logo
Confucian peace myth: East Asia minus US risks disaster

Confucian peace myth: East Asia minus US risks disaster

AllAfrica3 days ago
Skip to content
History shows the notion of a 'Confucian peace' in East Asia is a myth. Image: X Screengrab
Recently, several arguments have emerged suggesting that Korea, Japan and China could peacefully coexist without the US's presence in Northeast Asia.
Columbia University economist Jeffrey Sachs recently argued that China has never invaded Japan in its entire history – aside from two failed attempts – and characterized Japan's incursions into China as anomalies.
Citing Harvard sociologist Ezra Vogel, he claimed the two Confucian civilizations enjoyed nearly 2,000 years of relative peace – a striking contrast, he noted, to the near-constant wars between Britain and France.
Yonsei University professor Jeffrey Robertson added that, as 'US attention drifts away from East Asia, the unthinkable becomes thinkable' – a region where Europe, Russia, India, and China balance each other imperfectly, but none dominates.
Political scientist John Mearsheimer also weighed in: 'If I were the national security adviser to Deng Xiaoping – or Xi Jinping – and they asked me what I thought about the US military presence in East Asia, I'd say, 'I want the Americans out. I don't want them in our backyard.''
This vision of a self-balancing Asia – shared by economists, sociologists, strategists and realists alike – assumes that history, culture and trust can fill the vacuum left by American power. But can it?
Sachs's notion of a historical 'Confucian peace' collapses under scrutiny. In his speech, he conveniently omits Korea – arguably the most Confucian state in East Asia – which has frequently been at war with both China and Japan.
Consider Goguryeo, one of Korea's ancient kingdoms. Confucianism had already been influential in the region for 400–500 years when Goguryeo emerged. Yet Goguryeo fought multiple wars against various Chinese dynasties: Han, Liaodong, Wei, Lelang, Yan, Sui and Tang.
While modern Chinese narratives frame Goguryeo as a tributary, historical records – marked by repeated wars and political stalemates – depict it as a rival power that directly contributed to the collapse of multiple Chinese dynasties.
As for Japan, the fact that typhoons thwarted China's attempts to conquer it doesn't mean those efforts lacked seriousness. On the contrary, China was determined.
After its initial invasion in 1274 – involving 900 ships and 40,000 troops – ended in failure, it doubled down. In 1281, it returned with 4,400 ships and 140,000 troops – the largest seaborne invasion force in world history before D-Day.
To claim that China 'never invaded' simply because these attempts failed is nonsense. These were not theoretical plans – they were full-scale invasions, launched with overwhelming force and clear intent.
Typhoons may have stopped them, but they do not erase the historical fact of the invasions themselves.
Robertson's claim that the US is 'drifting away' from East Asia is inaccurate. Washington isn't pulling back – it's doubling down. The goal is clear: contain China.
This has been official US policy since Hillary Clinton's 2011 article, 'America's Pacific Century,' which outlined a strategic pivot to Asia as the cornerstone of US foreign policy.
The US may be distracted by Ukraine and Gaza, but its top strategic priority remains unchanged – and is, in fact, becoming more focused.
Washington has bolstered its Indo-Pacific posture through large-scale multinational exercises, such as the 40,000-strong Talisman Sabre in Australia, and expanded military deployments under AUKUS, rotations through Guam and greater access to bases in the Philippines through the Enhanced Defense Cooperation Agreement.
Mearsheimer says China wants the US out of East Asia. That may seem true on the surface – but the reality is more complicated. After World War II, China initially viewed US security treaties with Japan, Korea and Taiwan as part of a broader strategy to contain its rise.
In an October 1971 meeting with US National Security Advisor Henry Kissinger, Chinese Premier Zhou Enlai accused Washington of using Taiwan and Korea as 'two wings of outward expansion by Japanese expansionist policies.' Zhou Enlai and Henry Kissinger in Beijing in 1971. Photo: Henry Kissinger Archives / Library of Congress
In response, Kissinger offered a candid and far-reaching explanation of why the US maintained its military presence in Japan.
'China,' he said, 'has a universal outlook; Japan's has had a tribal outlook.' More than cultural commentary, this was a strategic warning.
He argued that 'the Japanese are capable of sudden and explosive changes. They went from feudalism to emperor worship in two to three years, and from emperor worship to democracy in three months.'
Such volatility, in Kissinger's view, made a self-armed Japan a latent threat – not because of intent, but because of potential. 'A Japan that defends itself with its own resources will be an objective danger to the region. The US alliance actually restrains it.'
He acknowledged the cynical alternative: 'We could cut Japan loose and let it stand on its own. That would trigger tension with China and let us play the middleman.' But he dismissed that option as dangerously shortsighted: 'Either you or we would end up the victim.'
Kissinger warned against romanticizing US withdrawal. 'We didn't fight World War II to stop Japan's domination of Asia only to enable it 25 years later. If Japan truly wants us out, we'll leave – but I don't think you should rejoice when that day happens, because some day you may regret it,' he said.
The shift in Chinese thinking was so significant that Zhou began to question whether the US could truly restrain what he called the 'wild horse' of Japan.
Chairman Mao even encouraged Kissinger to maintain good relations with Japan. 'When you pass through Japan, you should perhaps talk a bit more with them.' On Kissinger's most recent visit, Mao remarked, 'You only talked with them for one day, and that isn't very good for their face.'
The conversation took place in 1971, seven years after China had become a nuclear power and while Japan remained non-nuclear. Yet Beijing was still deeply uneasy about what a remilitarized Japan might do without US oversight.
That fear lingers to this day – not just in China, but across all the nations that clashed with Japan in the first half of the 20th century.
Historian Kenneth Pyle distills Kissinger's view in contemporary terms: The real issue is trust.
'Part of the answer' regarding the continued US presence in Japan, says Pyle, 'lies in a fundamental, often unspoken question in the minds of US policymakers: Can Japan be trusted to participate responsibly in international security affairs?'
He continues, 'This Japanese question is at the core of American thinking about its alliance with Japan and beclouds the issue of how Japan should contribute to the maintenance of the international order. Mindful of Japanese nationalism and militarism, world leaders are intensely ambivalent as to whether Japan should enlarge its security role.'
'Prompted by a fear of revived Japanese nationalism, US leaders are extremely circumspect toward Japan. This feeling recurs throughout Asia, in the Soviet Union, and in Europe – indeed, in Japan itself.'
'This concern must be resolved, for it is fundamental to the continued relationship between the United States and Japan and to the potential role of Japan in the changing pattern of international relations in East Asia.'
Perhaps the most surprising endorsement of US presence in East Asia comes from an extremely unlikely source – North Korea's Kim Jong Un.
In 2022, Mike Pompeo, who had been US secretary of state during Donald Trump's first presidential term, revealed: 'As we developed our relationship more fully, what became very clear is he [Kim Jong Un] views the United States of America on the Korean Peninsula as a bulwark against his real threat, which came from Xi Jinping.'
Kim Jong Un rules over what was once the heartland of Goguryeo – and he knows who the real enemy is. He has reportedly told his aides in the past: 'Japan is the 100-year enemy, but China is the 1,000-year enemy.'
The real question isn't whether China becomes a hegemon in Asia. It's what comes next.
That's what most commentators overlook – yet it carries the gravest consequences. Once a regional power secures dominance, it no longer has to watch its flank – it becomes 'free to roam.'
When China eventually pushes into the Western Hemisphere, it will challenge the Monroe Doctrine – Washington's historical red line – for the first time since the Cuban Missile Crisis. The resulting showdown could rival, or even surpass, that Cold War standoff.
In comparison, current and potential proxy wars in Ukraine, the Middle East, Taiwan and Korea would look like child's play.
Calls for an 'Asia without America' might sound like peace. But remove the US and the ghosts of history come rushing in – from Goguryeo's defiance to kamikaze invasions, from Japanese militarism to Cold War paranoia.
In Northeast Asia, peace without the US isn't just unlikely – it's historically unprecedented, strategically reckless and potentially catastrophic.
Hanjin Lew is a political commentator specializing in East Asian affairs.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

China-EU play nice despite widening cracks
China-EU play nice despite widening cracks

AllAfrica

time25 minutes ago

  • AllAfrica

China-EU play nice despite widening cracks

Beijing has called on the European Union to increase diplomatic dialogue and improve trade relations after the bloc sanctioned two rural banks in northern China, accusing them of facilitating trade between China and Russia. Chinese President Xi Jinping met with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and European Council President Antonio Costa in Beijing on Thursday. 'The challenges facing Europe today do not come from China,' Xi told the two European leaders during their visit to China for the China-EU Summit. 'There are no fundamental conflicts of interest or geopolitical contradictions between China and Europe.' Xi said that China has always viewed and developed its relations with the EU from a strategic and long-term perspective, regarding Europe as an essential pole in a multipolar world, and has consistently supported European integration and the EU's strategic autonomy. He said that China and the European Union should uphold openness and cooperation, and properly manage their differences. 'History and reality have proven that mutual dependence is not a risk, and the integration of interests is not a threat,' he said. 'Improving competitiveness cannot rely on 'building walls and fortifications,' while 'decoupling' will only isolate oneself.' Xi also stated that the EU should practice multilateralism, help safeguard the international order of rules, and collaborate with China to address global challenges such as climate change. The Chinese leader made the conciliatory remarks amid rising political tensions between the EU and China over trade issues and the Ukraine war. In April, the EU imposed anti-subsidy tariffs on Chinese-imported aerial work platforms, ranging from 20.6% to 66.7%. Investigations found that Chinese manufacturers enjoyed an advantage in European markets, as they could lower prices after receiving government subsidies, low-interest financing, and support for raw materials. On June 20, it announced the exclusion of Chinese companies from the EU government's procurement of medical devices exceeding €5 million (approximately US$5.84 million). It said the measure aims to incentivize China to cease discriminating against EU firms and EU-made medical devices, and to treat EU companies with the same openness as the EU treats Chinese companies and products. China retaliated against the EU by restricting the purchase of European medical equipment and imposing tariffs on Brandy. However, China still wants to maintain a good relationship with the EU, which was also hit by the Trump administration's reciprocal tariffs in April. US President Donald Trump said the US would impose a 30% tariff on imports from Europe on August 1 if the two sides could not reach a trade deal. Media reports indicate that the US may agree to impose only a 15% tariff on European products, but a final agreement has not been reached. On July 16, China removed entry restrictions on Reinhard Buetikofer, the former EU lawmaker who was sanctioned by China in 2021 due to his comments on human rights issues of Uighurs in Xinjiang. Chinese commentators said China wanted to show a friendly gesture to Brussels ahead of the EU-China Summit, but the EU replied with sanctions on two Chinese banks. 'China removed entry restrictions on Buetikofer to pave the way for the 50th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic relations between China and the EU,' a Fujian-based writer says in an article. 'The outside world described it as China's 'strategic gift package' for the EU.' 'However, the EU did not respond to this gift for three days and suddenly announced the 18th round of sanctions against Russia on July 19 and added over 10 Chinese companies to its Entity list,' he says. 'The sanctioned entities include two small Chinese banks, Heilongjiang Suifenhe Rural Commercial Bank and Heihe Rural Commercial Bank, which were accused of 'helping Russia circumvent sanctions'.' The writer notes that the annual transactions settled by the two banks were relatively small compared to Gazprom's daily exports. He says people in Heilongjiang use cash to trade Chinese electric heaters and Russian flour, but the EU was upset and blamed China for these legal activities. He says the EU wants a tough stance against China to please Washington and gain bargaining chips in the US-EU trade negotiations. A Yunnan-based columnist says it's unfair that the EU, which imported 18% more liquefied natural gas (LNG) from Russia last year, accused Chinese firms of having legal cooperation with Russian counterparts. 'The EU exposed the nature of its 'de-risking' strategy towards China in this incident,' he says. 'China has long been the EU's second-largest trading partner. However, with the rise of China in new energy, semiconductors, and other sectors, the EU's positioning of China has shifted from 'partner' to 'systemic rival', trying to use sanctions to slow China's growth.' He says the EU is like committing suicide as it sanctions Chinese firms, and at the same time asks China for rare earth elements. Reuters reported on April 22 that major Russian banks have set up a netting payments system called 'The China Track' to settle Russia's trade with China. The report, citing banking sources, stated that the new system, which has been in place for some time, was established by several sanctioned Russian banks and some intermediaries registered in countries that Russia considers friendly. It said each bank operates several verified payment agents, some of whom handle payments for exports, while others handle payments for imports. The minimum cost of the 'China Track' service, including commissions and exchange rate differences, is approximately 0.5% for exports and 1% for imports, compared to 2-4% outside the system and up to 12% at the height of the issue last year. The involved banks can complete the payment within two days. The service is now available in 11 Chinese provinces that have strong manufacturing sectors. According to an article published by the Heilongjiang-based Tianfusheng International Logistics Co on May 6, 'The China Track', a secret trade settlement channel between China and Russia, is now online. Tianfusheng said top Russian banks have jointly established this highly encrypted payment system to facilitate bilateral trade between Russia and China. It said this system can effectively bypass the SWIFT system and the West's monitoring, helping involved parties reduce sanction risks. In another article, Tianfusheng promoted its 'golden route' service, which guarantees that it can transport goods from China to 'anywhere in Russia' within eight days. The company said it has 150 trucks and an innovative tracking system. It claimed that its trucks can reach their final destinations directly without transit and complete customs clearance smoothly under the Transports Internationaux Routiers (TIR), a global customs transit system overseen by the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (UNECE). Read: China's patience wears thin with EU over medical device row

EU-China cooperation ‘only right choice', Premier Li Qiang says at business symposium
EU-China cooperation ‘only right choice', Premier Li Qiang says at business symposium

South China Morning Post

time3 hours ago

  • South China Morning Post

EU-China cooperation ‘only right choice', Premier Li Qiang says at business symposium

China and Europe should foster a 'healthy' economic relationship characterised by both competition and cooperation, the Chinese premier told European Union leaders and businesses on Thursday. At a business symposium held on the sidelines of the EU-China Summit on Thursday, Li Qiang urged both sides to find new grounds for collaboration. 'China and the EU can further leverage their complementary economic strengths, focusing on areas such as services trade, technological innovation, the green economy, and third-party cooperation to cultivate more new growth drivers for collaboration,' Li said, according to Xinhua. 'Looking back at the 50-year history of diplomatic relations between China and Europe, cooperation remains the only right choice for both sides.' Amid rising protectionism and unilateralism, if China and Europe join hands in upholding free trade and multilateralism while deepening economic and trade collaboration, they can serve as a stabilising anchor for economic globalisation and the stability of global industrial and supply chains, Li was quoted as saying. Li and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, along with other Chinese and EU officials, attended the symposium, which hosted nearly 60 representatives from business chambers and companies.

Beijing, EU agree on plan; Nvidia CEO Huang delights Chinese fans: SCMP's 7 highlights
Beijing, EU agree on plan; Nvidia CEO Huang delights Chinese fans: SCMP's 7 highlights

South China Morning Post

time4 hours ago

  • South China Morning Post

Beijing, EU agree on plan; Nvidia CEO Huang delights Chinese fans: SCMP's 7 highlights

We have selected seven stories from this week's news across Hong Kong, mainland China, the wider Asia region and beyond that resonated with our readers and shed light on topical issues. If you would like to see more of our reporting, please consider subscribing The EU and China agreed on a new mechanism to help smooth the export of rare earth elements and magnets, as Brussels pushed Beijing to take its trade concerns seriously, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said after a summit in the Chinese capital on Thursday. An X-47B Unmanned Combat Air System drone seen aboard the aircraft carrier USS George H.W. Bush in 2013. The US X-47B programme was cancelled 10 years ago. Photo: AFP Chinese aerospace engineers have a revolutionary software design that they say will allow them to overcome a major barrier to stealth aircraft development. Cambodian soldiers reload a BM-21 multiple rocket launcher in Preah Vihear province on Thursday. Photo: AFP Thailand launched air strikes on Cambodia on Thursday as a simmering border dispute erupted into open conflict, with soldiers on both sides exchanging fire and Cambodian troops unleashing rockets that killed at least 12 Thais, most of them civilians. A Chinese company has converted a giant cargo ship into a mobile fish farm as part of a project that aims to boost the nation's food security by repurposing old vessels for use in aquaculture. China's new mega dam project is being built on the Yarlung Tsangpo river, shown here in 2021, near Nyingchi city in the Tibet autonomous region. Photo: AFP On the eastern rim of the Tibetan plateau, China envisions a future powered by the roaring waters of the Yarlung Tsangpo, also known as the Brahmaputra. The river will be the site of a mega dam – the world's most ambitious to date – that promises to bring clean energy, jobs, infrastructure and prosperity to the region. Construction on the world's largest hydropower dam began on Saturday, according to Premier Li Qiang, who called it the 'project of the century'. But the project is not just about electricity and economic benefits – the stakes are far higher. Regional security, ecological stability and the future of one of Asia's great rivers all hang in the balance. Four Hong Kong Airlines passenger flights touched down at the city's airport while the highest typhoon signal was still in force on Sunday, with experts saying such landings were possible under the right wind and operational conditions. Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang captivates millions of Chinese fans with a charm offensive that includes wearing a Tang suit and speaking imperfect Mandarin. Photo: SCMP composite/AP/Kyodo Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang captivated millions of Chinese fans by donning a Tang suit and speaking in rusty Mandarin at the third China International Supply Chain Expo (CISCE), marking his third visit to China this year. Advertisement

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store