No one comes out of personal injury award fiasco well
But he certainly did nothing to suggest he opposed it or that he intended to blank the Judicial Council on this issue in dramatic fashion this week.
Was the plan simply to sit back and measure the scale of opposition to the proposal for five whole months? If so, what does this tell us about policymaking here? Where's the leadership?
The whole fiasco simply serves to highlight the mockery that is the process by which such a sensitive issue is addressed – a classic Irish solution to an Irish problem.
READ MORE
Following last year's Supreme Court ruling, we have the bizarre stage play of the Judicial Council conducting periodic reviews of the guidelines as provided for under the 2019 legislation it operates under.
However, its recommendations are just that. Passed to the Minister for Justice, they have no force until the minister lays them before the Oireachtas alongside a resolution to give them force of law when backed by a vote.
That way, a judiciary that can be prickly at any perceived intrusion into their realm can maintain its appearance of independence by reviewing the rules. Politicians, for their part, can largely wash their hands of responsibility by arguing that the proposals are not theirs, but the judiciary's.
Meanwhile, costs rise and Ireland's compensation culture continues largely untouched.
When the Judicial Council concedes that the outcome of this, its first review of the guidelines, amounted to little more than applying the impact of consumer price inflation over the intervening period, the circus is complete.
The process is indefensible.
It remains unclear whether the decision was of the Minister's own volition or at the behest of the Cabinet or the Coalition party leaders eager to damp down the flames of fury from industry and consumers alike over the increases that would inevitably follow – not least given his petulant pronouncement after the decision that a failure to present the 17 per cent hike might only see courts ramping up awards anyway and encourage people to bypass the Injuries Resolution Board.
The guidelines that have started to put manners on personal injury awards remain in place, complete with provisions to curb precisely those tendencies, as the Minister well knows.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Tributes paid as award-winning Irish press photographer dies in road crash
Awarding-winning press photographer Mick O'Neill has been named as the victim of a fatal road-traffic collision in north Dublin . Mr O'Neill, who worked mainly for the Irish Star and Irish Daily Mirror, was killed while riding a motorcycle close to Dublin Airport on Saturday morning. He was treated at the scene by paramedics and then taken by ambulance to the Mater hospital in Dublin where he was later pronounced dead. A Garda investigation is under way and the scene was examined by Garda forensic collision investigators. Gardaí in Santry are carrying out the inquiry and have appealed for witnesses to come forward. 'The collision, involving a motorcycle and a tractor-trailer, occurred on the Old Airport Road, Collinstown Lane, at approximately 10:50am,' the Garda said. Mr O'Neill was winner of the Press Photographers Association News Picture of the Year award in 2021 and won the Sports Picture of the Year in 2006. The 62-year-old from Swords, Co Dublin, is survived by his wife, Lorraine, and son Karl as well as his two grandchildren, Mya and Kai. He was a motorsport enthusiast who regularly travelled to the Isle of Man to watch the TT races and was also press officer for Motorcycling Ireland for two years in the 1990s. Neil Leslie, editor of the Irish Star and the Irish Daily Mirror, said all of Mr O'Neill's colleagues across the wider Reach media group were devastated at his loss. 'On behalf of Reach, I would like to extend our deepest sympathies and offer our support to his family and all his many friends and colleagues,' he said. 'Mick was a truly outstanding journalist and photographer. Moreover, he was a great friend and a wise mentor to the other journalists who worked alongside him over many years.' Mr O'Neill worked on many crime stories in Ireland and defence-related assignments abroad, often alongside Irish Daily Star crime and defence editor Michael O'Toole, who described him as 'the snapper's snapper'. He added that Mr O'Neill had a gift for dealing with people during his work. 'There was nobody who came close to him. He travelled all over Ireland and the world doing a job he loved and excelled at, one which came naturally to him,' Mr O'Toole said. 'I have never seen any media professional as gifted as Mick at talking to people, at making them feel at ease in the most stressful of situations – at connecting with them, essentially. He made the job of the reporter working with him easy.' Paul Healy, crime correspondent at the Irish Daily Star, described Mr O'Neill as a 'mentor and a friend' and someone who loved his family, with complete dedication to his work. 'He had an incredible way with people, and even though it would be me doing the interview he was often the one that had gotten the best lines out of someone. He had a keen news sense, incredible contacts, and after over 30 years in the business still had an incredible appetite to work.' Dan Linehan, Irish Examiner chief photographer and director and vice-president of Press Photographers Ireland, said Mr O'Neill was known across the industry for the standard of his work. He would also be remembered for 'his wicked sense of humour which was appreciated by all his colleagues in the media'. 'Mick would always give me a ring to inquire about a news story when coming to Cork. I met him recently while covering the Michael Gaine story in Kenmare,' Mr Linehan said. 'He was a brilliant photographer and he showed me a recent picture which I thought was the best news picture taken this year. He had great pride in his work and won a recent award at the press photographers Ireland 2025.'
RTÉ News
5 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Game Changer 'Activation Day' to take place at Croke Park
Croke Park's All-Ireland semi final crowd will be the audience for a pitch-side interview with Jason Poole, whose sister Jennifer was murdered by her former partner in 2021, as part of a GAA initiative. This GAA first is part of the collaborative 'Game Changer' initiative which aims to challenge the social norms that contribute to domestic, sexual and gender-based violence, and highlight how male allyship and positive role modelling can help. The interview will be transmitted on the stadium's screens at half time, as Donegal and Meath go head-to-head, vying for a place at the All-Ireland Football Final. It is one of a number of 'Game Changer' events taking place as part of today's Senior semi final and Junior Championship Final in Croke Park. Donegal footballer Oisín Gallen, who will be playing in today's semi final is also a Game Changer ambassador and he will feature in a video that will also be played on the stadium's screens throughout the day. "There's incredible encouragement in the GAA on the pitch to back up your teammate and to leave no man behind," Mr Gallen said. "That should be the same when you're calling out gender-based violence. If it was racism or if it was any other type of abuse, I'm sure there'd be a lot of people who'd be standing up to call out what's wrong, so it shouldn't be any different when it comes to gender-based violence." The Game Changer initiative is being done by the GAA, in partnership with Ruhama, an organisation that supports women who have been sexually exploited and White Ribbon Ireland, which encourages men and boys to act against domestic, sexual and gender-based violence. It is also supported by the Ladies Gaelic Football Association (LGFA) and the Camogie Association. The initiative started in November 2024, but today has been billed as Game Changer Activation Day, with the series of events at Croke Park taking place, while a new website will also go live. A nationwide advertising campaign will begin tomorrow. Jason Poole's sister Jennifer was 24 when she was murdered by her former partner Gavin Murphy in 2021. She was a mother of two. Mr Murphy had a history of violence against women and was previously jailed for two years for attacking a former partner and her mother with a knife in 2015. Mr Poole and his family have campaigned for a number of years for the establishment of a domestic violence register. Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan has committed to enacting legislation in Jennifer Poole's name, Jennie's Law, that would establish such a register.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Tramore community rally around Albanian family facing deportation
Dozens of parents and children gathered under the hot July sunshine on Saturday morning in the seaside town of Tramore calling on the Minister for Justice not to deport an Albanian family and to grant them permission to remain on humanitarian grounds . Students from Tramore Educate Together national school, including classmates of Luna, the six-year-old daughter of the family, took part in the rally outside Ocean View Guest House, where the family has lived since they moved to Co Waterford in 2022. The family has been told they must return to Albania by the end of August or they will be removed from the State. Participants in Saturday's rally chanted 'deportation no way, we want our friends to stay' and held up posters with messages including 'trá mór, grá mór' and 'our friends belong here'. 'The fact that we're rallying support around a six-year-old is horrendous,' said parent and organiser Aoife O'Driscoll. 'Our kids are sitting around making posters to stop her being taken away. It's lovely but it's awful.' READ MORE Ms O'Driscoll launched a campaign for the family last week after discovering her child's classmate had received a deportation notice. Nearly all the parents in the 180-pupil school have since offered their support for the family, says Ms O'Driscoll. 'Luna's entire life is in Tramore, her friends are in Tramore. We saw her running out of school recently with Réalt na Seachtaine for the best Irish that week. She doesn't know any of this is happening.' Luna's mother, who requested not to be named, says the family was 'forced to leave' Albania in 2022 because of threats to their safety. They were particularly concerned for their daughter due to the risk of child trafficking, she said. 'We heard Ireland was safe and it was very far from Albania. I was sure that person looking for us would not find our family here,' she said. 'No one wants to talk badly about their country of origin but Albania is not safe.' Albania is one of 15 jurisdictions designated as safe countries of origin by the State for the purposes of international protection applications. The family spent a few months in the Balseskin accommodation centre in Finglas, Dublin, before being transferred to Tramore in late 2022. Parents and students from Tramore Educate Together National School on calling on Saturday for an Albanian family not to be deported. Photograph: Aoife O'Driscoll They were refused permission to remain and were notified in April they had to leave Ireland by May 17th, 2025. They secured an extension until the end of August because Luna's younger brother, who was born in Ireland with complex medical needs and underwent surgery earlier this year, had a hospital appointment in July. The mother, who worked as an English-language teacher in Albania, works as a cleaner and her husband is in construction. The suspense of not knowing what will happen to her children 'is killing me', she says. 'I'm trying to be strong but there are days I feel I cannot breathe, you feel your time is ending. Sometimes I just want to give up but I have to go on for my children. It's not their fault that we had problems and were forced to leave Albania.' The Tramore Educate Together parents association contacted the Department of Justice on July 1st, saying its decision to deport the family 'knowingly put a child's life at risk'. The two-year-old 'requires complex care that will simply not be available to him should this family be deported', read the letter. The family have 'built a life' in Tramore and deporting them will 'inflict irreparable trauma on each of them', it said. An petition , signed by more than 500 people, calls on the Government to treat the family's situation with 'the nuanced, discerning approach that is required when human lives are at stake'. A Department of Justice spokesman said officials 'aim to process families in a holistic manner' but 'a child's immigration case is highly dependent on the status of their parents'. He added: 'Each child's circumstances are examined in detail before a deportation order is made and voluntary return is offered.' If families do not engage with gardaí and leave the State within a prescribed time frame, 'they can be arrested and detained in order to make the arrangements for their deportation,' he said, adding that 'children are never detained'. Enforced removals of children are only carried out 'as a measure of last resort when the family concerned has not removed themselves from the State as they are legally required to'. Some 106 people have been deported from Ireland on chartered flights so far this year, while 69 were removed on commercial airlines and another 30 people left unescorted. These included 106 Georgians, 36 Nigerians, 18 Brazilians, seven Algerians and five Albanians, according to Government data. Thirteen of those deported so far this year were children. Last week, Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan said he had no plans to cease the deportation of children. 'Any such policy would make Ireland an outlier in Europe and could encourage more people to come here with children, knowing that they could not be removed regardless of the outcome of their case,' he told the Dáil.
