2025 MLB NL CY Young Prediction: Odds, Expert Picks, including Paul Skenes vs Zack Wheeler
Follow Rotoworld Player News for the latest fantasy and betting player news and analysis all season long.
NL CY Young: Paul Skenes (-105) vs Zack Wheeler (-125)
Wheeler's calling card to voters is simple — he's never won a CY Young. At age 35, this could be Wheeler's final shot at the elusive award, but is what he's done enough or more impressive than Skenes?
understand the logic of betting Wheeler, but if you've watched the two pitch this season, I think Skenes is the better of the two and arguably the best in all of baseball (Tarik Skubal says hi). However, if you look at basic stats and their consistency, you would say Wheeler has the slight edge, right?
Pre All-Star Break Stats and NL Ranks
Paul Skenes
Zach Wheeler
2.01 ERA (1st)
2.36 ERA (6th)
122.0 innings pitched (T-3rd)
.189 opponent batting average (T-3rd)
.181 opponent batting average (1st)
0.93 WHIP (5th)
0.86 WHIP (2nd)
131 strikeouts (8th)
154 strikeouts (2nd)
12 starts with 0 or 1 ER allowed
11 starts with 0 or 1 ER allowed
3 games of 3 ER or more
4 games of 3 ER or more
4 wins (T-104th)
9 wins (T-8th)
8 losses (tied-20th most)
3 losses (T-4th best)
If you're looking for more key trends and stats around the spread, moneyline and total for every single game on the schedule today, check out our MLB Top Trends tool on NBC Sports!
There isn't much that differentiates the two besides the wins, losses, and strikeouts, which all favor Wheeler. Skenes does have 26 more ground-balls than Wheeler and seven fewer homers allowed (13 to 6), which may bother some. Skenes clearly isn't trying to be that high-rate strikeout guy like early in his rookie season, but get more efficient outs and pitch longer into games — which he's done exceptionally well.
However, while wins and losses historically are a common driving factor for voters, it's becoming not as detrimental since the offense is out of the pitchers control, more so than ever with the universal DH — meaning Skenes could have the upper hand.
If you haven't seen or heard about that stat by now here it is — If the Pirates would have scored four runs in each of Skenes' 42 career starts, his win-loss record would be 28-1 rather than 15-10.
Insanity at its finest! While four runs is a lot for any pitcher to get, that stat is supposed to provide clarity on how poor the Pirates offense and bullpen is and why that shouldn't hold Skenes back in CY Young voting.
In his career wins, Skenes has a 1.19 ERA compared to a 2.39 ERA in losses or non-decisions, so either way, he hasn't been the Buccos' problem since he arrived. This year alone, Skenes has allowed 27 runs over 20 starts and the Pirates have lost 11 of those 20 games!
Pittsburgh's offense has scored the fewest runs in not just the NL, but all of baseball — even the Rockies and White Sox. For more context, the Phillies have scored 112 more runs than the Pirates in one less game.
Both Skenes and Wheeler will be dominant in the second-half, I have no doubts, but Skenes could post a sub 2.00 ERA this season (was doing so through 19 starts), sub .200 OBA, and still have a losing record, which on surface level makes no sense.
Despite how it looks or sounds, I think what Skenes is doing weighs more impressive, challenging, and deserving than what Wheeler is doing. Pitching under the pressure of allowing two earned runs and being almost guaranteed a loss is not common and that's what Skenes goes through every start.
I played and tweeted Skenes out at +115 to win NL CY Young and would go out to -115 odds prior to his first start for the second half of the year. I already played him at +300 on Opening Day to win CY Young, so I am double-dipping.
Pick: Paul Skenes to win NL CY Young (1u)
Vaughn Dalzell's MLB Futures Card
2 units: Aaron Judge to lead MLB in home runs (+130)
2 units: Cam Smith to win AL Rookie of the Year (+150)
2 units: Jacob Misiorowski to win NL Rookie of the Year (-110)
1 unit: Shohei Ohtani to win NL MVP (-110)
1 unit: Bobby Witt to win AL MVP (+450)
1 unit: Elly De La Cruz to win NL MVP (+2000)
1 unit: Garrett Crochet to win AL CY Young (+450)
1 unit: Paul Skenes to win NL CY Young (+115)
1 unit: Paul Skenes to win NL CY Young (+300)
1 unit: Jacob Misiorowski to win NL Rookie of the Year (+100)
1 unit: Byron Buxton to win AL Comeback Player of the Year (+430)
1 unit: New York Yankees to win AL East (-115)
0.5 unit: Dodgers to win 117-plus games (+650)
0.5 unit: Paul Skenes to lead MLB in wins (+1400)
0.5 unit: Garrett Crochet to lead MLB in wins (+2200)
0.5 unit: Juan Soto to lead the MLB in homers (+2800)
0.5 unit: Yordan Alvarez to lead the MLB in homers (+2000)
0.5 unit: Roman Anthony to win AL Rookie of the Year (+1200)
0.5 unit: Jacob Misiorowski to win NL Rookie of the Year (+1100)
0.25 unit: Drew Pomeranz to win NL Reliever of the Year (+1500)
0.25 unit: Aaron Judge to bat .400 by the All-Star break (+800)
0.25 unit: Aaron Judge to bat .400 for the season (+5500)
0.25 unit: Oneil Cruz to lead MLB in stolen bases (+15000)
Follow our experts on socials to keep up with all the latest content from the staff:
Jay Croucher (@croucherJD)
Drew Dinsick (@whale_capper)
Vaughn Dalzell (@VmoneySports)
Trysta Krick (@Trysta_Krick)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
a minute ago
- USA Today
Caitlin Clark jokes during Shane Gillis' ESPYS monologue met with mixed reactions
Shane Gillis served as host of the 2025 ESPYS and was front and center with a pair of Caitlin Clark-related jokes during his opening monologue. Gillis' first joke was met with a mixed reaction from the crowd as he compared himself to the Indiana Fever star. 'It's been a big year for the WNBA, I love Caitlin Clark,' Gillis said. 'She and I have a lot in common. We're both whites from the Midwest who have nailed a bunch of threes.' Clark was not in attendance for the awards show, as the Fever were on the road for a game against the New York Liberty at the Barclays Center. After what appeared to be a mixed reaction, Gillis paused and said, 'There you go, lighten up a little. It's not serious. We'll see about this one,' before telling his second joke. "When Caitlin Clark retires from the WNBA, she's going to work at a Waffle House so she can continue doing what she loves most: fist-fighting Black women,' Gillis said. The remarks were a reference to the heated exchanges Clark has had this season with opponents. Shane Gillis: "When Caitlin Clark retires from the WNBA, she's going to work at a Waffle House so she can continue doing what she loves most: fist-fighting Black women." #ESPYs Caitlin Clark wins at ESPYS It was announced before the ceremony that Clark won the ESPY for Best WNBA Player. In 2024, Clark was named All-WNBA and Rookie of the Year. They couldn't stand Caitlin Clark winning Best WNBA Player Award at the ESPYS 😭'Her villain origin story has started' 💀
New York Post
31 minutes ago
- New York Post
Mets' Brett Baty gets engaged in touching moment at New Jersey beach
Access the Mets beat like never before Join Post Sports+ for exciting subscriber-only features, including real-time texting with Mike Puma about the inside buzz on the Mets. Try it free It was a special All-Star break for Brett Baty. While the Mets third baseman wasn't in Atlanta for any Midsummer Classic festivities, he used his days off from baseball to propose to his now-fiancée Anna Sprys. Advertisement Baty and Sprys made a collaborative Instagram post Wednesday evening with photographer Jordan Simone, who helped capture the proposal. 4 Anna Sprys posted a photo of her and Baty holding hands following their engagement. Instagram / annasprys Advertisement 'Forever with my best friend,' the post was captioned. The couple received many congratulations in the comments, including from Katia Lindor, Mets All-Star Francisco Lindor's wife. 'Congrats!!! So happy for you guys,' she wrote. 4 Brett Baty and Anna Sprys announced their engagement Wednesday evening. Instagram / Brett Baty Advertisement The pictures featured Baty getting down on one knee and popping the question on the beach in Cape May, N.J., before loved ones later came to celebrate and were photographed alongside the couple. The couple's relationship has been fairly private outside of periodic Instagram posts, but they have been together since June of 2022, as Baty made a first anniversary post on June 12, 2023. While Baty hails from Texas, Sprys is originally from Pittsburgh. Sprys attended Binghamton University, where she played volleyball from 2019 to 2023 as a 6-foot middle blocker. Advertisement 4 Brett Baty and Anna Sprys have been together since 2022. Instagram / Brett Baty Baty played 129 games across 2021 and 2022 for the Mets' Double-A affiliate, which plays in Binghamton. Sprys was a team captain for Binghamton's volleyball team and played five seasons while earning an MBA with a concentration in Marketing as well as a Bachelor of Science in Accounting. She currently works as a marketing coordinator. Baty has played 75 games so far this season for New York, posting a .226 batting average with a .685 OPS. 4 Brett Baty is looking to set career highs in numerous different categories this season. Charles Wenzelberg/New York Post The 25-year-old has nine home runs this season, which have already tied his career high that he posted in 2023 in 108 games. He will now play the rest of this season as a fiancé.
New York Post
31 minutes ago
- New York Post
MLB's looming trade deadline chaos will set off frenetic second-half
Twenty-two teams entered the All-Star break either in postseason position or within 5 ½ games of a playoff spot — 22 teams that could talk themselves into buying (or at least not selling) at the trade deadline. Among the eight clubs that appear out of contention are several — the Rockies and White Sox, for instance — that are so dreadful that they do not have much that interests the contenders. Advertisement This dynamic adds up to a lot of teams being desperate for a relatively small number of players, which is expected to complicate a crazed July 31 deadline. Need a true ace? Barring an unforeseen Paul Skenes or Jacob deGrom blockbuster, too bad. Teams will have to pay more than they want for the likes of Sandy Alcantara (whose stuff is there, but whose ERA is 7.22) or maybe Seth Lugo (very solid, but likely a rental) or maybe raid the teetering Diamondbacks for Merrill Kelly or Zac Gallen. Other possibilities include Mitch Keller and Zach Eflin in what will be a seller's market. Virtually every team could use another starter — including the Yankees, who have lost Clarke Schmidt for the season, Ryan Yarbrough probably until August and have at least some concern with Max Fried's blister — in a field that will not have enough to go around. Advertisement Need a top infielder? Get ready to gather and part with your top prospects. The Diamondbacks would receive a haul for Eugenio Suárez, who is clearly the best third baseman at least somewhat available and who would have a strong market. Three of the best teams in the game — the Yankees, Tigers and Cubs — could use an upgrade at the spot and might be bidding against one another for him. Need an outfielder? There are at least a few intriguing pieces. Jarren Duran could help a team like the Mets — or Padres or Phillies or a few more — if the Red Sox decide they can cash in a 28-year-old who can hit and play center field because of the emergence of Roman Anthony. The sinking Orioles should find a taker for Cedric Mullins, and perhaps this is the year Luis Robert Jr. is sent out of Chicago. 3 Third baseman Eugenio Suarez of theDiamondbacks throws to first base for an out. Getty Images Need a reliever? Get in line, as just about every one of those 22 teams could envision buying another back-end arm. Will the Guardians put Emmanuel Clase up for grabs and see how high the proposed prospect pile rises? The Royals' Carlos Estévez, Pirates' David Bednar, Rockies' Jake Bird and Twins' Jhoan Duran and Griffin Jax also should have their bags packed, just in case, in a reliever market that is always active this time of year. Advertisement Because of the extra wild-card spots, the absence of a truly bulletproof team and the dregs of the league being worse than ever — and thus little help to others — the trade deadline will test plenty of front offices regarding how badly they wish to upgrade their World Series chances. 3 Twins relief pitcher Griffin Jax throws a pitch against the Tigers. Lon Horwedel-Imagn Images The next few frenetic weeks will be fascinating and revealing. Other storylines around the majors to follow during the second half: Will there be another home run chase? Home Run Derby champion Cal Raleigh has 38 home runs in 96 Mariners games — Barry Bonds tallied 39 in the first half of 2001, when he finished with 73 — which puts Raleigh on pace for 64. Advertisement Aaron Judge is up to 35 through 96 Yankees games, on pace for 59. 3 Cal Raleigh of the Mariners. Charles Wenzelberg/New York Post Could the most talked-about butt in the sport, and arguably the face of the sport, threaten Judge's AL record of 62 home runs? Will the Dodgers superteam come together? The most expensive baseball team ever is 19 games over .500, comfortably in first place in the NL West and probably considered a disappointment. A club perennially hard-hit by pitching injuries has been hard-hit by pitching injuries, but Tyler Glasnow has returned, Shohei Ohtani is building up his right arm, Blake Snell is making rehab starts and Roki Sasaki is throwing bullpen sessions. They still could add a bullpen arm at the deadline, though Blake Treinen is nearing a return, and Michael Kopech is expected back late this season. Will the Rockies stupor-team (further) fall apart? The worst team in baseball might be the worst team ever in baseball. The 22-74 Rockies have set the record for first-half losses, at least since the All-Star break came into existence in 1933. Last year's White Sox — who set the all-time record for defeats during a 41-121 disaster — were 27-71 at the 2024 hiatus. Colorado is on pace for 125 losses, which would 'break' the White Sox record. Any decent pieces the Rockies have lying around, such as Bird and Ryan McMahon, could be shipped out in the next few weeks. Their remaining opponents have a combined .517 winning percentage that is the second-most daunting in baseball.
