Heydon committed to 2-pillar CAP but has no ‘crystal ball'
The minister was speaking at his first appearance as a senior minister in front of the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Agriculture, Food and the Marine.
A range of topics came up, with CAP, and its future post-2027, being one of the main issued raised by TDs and senators on the committee.
The European Commission is understood to be planning a radical overhaul of the EU's long-term budget, the Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF), in which the funding to member states would be consolidated into a single funding pot, with member states then developing a plan to outline how they would use that funding.
This has sparked concern that the two-pillar structure of CAP, and even a dedicated budget for the entire CAP, could be scrapped in favour of a single member state fund.
The minister was quizzed on this by Roscommon-Galway TD Michael Fitzmaurice, who asked: 'The overall budget in CAP, is it going to be bigger, yes or no? Is Ireland's budget going to be bigger to accommodate it if we're going to be tweaking around on it? Are we going to have Pillar I and Pillar II, is it going to be the same system?'
In answer to Fitzmaurice, the minister said: 'Apologies deputy, I left my crystal ball at home, so I don't have that, and we'd all love to know those answers.
'What I can tell you is we'll know in the middle of July. Around July 16 is when these [plans] are going to be announced, and all I can tell you is we are doing everything in our power.
'I can't be clearer – we want to maintain the [CAP] fund, we want to maintain Pillar I and II, we want a fully funded CAP,' he added.
'Will we get that?… We know all the other demands there are on other sides.'
Fitzmaurice then asked if, in a situation where the CAP in its traditional form was not forthcoming, the government would be prepared to step in and 'prop it up'.
Minister Heydon said: 'We could end up with so many different scenarios here… If what was leaked out in terms of a single fund was to come about…I would make the point that it would be a very bad thing. That would mean renationalisation of our system. It would actually undermine the whole [EU] single market.
'I'm not going to get into predicting what might come of what outcome, because there's so many different outcomes there can be here.
'What I can tell you right now is we are making every effort across government to put our best foot forward to maintain a fully funded cap with the traditional structure that has served our sector so well,' he added.
The minister also noted that, in the second half of 2026, when the CAP budget is likely to be finalised, Ireland will hold the rotating presidency of the Council of the EU, one of the legislative bodies of the EU, meaning Minister Heydon, if he is still in office, will be the chairperson of the council of agriculture ministers during that period.
He said: 'The first element of this is actually the MFF. What happens with the overall budget will totally determine what happens with CAP.
'In terms of the role we play in the agriculture council… What we do have is, in the second half of 2026, I'll be the chair of the council of ministers and, as we're working through that, we'll be working on the basis of consensus.
'I'm meeting with every other minister bilaterally to understand their priorities and so they understand our priorities… Hopefully before the end of 2026 under the Irish presidency, I;ll be in a position to get that CAP over the line by means of consensus.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
3 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Tariff fallout set to harm Irish growth this year even if EU strikes deal with Trump administration
The EU has until Wednesday to clinch a crucial trade agreement with the US administration before tariffs on almost all exports to America surge to 50pc. Brussels appears willing to accept an outline agreement that includes a 10pc baseline levy, with lower rates for key sectors such as cars, chemicals and pharmaceuticals. Ireland would feel an economic aftershock even if such a deal is secured, according to Kate English, chief economist at Deloitte Ireland. I am not on the page that Ireland is about to crash She said the Irish economy was demonstrating resilience, with strong consumer spending, but believes growth will slow this year. The Department of Finance recently warned growth is expected to slow to 2pc if Trump's 10pc tariffs remain in place. 'There is no world in which there isn't a fallout from this and a reduction of growth,' English said. Despite this, she does not believe Ireland is about to experience a crash or a recession. Some businesses will feel more pain than others, especially those in low-margin sectors, such as the food industry. 'I am not on the page that Ireland is about to crash, or that a recession is coming,' she said. 'But, I definitely would believe growth will be slower than what we have been used to experiencing for the past few years.'¶She warned that extending the trade deal deadline would create more uncertainty, which had been damaging for investment decisions. 'Whatever comes from next week, if we get a deal, it provides some element of clarity or certainty to companies,' she said. 'At the moment, that uncertainty is causing the greatest amount of damage. People are pausing decisions by it. It is impacting sentiment. We know sentiment drives everything.' Since Trump's tariff announcement, the euro has rallied against the dollar and is up nearly 14pc since the beginning of the year. This means Irish products have already become more expensive for American buyers. ADVERTISEMENT Some of the noise is louder than what will actually be implemented Oliver Moloney, chief investment officer with wealth manager Fordel, said the euro's strength was acting like another tariff for Irish exporters. He has been heartened by the market's stability since the significant declines that accompanied Trump's tariff announcements. Markets have more than recovered from the initial shock in April and appear to be heading on a positive trajectory, barring any huge surprises. 'Whenever markets are calm, they are probably more liable to some bad news on the downside,' Moloney added. 'If Trump comes out in a day or two and says: 'We are not going to cut any deal with Europe, they are not negotiating,' that may well cause a bit of a shock downwards,' Moloney said. 'But it seems like since April, people have digested this trade tension and understood that some of the noise is louder than what will actually be implemented in reality. Markets do fall, but they take it in their stride Moloney said investors should not panic if there is not a deal and the markets fall by 10-20pc next week. Such problems can create opportunities. 'Anyone that still has cash that they are due to invest or in the middle of building out a portfolio, a 20pc fall is usually a good time to buy in,' he said. 'Take Covid or the rapid interest rate hikes — markets do fall, but they take it in their stride.' Pressure is mounting strike a deal with Washington, although fractures have emerged within the EU. Germany and Italy are leading a pack of countries eager to cut a quick deal, even if it means a baseline of 10pc tariffs. However, last Friday, France described this was a bad deal for Europe. Tánaiste Simon Harris has appeared to accept trade with the US will involve 10pc tariffs. US threatened Sefcovic with 17pc tariffs on agricultural exports He has not given up on a better deal, telling Edward Walsh, the new US ambassador, that the two countries should 'use every hour' to reach a zero-for-zero tariff settlement in as many areas as possible. What shape any deal looks like will have to wait a little longer. On Friday, Europe's chief negotiator, Maros Sefcovic, revealed he was returning to Brussels after failing to strike an agreement last week with his US counterparts. Talks are set to continue following what he called a 'productive week'. However, the Financial Times reported the US threatened Sefcovic with 17pc tariffs on agricultural exports. Trump also wants US companies to have wide-ranging exemptions from regulations to help cut America's trade surplus.
Irish Independent
5 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Letters: Our trip to World Cup in Japan just wasn't the same without Giles and Co
This was before smartphones and instant internet news. When we arrived, we heard from other Irish supporters that Roy Keane had left the Irish squad. We hungered to know what the RTÉ panel were saying. Supporters took turns making the expensive call home for an update, then shared the news with all the Irish supporters. It was a similar story as we travelled along to the matches, asking what Giles thought and wondering if Dunphy had thrown the head. When we got home, everyone asked us about our experience. We said Japan was nice, the people lovely, the matches exciting and Ireland minus Keane brilliant; but we felt we kind of missed the World Cup, really, because we had no RTÉ panel out there. We decided to stay home for future tournaments so as not to miss out again. Family ties can resist Israeli bombardment Madam — It is early Sunday morning, and I've read Colin Murphy's piece on being Jewish in New York in the context of what's happening in Gaza three times already, looking for a sliver of hope — any type of hope, really ('New York's Jews increasingly divided over Gaza war and the 'heresy' of criticising Israel', June 22). What I would say to Naftuli Moster of the Modern Orthodox tradition is that, yes, you are correct in saying that many of the young pro-Palestinian supporters around the world do not have families and kids yet. But saying a 'protective instinct' will kick in that will see them rally to Israel (when they have kids) is also true of every Palestinian family living in the war-torn region. Families and the love that binds them can never be defeated by military might, irrespective of whether you are a Jew or a Muslim, an Israeli or an Arab. Tom McElligott, Tournageehy, Co Kerry Criticising genocide is not antisemitic Madam — Colin Murphy's article is interesting in that right-wing Jews in New York seem to ignore or play down the genocide being perpetrated by the IDF. They do not mention the blockade of Gaza, the militarisation of food distribution and Israel's refusal to give access to external journalists. How would they respond if they and their families were to swap places with a Palestinian family in Gaza for a week? I am sure that experience would bring the reality of IDF oppression home to them. The actions of the Israeli state in Gaza in the past 20 months only highlights its inhumanity and lack of respect for Palestinian lives. Being anti-Israel in this oppression is not being antisemitic. Michael Ryan, Stillorgan, Dublin Gazans need us to keep flag-waving Madam — Eoin O'Malley's article on flag-waving is a very reasonable piece of journalism ('War is not a football match, so put those Palestinian flags away', June 29). However, in the case of Palestine, I would dissent. To paraphrase Donald Trump, the people of the West Bank and Gaza 'have no cards'. In the face of more than 55,000 deaths in Gaza alone, the EU will take no action. The UK is banning Palestinian Action on the grounds that it is a terrorist group. Fear stalks those who speak out against Israel in the US. Without the flag-waving, the Palestinian question would be forgotten. In life-and-death situations, clinical analysis just means more bodies in the morgue. Richard Collins, Castleknock, Dublin Free speech bill is a well-meaning folly Madam — I could not agree more with Eilis O'Hanlon ('Policing speech is only OK when it's Simon doing it', June 29). Yes, the new American security requirements may be excessive, but that's up to them; Micheál Martin's comments on the issue are just irrelevant. Far more worrying are our own home-grown restrictions on free speech. This all emanates from well-meaning men and women in Brussels, our own included, who are striving for a beautiful world where everybody will be polite and reasonable in their dealings with their fellow humans and nobody will ever feel offended. My late mother used to observe that 'the road to hell is paved with good intentions', and this scenario fits the bill. A free, open society, which is what I and most others want, must allow people to speak their minds, even if that is offensive to some. They will just have to suck it up. Anthony Hanrahan, Salruck, Renvyle, Co Galway Peter Power would be a great president Madam — I was pleased to see Peter Power being suggested as a suitable candidate for election as President of Ireland ('Former FF minister Peter Power in secret talks to run for Áras', June 29). I've read of other possible presidential candidates from the left to the right in our political system, sadly without much enthusiasm about any of them to date. As executive director of Unicef Ireland since 2011 and a former TD and junior minister for Overseas Development, Mr Power has all the attributes needed and is well placed for the important position of First Citizen. Aged 59, he has the energy and enthusiasm required for this position. JJ Ryan, Lisnagry, Co Limerick Gender ideology is forced upon us Madam — In your editorial last Sunday to mark Pride Week, you stated: 'What is beyond question is that the country today, while by no means perfect, is a far more open and progressive place in which to live than it has ever been.' I would take issue with this statement and say that, although some things may have changed for the better, in this country freedom of speech only exists for those who follow the Government line. Unlike Marriage Equality, the Gender Recognition Act – which is also 10 years old – was introduced with no referendum and no real discussion of the implications and possible impact on women's rights. Gender identity and transgender matters are controversial and contested. Despite this, the Government flung itself into the job of embedding this ideology into our legislation, school curriculums, health service, public services and NGOs. Even in his heyday, John Charles McQuaid never managed quite this level of ideological saturation and domination. Julia Anderson, Kilpedder, Co Wicklow Men have no right to be in female spaces Madam —Bernie Linnane says she has a right to be heard (Letters, June 22). Over a two-week period, she has had letters in two national newspapers, an article in a third and has been a guest in Áras an Uachtaráin. Congratulations, Ms Linnane, on your success. It constantly astonishes me that defending the 'right' of a cohort of men to enter women's spaces, where women are vulnerable due to their biology, is considered a righteous cause and is celebrated. Whereas our belief that our daughters, our nieces, our sisters, our friends, our mothers, our grannies and all other women deserve privacy from the male sex when dealing with intimate bodily functions is considered bigoted and wrong. In reply to Margaret McPherson (Letters, June 29), I would like to provide clarity that the only people we want to keep out of women's toilets are men. Females of all ages, sexual orientations, identities, races and religions are welcome. Just not men. Can anyone explain to me what is wrong with that? E Bolger, Dublin Br Kevin Crowley changed lives Madam — Brother Kevin Crowley, who died last week, was a remarkable man. I met him on Dublin streets on numerous occasions, and one in particular always stays in my memory. Br Kevin encountered a middle-aged man who had unfortunately fallen on hard times. He put his hand on the man's shoulder and walked him to the Capuchin Centre, which he established to help those in need. After a shower, a shave and some nourishing food, that man was a different man. For those who fall on hard times, help is always available thanks to men like Br Kevin. May he rest in peace. Kevin Carolan, Bailieborough, Co Cavan How cricket united Major and Reynolds Madam — I was amused by Shane Ross's excellent column ('Sobriety gives me new respect for a Soc Dem', June 29) about the drinking and non-drinking at the Dáil members' bar during days gone by when he and the hardline republican Neil Blaney talked about cricket, that most English of sports. It reminded me of a meeting with Albert Reynolds, who told me he had a fierce row with John Major in Dublin when both thought the other had been leaking details of their meetings to the media. When both leaders discovered that neither was to blame, they went to lunch and talked animatedly about cricket. John Major later confirmed this to me. It is well-known that Martin McGuinness was a keen cricket fan, and I have been told on great authority that when he and General John de Chastelain, the Canadian who oversaw Provisional IRA disarmament, met at a dinner party in Belfast, they had a long discussion about their passion for fly-fishing. All of which shows our inherited cultures on these islands and elsewhere are not always what they seem. Alf McCreary, Belfast Trump's tactics will soon poison Ireland Madam — Referring to Caitríona Perry's article on Donald Trump ('F-bombs, love bombs and actual bombs — inside Trump's big week', June 29), it is tempting to write off the recent events in Washington as just more chaos. But there's more at stake here than headline drama. What's happening is a new kind of power play — quick military strikes, court rulings that clear the way for presidential moves and political decisions announced on social media. The old checks and balances are being ignored, and that should worry us all. This style won't stay American for long. Other world leaders will see how bold moves and controlling the message can get results fast. These days, it seems attention matters more than honesty or skill. There's a bitter irony in a president who orders bombings while chasing the Nobel Peace Prize. If that prize is given under these conditions, it risks losing its meaning and value. Irish readers should watch closely. This isn't just one 'big, beautiful week' in US politics. It's a sign of lasting changes in how power is used around the world, with consequences for Ireland too. Enda Cullen, Tullysaran, Co Armagh An all-time great response to Dunphy Madam — I have long admired and enjoyed your columnist Declan Lynch. He writes wittily and intelligently on a wide range of subjects. In particular, his analysis of the far right, as epitomised by the likes of Trump, Farage, Orban and far too many others, is a beacon of sanity in what seems to me an increasingly insane world. I would like to thank him for his wonderful column last week on John Giles and his role as a great football analyst. I was somewhat disappointed, though, that he didn't include what I thought was one of the great exchanges between Giles, Eamon Dunphy and Bill O'Herlihy. Bill asked Dunphy and Giles for their predictions on the match that was about to be played. He then mischievously asked Giles if he was as sure of his prediction as Dunphy was of his, to which Giles gave the magnificent response: 'I'm not as sure of anything as Eamon is about everything.' Noel Kennedy, Thurles, Co Tipperary A welcome article on Máirtín Ó Direáin Madam — Mícheál Ó hAodha's translation of Feamainn Bhealtaine by Máirtín Ó Direáin ('Lament on loss of community, People & Culture, June 29) is a welcome development in allowing a wider understanding of this fine poet. As Mícheál observes, Ó Direáin was often associated with a nostalgic recreation of the Aran Islands, especially since many of his early poems were prescribed material on school curriculums. However, the poet was a well-read autodidact who went on to discover such modernist poets as TS Eliot, WB Yeats and Ezra Pound, incorporating some of their themes into his middle and later poems where his beloved island became a metaphor to measure — morally, and find wanting — the worst excesses of urban life. I had the privilege of working with him on postgraduate work and can still recall, poignantly, the day I last visited him in the nursing home above Greystones in the winter of 1988 when he told me he was dying. We will remember the poet by the immortal lines from his seminal poem Cranna Foirtil (Strong Oars): 'Coigil aithinne d'aislinge/Scaradh léi is éag duit' — 'Preserve the spark of your vision/To part with it is death'. Declan Collinge, Templeogue, Dublin David Quinn is right about Tuam home Madam — Thank God (and whoever/whatever, if anything, atheists believe in) for David Quinn's excellent analysis of the mother and baby homes issue ('Lurid claims obscure truth of Tuam', June 22). This subject has been crying out for a more reasoned critique for a very long time. As he points out, it's not as if the evidence is not already there. The report of the government-appointed Commission of Investigation is available for all to read. It's quite comprehensive. The only problem is it totally contradicts the false narrative that has been allowed to gain traction in recent decades. A few significant facts illustrate this. For example, it explains that the vast majority (about 75pc) of unmarried mothers chose to have and rear their children at home, with no major deleterious consequences — not exactly evidence of a very malignant society. The commission also found that the religious-run institutions were generally better than the state-run county homes, where most poor unmarried mothers received care. Eric Conway, Navan, Co Meath Keep up great work, Tommy Conlon Madam — Tommy Conlon was the only pundit to call the Armagh-Kerry contest right ('Old order not quite ready to be written off', Sport, June 29). He didn't buy all the ullagoning from everybody in Kerry and was spot-on in his observations about David Clifford, who brings all the players into the game. Keep up the good work.
Irish Independent
5 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Local credit unions will beat the pillar banks in the race to offer customers instant transfers
Sepa instant payments will take 10 seconds or less Credit unions are poised to steal a march on the pillar banks by enabling members to send Revolut-style instant payments from September, ahead of an EU deadline that will require financial institutions to facilitate transactions within 10 seconds. These instant transfers are part of the Single Euro Payments Area (Sepa) system, which was designed to simplify euro-denominated cross-border payments within the EU and make them as fast and simple as domestic transfers. Typically, Sepa transfers take one to two business days – but Sepa instant payments take 10 seconds or less. The EU's Instant Payments Regulation, which was enacted last year, stipulated that bank and payment service providers' systems should be capable of receiving Sepa instant transfers no later than January 9, 2025, and able to send Sepa instant transfers by October 9. The service is limited to countries in the Sepa 'zone', which includes all EU member states plus Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway, Switzerland, Monaco, Andorra, San Marino, and the Vatican. Banks and payment companies will not be able to charge customers extra to send payments instantly. Last week, a slew of credit unions across the country wrote to members to say they would start offering Sepa instant payments as soon as September, and posted that information on their websites. These included Crosshaven Carrigaline Credit Union, Affinity Credit Union, and Claddagh Credit Union. Cara Credit Union, which has branches in Co Kerry, said on its website that it would offer instant payments from September 1. Cara is part of Metamo, a business-to-business joint venture that provides products and services to credit unions. It has attracted investment from Fexco, the Kerry-headquartered financial services group. Payac, the credit union-owned payments provider, last year signed an agreement with Milan-based payment technology firm Nexi to deliver Sepa instant payments to all participating credit unions in Ireland. The pillar banks planned an instant payments app, but it was beset by problems Payac, the Irish League of Credit Unions, and the Credit Union Development Association did not have anyone available to comment on the timelines for implementation when contacted by the Sunday Independent last week. The main retail banks had planned to launch an instant payments app called Yippay to rival Revolut and N26, through a joint venture called Synch Payments – but the initiative was beset by delays and regulatory challenges. The banks finally pulled the plug on the app in late 2023, four months after the Central Bank said the planned new service needed to be authorised by it. Plans for the venture were co-ordinated by the Banking and Payments Federation Ireland (BPFI). A spokesperson for the BPFI last week told the Sunday Independent that the rollout of Sepa instant payments 'will be phased in the run-up to October 9, according to the specific schedules of each individual bank and payment service provider.' PTSB last week emailed customers to inform them they would be able to send instant payments from October 9. A spokesperson for Bank of Ireland said its customers can use instant payments via the 365 app and online banking service 'on or before October 9'. In Ireland, 280 credit unions offer current accounts that come with online banking, a mobile app, and contactless payments.
