Fewer than 1 in 5 people noticed suspicious items during MHA's social experiments
Over a few hours in the afternoon and evening, the car was left in a public place to test the public's response to terror incidents.
SINGAPORE – More than 2,500 people in Tampines and Bishan walked past a black suitcase and a black car with a concealed number plate, but fewer than 500 of them noticed the suspicious objects.
Even fewer of them either intended to or actually did alert the authorities to the items – just 26.
Over a few hours during lunch and dinner, the suitcase and car were left in public places to test the public's response to terror incidents. The social experiments were
conducted by the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) on June 10 and 13, respectively.
Noting the results of the social experiments, Minister for Home Affairs K. Shanmugam said: 'How do we explain this reaction? The reality is, Singapore is a safe place, probably one of the safest cities of our size.
'For decades it has been like that, so very few people think in terms of crime or terror. That explains the awareness of threats.
'The level of safety we have is good, but it brings huge challenges when we want to educate the public to say 'it's not a question of if, but when'. It will happen at some point, and we need to be prepared.'
He was speaking on July 30 at the launch of MHA's web series, What Would You Do When Terror Strikes, which features footage from the social experiments.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore MHA to support HSA's crackdown on Kpod abusers and help in treatment of offenders: Shanmugam
Business S'pore's economic resilience will face headwinds in second half of 2025 from tariffs, trade conflicts: MAS
Business S'pore's Q2 total employment rises, but infocomm and professional services sectors see more job cuts
Asia Powerful 8.8-magnitude quake in Russia's far east causes tsunami; Japan, Hawaii order evacuations
Singapore Migrant workers who gave kickbacks to renew work passes were conservancy workers at AMK Town Council
Asia Japan, Vietnam, EU contest terms of US tariff deals behind the scenes
Singapore Escape, discover, connect: Where new memories are made
The suitcase contained a dummy improvised explosive device and was left next to a potted plant at Our Tampines Hub.
A red blinking light was later attached to the suitcase before it was placed by a pillar in front of a convenience store.
In the car-bomb simulation, the car, containing multiple gas cylinders, was parked near Bishan Community Club in the afternoon.
In the evening, more gas cylinders were added to the car boot, and the vehicle emitted smoke periodically.
Despite the escalation in both experiments, only 438 out of 2,530 passers-by noticed the suspicious items, and 26 of them either intended to, or did, inform the authorities.
MHA said the results of the social experiments differed from those of the 2024 SGSecure public perception survey, where 77 per cent of participants claimed they were generally alert and kept a lookout for suspicious activity and behaviour in public.
Telltale signs included oily stains near the zippers, bulges to indicate a high payload of explosives, and an actor who dropped the suitcase off before hurriedly moving away.
PHOTO: MHA
In the same survey, 88 per cent of respondents said they would alert the authorities if they spotted suspicious behaviour or items.
Senior Minister of State for Home Affairs Sim Ann, who also attended the launch event at The Projector at Cineleisure, said: 'This shows that we still have some way to go in raising the public's alertness and awareness and their readiness to combat terrorism.'
Mr Shanmugam, who is also Coordinating Minister for National Security, said the web series is an effort to increase public awareness about SGSecure messages like 'Run, Hide, Tell' and 'Press, Tie, Tell'.
SGSecure is a national movement launched in 2016 to prepare Singaporeans to deal with terrorist attacks and equip them with skills to handle a crisis.
The first of the three-episode series, which was released on MHA's YouTube channel on July 30, features eight local influencers responding to a simulated terror attack.
The other two episodes will be released on Aug 13 and 27, and will feature footage from the social experiments conducted in June.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
13 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Bangladesh grapples with fraught politics a year after former PM Hasina fled
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox FILE PHOTO: A protester vandalises a mural of Bangladeshi Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina with paint, demanding her resignation at Teacher Student Center (TSC) area of University of Dhaka in Dhaka, August 3, 2024. REUTERS/Mohammad Ponir Hossain/File Photo DHAKA - Bangladesh marks on Tuesday a year since long-serving former Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina fled the South Asian Islamic nation following student-led protests, but it is still grappling with instability. Here are key tasks ahead for the country of 173 million governed by the interim administration of Nobel peace laureate Muhammad Yunus. DEADLY JULY PROTESTS Led by the 'Students Against Discrimination' group, they initially targeted a quota system in public sector jobs but escalated into deadly unrest as protesters, demanding Hasina's resignation, clashed with security forces and supporters of her Awami League party. Protesters blamed the government for a crackdown that killed hundreds and injured thousands with unrest peaking on August 5 when Hasina was forced to flee to neighbouring India just before protesters stormed her official residence. YUNUS TAKES CHARGE An interim government was formed and tasked with restoring stability and preparing for parliamentary elections. Yunus, 85, took charge as de facto prime minister. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore 'She had a whole life ahead of her': Boyfriend mourns Yishun fatal crash victim World Israel to decide next steps in Gaza after ceasefire talks collapse Singapore Singapore-made bot matchmakes strangers virtually – without profile photos Life Urinary issues: Enlarged prostate affects half of men in their 50s and up Singapore Jail for man over scheme to buy phones worth more than $45k with stolen credit card details Singapore Conditional warning for ex-manager at Mendaki accused of trying to obtain laptop as bribe It promised sweeping institutional reforms but progress has been slow and fragmented, despite broad consensus on key reforms such as restoring a non-partisan caretaker government to oversee elections, depoliticising state institutions and overhauling the Election Commission. But deeper reforms have stalled in the face of sharp disagreements with political parties over proposals for constitutional change, judicial reform and introduction of a bicameral parliament. Political analysts point to a widening gap between public expectations and outcomes. ELECTION, INCLUSION AND CONTENTION Yunus' government is caught between the need for reform and pressure for early elections, its biggest challenge. Yunus has suggested February 2026 as a possible date after the Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) of former Prime Minister Khaleda Zia called for a December 2025 deadline. Further strain has been added by the controversy over the exclusion of Hasina's Awami League party, after its registration was suspended, effectively barring it from contesting. Many want it to participate, despite its top leadership being prosecuted for alleged violations of human rights during the protests. Without broad political inclusion, the legitimacy of a vote could be suspect. The newly formed National Citizen Party (NCP), born out of the 2024 protests, is viewed by critics as being favoured by Yunus' administration, which the government denies. But the suspicion could also cloud the credibility of the vote. CHANGED POLITICAL CULTURE, BUT FRAGILE GAINS Law enforcement remains a challenge, though analysts say freedom of expression has expanded since Hasina's exit while suspected forced disappearances during her tenure appear to have stopped. Political violence, mob attacks and harassment of journalists and minorities, especially women, are regularly reported. Mob violence claimed at least 199 lives between August 2024 and July 2025, says rights group Ain o Salish Kendra. New York-based Human Rights Watch warns that while some authoritarian practices have ended, the interim government has adopted troubling tactics of its own. Among these arbitrary detentions, mass arrests, and politically motivated prosecutions mostly targeted at supporters of Hasina's party, the group said. Torture in custody and use of the Special Powers Act continue, mirroring repressive tactics of the past, HRW said. The government denies the charges. JULY DECLARATION A charter, called the 'July Declaration' after last year's uprising, is set to be unveiled on Tuesday, laying out a roadmap for democratic reforms. Drafted by the government in consultation with political and student leaders, it aims to commit to electoral reform, constitutional changes, and institutional accountability. It is seen as both a symbolic tribute and a strategic blueprint for Bangladesh's political transition. But critics warn it could remain merely symbolic without legal safeguards and broad parliamentary consensus to help drive major change. REUTERS
Straits Times
13 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Jail for man over scheme to buy phones worth more than $45k with stolen credit card details
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Ding Jiun Hao had pleaded guilty to two counts of engaging in a conspiracy to commit cheating, and one count of removing the benefits of criminal conduct out of Singapore. SINGAPORE - A Malaysian driver has been jailed over his involvement with a group that came to Singapore to buy 23 phones by using stolen credit card details . Most of the devices , which were worth over $45,000 in total, were later resold in Malaysia for profit . Ding Jiun Hao, 26, was sentenced to two years' jail on Aug 5. He had pleaded guilty to two counts of engaging in a conspiracy to commit cheating, and one count of removing the benefits of criminal conduct out of Singapore. His childhood friend, Tang Chin Huat, then 27, who is also a Malaysian, was sentenced to a year and 11 months' jail in June. A third man, identified as Liau Wei Zheng , is still at large and is believed to be in Malaysia. Deputy Public Prosecutor Ronnie Ang said that the police are making efforts to locate and apprehend him. Court documents stated that Tang and Ding worked as drivers, ferrying passengers between Malaysia and Singapore. In early November 2024, Liau asked Ding if he wanted to earn some extra money. Liau also told him that an unknown person, known only as 'Boss', would give him credit cards belonging to other people to buy 'as many iPhones as possible' in Singapore, for resale in Malaysia. The court heard that third parties had stolen details linked to these cards. Such details were later stored in Liau's electronic wallet. 'Boss' had promised Liau RM500 (S$151) for every phone they sold, and Liau offered to share the profits with Ding, who agreed to take part in the scheme . As they needed a car to travel to and around Singapore, Ding asked Liau to rope in Tang, who owned one. Liau then contacted Tang, who also agreed to be part of the scheme. As part of the plan, Liau would receive 50 per cent of the profits, while the other two men would receive 25 per cent each. On Nov 8, 2024, the three men travelled to Singapore in Tang's car to visit four mobile phone shops at places including Orchard Road and Geylang. They decided to leave Singapore after they bought 13 phones at an Orchard Road shop and one of its employees sensed that something was amiss due to this large purchase. DPP Ang said: '(The employee) held back five phones and requested passport verification from Liau before releasing the phones. 'Liau and Ding went back to the car and left without those five phones as Liau wanted to return to Malaysia as soon as possible.' The three men went back to Malaysia with the 18 remaining iPhones, worth more than $39,700 in total, and Liau later sold the devices. He then gave Ding and Tang RM2,250 each. Ding was arrested when he re-entered Singapore on Nov 10, 2024, to ferry passengers. He was remanded before he was released on bail 16 days later. He has made no restitution. Tang, who found out from newspaper reports that he was a wanted man, returned to Singapore on Nov 24, 2024, and surrendered himself to the authorities. He has made restitution of $2,000. On Aug 5, defence lawyer Clarence Lun pleaded for Ding to be given a year and four months' jail. The lawyer from Fervent Chambers added: 'He was not the mastermind, organiser, or initiator of the conspiracy. Rather, the offences were orchestrated primarily by Liau... who remains at large.' Mr Lun also said that Ding had come from a very poor family, and had 'acted out of naiveté and misguided trust' after Liau persuaded him.
Straits Times
13 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Chinese government has 'final say' in Dalai Lama reincarnation, Tibetan official says
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox FILE PHOTO: Tibetan spiritual leader, the 14th Dalai Lama, is served food on his 90th birthday celebration at the Tsuglagkhang, also known as the Dalai Lama Temple complex, in the northern town of Dharamshala, India, July 6, 2025. REUTERS/Anushree Fadnavis/File Photo BEIJING - The discovery of the next Dalai Lama will be carried out by the Chinese government, and not under the current Dalai Lama's directions, a Chinese Communist Party committee official for Tibet said on Tuesday. China considers the Nobel laureate Dalai Lama a separatist and wants to bring Tibetan Buddhism under its control, but the Dalai Lama and his huge following have been obstacles to that ambition. At his 90th birthday celebration last month, he assured followers that he would be reincarnated, and a non-profit institution he has set up will have the sole authority to identify his reincarnation. But Gama Cedain, the deputy secretary of the Chinese Communist Party committee in Tibet, said the Dalai Lama's reincarnation would be found using a domestic search and approval by the central government. "The central government has the indisputable final say in the reincarnation of the Dalai Lama," he told reporters at a press conference about the socioeconomic development in Tibet. He said that was the creed devotees adhered to, and the government's process follows the strict religious rituals and historical customs of the reincarnation of living Buddhas. "The reincarnation has never been decided by the Dalai Lama himself," he said. The current Dalai Lama, 14th in the line of spiritual leaders for Tibetan Buddhism, has said his reincarnation will be born outside China and ruled out Beijing's role in choosing his successor. China installed a Tibetan Buddhist monk picked by Beijing as the faith's No. 2 leader, the Panchen Lama, three decades ago after a six-year-old chosen by the Dalai Lama for the position disappeared in 1995. REUTERS
