say.
'Both women, I believe they were very credible. They wouldn't go up there and want to lie. I believe the women. [But] I think having a smoking gun for intent, that was one of the things we were looking for,' the alternate juror, who asked to be identified only by his first name, George, tells Rolling Stone. 'I was looking for something that would prove intent. And the defense did raise some doubt whether there was intent to coerce.'
While George was effectively excused last week just as deliberations started, he heard the same live testimony from the govenment's 34 witnesses and filled up three spiral notebooks with notes. He says that for him, the hard evidence in the case — the text messages and the so-called 'freak off' videos — fell short of proving that Combs knew the women felt coerced.
According to George, the freak-off videos shown to jurors on privacy screens not visible to the courtroom gallery depicted some sexual activity, but they were mostly 'just talking and rubbing oil.' He says in some of the footage, Ventura appeared to be setting up candles or otherwise helping with 'the ambiance' of the alleged drug-fueled threesomes that could last for days while Combs recorded video and masturbated.
George says 'nothing in the video' showed a bright line of coercion. In other words, any distress or thoughts of coercion going on in the minds of the participants wasn't visible to him. Even so, he believed the women's testimony about feeling coerced, he reiterates.
'I really give credit and kudos to Cassie for coming in early on, heavily pregnant, testifying for days on end, and getting cross-examined. To put yourself through that — that testimony was very important,' he says. 'Listening to both women, I did find them credible. But there were holes … Sometimes everything didn't exactly fit.'
Two former federal prosecutors who secured the 2021 racketeering conviction of R. Kelly in Brooklyn say proving intent is notoriously difficult.
'I thought the government built a compelling case as to trafficking Cassie on at least some occasions. But the reality is that it's very hard to prove that a defendant had the requisite intent to compel a person to perform labor, or engage in commercial sex, even if his conduct arguably had the effect of compelling the labor,' Elizabeth Geddes, the former EDNY prosecutor who delivered the closing arguments in the R. Kelly case, tells Rolling Stone. 'Put another way, the jury could have credited that Cassie felt compelled to engage in the freak-offs for fear of otherwise enduring serious harm but found that there was not enough evidence to prove that Combs' intent was for her to do so.'
Maria Cruz Melendez, the other lead prosecutor on the R. Kelly case — now a partner at Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom — says proving intent is 'one of the hardest elements' of prosecuting a crime.
'Essentially, it's because you have to enter the mind of the defendant and then prove his intent to the jurors so they can say beyond a reasonable doubt that they knew what Combs was thinking when he engaged in the alleged conduct,' she says. 'So, it's understandable that some jurors will have a hard time with that, absent a confession or other type of admission that, from their perspective, is crystal clear.'
She says the law recognizes confessions aren't the norm, so jurors are allowed to look at circumstantial evidence and the actions of defendants. 'But ultimately, each juror is different,' she says. 'What constitutes reasonable doubt for each person is different. That's part of the challenge — whether you've met each individual juror's threshold for reasonable doubt. And, in many ways, it is the same for meeting the intent element.'
When the jury's unanimous verdict was read, Combs covered his face, let out a massive sigh and pumped his fist by his side. He was acquitted of two counts of sex trafficking and a single count of racketeering conspiracy. The jury convicted him on two lesser counts of transportation to engage in prostitution. He is due to be sentenced in early October.
In a letter to the court after the verdict, Combs' defense calculated his expected sentencing guidelines to range between 21 and 27 months. Lead defense attorney Mark Agnifilo said he planned to argue Combs is 'entitled' to 'a below-guidelines sentence' considering he wasn't a 'pimp' making money off the escorts.
Prosecutors, meanwhile, said the correct calculation for Combs' sentencing range was at least 51 to 63 months imprisonment, meaning about four to five years. Federal judges aren't required to follow sentencing guidelines and may treat them as a starting point while considering other factors, including certain evidence at trial they considered credible. In the Southern District of New York, judges stuck to guideline ranges 34.5 percent of the time in the last fiscal year, according to the U.S. Sentencing Commission.
'Today is a great victory for Sean Combs. It's a great victory for the jury system,' Agnifilo told reporters outside the courthouse last week. 'Today is a win. Today is a victory of all victories for Sean Combs.'
In his closing arguments, Agnifilo told jurors they were faced with a 'tale of two trials.' He said one trial was 'told from the mouths of witnesses,' while the other was based on the text messages and videos. He said the texts exchanged between Ventura and Combs around the time of their breakup in 2018 were 'some of the most beautiful things I've ever read.' He called the couple's relationship a 'great modern love story.' Summing up the heart of the defense case, Agnifilo said Combs owned the fact he was violent at times, but domestic violence didn't make Combs a sex trafficker leading a criminal enterprise.
Agnifilo challenged jurors to search through the hundreds of text messages between Combs and Ventura. 'You won't find one, you won't find one where she is like, 'I didn't like that sex. I am not attracted to you. I don't like our sex life,'' he argued.
In her four days of grueling testimony, Ventura said she regularly faced physical beatings and threats at the hands of Combs, so she learned to feign enthusiasm as a survival tactic. 'It was always in the back of my mind that I would somehow be hurt by him,' she said. 'Make the wrong face, and the next thing I knew, I was getting hit in the face.'
Still, George said the text messages Ventura and Jane exchanged with Combs raised doubt.
'The general feel of the messages was that they knew what they were doing, they knew what was happening,' he said. 'Beyond a reasonable doubt, that's such a high standard. But believe me, if we did find there was true intent, and there was an opportunity to convict [Combs] on any of the charges he was found not guilty on, the jury would have done that.'
After the verdict, Agnifilo said the jury got the verdict right, 'or at least right enough.' He then said the defense planned to keep fighting in the face of the two prostitution convictions. 'We're not going to stop until [Combs] walks out of prison a free man to his family,' the lawyer vowed.
Best of Rolling Stone
Sly and the Family Stone: 20 Essential Songs
The 50 Greatest Eminem Songs
All 274 of Taylor Swift's Songs, Ranked
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

George Clooney's wife Amal bans phones in family's home to protect privacy
George Clooney's wife Amal bans phones in family's home to protect privacy

New York Post

time2 hours ago

  • New York Post

George Clooney's wife Amal bans phones in family's home to protect privacy

Amal Clooney is laying down the law. When it comes to entertaining guests at the home she shares with George Clooney, the human rights lawyer has a strict no-phone policy. During a recent interview with Glamour, Amal detailed how she protects her family's privacy while constantly being in the spotlight. 'Creating private moments and spaces is becoming increasingly difficult,' Amal admitted. 'But that's also why we entertain a lot at home. I now have a phone basket that I use to take everyone's phones away!' Amal continued to candidly share that she's fiercely guarding one thing – her family's privacy. 'It's important to get that balance where you have time alone with your family and with your friends where people feel like you can have a safe and frank exchange,' she explained. 5 George and Amal Clooney arrive for The King's Trust and TKMaxx & Homesense Awards 2025 at The Royal Festival Hall in London, England, on June 26, 2025. GC Images While being a mom of two twins, Amal admitted that it's paramount to protect her brood. 'I would say becoming a parent means you're more troubled by some of the intrusions. So, we do the best we can to minimize any impact on our children. We don't put our children out there; we've never put their photo out there or anything like that.' Meanwhile, the Hollywood couple have appeared to balance being in the spotlight and taking care of their family. 5 Amal Clooney and George Clooney in London, England, on June 26, 2025. Getty Images 5 Amal and George Clooney in Venice, Italy on Aug. 29, 2023. GC Images As Clooney debuted the Broadway play he wrote and starred in, 'Good Night, and Good Luck,' in April, his wife Amal was visibly absent. While speaking to reporters, George said Amal missed his big night because 'she's with the kids,' according to People. The couple's twins are named Alexander and Ella. The Clooney family relocated to New York while he focused on his Broadway debut. 5 Amal and George Clooney attend the DVF Awards 2023 during the 80th Venice International Film Festival on Aug, 31, 2023. Getty Images 5 George Clooney greets fans after the final performance of 'Good Night and Good Luck' at Winter Garden Theater in New York City on June 8, 2025. GC Images In February, George was a guest on 'The Late Show with Stephen Colbert' and shared how his family was adapting. 'They love being here. I mean, come on, how do you not love this? It's New York City,' George remarked. 'Actually, a play is kind of a good schedule because you're working at night. You get to see the kids during the day. So, it's OK,' he added. 'Good Night, and Good Luck' is George's Broadway adaption of the 2005 movie he directed. The play, like the movie, portrays the true story of CBS news journalist Edward R. Murrow's exposé on Sen. Joseph McCarthy. George proposed to Amal in April 2014, and the couple married five months later in Venice, Italy. Three years later, in 2017, the Clooneys welcomed their twins. The couple have homes all around the world, including Italy, England and a French property roughly 30 minutes away from Château Miraval, an operating winery owned by George's friend, Brad Pitt.

JAY-Z's Defamation And Extortion Lawsuit Against Tony Buzbee Gets Dismissed
JAY-Z's Defamation And Extortion Lawsuit Against Tony Buzbee Gets Dismissed

Yahoo

time6 hours ago

  • Yahoo

JAY-Z's Defamation And Extortion Lawsuit Against Tony Buzbee Gets Dismissed

JAY-Z's campaign against Tony Buzbee has run into a snag. A California judge dismissed his extortion and defamation lawsuit against the controversial attorney. Mark Epstein, a Los Angeles County judge, admitted he was not 'wholly satisfied' with his decision in a new 65-page ruling, per Rolling Stone. Epstein said he had to weigh the 'competing interests at play,' but would ultimately leave the final decision in the hands of the Court Of Appeal. So, despite making this decision, he ended his ruling saying to 'stay tuned.' Hov sued Buzbee last year after the rape accusations against him were dropped, which the Texas lawyer was a driving force behind. The Brooklyn rapper claimed that Buzbee knew he was operating on false information, yet still proceeded with the suit. He also accused the 56-year-old attorney of contacting him on two separate occasions to demand money before adding him to Diddy's rape lawsuit, which Hov believes was due to him not handing over the requested money. The '99 Problems' rapper's legal team was not pleased with Judge Epstein's decision. 'We are surprised and disappointed by this ruling which turns on the misapplication of California law on the admissibility of the investigators' statements,' his lawyer, Alex Spiro, told Rolling Stone. 'Notably, the Judge expressly states that his decision would have 'change[d] dramatically' if he had admitted the statements into evidence as they would have shown 'not only that Carter had nothing to do with any sexual assault on Doe, but that Buzbee knew it…' and thus 'the court would come out the other way on this motion.' What does it say about our justice system if someone can knowingly bring about completely false claims of the most heinous nature imaginable against an innocent individual and get away with it on a technicality?' Buzbee, on the other hand, was thrilled to be on the right side of a dropped lawsuit this time around. 'Yet another huge win!!' he wrote on X. 'John Doe's case against me and The Buzbee Law Firm alleging extortion and defamation was thrown out by the court. As I said when it was filed, the case was completely meritless. We will now seek attorneys' fees against John Doe for bringing the legally flawed case.' More from Jeezy Claims JAY-Z Axed His Verse On Beyoncé's "Drunk In Love" Mario Admits Shocking Choice Between A Date And Performing With JAY-Z JAY-Z Joins Beyoncé On Stage For "Crazy In Love" Performance At Cowboy Carter Tour

Nicki Minaj Goes on Social Media Tirade Against Megan Thee Stallion, Jay-Z, Roc Nation
Nicki Minaj Goes on Social Media Tirade Against Megan Thee Stallion, Jay-Z, Roc Nation

Yahoo

time8 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Nicki Minaj Goes on Social Media Tirade Against Megan Thee Stallion, Jay-Z, Roc Nation

On July 8, Nicki Minaj took to both Instagram and X to air a series of grievances. Over a sprawling series of posts, she took aim at Megan Thee Stallion, her management company Roc Nation, its founder Jay-Z, its CEO Desiree Perez and even the Democratic party in the U.S. Here's a brief breakdown of her gripes, which she repeatedly wrote were 'all alleged & for entertainment purposes only.' A Roc Nation representative and a rep for Megan Thee Stallion did not immediately respond to Rolling Stone's requests for comment. On Megan Thee Stallion More from Rolling Stone T.I. and Tiny's $71 Million Award at Doll Trial Chopped Down to $18 Million Sean Combs Trial Alternate Juror 'Believed' Cassie and Jane, but 'Intent' Was Issue Sean Combs' Sentencing Set for October Minaj seemed to delight in the news that Megan Thee Stallion and her management company Roc Nation could not dismiss her former cameraman's lawsuit against them. Last spring, Emilio Garcia accused the rapper of forcing him to watch her have sex with women while traveling with her in Ibiza, Spain, in 2022. Among claims that he was stripped of pay and fired by Roc Nation, he alleged the Ibiza incident happened in part because he is a gay man, constituting a hostile work environment based on his sexual orientation and gender. The Pink Friday rapper appeared to bolster this claim, writing, 'Being a gay man doesn't give any woman the right to sexually grind on you or have sex in front of you.' She added, 'I remember seeing someone grinding on their hair stylist & he seemed so uncomfortable.' Minaj has previously claimed Megan acted inappropriately around the time they filmed the music video for their one collaboration, 'Hot Girl Summer,' in 2019. The pair have had tension since, culminating in Megan's chart-topping diss 'Hiss' where she seemingly taunted Minaj by rapping: 'These hoes don't be mad at Megan/These hoes mad at Megan's Law,' an apparent nod to Minaj's husband and brother's sex offender convictions. 'What was the name of that law again????????' Minaj wrote in an Instagram caption of a screengrab of the news of Garcia's lawsuit persisting. 'Karma's Law? Touch not my anointed law? Vengeance is the Lord's law? We give God the glory & he's only just begun. Have a blessed day if you can.' On Desiree Perez Retweeting an X account invoking Roc Nation CEO Desiree Perez in Garcia's case against the company, Minaj began attacking the music executive, calling her 'Desirat.' Among her attacks, Minaj targeted Perez for receiving a pardon for decades old narcotics and parole crimes from President Trump in 2021. 'Desirat were you out marching with your fellow Mexican immigrants?????,' wrote Minaj, seemingly referencing anti-ICE movements across the country. (Also, Perez is Cuban.) 'Oh, right…you were pardoned by President Trump so you kinda can't, right? I mean it kind of implies you guys are cool with him while yall seem to pretend to be against him.' Minaj lambasted Jay-Z for not hiring a Black woman as CEO and wrote that the pair have 'ruined' several aspects of the sports and music industry. Minaj previously appeared to criticize Roc Nation when Kendrick Lamar was chosen to perform at this year's Super Bowl over Lil Wayne. Jay-Z and Roc Nation produce the halftime spectacle with Apple Music and the NFL. On Jay-Z When Minaj turned her ire to Jay-Z, she accused him of letting 'Desirat do a lot of evil to black ppl & you stayed silent. We used to believe you.' Among many complaints about Jay-Z's work with Perez, Minaj claimed the mogul owed her money, which she would use to 'send some of my Barbz to college, pay their school fees & student loans via my #StudentOfTheGame charity.' She also invoked a prior claim that Roc Nation employed 'bots' in support of their artists online. '#JayZ call me to settle this karmic debt,' she wrote. 'It's only collecting more interest. You still in my TOP 5 tho.' Minaj also insinuated that Jay-Z and Perez didn't support former Vice President Kamala Harris' 2024 run for president with the vigor that the rapper supported former President Obama's campaigns because of an alleged allegiance to President Trump due to Perez's pardon. 'Brother billionaire never got in the field for yall, huh?' she wrote. On the Democrats That brings us to Minaj's beef with Democrats more broadly. 'President Biden posting not like us after Desirat was pardoned by President Trump is so 😩,' she wrote, uniting her complaints about Kendrick Lamar's Super Bowl performance and Perez's pardon. Then, in one of her last X posts of the day, Minaj wrote, 'Democrats attacked me over my cousin's balls. Remember?' This is seemingly in reference to the Covid-19 vaccine skepticism Minaj notably shared in 2021, which was fact-checked by Joe Biden's chief medical advisor, Dr. Anthony Fauci. 'Let's see if they have any thoughts on that DESIRAT pardon,' Minaj continued. 'Let's see if they have any thoughts on brother billionaire never campaigning for Kamala even after Obama pleaded with the 'brothers.' Isn't this THEE 'brother'?!??!! Thee one 'brother' who could've probably gotten the job done for yall?!?!!!!! Welp. If the top brother in charge can leave yall hanging w/o repercussions then may everyone else leave you hanging as well. Hanging like my cousin's friend's balls.' Best of Rolling Stone Sly and the Family Stone: 20 Essential Songs The 50 Greatest Eminem Songs All 274 of Taylor Swift's Songs, Ranked

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store