Karun Nair's Comeback Sparks Debate as Sarfaraz Khan, Shreyas Iyer Miss Out On England Tests
As India prepares for a crucial five-match Test series in England starting June 20, the omissions of Sarfaraz Khan and Shreyas Iyer from the squad have triggered plenty of debate. Both batters were widely expected to be part of the team, especially with the retirements of stalwarts Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma. Instead, the selectors opted for Karun Nair, marking a surprise recall after nearly eight years, and handed Sai Sudharsan his maiden call-up. The buzz now is whether Nair's resurgence came at the cost of Sarfaraz and Iyer's Test futures.
The announcement of India's 18-member Test squad for the England tour raised more than a few eyebrows. With two batting spots available due to the recent retirements of Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli, the general belief was that Shreyas Iyer and Sarfaraz Khan – both of whom played for India in the last year – were front-runners. However, in a surprising move, the selectors, led by Ajit Agarkar and head coach Gautam Gambhir, chose to go in a different direction.
Karun Nair, who last played a Test for India in 2017, was recalled following an outstanding domestic season. Meanwhile, Sai Sudharsan was rewarded for consistent performances with a maiden call-up. These selections meant there was no place for Sarfaraz or Iyer, and the decision has since drawn mixed reactions.
Former India pacer Atul Wassan believes the omissions were driven more by perception than performance. Speaking on the 12th episode of Bails and Banter on OTTPlay, Wassan suggested that Sarfaraz and Iyer were overlooked due to doubts about their ability to succeed in English conditions.
'Sarfaraz made three fifties and a hundred but didn't get a single game in Australia. It's this perception that he may not perform overseas. Same with Shreyas Iyer – people feel he hasn't done enough in red-ball cricket,' Wassan said. 'On the other hand, the buzz was all about Karun Nair. Sometimes the team management just backs a gut feeling.'
Sarfaraz had a memorable debut earlier this year, scoring 62 against England before being run out due to a mix-up with Ravindra Jadeja. He backed it up with a 68* in the next innings and went on to score another fifty and his maiden Test century – 150 vs New Zealand in Bengaluru. Despite his performances, he did not feature in a single match in the Australia series and now finds himself out of the squad entirely.
Shreyas Iyer, on the other hand, last played a Test during the England series before a back injury sidelined him. While he returned strongly in white-ball cricket – playing a key role in India's Champions Trophy win – his red-ball spot remains elusive. His exclusion from BCCI's central contracts list earlier this year had already hinted at his uncertain Test future.
Karun Nair, meanwhile, made a strong case with 863 runs in nine Ranji Trophy matches and 779 runs in the Vijay Hazare Trophy. His consistent form seems to have convinced the selectors to give him another shot in the longest format.
Listen to the latest songs, only on JioSaavn.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
20 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
No end to Pakistan's musical chair; Azhar Mahmood appointed acting Test coach after Aqib's woeful ouster
There is no end to the musical chairs within the support staff of the Pakistan men's cricket team. On Monday, the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) confirmed the appointment of Azhar Mahmood as the acting red-ball coach. The former Pakistan all-rounder takes over the new role following a long stint as the bowling and assistant coach of the men's side. The Pakistan Cricket Board confirmed the appointment of Azhar Mahmood as the acting Test coach. (AFP) Azhar Mahmood will stay in the role of acting Test coach until the conclusion of his current contract. The 50-year-old takes over from Aaqib Javed as the Test coach. Aaqib Javed had taken over as the Pakistan Test coach on an interim basis after Jason Gillespie stepped down following disagreements with Javed and the PCB. "A seasoned cricketing mind, Azhar Mahmood steps into the role with an impressive portfolio of experience. Having served as the assistant head coach of the national side, Azhar has long been a pivotal part of the team's strategic core. His deep knowledge of the game, combined with hands-on international exposure and proven success in the English county circuit, make him exceptionally well-suited for this position," the PCB said in an official release. Also Read: Ex-Pakistan Test head coach Jason Gillespie takes brutal dig at PCB chairman Mohsin Naqvi "His red-ball pedigree is underscored by two County Championship titles—an achievement that speaks volumes about his leadership, tactical acumen and unwavering commitment to excellence. The PCB is confident that under Azhar's guidance, the red-ball squad will continue to grow in strength, discipline and performance on the global stage," the statement added. Mahmood's first assignment as Test coach Mahmood's first task as the Test coach will be to ready the side for their upcoming World Test Championship (WTC) assignment against South Africa. The Proteas will tour Pakistan for a two-match Test series later this year. Pakistan has failed to make it to the final of the WTC three times in a row. In the last WTC cycle, Pakistan finished at the bottom of the standings. The hosts defeated England at home, but they lost the series against Bangladesh. Pakistan also faced defeat in the away series against South Africa. Earlier, Gary Kirsten had also stepped down as Pakistan's white-ball coach. "It was a tumultuous few months. I realised quite quickly I wasn't going to have much of an influence. Once I was taken off selection and asked to take a team and not be able to shape the team, it became very difficult as a coach then to have any sort of positive influence on the group," Kirsten told Wisden.
The Hindu
37 minutes ago
- The Hindu
IND Women vs ENG women 2nd T20I: India hopes for Mandhana encore, Harmanpreet availability against England
A confident India will aim to capitalise on opener Smriti Mandhana's sublime form and hope for skipper Harmanpreet Kaur's availability to achieve another big win when the second Women's T20I against England is played in Bristol on Tuesday (July 1, 2025). Mandhana's maiden T20I century in the opening game at Nottingham guided India to a massive 97-run win, and the likely presence of skipper Harmanpreet — who was rested for the first game as a precautionary measure following a head injury sustained during a warm-up match — for the second game would only add to the hosts' worries. Mandhana's stroke-filled century would have rung alarm bells in the English camp as it tries to find answers to the dramatic batting collapse it suffered while chasing a steep 210-run total. It was a day when Mandhana's entertaining innings brought the hosts under tremendous pressure, which was later exploited by the Indian bowlers. India struck twice early and the slow bowler, especially left-arm spinner Shree Charani who grabbed four wickets in her maiden T20I, complete the demolition job. Mandhana, who led the T20I run-scoring charts last year, seemed to have picked up from where she had left off, smashing all the English bowlers with impunity. Though the left-handed batter said after the match that the T20I format wasn't her forte, it was a statement the cricket experts would take with a pinch of salt. The India vice-captain's power-hitting was on full display as she collected most of her boundaries on the off-side, while her three maximums came on the on-side. The long camp in Bengaluru followed by their early arrival in England and a couple of tour matches seem to have helped the Indian players get into the rhythm of the shortest format as they showed no signs of rustiness in Nottingham. India looked like a well-knit unit despite missing their premier seamers, Renuka Singh Thakur and Pooja Vastrakar, who are injured. Harleen Deol at No. 3 looked the right call as she forged a 94-run stand for the second wicket with Mandhana to set up the platform for a big total. While the bilateral white-ball series may not have immediate implications, it will certainly give the young Indian players the look and feel of the things to come when the T20 World Cup is held next year in England. And, the 20-year-old debutant Shree Charani did really well in her maiden outing, delivering a dream spell of 3.5-0-12-4 to set up India's win by displaying a lot of discipline and focus to strangle the England batters. England skipper Nat Sciver-Brunt (66) waged a lone battle even as Indian spinners enjoyed a cakewalk, with Deepti Sharma and Radha Yadav too chipping in with a couple of wickets each. Squads: India: Harmanpreet Kaur (c), Yastika Bhatia (wk), Harleen Deol, Richa Ghosh (wk), Jemimah Rodrigues, Shafali Verma, Amanjot Kaur, Sneh Rana, Sayali Satghare, Deepti Sharma, Kranti Goud, Arundhati Reddy, Shree Charani, Radha Yadav. England: Natalie Sciver-Brunt (c), Tammy Beaumont (wk), Sophia Dunkley, Amy Jones (wk), Danni Wyatt-Hodge, Alice Capsey, Charlie Dean, Paige Scholfield, Em Arlott, Lauren Bell, Sophie Ecclestone, Lauren Filer, Linsey Smith, Issy Wong. Match starts at 11:00pm IST.
India Today
39 minutes ago
- India Today
Can Kuldeep Yadav dismantle England? India's spin gamble against Bazball in Birmingham
The fearless English Test side has rewritten the rules, but at Edgbaston, they face an Indian team desperate to respond after a bruising loss in Leeds. With Jasprit Bumrah likely sidelined, the big question is whether India have the firepower—and the right mix—to strike England steamrolled India in the first Test at Headingley, Leeds, several experts criticised the team management for a questionable selection. While the pace trio struggled to support spearhead Bumrah, it was Shardul Thakur who drew the most criticism for his lack of impact after being chosen as the sole medium pace-bowling managed scores of 1 and 4 across two innings and claimed just two wickets from 16 overs, conceding runs at an economy rate of 5.56. Numerous pundits have urged the management to bench the seam all-rounder and instead include Kuldeep Yadav, a proven wicket-taking option, in the Playing XI for the second Test at Edgbaston, Birmingham. Following the retirement of Ravichandran Ashwin, Kuldeep is now the second-most experienced spinner in the squad and could offer a touch of mystery to England's Bazballers with his variation and dominance over EnglandThe left-arm wrist-spinner has taken 21 wickets in six matches (11 innings) against England at an impressive average of 22.28, including one five-wicket haul. Kuldeep was a key figure in England's only series defeat under the Ben Stokes–Brendon McCullum regime—during their 2024 tour of 30-year-old was instrumental in outfoxing England's hard-hitting batters throughout the series as he amassed 19 wickets from four matches, including a Player of the Match performance in the fifth Test in Dharamsala with match figures of 7/ struggles against Kuldeep are not limited only to Tests, as he has also troubled them in the white-ball formats. The southpaw has eight wickets from three T20Is against the Three Lions at an average of 9.62 with best figures of 5/24. In ODIs, he has 14 scalps from nine matches to his name with best figures of 6/ the air and taken by Jasprit Bumrah!Kuldeep Yadav with the final wicketEnd of the match and series in DharamsalaScorecard | #INDvENG | @IDFCFIRSTBank BCCI (@BCCI) March 9, 2024How have spinners fared at Edgbaston?Kuldeep has had the wood over England across formats, making his case for selection even stronger for the second Test. Moreover, Edgbaston is counted amongst one of the most spin-friendly venues in England as spinners average 34.17 at the ground — the best in the 21st century for any venue in England with a minimum of eight would also like to take some inspiration from his idol Shane Warne, if he indeed gets a chance to feature in the Playing XI, who has ruled the roost every time he's played at Edgbaston. The 'King of spin' has wreaked havoc at the venue, being the most successful spinner with 25 wickets from four matches at an average of 21.76 with three five-wicket hauls and one ten-wicket haul to his success indicates how a wrist spinner can use the conditions to the best of his advantage at Edgbaston. Moreover, England's attacking mindset will keep Kuldeep in play throughout the several factors may back Kuldeep's selection, his lack of experience in SENA (South Africa, England, New Zealand and Australia) countries doesn't paint a promising picture. With just four matches under his belt away from home, he's had only two appearances outside of Asia, one each in England and Australia, bagged a five-wicket haul during the fourth Test of the Border-Gavaskar Trophy 2018-19 in Sydney vs Australia. However, Kuldeep didn't have a memorable outing in his only Test in England as he remained wicketless from his nine overs at Lord's in 2018.!R Ashwin Kuldeep YadavFollow the match #TeamIndia | #INDvENG | @ashwinravi99 | @imkuldeep18 | @IDFCFIRSTBank BCCI (@BCCI) March 7, 2024advertisementMisfiring tail to impact the decision?There are a variety of factors which are likely to be taken into consideration before picking him in the XI. India's lower order struggled massively to add crucial runs in both innings of the first Test as the team lost their last seven wickets for 41 runs in the first the second innings, India lost their last six wickets for just 31 runs and failed to extend their lead to post a daunting target for England in the fourth innings. The failure of the lower order culminated in India's loss as they became the first team in the history of the game to lose a Test match after registering five Kuldeep not being a reliable tailender with the bat, it could prove to be a massive gamble for India, given how England have pinch hitters in their lineup right from top to bottom. However, if India have to deflate England, they will also have to reply with an attacking mindset and go for wickets at all costs as runs are not going to dry up even after the tail is best bet to stop the Bazball mayhem could well be the mystery of Kuldeep Yadav. The wrist spinner has the backing of the entire cricketing fraternity to play in the second Test. Now it's up to head coach Gautam Gambhir and captain Shubman Gill to use their secret weapon, or he will continue to rot on the bench as the series slips away.- EndsMust Watch
