Labour Party declares war on Ramaphosa's National Dialogue
Image: Ron AI
THE Labour Party of South Africa has launched a blistering legal and political offensive against President Cyril Ramaphosa's controversial National Dialogue, branding it an unconstitutional, fiscally reckless, and elitist manoeuvre designed to sideline Parliament and the working class.
The Party's urgent High Court application, filed on June 18, seeks to interdict the process, citing its estimated R700 million to R800m cost as 'unjustifiable' amid South Africa's deepening crises.
Announced by Ramaphosa on June 10, the National Dialogue proposes a two-phase convention — first in August to 'set the agenda', followed by a 2026 summit — to address national challenges. But the Labour Party argues it is a redundant, unlawful parallel to Parliament and institutions such as the National Economic Development and Labour Council (Nedlac).
'South Africa doesn't need another elite summit behind closed doors,' said acting Secretary-General Lindi Mkhumbane. 'We already have Parliament, Nedlac, and civil society platforms. What we don't have is political will from the ruling elite to act on the people's demands.'
The court papers demand:- A declaratory order that the Dialogue is unconstitutional and irrational.- An interdict blocking public funds for the process, including payments to the appointed 'Eminent Persons Group'.- A review of all executive decisions initiating the Dialogue.
The case has escalated into a showdown between the Labour Party and a coalition of high-profile civil society groups aligned with the state. On June 30 the Desmond & Leah Tutu Legacy Foundation, the Strategic Dialogue Group, and the Thabo Mbeki, Steve Biko, and Albert Luthuli Foundations filed to intervene, defending the Dialogue.
'These are not bystanders. These are political actors with deep ties to the post-apartheid ruling class,' fumed interim Labour Party President Joseph Mathunjwa. 'Their role isn't to unite the nation, it's to preserve an elite consensus forged behind closed doors.'
The Foundations submitted answering affidavits before being granted leave to intervene, a move Mathunjwa described as 'arrogance, plain and simple'. He accused them of betraying their legacies: 'The same communities (these leaders) stood for are ravaged by gender-based violence (GBV), unemployment, and poverty. Now these elites want a 'dialogue' instead of action.'
The Labour Party claims that the dialogue is a smokescreen for IMF-driven austerity, including Eskom's privatisation and neoliberal reforms. 'This is a rubber stamp for IMF instructions, nothing more,' Mathunjwa said. 'If Parliament is functional, why create a new platform? This isn't inclusion, it's circumvention.'
The state's late filing of answering papers — missed deadlines and procedural delays — has further fueled suspicions. 'They missed the deadline, and now they're bringing in reinforcements to stall,' Mathunjwa said. The case, initially set for July 1, was postponed to July 4.
At its core, the Labour Party's challenge questions whether South Africa's democracy can withstand executive overreach and elite capture. 'The President cannot wake up and decide to allocate R800m without parliamentary scrutiny,' Mkhumbane argued. 'This is executive overreach masquerading as participation.'
With the hearing imminent, the Labour Party has called for public support, urging South Africans to reject what it described as a 'PR stunt' while the country burns. 'Rape, violence, and poverty don't need a dialogue, they need action,' Mathunjwa said. 'We're ready to meet them in court.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
4 hours ago
- IOL News
How Black Sash's 70-year legacy continues to shape human rights advocacy
Bishop Malusi Mpumlwana gave a keynote address at the Black Sash 70th Gauteng regional event at Constitution Hill on Wednesday. Image: Timothy Bernard / Independent Newspapers One of the country's oldest civil society and human rights organisations, Black Sash, celebrated its 70th anniversary at Constitution Hill in Johannesburg on Wednesday. Established in 1955 by a group of white women activists, Black Sash has been at the forefront of some of the most fervent human rights campaigns, having taken the government and other entities to court over various human rights violations. In recent years, this formidable organisation has turned its attention to tackling issues of social protection, dignity, and democracy on behalf of millions of social grant recipients, who continue to bear the brunt of indignity, shame, and inequality more than 30 years since the advent of democracy. Black Sash's regional manager and advocate for social justice, Thandiwe Zulu, commended the founding members and those who dedicated their lives to fighting both social and political injustice, which continues despite the advent of democracy in 1994. "It is with immense pride and deep gratitude that we welcome you today. This celebration is more than a marker of time, but is a celebration of the contribution made by our founders. The women who dared to challenge the apartheid regime, known for its cruelty and inequality. This inequality remains etched into the geography of our cities and townships. "Over the years, Black Sash has created a space of dignity for those who were denied their rights to justice and equality. From the injustice of pass laws to forced removal to defending the right to social protection, our work has always been driven by the belief that every right must be protected," Zulu said. The organisation, which has evolved over the years, has been commended for its contribution towards equitable justice and equipping ordinary people with information and tools to fight for their basic human rights. In Gauteng, home to some of the country's most unequal and densely populated communities, the organisation is credited for having played a critical role in building civic resistance, providing paralegal advice, and defending the rights of the most marginalised. One of the earliest activists, Judith Hawarden, took guests down memory lane to Black Sash's formation and how in the 1970s, a group of women collaborated with other women in a series of pickets, protests, and other campaigns that placed human rights issues at the centre of the injustices of the apartheid regime. "When the apartheid regime tried to flex its muscles and tried to change the laws in Parliament, six women became outraged as they could not allow this injustice and racist law to go unchallenged, and each one of these women went home and called on other women to join in under the name, Women's Defense of the Constitution League. But because they wore a sash as a sign of mourning over these laws, the media then gave them the name Black Sash. Since then, the organisation became known as Black Sash," she stated. For Bishop Malusi Mpumlwana, who gave the keynote address, Black Sash represents an insurmountable fight against race-based laws, injustice, and empowerment of ordinary citizens through information sharing. "Black Sash mounted protests against unjust government actions and campaigned against just about any and every form of injustice. The emphasis was on unjust laws such as pass laws, forced removals, and Bantustans, and the lost fundamental was about the search for information through its information services that continue to equip ordinary people with information to navigate the minefields of the apartheid regime and its unjust laws," he stated. [email protected]
The Citizen
6 hours ago
- The Citizen
'Criminal investigation against Thembi Simelane underway,' DA
A Saps investigating officer has been assigned to investigate the complaint against her. Justice Minister Thembi Simelane and Democratic Alliance (MP) Glynnis Breytenbach. Deputy Justice Minster Andries Nel is at the back. Picture: GCIS The DA says a criminal investigation against Minister of Human Settlements Thembi Simelane is currently underway, and a South African Police Service (Saps) investigating officer has been assigned to investigate the complaint against her. Investigation DA spokesperson on Justice and Constitutional Development Advocate Glynnis Breytenbach said Simelane is 'yet another ANC minister in the national executive of President Cyril Ramaphosa under investigation for a serious crime.' 'The DA had previously laid charges of corruption against Simelane, alleging theft of more than R700,000 by fraudulently billing Eskom when she worked for Vitrovian. Eskom is reported to have used Vitrovian, a consulting firm, to suppress protests at the Kusile Power Plant during its construction. 'Vitrovian's charges to Eskom appeared to have been severely inflated, and Eskom was allegedly invoiced by Vitrovian for work done by employees that did not exist. Simelane's signature appears on the very first of these fraudulent invoices, directly implicating her in the scandal,' Breytenbach said. The Citizen has contacted Simelane's office for comment. This will be added to the article once received. ALSO READ: DA submits PAIA request for Simelane's VBS report to Ramaphosa Claims denied In March 2025, Simelane dismissed these claims, saying she viewed them as a 'desperate attempt to draw her name in controversies for sensationalisation.' 'The office of the minister can confirm that the minister was an employee of Vitrovian in 2011 as a Project Director for seven months and was remunerated for the work she performed for the period she stayed at Vitrovian until she left. 'Notably, the minister can categorically state that she was not responsible for the contractual obligations of Vitrovian, and it is malicious to paint a picture that she might have been involved in any alleged activities or operations of price inflation as a mere employee of the company,' Simelane's office said. Cabinet reshuffle Simelane also faced serious criminal allegations for involvement in the looting of VBS Bank while she was the executive mayor of Polokwane. In December last year, Ramaphosa redeployed Simelane in a Cabinet reshuffle from the Justice and Constitutional Development cluster Ministry to Human Settlements. Swapping portfolios, Human Settlements Minister Mmamoloko Kubayi took over Simelane's spot as Justice and Constitutional Development Minister. ALSO READ: Ramaphosa owes nation explanation why Simelane still in Cabinet – Casac [VIDEO] VBS scandal Ramaphosa's decision to reshuffle Simelane came as she faced severe criticism over a R575 600 'commercial loan' she received from Gundo Wealth Solutions, a company accused of brokering unlawful investments of R349 million by the Polokwane Municipality into the now-defunct VBS Mutual Bank. Simelane used the 'commercial loan' from Gundo Wealth Solutions, owned by Ralliom Razwinane, to purchase a coffee shop in Sandton. She vehemently denied wrongdoing, asserting that she handled everything transparently and repaid the loan in full. In September 2024, Ramaphosa vowed not to sweep the allegations against Simelane, related to the VBS bank scandal, under the carpet. DA 'confident' Breytenbach said the DA is confident that the Saps will conduct a 'thorough investigation into these serious allegations'. The DA has for a long time now called for President Ramaphosa to remove Minister Thembi Simelane from the national executive, along with all ANC ministers and ANC deputy ministers, under the cloud of corruption. Breytenbach said it is time for Ramaphosa to act against 'ANC corruption'. ALSO READ: VBS Bank: 'Let us not condemn without evidence,' says Madonsela
IOL News
6 hours ago
- IOL News
Over 33,000 phones, 232kg of drugs seized in SA prisons – Groenewald declares war on corruption
Minister of Correctional Services Pieter Groenewald addresses Parliament in Cape Town, vowing to intensify raids and root out corruption inside South Africa's prisons. Image: File In a determined move to reclaim South Africa's correctional facilities from criminal networks, Minister of Correctional Services Pieter Groenewald has vowed to intensify raids and root out corruption within prisons. Delivering his Department's Budget Vote speech before the National Assembly on Tuesday, Groenewald revealed alarming figures from ongoing unannounced raids and outlined a zero-tolerance approach to illicit activities behind bars. Minister Groenewald disclosed that in the past year alone, 466 raids were conducted in correctional centres across the country, resulting in massive confiscations. 'Since July 3, 2024, various smuggled items have been found and confiscated. These include 33,874 cell phones, 20,577 sharpened objects, and a total of 122,407 items related to alcohol and other substances, 232.16 kg of drugs and R394,450.40 worth of money,' he said. Highlighting the threat posed by crime syndicates operating from inside prisons, Groenewald stressed that communities suffer when crimes are orchestrated behind bars. 'It is an evil that members of our communities, including the most vulnerable, suffer under horrendous crimes that are organised and committed from within our correctional facilities,' he said. The Minister underscored the critical importance of removing illegal items such as cellphones from prisons to prevent further crimes from being coordinated externally. 'It is therefore important that we get illegal objects, such as cellphones, out of our facilities and prevent them from landing there,' he emphasised. Raids, unannounced inspections, and disciplinary action against corrupt officials form part of Groenewald's strategy to restore order and integrity in the system. Over the past year, he reported, 515 officials received final written warnings, 181 were suspended without pay, and 146 were dismissed. 'When we fail to act against the few who betray their duty, we expose the many who serve with honour amidst grave danger,' Groenewald said. The Minister also highlighted the courage of honest officials who refuse to cooperate with gangs, often becoming targets themselves. He assured them that the Department remains committed to protecting staff who uphold the law and to 'swiftly and decisively' remove corrupt elements. Groenewald reminded Parliament and the nation of the collective mission. 'Together, we will continue to strengthen our department, affirm our constitutional commitments, and ensure that justice prevails in South Africa. Every day, we are newly afforded the opportunity to restore and build; to fix what is broken; and to render hope for a safe, peaceful and prosperous future.' As prison raids intensify, Groenewald's uncompromising stance sends a clear message. South Africa's correctional facilities will not remain safe havens for crime syndicates. Instead, they are to become true centres of rehabilitation and public safety, supporting the broader fight for a safer country. IOL News
