logo
Man's Nazi salute conviction overturned after claim he was copying Ricky Gervais

Man's Nazi salute conviction overturned after claim he was copying Ricky Gervais

News.com.au13-06-2025
A man who argued he was merely copying a performance by comedian Ricky Gervais when he performed a Nazi salute outside a Jewish museum has won his bid to overturn the conviction.
Ryan Marshall, Anthony Mitchell and Daniel Muston were last October convicted of performing a Nazi salute outside the Sydney Jewish Museum in October of 2023.
The trio, working nearby the museum, were on their way back to their work van when they performed Nazi salutes and a goose step one after the other.
Marshall, Muston and Mr Mitchell were each convicted and handed down respective fines of $1500, $1000 and $500.
All three men appealed their convictions in Sydney's District Court on Friday, the group arguing their actions couldn't be constituted or characterised as a Nazi symbol under the public act.
'Put differently, the issue is whether as a matter of statutory construction the gesture is capable of amounting to a Nazi symbol,' Judge Craig Smith SC told the court on Friday morning.
However, the prosecution argued there was 'no basis and it was artificial to limit the definition of a symbol to a tangible object'.
Mr Mitchell's lawyer's further argued their client was repeating, reciting or mimicking part of a performance by popular English comedian Ricky Gervais.
They argued Mr Mitchell's intent was not subjectively malicious.
'It was submitted that if Mr Gervais' performance was artistic, and the appellant was copying the artistic performance, that what the appellant did (had artistic purpose),' Judge Smith said.
The prosecution submitted Mr Gervais' performance was before an audience, in a theatre, and had a particular context, while what Mr Mitchell did was not reasonable or in good faith as part of an artistic performance.
Therefore, there was no reasonable excuse for his actions.
Turning to Mr Mitchell's argument of artistic expression, Judge Smith said a Nazi symbol during a lecture might reasonably be seen as for academic purposes and similarly during a performance for artistic purposes.
'What (Mitchell) did was not an expression of artistic purpose, it was repeating the expression of someone else's arguably artistic purpose,' Judge Smith said.
'The facts and circumstances here are a good distance from that which is excusable.
'I respectfully fail to see how … what he did could possibly be characterised as being done for an artistic purpose.'
Judge Smith initially dismissed each of the men's appeals; however, he was later 'persuaded' to overturn Mitchell's.
Lawyers on behalf of Mr Mitchell and Muston challenged the severity of their sentences after Judge Smith ruled to throw out their appeals, with Mitchell's lawyer arguing his client was simply copying Mr Gervais' skit and had no ties or intent related to the Nazi party.
The court was also told Mr Mitchell didn't know he was outside the Sydney Jewish Museum at the time while Muston did.
'The conduct occurred over one second…it was really one second,' Mr Mitchell's lawyer told the court.
'It was definitely not intended to be seen by anyone other than the co-offenders. Importantly, the conduct was not viewed by any member of the public…it was viewed by someone from the museum who was looking at a screen.
'My submission is that the conduct of Mr Mitchell falls at the very bottom of the range in objective seriousness.'
Judge Smith told the court that he was 'persuaded' to a different position in respect of Mr Mitchell, allowing the appeal and thus quashing his conviction.
Muston's lawyer, Bryan Wrench, argued his client had no Nazi ideology, had expressed regret, and that he'd participated in a tour at the Jewish museum which made him appreciate the seriousness of the actions.
Judge Smith didn't consider it appropriate to overturn Muston's conviction; however, he did reduce his fine from $1000 to $500, calling the initial figure 'excessive'.
No severity appeal was entered on Marshall's behalf.
Judge Smith emphasised the offences were to be taken 'very seriously' by courts.
'The display of Nazi symbols will not be tolerated and will be dealt with sternly by the courts,' Judge Smith said.
Marshall had a cigarette hanging outside his mouth as he walked outside the Downing Centre on Friday, pausing for a moment to pose for the cameras after his win.
Asked how he was feeling, he told reporters 'it is what it is', telling them to 'have a good day'.
The court was earlier told there didn't appear to be any hateful ideology behind the men's' actions.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Restless Dance Theatre takes the arts to the end of a hospital bed with The Lensical
Restless Dance Theatre takes the arts to the end of a hospital bed with The Lensical

ABC News

time23 minutes ago

  • ABC News

Restless Dance Theatre takes the arts to the end of a hospital bed with The Lensical

Inside a hospital room at the Adelaide Women's and Children's Hospital, the lights are dimmed and voices gentle. A small, smiling figure is tucked in white sheets in a bed at the centre of the room, his parents in chairs by his side. In the low light, the boy's eyes are bright and open wide, watching intently as dancers in white boilersuits quietly enter the room. They bring with them a very curious structure. It's large and about a metre-and-a-half long. There's a face-sized hole at one end, extending out into an octagonal shape at the other — and it's designed to hover over the hospital bed. For the patient, the device blocks from sight the hospital setting, and headphones playing music replace the sound of whirring medical machines. And so the unconventional stage is set for a first-of-its-kind performance, especially designed for long-term patients in hospital. This performance, and the device, is called The Lensical. And it's been years in the making. "The work is about delivering a unique, special experience to people who may not otherwise be able to experience that at that time," choreographer Michelle Heaven says. The work aims to create "something magical" that can shift the space for a patient, "even if it is just for a short period". Bhodi Hudson, a dancer in the performance, describes the Lensical object as like "a road cone or a megaphone, but it's on its side ... and you're looking through it". "It is essentially a ginormous cone where the patient in a hospital bed gets to view it," he says. "It's like a personal viewing experience, like you're watching something on a screen but it's there in reality. It's oddly very surreal yet fascinating when you're seeing it first hand." For around four minutes, performers from Restless Dance Theatre, an acclaimed company made up of dancers with and without disabilities, move in and out of this frame, performing enchanting choreography. In response, the small boy becomes animated, doing wiggly, dancing movements as he sits up in his bed looking through the giant lens. The innovative Lensical concept was devised by Heaven in collaboration with her partner, theatre designer Ben Cobham. They've made a lot of theatre together over the years, and Cobham himself was a long-term patient in hospital when he was a kid. "We [wanted] to do something for kids that are like he was when he was little," Heaven says. "He spent close to a year in hospital and one of the things that brought him relief was to watch the fish in the fish tank, their organic movements. "This was also pre-screens and phones that are very prevalent now, which also provide a form of escape, but we [were] wanting to offer a human interaction and not always be so reliant on screens for distraction … to be immersed in something that's really directly shared between people." They arrived at the idea of a performance located at the end of a patient's bed that could "change the environment for them momentarily". Many stages of development and testing followed until the pair arrived at the uplifting and immersive Lensical project. Initial trials took place at the Royal Children's Hospital in Melbourne, where they learnt about hospital codes and infection control. They did additional trials at Adelaide's Flinders Medical Centre and Women's and Children's Hospital, refining the work to both evoke delight and meet strict hospital protocols. And the choreography came with specific constraints too: the piece needed to be able to be performed in the very narrow space at the end of a hospital bed. "There's not a lot of room and we need to be mindful of staff needing to get past to attend to other patients … so it's a very different environment to consider," Heaven says. "There's a lot of different needs here, and … we really try and gently navigate that and be very respectful of it." Hudson, who is autistic, is used to shows on a stage, and describes performing in the restricted space as "tricky". "You may be a little bit squeezed in … You have to make sure you're at the right tempo all the while making sure you're not smacking your partner in the face. You may also give way to other people who need to get [through]." But the contorting effort is worth it for Hudson, who says the work is "funky … not smelly, [but] fun funky". In the sequence he performs with fellow Restless dancer Sidney Debba, the pair hold cloths and perform choreography based around pretending to clean an invisible window at the end of the Lensical. "It's like a fantasy sequence in a film where someone just dances to music [doing] the most mundane thing, like someone dancing with a broom like it's a partner," Hudson says. Dancers perform two short works, Heaven explains. "One is quite light and fun and literally makes particularly the younger ones giggle … That's really magical. And the other work is quite transporting, you are immersed in something; it's quite special. "We might just bring the hands in for a moment, or something else might come into frame you might not expect … It's very non-threatening and brings your attention to detail and creates a human connection." Across four days at two different hospitals, the troupe moves quietly through different wards, the Lensical rolling into the rooms of patients who are keen to see the visiting spectacle. Heaven says seeing the work properly performed for the first time, as part of Adelaide's DreamBIG Children's Festival, has been a moving experience. At Adelaide Women's and Children's Hospital and Flinders Medical Centre, they performed the short dances to audiences of a wide range of ages, from children between two and 18 years old through to their families — and even staff. "It [was] a moment of relief, like a little reset, people have used that word … and then [they] go on to do what else they have to do that day." Heaven says the main response among patients has been a feeling of calm joy. She's seen some patients moved to tears, "but in a joyful release".

Hip hop heroes Hilltop Hoods announce comeback to Australian arenas in February and March
Hip hop heroes Hilltop Hoods announce comeback to Australian arenas in February and March

News.com.au

timean hour ago

  • News.com.au

Hip hop heroes Hilltop Hoods announce comeback to Australian arenas in February and March

Australian hip hop heroes Hilltop Hoods will make their long-awaited return to the country's biggest stages in February and March next year. The Never Coming Home tour is the latest in a flurry of activity from the award-winning group who next month release Fall From The Light, the first new studio record in six years. The hip hop trailblazers were deluged with 'what about Australia?' comments on social media channels last week from loyal fans when they revealed UK and European tour dates for August ahead of a hometown run. 'Oh, we have heard (all) about it in the comments section which is fine, I understand it – I feel the same with bands that I like,' Suffa said about the protests from local fans. 'It's just the way that it worked out with the physics, the Northern Hemisphere summer, the rotation around the sun and the Gregorian calendar; it's nothing personal.' Suffa, Pressure and DJ Debris will kick off the tour at the MyState Bank Arena in Hobart on February 14 and then head to the Adelaide Entertainment Centre on February 21, Sydney's Qudos Bank Arena on February 28, Melbourne's Rod Laver Arena on March 7, Brisbane Entertainment Centre on March 14 and RAC Arena, Perth on March 21. The hip hop group is one of the biggest Aussie artists of all time, with more than 1.3 billion streams on Spotify alone and one million records sold over the past two decades. They hold the record for the most tickets sold by an Australian artist at Qudos Bank Arena, with more than 15,000 fans rocking the foundations of the venue during the Great Expanse tour in 2019. Suffa said 'a lot happened' to force the long break between albums and tours, although they have kept the fan fires burning with a succession of singles including So Good?, Show Business and Laced Up. 'I had two young children and a cavoodle, so I had my hands full. And Dan had a young lass as well just before lockdowns. We had young families, Covid happened and a bunch of false starts,' Suffa said. 'It sucked at the time, but I think like as far as the album goes, it was good for it in the long run because we shed a lot of the fat.' Hoods fans were recently shocked by the group's video for their recent single Don't Happy, Be Worry – because it featured Suffa with hair for the first time in his career. And no, he hasn't had a transplant – he just always hid under a cap. 'That's my real head! That's the only film clip I've ever done without a hat and the amount of people that have said to me, 'I thought you were bald!' I just wear a hat which means I constantly have hat hair,' Suffa said. The Hoods will release the new single Never Coming Home, featuring SIX60, on Friday and tickets for the tour go on sale on July 17 from 10am via

'I want people to sip something distinctly Filipino': How Pinoy Liquido Maestro pours pride, culture, and native ingredients into every bottle
'I want people to sip something distinctly Filipino': How Pinoy Liquido Maestro pours pride, culture, and native ingredients into every bottle

SBS Australia

time8 hours ago

  • SBS Australia

'I want people to sip something distinctly Filipino': How Pinoy Liquido Maestro pours pride, culture, and native ingredients into every bottle

Demetrio is a visionary mixologist and the creative force behind Destileria Barako, the Filipino craft distillery known for bold, proudly local spirits like Ube Cream Liqueur, Kanto, and Agimat. As a passionate advocate of the Slow Food Movement in the Philippines, he works closely with communities to rediscover and celebrate native botanicals, foraged herbs, and forgotten flavours. While visiting Australia, he shared his curiosity for local bush tucker and Indigenous fruits — hoping to find common ground between Filipino and Australian native ingredients. The Philippines is home to a treasure trove of native botanicals, many of which remain unknown to the world. But a growing movement led by artisans like Kalel Demetrio, also known as the Liquido Maestro, is changing that. Kalel Demetrio distilling Lambanog in Quezon Province. Source: Supplied From sampaguita to ylang-ylang, from wild ginger to rare citrus, Kalel brings forgotten local ingredients to the global stage, one cocktail at a time. Rooted in heritage and driven by innovation, Kalel Demetrio and Siggy Bacani are are working in parallel to make Filipino flavours part of the global palate, and the global conversation. Source: Supplied Dive deep into the world of Philippine craft spirits with Kalel Demetrio and Siggy Bacani. Listen to the podcast for the full conversation. 📢 Where to Catch SBS Filipino

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store