logo
HC slaps Rs 1 lakh fine on Punjab for charge-sheeting retd engineer: ‘avoidable' litigation, wasted court time

HC slaps Rs 1 lakh fine on Punjab for charge-sheeting retd engineer: ‘avoidable' litigation, wasted court time

Indian Express3 days ago
Slapping a penalty of Rs 1 lakh on the Punjab government for pursuing what it called 'avoidable' and 'legally untenable' litigation that wasted court's time, the Punjab and Haryana High Court quashed disciplinary proceedings against a former executive engineer by the state Public Works Department (B&R) four years after retirement.
A single bench of Chief Justice Sheel Nagu held that the charge-sheet issued by the Principal Secretary, PWD (B&R), on July 9, 2021, was 'wholly barred' by Rule 2.2(b) of the Punjab Civil Services Rules, Volume II. 'The impugned charge-sheet cannot survive the test of law and has to be quashed on anvil of Rule 2.2(b),' the court said, pointing out that the alleged lapses dated back to 2008–2010, more than 11 years before the issuance of the notice and well beyond the permissible four-year limit for post-retirement proceedings.
Chief Justice Nagu strongly criticised the Punjab government for forcing retired executive engineer Paramjit Singh to litigate to vindicate his rights. 'The precious time of this Court has been wasted in adjudicating this avoidable piece of litigation, which the petitioner was compelled to initiate due to cause given by the respondents in blatant violation of law,' Justice Nagu observed.
24 years of service, charge-sheet after retirement
Appearing for the retired officer, Advocate Sarthak Gupta said Paramjit joined the Punjab PWD (B&R) as sub divisional engineer in July 1993 and rose to the post of executive engineer in January 2008. He retired on December 31, 2017, after 24 years of what he described as unblemished service. Four years later, the 2021 charge-sheet accused him of multiple lapses in handling land acquisition cases during his tenure as executive engineer in Construction Division No. 1, Ferozepur.
The allegations stemmed from a long-standing dispute over land in village Mohan Ke Uttar, Ferozepur. Paramjit was accused of submitting an incorrect report, failing to verify revenue records, and recommending re-acquisition of land without due diligence, allegedly causing a loss of Rs 1.83 crore to the state. The case arose from a civil suit filed in 2000 by one Gurmit Singh, decreed in 2006, which directed compensation or the return of possession. Appeals by the department were dismissed in 2007.
Advocate Gupta contended that Paramjit had acted in good faith and with due diligence, repeatedly seeking records from the Land Acquisition Officer, Jalandhar, the Deputy Commissioner, Ferozepur, and other authorities. Some of these records, the lawyer claimed, dated back to 1965 and were missing or not made available until 2020. Based on the Jamabandis (land records) available at the time, Paramjit recommended acquiring Khasra No. 116, akin to Khasra No. 117, and prepared a draft notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, which was duly approved by competent authorities, his counsel contended.
Advocate Gupta further contended that after Paramjit's transfer in April 2010, the acquisition process continued under his successor and higher officials. In a 2011 meeting, it was reaffirmed that Khasra No. 117 had not been acquired in 1962, prompting proceedings for the acquisition of both parcels. It was only in 2019 that official records surfaced showing the land had, in fact, been acquired in 1962 and compensation already paid, leading to recovery suits filed by the department in 2020.
Terming the case 'de hors the very basic object of Litigation Policy of the State of Punjab,' the court noted that the government had filed 'an affidavit running in 56 pages opposing the claim of petitioner tooth and nail.' This conduct, Justice Nagu said, was 'nothing short of misusing the judicial process.'
The court imposed a cost of Rs 1 lakh on the State, directing it to deposit the amount in the Poor Patients Fund at PGIMER, Chandigarh, and gave the government liberty to recover the sum 'from the salary of the authority issuing the impugned charge-sheet' , in this case, the Principal Secretary, PWD (B&R).
Chief Justice Nagu pointed out, Rule 2.2(b) of the Punjab Civil Services Rules, Volume II, 'places a complete bar for issuance of a charge-sheet when issued after the date of superannuation in regard to any incident which took place four years before the issuance.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

‘Used it as sacred seat for decades': EOW seizes tiger hide from woman during raid in DA case against son in Madhya Pradesh
‘Used it as sacred seat for decades': EOW seizes tiger hide from woman during raid in DA case against son in Madhya Pradesh

Time of India

timean hour ago

  • Time of India

‘Used it as sacred seat for decades': EOW seizes tiger hide from woman during raid in DA case against son in Madhya Pradesh

BHOPAL: A tiger skin gifted by her father-in-law in 1977 has now landed a 70-year-old woman in Jabalpur, MP, behind bars. It resurfaced unexpectedly during an Economic Offences Wing raid at her home, a fallout of an ongoing disproportionate assets case against her son, Jagdish Prasad Sarvate, deputy commissioner in the tribal welfare department. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Savitri Sarvate was arrested under the Wildlife Protection Act by the forest department, and sent to judicial custody on Thursday. She said she was unaware of the legal implications of possessing a tiger skin and had been using it for over four decades as a 'sacred seat' during religious rituals. Forest officer Aniruddha Majumdar and a senior scientist from the State Forest Research Institute, Jabalpur, confirmed the skin was that of a tiger. Measuring 5ft and 5inches in length and 5ft and 3 inches in width, it was handed over to the Special Tiger Task Force. Assets worth Rs 6 cr seized from Sarvate Forest officials said possession of tiger parts, even if acquired decades ago, remains a serious criminal offence under the Indian law if not registered. The tiger skin was just one element of the larger recovery from Sarvate's properties. The EOW raid, which started on July 22, is being conducted at Bhopal, Jabalpur, Sagar and Mandla districts. Valuables and documents worth Rs 19 lakh were seized from the family's ancestral home in Adhartal. A joint locker in the name of Jagdish Prasad and his mother at SBI's Tularam branch yielded gold and silver jewellery worth Rs 18.41 lakh. So far, investigators have unearthed assets worth Rs 6.75 crore linked to Sarvate and his family, vastly disproportionate to his declared income of Rs 1.56 crore. From his govt residence in Sagar, Rs 2.80 lakh was recovered. Fifty-six bottles of liquor, seized from a property in Jabalpur, have been handed over to police.

Rameshwaram Cafe in Bengaluru files complaint alleging blackmail to tarnish brand
Rameshwaram Cafe in Bengaluru files complaint alleging blackmail to tarnish brand

New Indian Express

timean hour ago

  • New Indian Express

Rameshwaram Cafe in Bengaluru files complaint alleging blackmail to tarnish brand

BENGALURU: The Rameshwaram Café has lodged a police complaint against a group of individuals accusing them of attempting to malign the brand and extort money by staging a false incident of food contamination at its Bengaluru airport outlet. A video showing a group of people alleging that they found a worm in a Pongal dish at the outlet in the airport went viral on Thursday. However, the cafe strongly denied the allegation and claimed that the incident was staged to blackmail the brand. In a press statement, the cafe said a group of five-seven people created a disturbance at the outlet on Thursday morning and later demanded Rs 25 lakh to prevent the video from being circulated. The cafe has filed a police complaint and submitted call logs, screenshots and other evidence. Divya Raghav, founder of Rameshwaram Cafe, called the claims 'baseless' and added that similar blackmail attempts had occurred in the past.

Kerala woman cop booked for embezzling Rs 16.76 lakh in traffic fines over four years
Kerala woman cop booked for embezzling Rs 16.76 lakh in traffic fines over four years

New Indian Express

timean hour ago

  • New Indian Express

Kerala woman cop booked for embezzling Rs 16.76 lakh in traffic fines over four years

Altogether, Rs 16.78 lakh was under-reported over this period. During 2018-2022, she served as Writer at the unit and was responsible for handling challans. After 2022 she was transferred from Muvattupuzha Traffic Enforcement Unit. She is currently serving at Vazhakulam police station,' an officer said. After these manipulations were discovered in the recent audit, the Ernakulam Rural Police Chief initiated an internal probe. Following the probe, a case was registered against Shanthi Krishnan, and she was suspended from service, officers confirmed. Police are also probing the involvement of any other cops in the graft. Police officers said that corruption took place before digital system was introduced for issuing challans. 'Earlier, challans were issued manually. After paying the fine amount, a receipt was issued to offenders. The amount was later deposited in the bank on a daily basis. Currently the entire system has been digitised ending such malpractices,' he said. The case was registered under various sections of the IPC and Prevention of Corruption Act. 'We plan to transfer the probe to the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau (VACB) for a detailed investigation. The initial report has already been submitted to VACB,' he said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store