logo
An unnecessary overreach

An unnecessary overreach

EDITORIAL: In a move signaling urgency, President Asif Ali Zardari on Sunday promulgated an ordinance granting the federal government the authority to elevate the Frontier Constabulary (FC) to the status of a federal force. The FC, which has long been deployed in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa's (KP's) former tribal areas and the troubled border regions of Balochistan – regions plagued by insurgencies, terrorism, and tribal conflicts – has already functioned as a federal paramilitary force under the control of the Ministry of Interior.
However, its role was largely confined to localized operations within these specific regions. What is different now is that the government has expanded the FC's jurisdiction, establishing a new Federal Reserve Force under its command with responsibilities for anti-riot and special protection duties.
This new structure will be granted powers as outlined in the Code of Criminal Procedure, the Anti-Terrorism Act, the Police Order, and any other applicable laws. Furthermore, the ordinance empowers the federal government to confer upon any FC member the powers of a police officer, of any class or grade, as per the laws in force at the time.
Ostensibly, this move is a response to growing national security concerns. However, the decision to elevate the FC to a federal force and deploy it nationwide raises questions about the underlying rationale, particularly given its potential overlap with other paramilitary forces.
The Rangers, for instance, already operate in various parts of the country, particularly urban centers like Karachi, where they have played a key role in counterterrorism and controlling civil unrest. The necessity of expanding the FC's role, therefore, is questionable.
Its current deployment in the border regions of Baluchistan and the tribal districts of KP is justified by the unique security challenges these regions face, such as cross-border militancy, insurgency, and ethnic tensions. These challenges do not exist in other provinces – at least not at the same level of intensity.
The police are quite capable of handling civil disturbances and riots. Additionally, there already are a range of law enforcement agencies, including the Rangers, and even the military in certain situations. The involvement of army officers in the leadership of the FC's new Federal Reserve Force raises further concerns.
This suggests a more militarised approach to policing, which could undermine civilian authority and exacerbate tensions between law enforcement agencies and the public. In non-conflict areas, such a heavy-handed approach would not only be unnecessary but could also lead to potential abuses of power, eroding what little trust remains between citizens and the government.
Ultimately, the decision to deploy the FC across the entire country risks creating more problems than it aims to resolve. The focus should instead be on improving the efficiency of existing law enforcement agencies, enhancing inter-agency cooperation, and ensuring that the right force is deployed in the right context. Overwhelming the country with multiple paramilitary forces will create challenges that may undermine the very security these forces are intended to protect.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Nishan-i-Imtiaz conferred on Saudi naval chief
Nishan-i-Imtiaz conferred on Saudi naval chief

Express Tribune

time11 hours ago

  • Express Tribune

Nishan-i-Imtiaz conferred on Saudi naval chief

President Asif Ali Zardari on Monday conferred Nishan-i-Imtiaz (Military) on Saudi Naval Chief Vice Admiral, Mohammad Bin Abdul Rehman Al-Ghoraibi in recognition of his outstanding efforts to strengthen naval and defence cooperation between the two countries. The award was conferred at a special investiture ceremony held at the Aiwan-e-Sadr which was attended by Chief of the Naval Staff Admiral Naveed Ashraf, Ambassador of Saudi Arabia to Pakistan, Nawaf Bin Saeed Al Malki, and senior officers from the armed forces. His contributions to enhancing joint naval exercises, training exchanges, and strategic maritime dialogue have greatly deepened the bilateral ties.

Pakistan offers Kabul to jointly fight terror
Pakistan offers Kabul to jointly fight terror

Express Tribune

timea day ago

  • Express Tribune

Pakistan offers Kabul to jointly fight terror

Listen to article Pakistan offered the Afghan interim government to jointly fight terrorist groups, which are causing unrest and instability, as Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi held crucial talks with Taliban authorities in a daylong visit to Kabul on Sunday. Naqvi is the latest high-ranking Pakistani minister to travel to the neighbouring country as part of a renewed push to reset ties and address the issue of cross border terrorism. The interior minister's visit came on the heels of Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar's trip to Kabul a few days ago. Naqvi, who was accompanied by special representative for Afghanistan Ambassador Muhammad Sadiq Khan and Interior Secretary Khurram Agha, met with Afghan Interim Interior Minister Sirajuddin Haqqni. The talks, according to officials, focused on the issue of terrorism, border management and repatriation of Afghan refugees. But the issue of presence of banned Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) and other anti-Pakistan groups in Afghanistan was on top of the agenda. Sources said that Naqvi delivered a clear message that Pakistan considers Afghanistan as its "brotherly neighbouring" country but highlighted the activities of terrorist groups as major obstacle in the bilateral ties. "Terrorist organisations are causing unrest and instability, we must jointly stop them," Naqvi was quoted as saying by his office after his meeting with the head of Haqqani Network. An interior ministry handout said the two sides discussed bilateral relations, particularly focusing on counterterrorism, cross-border infiltration, and the banned TTP. The talks were also held on effective management of the Pakistan-Afghanistan border, prevention of drug trafficking, and regulating cross-border movement. The repatriation process of Afghan nationals, illegally residing in Pakistan, also came under discussion. Both interior ministers emphasised the need for peaceful coexistence, stability, and enhanced cooperation between Pakistan and Afghanistan. They agreed to strengthen mutual collaboration to improve border management and eliminate the menace of terrorism. "Pakistan desires fraternal and long-lasting relations with Afghanistan. For decades, Pakistan has hosted millions of Afghan refugees selflessly, and the doors remain open for Afghan citizens to enter Pakistan legally," Naqvi said. Relations between Pakistan and Afghanistan have remained stalled for many months before the two sides made a fresh attempt to sort out their differences. Dar's visit to Kabul in April led to greater engagement between the two neighbours. The Afghan government, according to sources, took certain steps to control the TTP. Some measures including a crackdown on Afghans, who were joining the TTP. Those steps helped build some trust between the two countries. Officials, however, cautioned that the Afghan side will have to demonstrate a lot more commitment to completely eradicate the threat emanating from the neighbouring country. Meanwhile, high-level exchanges between the two countries will continue as Afghan Interim Foreign Minister Amir Khan Muttaqi is expected to travel to Islamabad soon.

Four terrorists killed in Kalat IBO
Four terrorists killed in Kalat IBO

Express Tribune

timea day ago

  • Express Tribune

Four terrorists killed in Kalat IBO

Elsewhere, the spokesperson said the FC personnel seized a local leader of the banned BLA in the Sheikhri area of Kalat. PHOTO: EXPRESS Listen to article Security forces killed four terrorists belonging to an outlawed separatist group during an intelligence based operation (IBO) in Kalat district on the night between Saturday and Sunday. The operation was carried out in the Pahrod area of the district on the basis of reports regarding the presence of terrorists. According to an official statement, troops effectively took position near the hideout of the terrorists, who were neutralized after an intense exchange of fire. The forces also seized a large cache of arms, ammunition and explosive material from the hideout. A sanitization and clearance operation was underway in the area. The operation took place days after terrorists opened fire on a Karachi-bound passenger bus in Kalat, killing at least three and injuring seven others. In another attack on July 11, terrorists abducted and executed nine passengers after removing them from buses in Loralai district. President Asif Ali Zardari, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and Balochistan Chief Minister Mir Safraz Bugti congratulated the security forces for the successful operation in separate messages. The president noted that the state is determined to eradicate terrorists at all costs with the support of the nation. "The state will continue to take action against terrorism with full force. The terrorists of Fitna-tul-Hindustan will be pursued till the end," Zardari added. Terrorists belonging to banned separatist organizations are also referred to Fitna-tul-Hindustan due to their links with India. In a separate message, Prime Minister Shehbaz said that the entire nation stands with the security forces in the war against terrorism. "The government is firm in its drive to eradicate all forms of terrorism from the country," he added. Balochistan Chief Minister Bugti also lauded the forces' professionalism and unwavering resolve. He expressed satisfaction over the timely intelligence and rapid response that neutralized the threat. "The swift reaction to terrorist activity in Pahrod is commendable. Our security forces have once again demonstrated their readiness and resolve to protect the province," he said. Labeling the group a threat to national stability, the CM reaffirmed the provincial government's commitment to decisive action against all enemies of the state. "Operations against the enemies of the state will continue on all fronts. Any attempt to sabotage the peace of Balochistan will be crushed," he asserted. Bugti described the operation as a clear message to hostile elements, declaring that the nefarious designs of Fitna-tul-Hindustan had been dismantled. "Their plans lie in ruins. Our forces have defeated their evil intentions," he remarked. He paid tribute to the personnel involved, emphasizing that their success reflects the vigilance and dedication of Pakistan's security forces. "They have once again thwarted the enemy's malicious plans and proved their unwavering commitment to national security," he added. WITH INPUT FROM APP

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store