Campaigners secure crunch meeting as concerns rage over Strathyre felling plans
The meeting has been called between the main forestry organisation, community groups and councillors after a petition protesting the tree felling plans attracted more than 600 signatures.
Concerned campaigners have secured a meeting with forestry chiefs over tree felling plans affecting more than 4,000 hectares of woodland near Strathyre.
The Observer reported last week on a petition protesting proposals from Forestry and Land Scotland following growing concern over the presence of 'Phytophthora ramorum' infections across forests in the Trossachs region.
The Strathyre Forests Larch Removal Plan (LRP) covers a total area of 4,225 hectares and is targeting both infected and uninfected trees within a prescribed 'buffer zone'.
But those plans were subject to a petition of more than 600 signatures - and the pressure now appears to have paid off with a meeting in the works between residents, pressure groups, councillors and FLS themselves.
Petition author Karen Clough said: 'We want the best outcome for the woodland here but the scale of the work planned is both exceptional and extraordinary.
'To lose almost 200 hectares of woodland in the next two to three years would really be devastating for the area, not just the habitats built up but also the eco-tourism which businesses can be so reliant upon.
'People come here to wander off into the quiet woodland and get lost - and they do so from all over the world - but who would want to come here if they're going to be surrounded by forestry work and logging machines?
'Why don't we ringfence an area around Strathyre as non-commercial woodland which can be more protected, where the diversity of habitats is saved and it wouldn't impact the community as severely?'
Further concerns over the proposals on wildlife have been raised by Duncan Orr-Ewing, chairman of the Central Scotland Raptor Study Group, who added: 'There is a really broad mix of conifer tree species in the area and because of that diversity, it is really attractive to an array of wildlife - we have an interest in breeding raptors, but there is also a healthy population of goshawks and owls.
'The main concern over the FLS plans are that we haven't seen much of a mitigation plan for the raptor and owl species and a whole load of conifers potentially being removed could cause serious damage to the raptor population.
'We commented on the proposals at an early stage but haven't had any feedback from that; they have the information on the breeding raptors and the concerns they will leave this area if this is not carried out properly.'
Trossachs and Teith councillor Martin Earl has been involved in brokering the meeting and welcomed the news - and also the extension of consultation over the plans until July 4.
Cllr Earl said: 'Given how extensive these proposals are, I can fully understand why there is so much interest from the community so I am delighted that FLS agreed to extend the consultation period and agree to a meeting with interested parties.
'I look forward to this being a constructive opportunity for concerns to be addressed.'
An FLS spokesman said 'Although the law requiring the removal of diseased larch within a timebound period does not require that the usual pre-felling checks are carried out, we nevertheless act in accordance with the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 and the Nature Conservation (Scotland) Act 2004, and use a number of measures to protect raptor and other species during our operations.
'In this instance, we have sought to minimise the potential impacts on wildlife by, as far as is possible, limiting the area of mature forest being removed, proposing the use of thinning and 'keyholing' techniques to minimise tree loss and, where we can, retain non-larch stands in excess of c.45 years of age.
'Where neither option is open to us we will continue to work with stakeholders, including NatureScot and the Central Scotland Raptor Study Group, to find other ways to minimise and mitigate the impacts on populations of priority and protected species.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
a day ago
- Daily Record
Campaigners secure crunch meeting as concerns rage over Strathyre felling plans
The meeting has been called between the main forestry organisation, community groups and councillors after a petition protesting the tree felling plans attracted more than 600 signatures. Concerned campaigners have secured a meeting with forestry chiefs over tree felling plans affecting more than 4,000 hectares of woodland near Strathyre. The Observer reported last week on a petition protesting proposals from Forestry and Land Scotland following growing concern over the presence of 'Phytophthora ramorum' infections across forests in the Trossachs region. The Strathyre Forests Larch Removal Plan (LRP) covers a total area of 4,225 hectares and is targeting both infected and uninfected trees within a prescribed 'buffer zone'. But those plans were subject to a petition of more than 600 signatures - and the pressure now appears to have paid off with a meeting in the works between residents, pressure groups, councillors and FLS themselves. Petition author Karen Clough said: 'We want the best outcome for the woodland here but the scale of the work planned is both exceptional and extraordinary. 'To lose almost 200 hectares of woodland in the next two to three years would really be devastating for the area, not just the habitats built up but also the eco-tourism which businesses can be so reliant upon. 'People come here to wander off into the quiet woodland and get lost - and they do so from all over the world - but who would want to come here if they're going to be surrounded by forestry work and logging machines? 'Why don't we ringfence an area around Strathyre as non-commercial woodland which can be more protected, where the diversity of habitats is saved and it wouldn't impact the community as severely?' Further concerns over the proposals on wildlife have been raised by Duncan Orr-Ewing, chairman of the Central Scotland Raptor Study Group, who added: 'There is a really broad mix of conifer tree species in the area and because of that diversity, it is really attractive to an array of wildlife - we have an interest in breeding raptors, but there is also a healthy population of goshawks and owls. 'The main concern over the FLS plans are that we haven't seen much of a mitigation plan for the raptor and owl species and a whole load of conifers potentially being removed could cause serious damage to the raptor population. 'We commented on the proposals at an early stage but haven't had any feedback from that; they have the information on the breeding raptors and the concerns they will leave this area if this is not carried out properly.' Trossachs and Teith councillor Martin Earl has been involved in brokering the meeting and welcomed the news - and also the extension of consultation over the plans until July 4. Cllr Earl said: 'Given how extensive these proposals are, I can fully understand why there is so much interest from the community so I am delighted that FLS agreed to extend the consultation period and agree to a meeting with interested parties. 'I look forward to this being a constructive opportunity for concerns to be addressed.' An FLS spokesman said 'Although the law requiring the removal of diseased larch within a timebound period does not require that the usual pre-felling checks are carried out, we nevertheless act in accordance with the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 and the Nature Conservation (Scotland) Act 2004, and use a number of measures to protect raptor and other species during our operations. 'In this instance, we have sought to minimise the potential impacts on wildlife by, as far as is possible, limiting the area of mature forest being removed, proposing the use of thinning and 'keyholing' techniques to minimise tree loss and, where we can, retain non-larch stands in excess of c.45 years of age. 'Where neither option is open to us we will continue to work with stakeholders, including NatureScot and the Central Scotland Raptor Study Group, to find other ways to minimise and mitigate the impacts on populations of priority and protected species.'
The Herald Scotland
20-06-2025
- The Herald Scotland
Scottish rainforest silent killer' rooted out by scientists
Yet, their survival has been threatened by thickets of rhododendron, first introduced to the UK as ornamental plants two centuries ago. However, progress is being made. Ahead of World Rainforest Day on June 22, Forest and Land Scotland (FLS) have announced a new milestone in their restoration efforts over the last year. FLS teams restored 1226 hectares in 2024/25, up from 930ha last year. Work included removing invasive rhododendrons, returning native species to the forest, and ensuring deer populations are effectively managed. Rhododendron has run rampant across Scotland's rainforests. (Image: FLS) Dubbed the 'silent killer of Scotland's rainforest', due to its proclivity to rob other plants of space, water, and light; rhododendron is FLS' top target. One 'practical and targeted' solution involves injecting each the stem of each plant with a small dose of herbicide. FLS Native Woodland Ecologist Richard Thompson praised his team's work in combating the rhododendron scourge. Thompson said: 'Following on from the success achieved by the National Trust at some of its sites, FLS is starting to use stem injection at large landscape scale. Results have been encouraging and we are hoping to roll out its use more widely across other FLS managed rainforests. 'FLS manages a substantial proportion of Scotland's rainforest, and with around 8000 hectares of priority rainforest rhododendron areas on land managed by FLS it is imperative that effective and efficient control measures at landscape scale can be refined and deployed. 'However, to truly control the spread of Rhododendron, it needs a strategic, collective and collaborative effort from all landowners and managers including estate and residential gardens.' Read more from Josh Pizzuto-Pomaco: 8,000 jobs boost in Peterhead after £1b energy transition investment Edinburgh University staff to strike today as 1800 job losses threatened 'The Hydro isn't real': Deacon Blue star on upbringing, career, and giving back In 2020 the National Trust for Scotland launched Project Wipeout, targeted at invasive species like rhododendron. According to the Trust: 'Cross breeding with frost-hardy rhododendron species from north east America has produced hybrid vigour and helped the plants adapt to colder temperatures. 'Together with its fertility and tolerance of shade, the plant has been able to thrive in our climate and out-compete native flora. 'Almost half of the core areas of Scotland's rainforests are being choked with R. ponticum.' Project Wipeout has been rolled out across Scotland over the last five years.
Glasgow Times
11-06-2025
- Glasgow Times
Dramatic story behind Glasgow's 'dangerous' railway station
The event tapped into the considerable public interest in the construction of Scotland's first intercity train line, with all proceeds going to the Paisley Relief Fund for workmen injured on the railway. The year 1830 saw the opening of the world's first intercity railway, connecting Liverpool and Manchester. An 1831 prospectus for the Edinburgh and Glasgow Railway (E&GR) claims that the Liverpool and Manchester line had 'infinitely exceeded the expectations of even the most sanguine'. The success of this line led to demand across the country for other intercity routes. Queen Street Station, 1963 (Image: Glasgow City Archives) The E&GR prospectus sets out how passengers travelling between Edinburgh and Glasgow by stagecoach in 1831 faced a journey of five hours, and boasts that a railway connection between the two cities would more than halve journey times, to only two hours. After years of discussion, the legislative foundation for the opening of Queen Street Station was laid with the passing of the Edinburgh and Glasgow Railway Act of 1838. The Glasgow terminus of the line was officially opened at a ceremony on February 21, 1842. Prior to 1838, the site where Queen Street Station now stands was the location of a large rookery. Set within the rookery was Glasgow House, also known as Crawford Mansion, which served as the city residence of James Ewing of Strathleven. Ewing, former Lord Provost and MP for Glasgow, was a plantation owner, enslaver and active pro-slavery campaigner. In 1837, Ewing claimed compensation for the 'loss' of 586 enslaved people on his Jamaican sugar plantations, and was awarded substantial sums by the government. In 1838, Ewing sold Crawford Mansion to the E&GR Company for £35000 – around £3 million in today's money. The mansion was soon demolished to make way for the Glasgow terminus of the newly-authorised railway line. [Image of Cowlairs Locomotive Works, which serviced the Edinburgh & Glasgow Railway, 1921] (Image: Glasgow City Archives) The location of the proposed railway station presented challenges for the project's engineers. The initial proposal had the route into Queen Street running over the Forth and Clyde Canal by means of a railway bridge. However, the objection of the canal company to the bridge required Chief Engineer John Miller to change course, leading to the construction of the Cowlairs Tunnel. While the tunnel allowed the railway to pass beneath the canal, it had the disadvantage of a considerable incline which required incoming trains to be pulled into the station by a steam-powered rope haulage system. Brake vans were attached to the front of locomotives when descending the steep gradient, to keep the speed of the trains in check. The Queen Street of 1842 bore little resemblance to the station as it currently stands. The original station had only two platforms for passengers – one for departures and one for arrivals. Most of the station was given over to goods traffic and warehouses. By the early 1870s, Glasgow Corporation had grown very concerned about the allocation of space for passengers in the station. In letters to the North British Railway Company, which had taken over E&GR in 1865, Glasgow Corporation describes Queen Street Station as 'one of the most inconvenient and dangerous in the city'. According to the local authority, the limited space for passengers, along with an 'immense' increase in passenger traffic, resulted in 'the utmost confusion and danger' in the station, with passengers 'exposed to the imminent risk of being crushed between piles of luggage or of being jostled off the platform and beneath the wheels of the carriages'. The Corporation demanded that the Directors of the NBR submit plans for the improvement of the station as a matter of urgency. After some years of delay, Queen Street Station was almost entirely redesigned, with the new and improved station completed in 1880. It was in this phase of reconstruction that the station acquired the dramatic curved glass roof we know today. 1886 saw further expansion of the station, with the construction of the low level platforms. While Queen Street is sometimes overlooked in comparison to the grander and busier Central Station, it is nonetheless able to claim seniority over its sibling, as Glasgow's oldest surviving railway station.
