‘Volatile…': Ex-PM Deve Gowda Slams Opposition For Endorsing Trump's ‘Dead Economy' Remark
Former PM HD Deve Gowda criticised US President Trump for calling India's economy "dead," labeling him volatile and irresponsible.
Former Prime Minister HD Deve Gowda on Friday lashed out at US President Donald Trump over his recent comments describing India's economy as 'dead", saying that the latter is the most 'volatile, uncivil, and irresponsible" head of state in modern history.
In a statement, the JD(S) stalwart said that he was 'surprised" by Trump's 'baseless and ill-tempered remarks" on the Indian economy, and accused the US President of behaving badly not just with India but 'with every other country across the world."
'I don't think modern history has seen another head of state who has been so volatile, uncivil, and irresponsible. Mr Trump has not just behaved badly with India, but with every other country across the world. He has not spared his own longstanding allies," the former Prime Minister said.
'Even a small trader and a poor farmer in India, who conducts his business with great dignity, integrity and humanity, can teach many lessons to Mr. Trump." Read my full statement on the US President's recent comments on India. @narendramodi @PMOIndia @PiyushGoyal @AmitShah pic.twitter.com/CiibX0l5F8 — H D Devegowda (@H_D_Devegowda) August 1, 2025
The 92-year-old Rajya Sabha MP said that Trump has offended not just India but several countries across the world. He said that there was "something fundamentally wrong" with the US President.
'There is something fundamentally wrong with him for which reason, diplomacy or statecraft cannot diagnose and address," he added.
Gowda further said that even a small trader or poor farmer in India, who works with dignity and integrity, could teach Trump a lesson in conduct. 'Even a small trader and a poor farmer in India, who conducts his business with great dignity, integrity, and humanity, can teach many lessons to Mr Trump," he added.
Gowda Praises PM Modi
The former Prime Minister further praised the PM Narendra Modi-led government for standing firm against Trump's "bullying" and not succumbing to external pressure.
'I am very happy and proud that India, under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, has not compromised our national interest. It has not blinked to Mr Trump's bullying and has shown that it will never be dictated by threat," he added.
He also lauded the Modi government for going "the full length" to protect the agricultural sector and small and medium businesses, "on which more than half the nation's population is dependent".
He asserted that the government's "firm stand" would lead to "national resurgence of an unprecedented scale".
Gowda also defended India's economic performance, noting that it remains one of the fastest-growing economies in the world and currently ranks fifth globally. Responding to Trump's 'dead economy" jibe, he said the US President was either 'blind or ill-informed."
The former Prime Minister also hailed India's democratic and sovereign character, saying that the country has always acted in its national interest since Independence, with the "God-given ability and strength to negotiate all difficulties that come its way and emerge stronger".
Gowda's Jibe At Opposition
The veteran leader also rebuked some opposition leaders for echoing Trump's statements. He urged them not to act as 'deluded spokespersons" of the US President.
'They should not harm themselves and their parties, and end up very soon in the dustbin of history alongside Mr. Trump," he said.
Gowda's statement came after Trump imposed a 25% tariff on all Indian goods starting August 1. Later, Leader of the Opposition in Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi, backed Trump's criticism, saying, 'Yes, he is right. Everybody knows that the Indian economy is a dead economy. I'm glad President Trump has stated a fact."
About the Author
Shobhit Gupta
Shobhit Gupta is a sub-editor at News18.com and covers India and International news. He is interested in day to day political affairs in India and geopolitics. He earned his BA Journalism (Hons) degree from Ben...Read More
Get breaking news, in-depth analysis, and expert perspectives on everything from politics to crime and society. Stay informed with the latest India news only on News18. Download the News18 App to stay updated!
view comments
First Published:
Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
7 minutes ago
- The Hindu
BJP committed to uplift of denotified tribes, says Andhra party president Madhav
Ahead of the Denotified Tribes Liberation Day to be observed on August 31, the BJP State unit organised a roundtable with key leaders of the nomadic and denotified tribes in Vijayawada. Speaking on the occasion, BJP State president P.V.N. Madhav emphasised the Central government's efforts to recognise and uplift these marginalised communities. He said, 'It is the Narendra Modi-led government at the Centre that has made budgetary allocation for the denotified tribes. These communities, once unfairly labeled as criminals by the British in 1957, have long suffered social discrimination and neglect.' In 1952, India had officially liberated these tribes from such stigmatisation. Later, under former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee's leadership, a commission had been constituted to study and recognise their societal contributions. 'The very first line of the commission's report says that if Indian culture is as rich as it is, it is due to the role of these nomadic communities,' Mr. Madhav observed. Since 2014, the Narendra Modi-led government had initiated steps to restore the identity and dignity of the denotified tribes, he said. 'These tribes also reside in Andhra Pradesh, and the BJP has undertaken studies to understand their challenges, including the lack of voting rights,' he added. 'We believe their struggles stem from systemic exclusion, including disenfranchisement. That's why we're formulating an action plan to safeguard their existence and promote their welfare,' Mr. Madhav added. 'Vajrotsavams' As part of the 75th Liberation Anniversary of these tribes, the BJP plans to conduct 'Vajrotsavams' (diamond jubilee celebrations) across all districts. A month-long series of programmes titled, 'Spurthi', will be organised, culminating in a grand celebration on August 30. MLA Dr. Parthasarathi, former IAS officer Dasari Srinivas Rao, BJP State general secretary B. Shivannarayana, and OBC Morcha State president Rongala Gopi Srinivas, among others, attended.
Time of India
7 minutes ago
- Time of India
Make In India
High tariffs or not, self-sufficiency in critical areas must be a national imperative It is possible for a people to be self-sufficient. The Sentinelese in the Andamans, for example. But such living is extremely limiting. That's why all great nations have pursued trade, although not as a dogma in the modern way. Ancient Romans were big traders. Millennia later, Mussolini declared Italy would manage alone, only to concede as oil imports rose: 'Let us not delude ourselves about autarky.' As he continues lighting tariff fires well into the first year of his second term, Trump has not declared autarky or self-sufficiency as his economic goal, but his actions are tending in that direction. He wants US to make everything from chips to ships; buy little and sell a lot. The problem with America's protectionist turn is that it affects the global order. When the largest economy, and market, raises barriers for sellers, the whole free trade edifice is at risk. India has been especially stung by Trump's tariffs. In a speech last week, Modi flagged the resultant uncertainty and urged Indians to buy swadeshi. It does not signal India's retreat into its pre-91 walled garden, but a pragmatic pause. Globalisation may pick up pace again when Trump leaves office in Jan '29, or as our top column today suggests, it may not as the world shifts 'from open to managed trade'. India will have to rethink strategy in that case. The ease of buying everything from computer chips to warplanes – Trump's been pushing the F-35 at India – in the 21st century can lull nations into a false sense of security. But China and America's recent actions are a wake-up call. India's a laggard in manufacturing semiconductors and fighter planes – the air force is currently depleted – and needs to catch up in the field of drones now. Then there are so many high-tech articles of civilian use that we don't make. Almost all specialised medical equipment is imported and contributes to the high cost of treatment. So, setting up an industrial base to manufacture advanced equipment – along with a research base to develop them – should be a national priority. If low tariffs return, it will make India an export powerhouse. If they don't, we won't be vulnerable at least. In an essay he wrote in 1933, Keynes, who grew up believing in free trade, said self-sufficiency may be a worthwhile luxury for countries that want it and can afford it. 'Let goods be homespun whenever it is reasonably and conveniently possible…' It's good advice. Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email This piece appeared as an editorial opinion in the print edition of The Times of India.
Time of India
22 minutes ago
- Time of India
‘Far from dead': Economy that Trump buried ‘outpaces' US
1 2 Ludhiana: Indian business leaders have pushed back firmly against US President Donald Trump's recent remarks describing the Indian and Russian economies as "dead", calling the claim baseless and out of step with the country's economic trajectory. The resilient economy politely declines to attend its own funeral, and the critic must answer: "If we're dead, who's eating all the global market share?" Industrialists from Ludhiana, one of the country's leading manufacturing hubs, said on Sunday that while US tariff hikes may temporarily affect some sectors, the Indian economy remains vibrant, resilient, and driven by robust domestic demand. "India can never be a dead economy — our population and internal demand alone ensure that," said Ashpreet Singh Sahni, managing director of Sehaj Solutions and former chairman of the Confederation of Indian Industry's Ludhiana chapter. "Yes, tariffs may slow us down for a year or two, but we'll bounce back stronger." Sahni, who was in the US when the new tariff regime was announced, said American manufacturers were also feeling the pinch. "There's nervousness on both sides. US companies look actively for alternatives to China, and India is high on their list. I believe the US will have to reconsider these tariffs, eventually." Upkar Singh Ahuja, president of the Chamber of Industrial and Commercial Undertakings (CICU), echoed the sentiment, arguing that India's global reputation was rising. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Ask A Pro: "I'm 70 with $1.4M in IRAs. Should I convert $120K/Year to a Roth?" SmartAsset Undo "During my visit to Europe, I saw firsthand the interest in Indian goods. Yes, IT and pharma may face short-term pressure, but they're already exploring new, tariff-friendly markets." Ahuja warned that Washington's protectionist stance could have unintended consequences. "Such tariffs are inflationary. They may backfire on the US economy itself. In the long term, it's not sustainable." Pankaj Sharma, president of the Association of Trade and Industrial Undertakings (ATIU), said India should seize the moment. "This is a time to turn adversity into opportunity. The tariffs aren't India-specific — they affect many countries. Our govt should ramp up support for manufacturing and help Indian firms enter new global markets." He called for stronger policy support, including incentives to help exporters tap into emerging economies and underserved regions. "The Indian economy is not just surviving — it's adapting. And that's the hallmark of a living, breathing market." The remarks come as global economic tensions continue to rise, with supply chains still reeling from pandemic aftershocks and shifting geopolitical alignments. Indian industry, local leaders say, is determined not to be left behind. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Friendship Day wishes , messages and quotes !
