Eighteen EU countries call for EU Deforestation Law 'simplification'
"We urge the European Commission to swiftly include the Deforestation Regulation in its simplification plans in order to ensure coordinated and effective implementation of the EUDR across the EU," the letter said.
The communique was signed by the agriculture ministers of Austria, Bulgaria, Croatia, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Finland, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia and Sweden.
The European Commission has over the past few weeks already presented a range of simplification packages to amend pieces of legislation approved by the first Ursula von der Leyen Commission in the 2019-2024 mandate.
These packages targeted the Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive, as well as pieces of legislation related to the European Common Agricultural Policy, and the defence sector.
"Pending the Commission's simplification proposals, it might be advisable to further postpone the date of application of the regulation," the letter also read.
A spokesperson for the European Commission told reporters on Monday that they had not yet "located" the letter, adding however that the EU's executive has "done also a lot of effort already to simplify the regulation and the work, in a way, is still ongoing".
The EU Deforestation Regulation (EUDR) is a law aimed at reducing the EU's impact on global deforestation.
It entered into force in June 2023 and classifies countries according to their risk of deforestation in the production of seven commodities: cattle, cocoa, coffee, oil palm, rubber, soya, and wood.
The European Commission decided to postpone its implementation to 30 December 2025 for large and medium-sized companies, and to 30 June 2026 for micro and small companies, following pressure from member states.
In the letter, the signatory member states claim that the obligations placed on farmers, forest owners, and operators by the regulation are overly burdensome, especially for countries with little or no deforestation risk.
They argue that the requirements are disproportionate to the regulation's goal of preventing deforestation and result in higher costs for both businesses and governments.
The rules, the member states say, may also drive up raw material and production costs, increasing the risk that producers will move operations outside the EU.
Criticism by civil society
Civil society organisations have accused some EU lawmakers — including both member states and MEPs — of repeatedly attempting to undermine the legislation.
Hannah Mowat, campaigns coordinator at Fern, told Euronews that there is a disconnect between the political and technical levels. "Competent authorities in many EU countries, including some that have signed this letter, say they are ready to implement the law,' she said.
The signatories of the letter also undermined the concept of "degradation of forests", a phenomenon rising in Europe, Mowat explained.
'The agriculture ministers' letter states that European tree cover is rising, but ignores that Europe's forests are increasingly degraded. Tree farms are not forests, and across Germany, Austria, and more, large monoculture plantations have already collapsed due to disease, drought and overexploitation," Mowat told Euronews.
"The EUDR would bring much-needed scrutiny to the monoculture model by requiring that forest products be legally produced and not contribute to the degradation of forests in Europe and abroad,' she concluded.
'This proposal is not a simplification, but rather a complication for all involved parties - including companies, who will be faced with a lack of legal clarity, further delays in the application of the law, and more burdens for those that have already set up systems for compliance" Anke Schulmeister-Oldenhove, WWF Europe manager on forests, told Euronews.
"While paying lip service to stopping deforestation, ministers are in reality undermining one of the EU's flagship environmental laws, and turning a blind eye to the increasing deforestation rates globally and the impacts of climate change in the EU," she added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Euronews
4 hours ago
- Euronews
Kilis-Aleppo natural gas pipeline opened: Gas flow to Syria started
The export of natural gas from Azerbaijan to Syria via Turkey began on Saturday with the opening of the Turkey-Syria natural gas pipeline. The inauguration ceremony was held in the Turkish city of Kilis only seven kilometres from the Syrian border. It was attended by Turkish Minister for Energy and Natural Resources Alparslan Bakyraktar, Qatar Development Fund President Fahad Hamad Al-Sulaiti, Syrian Energy Minister Mohammed Al-Bashir and Azberbaijani Economic Minister Mikayıl Jabbarov. In his opening speech, Bayraktar said that the new pipeline means the electricity supply in Syria will be increased from between three and four hours a day to ten hours a day. Electricity will now be exported from Turkey to Syria from eight different points, Bayraktar said, with the export capacity expected to increase in the coming years. "With the new connections, the capacity will reach 860 megawatts," he said. Speaking to Euronews, Bayraktar said that European countries expecting Syrians to return home "need to put concrete projects in place to turn expectations into reality." He said that "Turkey has been an important host" to Syrians who fled their country due to war. While many of these people want to return to their home country, he said the conditions need to be provided for them to do so. "Many countries, especially European countries, refuse our Syrian brothers and sisters and do not accept them, Turkey has been and continues to be a very important host in this sense." "Syria has many needs, infrastructure needs and other needs. Therefore, it is important for the European Union countries, European countries, Western countries to support, embrace and contribute to these projects that are necessary for the normalisation of life there in this sense," he said. The minister had previously announced that Turkey would cooperate with Azerbaijan and Qatar in natural gas exports to Syria. He said that a significant increase in energy production would help with "accelerating the return" of Syrians in Turkey. Bayraktar also announced the signing of an agreement with Azerbaijani state-owned oil and gas company SOCAR for natural gas. Energy cooperation Immediately after the EU and the US lifted sanctions on Syria, it was announced in May that a $7 billion (€6.04 billion) strategic cooperation agreement was signed between Kalyon Holding and Cengiz Holding from Turkey, UCC from Qatar, Power International from the US and the Syrian Ministry of Energy. Within the scope of the agreement, the groups intended to build natural gas cycle power plants across Syria within the next three years. A solar power plant is also expected to be built in around two years. The consortium aims to ensure Syria's energy supply security, environmental sustainability and regional development. Energy supply during the civil war Syrians have been struggling with serious energy shortages since the start of the civil war. The years-long war paralysed more than 50 percent of the country's electricity grid, reducing electricity generation capacity from 8,500 megawatts to 3,500 megawatts. It is stated that the main reason for this is the serious damage to power plants in the regions of Mkharde, Aleppo and Zayzoun. Before the civil war in 2011, Syria was producing and exporting 400 thousand barrels of oil per day. However, now it can only produce 20 thousand barrels and is dependent on imports. The natural gas sector, which was just developing in 2011, is almost non-existent today.
Euronews
8 hours ago
- Euronews
Planes drop aid into Gaza as Israeli fire reportedly kills at least 18
Planes dropped aid from European countries and beyond into Gaza on Saturday, though both aid groups and Palestinians say changes have been only incremental. The aid comes from a coalition of Jordan-led nations, including Germany, France and Spain. To circumvent restrictions on aid trucks crossing overland into Gaza, they have orchestrated parcels being dropped from the skies. French President Emmanuel Macron said that the first French aid drop of several tonnes of food was carried out on Friday and that more would continue over the weekend. Spain reportedly dropped 12 tonnes of aid deployed in 24 parachutes. This is enough for around 11,000 people, according to Spanish Foreign Minister Jose Manuel Albares. Germany said 14 tonnes of food and medical aid was dropped off by plane, but German Foreign Minister Johan Wadephul said that 'sufficient quantities of relief supplies can only be provided to the people by land.' Both Italy and the Netherlands are set to begin airdropping aid into Gaza next week, according to the country's governments. 'We expect Israel to do more to enable humanitarian aid via land routes and to fully honour its humanitarian agreements with the EU,' Dutch Foreign Minister Caspar Veldkamp told the Dutch parliament. 'The humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza must end.' Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani said he had given the green light to military forces for the 'transport and airdrop of basic necessities to civilians in Gaza, who have been severely affected by the ongoing conflict.' Hunger has grown in Gaza during the past 22 months of war between Israel and Hamas because of aid restrictions, humanitarian workers warn. Experts say the 'worst-case scenario of famine is currently playing out in Gaza.' Israel enforced a complete blockade on food and other supplies for two and a half months beginning in March. It said its objective was to increase pressure on Hamas to release dozens of hostages it has held since its attack on Israel on Oct. 7, 2023. Though the flow of aid resumed in May, the amount is a fraction of what aid organizations say is needed. Situation on the ground At least 18 people were killed by Israeli fire in Gaza on Saturday, according to local hospitals. Eight of these people were reportedly aid seekers. Near a Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) distribution site, Yahia Youssef, who had come to seek aid Saturday morning, described a panicked scene now grimly familiar. After helping carry out three people wounded by gunshots, he said he looked around and saw many others lying on the ground bleeding. 'It's the same daily episode,' Youssef said. In response to questions about several eyewitness accounts of violence at the northernmost of the Israeli-backed American contractor's four sites, the GHF media office said 'nothing (happened) at or near our sites.' The group's efforts to deliver aid to Gaza has been marred by violence and controversy. However, Israel and the GHF have said they have only fired warning shots and that the death toll of aid seekers has been exaggerated. An Israeli strike also hit a family house in an area between the towns of Zawaida and Deir al-Balah, killing two parents and their three children, according to Gaza's Health Ministry. Another strike hit a tent close to the gate of a closed prison where the displaced have sheltered in Khan Younis, killing a mother and her daughter, they said. Israel's military did not immediately respond to questions about the strikes or deaths near the aid sites. Hostage's families protest to end war Families of Israeli hostages held in Gaza and their supporters protested in Tel Aviv and urged their government to push harder for the release of their loved ones. US President Donald Trump's special envoy to the region Steve Witkoff joined them a day after visiting Gaza. Of the 251 hostages who were abducted when Hamas led an attack on southern Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, around 20 are believed to be alive in Gaza. The war began when Hamas militants attacked southern Israel on 7 October 2023, killing 1,200 people, most of them civilians. A subsequent Israeli offensive has to date killed over 60,000 Palestinians, mostly women and children, according to the Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry whose figure does not distinguish between fighters and civilians. The Israeli military says almost 900 of its soldiers have died since the start of the war.
Local France
9 hours ago
- Local France
French phrase of the Day: L'état de droit
Why do I need to know l'état de droit? Because it's a fundamental principle of any democracy. What does it mean? L'état de droit - pronounced lay tat de dwah - literally translates as 'the state of right' but its real meaning is 'the state of law' - or the principle that a society should be governed by laws and a justice system. It's usually used as the opposite of vigilante justice, or the idea of people taking the law into their own hands and administering their own punishments to people they feel have wronged them. The most common use of it has a slightly clumsy near-repetition - L'Etat de droit doit primer - the rule of law must prevail. Advertisement The French word droit means right in the sense of the opposite of left ( gauche ). But it also means right as in the political right (in fact the whole concept of a political right and a political left comes from the layout of the French parliament) and also means 'rights' in the sense of fundamental entitlements of a person of group. When talking about 'rights' it is plural ( droits ), just as in English. Use it like this Le respect des droits de l'homme et des libertés fondamentales, ainsique de l'État de droit, principes qui sont communs aux États membres - Respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms, along with the rule of law, are common values for EU member states. Sans l'état de droit, nous aurions une société de justiciers - Without the rule of law, we would have a vigilante society Évidemment, nous comprenons l'émotion de ce père de famille : comment agirions-nous à la place de cette personne, il est difficile de le dire. Ce que je peux vous dire comme porte-parole du gouvernement, c'est ma conviction profonde que l'État de droit doit primer et que nous ne souhaitons pas rentrer dans ce modèle de société où les gens se feraient justice eux-mêmes. Clearly we understand the emotions of this family man; how we would act in his place it's difficult to say. What I can tell you as the government spokesman is my deep conviction that the rule of law must prevail and that we do not wish to enter a model of society where people take the law into their own hands. [Quote from former government spokesman Olivier Véran, via Le Parisien ]
