Scientists find 'proof' Jesus didn't feed 5,000 with bread and fish
The biblical miracle of Jesus feeding the five thousand with just five loaves and two fishes is well-known, but scientists now reckon it was a natural phenomenon that caused the event. Researchers have been studying Lake Kinneret, also known as the Sea of Galilee in the New Testament, monitoring oxygen levels in the water and wind speed and direction on the surface.
These devices enabled them to cross-reference results with historical accounts of fish die-offs, events which see the sudden mass deaths of fish in a particular region. According to Answeringgenesis.org, their research found short periods of time when winds across the surface of the lake were strong enough to pull oxygen from its depths.
This would result in a sudden die-off. To someone on shore or in a boat, it would appear as a mass number of fish slowly rising to the surface of the lake, allowing them to 'be easily collected by a hungry populace' as described in The Bible.
They believe when Jesus told his weary disciples, who'd fished all night and caught nothing, to throw their nets on the other side of the lake their success was due to a mass die-off.
Matthew 14:13-21 tells the story: 'Now when Jesus heard this, he withdrew from there in a boat to a desolate place by himself. But when the crowds heard it, they followed him on foot from the towns, reports the Mirror US.
'When he went ashore he saw a great crowd, and he had compassion on them and healed their sick. Now when it was evening, the disciples came to him and said, 'This is a desolate place, and the day is now over; send the crowds away to go into the villages and buy food for themselves.
' But Jesus said, 'They need not go away; you give them something to eat'. They said to him, 'We have only five loaves here and two fish.
"'And he said, 'Bring them here to me'.'Then he ordered the crowds to sit down on the grass, and taking the five loaves and the two fish, he looked up to heaven and said a blessing. Then he broke the loaves and gave them to the disciples, and the disciples gave them to the crowds. And they all ate and were satisfied. And they took up 12 baskets full of the broken pieces left over. And those who ate were about five thousand men, besides women and children.'
However, Biblical scholars have disputed the research, saying in the scripture there was no mention of the fish being 'easily caught'.
And they suggested the scientists needed to re-read the passages discussing the miracle.
The Answering Genesis article added: "Jesus simply took the five loaves and two fish, thanked God, broke the loaves, handed everything to his disciples, and the disciples handed the food out. No fish were caught!".
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
18-07-2025
- Daily Mirror
Lost tomb of Egyptian 'wizard doctor' reveals amazing evidence of ancient knowledge
The remains of a talented healer and 'priest and magician' who was thought to have treated pharaohs have been found in Egypt, archaeologists have announced Archaeologists have unearthed the remains of what they believe to be a 4,000 year old wizard/ doctor in Egypt. The Egyptian Ministry of Tourism and Antiquities announced the find earlier this year, with the tomb located in the ancient burial ground of Saqqara. The tomb, which features a false door and is adorned with vibrant engravings and drawings, was identified as belonging to Teti Neb Fu, a physician from the era of King Pepi II, who ruled from 2305BC to 2118BC during the sixth dynasty. "The tomb is adorned with stunning carvings and vibrant artwork, including a beautifully painted false door and scenes of funerary offerings," the ministry stated. This revelation follows their release of images showcasing the discovery of a 4,000 year old tomb that has illuminated aspects of a ruler's life from four millennia past. Teti Neb Fu's final resting place is a mastaba, characterised by its flat roof and sloping sides, which was common for that historical period. According to the ministry, this discovery provides fresh perspectives on the daily lives and medical practices of the ancient Egyptians. From the evidence unearthed, it appears Teti Neb Fu was no ordinary healer. The inscriptions within his remarkably well-preserved tomb have shed light on the physician's life, revealing that he held a 'complete set of titles', reports the Mirror US. Among these accolades were 'chief doctor of the palace' and 'priest and magician' of the goddess Serket. The tomb was discovered in an area often referred to as the City of the Dead, a site brimming with ancient structures and burial grounds. Like many other ancient Egyptian tombs, this location had already been plundered of its treasures, but the remaining decorations provided the French-Swiss archaeological team enough clues to piece together information about its enigmatic occupant. Researchers speculate that he was likely a specialist in treating snake or scorpion bites, given that Serket was revered as a protector against venomous bites and stings. The Independent reported that this esteemed healer also served as a Royal dentist and as 'director of plant medicine.' His high standing is evident from the numerous significant roles and positions he would have held at the pharaoh's court. The most recent findings from the site are a result of an ongoing dig in Saqqara that began in 2022, with researchers positing that the ancient Egyptian kingdom held both medicine and magic in high esteem. This theory is partly based on Teti Neb Fu's intricate burial and the notion that this civilisation was constantly in pursuit of knowledge. Past discoveries suggest that the ancient Egyptians were striving to comprehend and combat cancer. They also endeavoured to concoct lotions and herbal cures for a variety of ailments.
NBC News
13-07-2025
- NBC News
Hungary's oldest library is fighting to save 100,000 books from a beetle infestation
The abbey at Pannonhalma was founded in 996, four years before the establishment of the Kingdom of Hungary. Sitting upon a tall hill in northwestern Hungary, the abbey houses the country's oldest collection of books, as well as many of its earliest and most important written records. For over 1,000 years, the abbey has been among the most prominent religious and cultural sites in Hungary and all of Central Europe, surviving centuries of wars and foreign incursions such as the Ottoman invasion and occupation of Hungary in the 16th century. Ilona Ásványi, director of the Pannonhalma Archabbey library, said she is "humbled" by the historical and cultural treasures the collection holds whenever she enters. "It is dizzying to think that there was a library here a thousand years ago, and that we are the keepers of the first book catalogue in Hungary," she said. Among the library's most outstanding works are 19 codices, including a complete Bible from the 13th century. It also houses several hundred manuscripts predating the invention of the printing press in the mid-15th century and tens of thousands of books from the 16th century. While the oldest and rarest prints and books are stored separately and have not been infected, Ásványi said any damage to the collection represents a blow to cultural, historical and religious heritage. "When I see a book chewed up by a beetle or infected in any other way, I feel that no matter how many copies are published and how replaceable the book is, a piece of culture has been lost," she said. Books will spend weeks in an oxygen-free environment To kill the beetles, the crates of books are being placed into tall, hermetically sealed plastic sacks from which all oxygen is removed. After six weeks in the pure nitrogen environment, the abbey hopes all the beetles will be destroyed. Before being reshelved, each book will be individually inspected and vacuumed. Any book damaged by the pests will be set aside for later restoration work. Climate change may have contributed The abbey, which hopes to reopen the library at the beginning of next year, believes the effects of climate change played a role in spurring the beetle infestation as average temperatures rise rapidly in Hungary. Hajdu, the chief restorer, said higher temperatures have allowed the beetles to undergo several more development cycles annually than they could in cooler weather. "Higher temperatures are favorable for the life of insects," she said. "So far we've mostly dealt with mold damage in both depositories and in open collections. But now I think more and more insect infestations will appear due to global warming." The library's director said life in a Benedictine abbey is governed by a set of rules in use for nearly 15 centuries, a code that obliges them to do everything possible to save its vast collection. "It says in the Rule of Saint Benedict that all the property of the monastery should be considered as of the same value as the sacred vessel of the altar," Ásványi said. "I feel the responsibility of what this preservation and conservation really means."
Daily Mirror
04-07-2025
- Daily Mirror
Lost plane of legendary pioneer Amelia Earhart 'found' with 'parts spotted'
Amelia Earhart disappeared on July 2, 1937, over the Pacific Ocean en route to Howland Island from Lae, New Guinea, in one of the most enduring mysteries in aviation history Amelia Earhart, the trailblazing American aviator who vanished 88 years ago during her world flight attempt, remains shrouded in mystery. The American pilot Amelia and her navigator Fred Noonan embarked on a historic global trek that took them over the Pacific Ocean. After departing from New Guinea in July 1937, they aimed to touch down on a minuscule island. On July 2, 1937, aviation icon Amelia went missing above the Pacific Ocean – she was expected to arrive at Howland Island, just north of the equator, but she never made it. With cutting-edge technology and satellite imagery now at our disposal, there's a chance we might finally uncover her long-lost aircraft, reigniting the age-old question: What happened to Amelia Earhart? Archaeologist Dr Rick Pettigrew is optimistic that new satellite photos could shed light on this enigma – he's persuaded that the images reveal parts of the lost plane, reports the Mirror US. The remnants of the plane's tail, wing, and fuselage are thought to be resting on an isolated island in the vast Pacific. In a newsreel from July 1936, Amelia spoke about her aircraft, stating: "It's a real flying laboratory equipped with the latest of instruments." She piloted a state-of-the-art Lockheed Electra 10-E when she mysteriously disappeared. At that time, she expressed her ambition: "With it, I hope to accomplish something really scientifically worthwhile for aviation." Yet, merely a year later, Amelia and Mr Noonan vanished without leaving any clues or evidence of a crash landing. Now, archaeologist Mr Pettigrew has developed a theory - after examining the satellite images - he believes they landed on a different island. His hypothesis is that they reached Nikumaroro, an island south of Howland after overshooting Howland Island, their intended destination. Pettigrew described this as 'not a crash landing', but a 'successful landing on the reef with an intact aircraft'. Speaking to WISH TV, he explained: "I think it's likely Amelia was planning to be rescued, refueled, take off again and make it to Hawaii and continue on to California to complete her journey. We know there are radio transmissions from her for a period of about 4 or 5 days. She was basically sending out SOS." United States Navy aircraft scoured the Pacific Ocean back in 1937, but never located Amelia and Fred Noonan. It's thought that weather conditions, sea and tides could have demolished the aircraft over time. Possibly, the fuselage and tail was swept across the expanse of salt water to the far shore, experts such as Pettigrew suggest. If it is Amelia's aircraft it remained hidden for many decades, in 2015 it appears the wreckage was exposed after a cyclone weather event - then the plane parts became visible from space. Pettigrew has now teamed up with Purdue University - they will travel to verify if it's the aircraft - the team will head to the island this November (2025). The Purdue Research Foundation will assist with funding the expedition - Amelia was employed at Purdue University when she vanished in 1937. Pettigrew holds high hopes that this could be the lost aircraft in which Amelia Earhart and her navigator Fred Noonan attempted to circle the globe nearly nine decades ago. Should they confirm the plane's identity this November, a comprehensive excavation will ensue, with plans to return it to the research university.
