Climate Council warns against ‘dumb' proposal to allow forestry on peatlands
planting trees
on peatlands will only increase carbon emissions, the
Climate Change Advisory Council
has warned.
In its annual review of agriculture, land use and forestry, published on Wednesday, the council said: 'Urgent action and strengthened policy levers are required to incentivise increased tree planting to ensure Ireland's forestry sector does not become a source of greenhouse gas emissions.'
The Government's forestry policy is not achieving planting levels needed to meet
climate targets
despite an overhaul in recent years, it stated.
'Current afforestation policy is inadequate to meet our future needs as tree-planting rates remain well below the target of 8,000 hectares per year.' In 2024 the State added just 1,573 hectares of new forest; the lowest number in nearly 80 years.
READ MORE
Minister of State
Michael Healy-Rae
has said it may be necessary to plant trees on deep peatlands to address timber shortages.
But the independent advisory body has concluded that all evidence suggests 'this leads to significant carbon losses over time'. It is, therefore, 'essential that current constraints on afforestation on deep peat remain unchanged and are rigorously enforced', it said.
Mr Healy-Rae told the Seanad in May that he and officials in the Department of Agriculture would look at planting trees on peatland in what would be a reversal of current restrictions.
He suggested the ban on planting trees on deeper peatlands could result in a future shortage of timber, meaning a 'stupid' reliance on Scottish imports.
[
Storm Éowyn's €500m toll on Irish forestry revealed by satellite imagery
Opens in new window
]
In response, leading climate scientist Prof Peter Thorne of Maynooth University, who is chair of the council's adaptation committee, said afforesting peatlands was 'environmental vandalism' and 'about the dumbest thing we can do' from the point of view of climate action.
Commenting on the need for improved performance in the forestry sector, council chair Marie Donnelly said: 'What we have seen in the sector is a failure of policy, with schemes to incentivise more planting not delivering the results required. This has been exacerbated by damage to forests during the winter with Storms Darragh and Éowyn, which resulted in over 26,000 hectares damaged by windthrow.'
There is a need for a policy from Government that will 'actively encourage afforestation in the areas most suited to planting'.
The council highlighted the opportunity for the forestry sector to deliver modern methods of construction, notably expansion of timber frame construction with potential for a strong domestic market for locally-produced timber.
This would reduce significant amounts of carbon, it said, given one cubic metre of timber replacing concrete and steel in construction saves 0.77 tonnes of CO2 emissions. Yet only 24 per cent of building construction in Ireland is timber, compared with more than 80 per cent in Finland, Scotland and Sweden. Building with timber is at cost parity with conventional construction systems.
With emissions from agriculture having decreased by just 1.7 per cent in 2024 relative to 2023, and by 4.6 per cent relative to 2018, the council said an accelerated roll out of proven on-farm measures were required.
With agriculture remaining Ireland's largest source of emissions, it called for 'deployment of methane-reducing manure additives and greater use of protected urea fertilisers', which reduce ammonia loss and greenhouse gases.
[
The Irish Atlantic rainforest pulsing life back into the Beara peninsula
Opens in new window
]
Increasing diversification in farming is critical alongside scaling up biomethane production using anaerobic digesters, it said. 'Implementation of the national biomethane strategy has been piecemeal to date, leading to a worryingly low level of interest in progressing this mitigation option.'
The Government needs to ensure all available instruments, including taxation, regulation and incentives, are in place to enable farmers to make necessary changes to on-farm practices.
'Diversification is vital for the long-term sustainability of the sector, and the Government should set annual targets for the roll out of diversification options including bioenergy, organic productions systems, expanded tillage and agroforestry with policies to support this,' Ms Donnelly said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Search-and-rescue hangar approved for Weston Airport
Weston Airport, part-owned by Stripe co-founder Patrick Collison , has been granted permission to build a new search-and-rescue (SAR) hangar. Following an appeal, including objections from locals, An Bord Pleanála ratified the local council's decision to grant permission for the new infrastructure despite a recommendation from their inspector to reject the planning. The proposed hangar will serve to house the Bristow-operated Dublin search and rescue team, which has been relocated to Weston Airport from Dublin Airport. Hugh Dooley has the details. A €9.4 billion tax and spending package will form the foundation of the upcoming budget , the Government said on Tuesday in the Summer Economic Statement (SES). READ MORE Still, the Coalition warned it may have to 'recalibrate' its strategy, reducing the size of the overall package, if there is a 'deterioration in the tariff landscape' over the coming months. Budget 2026 will include additional spending of €7.9 billion – an increase of 7.3 per cent annually, and well above the Government's 5 per cent spending rule – and tax cuts amounting to €1.5 billion, writes Ian Curran. David McWilliams on how 'big incentives' to build could save Dublin city Listen | 36:51 The big questions arising from the Summer Economic Statement will, however, be about spending, writes Cliff Taylor in his analysis. Restoring control on day-to-day spending will be a big challenge. And if the budget numbers tighten, then the State will face the choice of borrowing to finance its increased investment plans. In the middle of all this is the commitment to billions into two funds each year, to help pay future bills. Reliance, the Cork-headquartered engineering and robotics component distributor where former táinaste Simon Coveney was appointed as a non-executive director earlier this year, reported revenues of close €20 million last year as domestic sales jumped 14 per cent. Accounts filed recently for the Reliance Bearing and Gear Company, which celebrates a century in business this year, reveal turnover climbed by more than 11 per cent to just under €19.6 million in 2024, Ian Curran reports. Some first-time buyers are getting their mortgage wrong, and it's costing them. Stiff competition for homes means being laser focused on getting a loan offer, and fast. However, getting the wrong mortgage could leave you in the wrong house, in the wrong location and on the hook for more debt than necessary. Your mortgage is going to shape your finances for decades to come, so here are the top 10 things you need to get right, writes Joanne Hunt. The correct, writes John McManus in his weekly column, but pretty much politically impossible thing to do about the housing crisis is to level with the electorate and say that fixing the problem is going to take far longer than anyone is prepared to admit. And that it will probably never be fixed if the definition of fixed is that we achieve European levels of housing provision. AIB has moved to require staff eligible for hybrid working to return to its branches and offices three days a week on a phased basis, introducing the tightest rules among Irish retail banks. The new regime will take full effect from the start of 2026, a spokesman said. AIB had more than 10,400 employees at the end of last year. Joe Brennan reports. If you'd like to read more about the issues that affect your finances try signing up to On the Money , the weekly newsletter from our personal finance team, which will be issued every Friday to Irish Times subscribers.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Big spending package advanced despite warnings on numbers becoming tighter
The summer economic statement is normally the Government's key piece of communication before the budget. But this year's comes with a serious health warning. The numbers may be revised, we are told, if the economy is hit by further tariffs. And the tariffs in place already and the Government's budget plans mean that the surplus next year will be 'considerably smaller' than the €6.3 billion anticipated in the forecasts published during the spring. The numbers, in other words, are getting tighter. In this context, it is notable that the Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe and Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers , put forward a planned budget package of a still relatively generous €9.4 billion, including a tax package of €1.5 billion. Spending growth is pencilled in at 7.3 per cent, with a 6.4 per cent rise in day-to-day spending. This may be a reduction from the average of 9.4 per cent-plus seen on average since 2019, but it remains well in advance of inflation. READ MORE Current spending is due to rise by 6.4 per cent next year. In recent years there have been regular overruns and this will be the case again in 2025. Importantly, the Ministers warned that the figures will have to be revised if the tariff situation worsens, as it may well do. So we will have to wait and see what level of tax revenue growth is anticipated next year and what budget surplus the Department of Finance anticipates. [ Tax and spending package of €9.4bn to form basis of Budget 2026 Opens in new window ] This is what will determine whether the budget numbers need to be adjusted – and if so, by how much. In recent years, the basic package has also been extended significantly on budget day by a cost-of-living package, including once-off measures. We are told this will not feature this year, probably. Battles may still lie ahead here. David McWilliams on how 'big incentives' to build could save Dublin city Listen | 36:51 If there is a need to adjust the figures, we are told that protecting capital investment and the large €102 billion five-year programme outlined in the revised National Development Plan will be the priority. Large cuts to State investment during the austerity years after the financial crash have cost the Republic dear. That said, if there is a need to revise the figures, there will surely be tensions. As things stand, some €850 million of the €1.5 billion tax package will be eaten up by the promised cut in the hospitality VAT rate. This will leave small pickings for income tax cuts, unless revenue is raised elsewhere. Applying the VAT cut to just food-based firms, while administratively difficult, would save some of the cash. But political difficulties loom here. [ NDP: €275bn spend over next 10 years, with housing receiving biggest boost Opens in new window ] The big questions will, however, be about expenditure. Restoring control over day-to-day spending will be a big challenge. And if the budget numbers tighten, then the State will face the choice of borrowing to finance its increased investment plans. In the middle of all this is the commitment to billions into two funds each year, to help pay future bills. We still have to see how the Department of Finance sees all this fitting together. The summer economic statement, bar its indications of the budget day package, did not take us much further, except for a warning that if a trade war erupts, then all bets are off.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Whether the abuse happens in Rathfarnham or west Belfast, the story is the same
Last weekend Máiría Cahill left a Belfast hospital bed and drove four hours to speak in the Galway Arts Festival 's First Thought series. As her interviewer, I expected moderate audience interest. It's been 15 years since she first went public in the Sunday Tribune about her alleged rape and abuse as a 16-year-old child by an IRA member and the heinous IRA 'investigation' which forced her to confront her abuser. Eleven years since a pivotal Spotlight BBC documentary on her case. Ten years since the former DPP for England and Wales, Keir Starmer, was asked to review the case and said he was sorry the Public Prosecution Service had let her down, soon followed by the NI Chief Constable's public apology to her and the other two victims after a shambolic trial. Seven years since the Northern Ireland Police Ombudsman revealed how as far back as 2000 CID and Special Branch had intelligence that her alleged abuser, Martin Morris - who had denied all wrongdoing - was abusing children and the IRA were investigating it. READ MORE Two years almost, since her book, Rough Beast: My Story and the Reality of Sinn Féin – described as 'shocking, important and unputdownable' by Roddy Doyle – was published. Yet such was the power of her quiet, measured, devastating delivery to a packed theatre on Saturday that the audience, visibly stunned, rose at the end to give her a thunderous standing ovation. To any other speaker, that visceral response would have been energising, but backstage she was drained to the point of speechlessness. It was a telling insight into the price that abuse victims continue to pay. Part of what continues to make her story so compelling after all this time, of course, is the involvement in that so-called 'investigation' of people with high status in the national political mainstream since that smart, funny 16-year-old girl was groomed, violated, isolated and often terrified for her life. She continues because she believes Sinn Féin leaders have never properly addressed the brutality of those investigations nor the generational reach of that savage misogynistic culture into the communities they ruled. But a larger part of her story is common to almost every case of abuse. It's in the context and the detail. The physical pain, confusion and humiliation, the gaslighting, the sudden shocking hostility of the family or tribe or institution closing ranks to protect itself, the urge to save other potential victims, the sense of a young, innocent mind and body being tested almost to destruction. One of the most agonising elements for any listener is the isolation invariably forced on the victims. No one is coming to help. It wasn't Cahill herself, but women – older Republican women – who 'reported' her complaints to the paramilitaries, despite the fact that they must have known the repercussions for her. Cahill – whose great uncle Joe Cahill founded the Provisional IRA – herself knew what happened to people who gave evidence against the IRA. The resulting sense of isolation for such a child is unimaginable, the damage unfathomable. How such children endure is a mystery. The case of the three remarkable Brennan sisters , Catherine Wrightstone, Paula Fay and Yvonne Crist, finally reached an endpoint in the criminal courts last week when the second of their brothers, Richard Brennan, was jailed for sexual offences against them in the 1970s and 1980s . They describe a childhood of suffocating fear: fear of unstable and violent parents, of their two abusive brothers, of revealing their terrible secrets to outsiders and not only jeopardising the family's reputation but Richard's aspirations for the priesthood, and fear of a wrathful God. In Máiría Cahill's case, her isolation was not rooted in fear of her parents – who still can't bring themselves to read her book – but rational terror of the larger tribe's vengeance. For the Brennan sisters in leafy Rathfarnham, Dublin, their isolation was about protecting reputations. When they tried to advocate for themselves they were failed at every level – by their parents, by the school, by the failure of state bodies to follow up. In 1984, when 12-year-old Catherine disclosed her abuse at Richard's hands to a trusted school connection, her parents were informed and raged at the child in disbelief. Family therapy meetings, organised following a referral by a hospital unable to diagnose the source of Catherine's lower limb disorder, were cut short by the parents. Lash marks on her body were noted by a teacher, but nothing was done. A poignant detail of the sisters' story all these years later is the harrowing internal battle common to many abuse survivors; that they should have found a way to speak out to protect others, even in the face of conditioning from the cradle. How do they endure? In that context it's important to remember the hundreds, maybe thousands, of vulnerable abused girls who are now no more than pawns in the Maga civil war over the Jeffrey Epstein files. Virginia Giuffre , the most prominent Epstein survivor who turned vocal anti-sex trafficking activist, was first abused by a family friend at the age of seven. Then at 15 while working a summer job at Mar-a-Lago was spotted by Ghislaine Maxwell and 'passed around like a platter of fruit' among her and Epstein's friends. Giuffre's multimillion dollar payouts from Prince Andrew, Maxwell and the Epstein estate brought no closure. Amid accusations of mental instability from her estranged husband – whom she accused of violent possessiveness – Giuffre lost custody of their children. She was just 41 when she took her own life in April. And of the long list of names associated with Epstein, Maxwell happens to be the only one serving time.
