Council's bin rummaging plan sparks 'nothing better to do' jibe
Recycling teams in a Welsh county will sift through residents' bins in an effort to increase recycling rates. Caerphilly County Council's recycling advisory teams could impose £70 fines on repeat offenders who dispose of recyclable materials in their general waste bins. North Wales Live readers have had their say on the whole plan.
Fines will only be implemented as a last resort if previous attempts to engage and educate repeat offenders prove unsuccessful. Councillor Chris Morgan, cabinet member for waste, informed colleagues that the county's residents are producing 410kg of residual waste each year, compared to a national average of 360kg.
Research conducted in 2023 discovered that 59% of the contents of general waste bins were actually recyclable. Failure to meet national recycling targets could result in multimillion-pound fines from the Welsh Government.
Speaking at a cabinet meeting, the council's waste strategy officer Hayley Jones stated that teams had "engaged with several thousand residents" on the existing recycling scheme, which coincided with a significant increase in food waste collections.
"As well as the positive impact that removing the material would have... there are significant financial savings that can be achieved, particularly if we can divert food waste," she said. "This is due to the fact that sending food waste for anaerobic digestion is cheaper than incinerating general waste."
Council leader Sean Morgan added: "When we are using the anaerobic facility it's a real circular economy because it's in our county borough."
PedroD says: 'If it wasn't that a proportion of waste collected correctly for re-cycling ends up in landfill anyway, then this may be just.'
Thewokearefastasleep predicts: 'No doubt it will cost the council more to operate than it will save through correcting any incorrect separation.'
Steamnut thinks: 'There is still a lot of confusion about packaging. The clear film on food containers is currently not recyclable whereas the container it was the cover for is. Some products - usually in very small print - say 'generally recyclable'. If the council is going to start handing out fines after having a time-consuming rummage then we need clarity on what is and is not recyclable.'
Jonesey1 agrees: 'Many times I've put plastics that aren't the usual household food packaging (power tool casings and other hard plastics) in the plastics recycling box. Sometimes the binmen leave them in the box so we just let them sit in there until the next week's collection and they magically disappear into the recycling wagon. I think it might depend on how diligent they're feeling as to whether or not the 'unrecyclable' recyclables are taken.'
Toxteth O'Grady adds: 'What if someone uses your bin without your knowledge as they're likely to do on certain streets?'
Pete Watson replies: 'Just because the wrong item is in a bin doesn't mean the householder put it in there. So unless there is a direct evidential link between the item and the householder then any fine will successfully be challenged.'
Nerys Dumbell said: "Have they nothing better to do like clearing up the rubbish that gets blown out the bins? There are tins and plastic wrappers everywhere and they just leave it!"
Tina Thompson replies: 'This will be a huge health and safety risk for the guys who collect the bins. You never know what will be in the bins.'
Helen Job points out: 'The crews are already stretched and sometimes it's not always clear if something is recyclable or not. £70 for an honest mistake won't go down well with residents. Why not ask the binmen to put the recyclable item in the correct bin if they find it in the general waste bin?'
Caroline Hartley writes: 'It's not a legal requirement for domestic waste to be recycled, it is a legal requirement for companies/ businesses to recycle. Maybe the council should focus on some of the bin collectors and wagons who drop rubbish from bins and don't pick it up. They leave recycling boxes in the roads or slide them down the path damaging them.'
Sue Davenport replies: 'It's staggering the cheek of our Councils expecting us to do their refuse sorting work for them whilst charging us higher and higher rates of Council Tax for the privilege.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
33 minutes ago
- Wales Online
Welsh Government wants black bin bags to be collected just once a month
Welsh Government wants black bin bags to be collected just once a month New guidance issued by the Welsh Government says that black bag waste should be collected from homes every three to four weeks The new guidance says a limit of 60 litres of black waste is "sufficient" The Welsh Government has recommended that black bag waste should be collected from households only once every three to four weeks. In newly issued guidance for councils, the government states that "collection once every three to four weeks is sufficient and more frequent collection should be avoided so that it does not undermine the effectiveness of the recycling service provided". The Collections Blueprint 2025 document outlines that a weekly limit of 60 litres of black waste per household is "sufficient", noting that a standard wheelie bin has a capacity of 240 litres. The document emphasises that the Welsh Government's advised approach is "for all aspects of collection (household recycling and waste collections, reuse and recycling centres, bring sites, bulky collections, non-household recycling and waste collections, and litter collections) to be managed in an integrated way to deliver high-quality resource and management services at the lowest practicable unit costs". Regarding residual waste – the black bag waste – the document points out that "with increased recycling and less material going into disposal significantly less residual capacity is needed". It also suggests that Wales' 22 councils should consider implementing waste weighing "for data collection for residual collections" and stresses that black waste policies should be "actively enforced", with "clear policies in place for households that require additional capacity". There are variations throughout Wales regarding the collection of black waste. Cardiff sees collections every fortnight, whereas Newport, the Vale, and Rhondda Cynon Taf have a three-week interval. Article continues below In Conwy, residents wait four weeks for their black waste to be collected. You can explore the differences between councils here. A document has outlined recommendations for local authorities on nappy collections, garden waste, bulky item collections, and food waste management. It advocates for weekly food waste collections and insists that food waste bags should be provided free of charge. When it comes to "dry recycling" – which includes paper and cardboard; plastic bottles, pots, tubs, and trays; metal tins, cans, aerosols, and foil; cartons and other paper-based composite products; as well as glass jars and bottles – the preference is for items to be sorted at the kerbside rather than being mixed. These materials should be collected on a weekly basis. The guidance suggests that items should be inspected upon collection to ensure "the lowest possible contamination". This means unsuitable or dirty items would be rejected on the spot, with residents informed immediately. The recommendation is for households to receive three or more "preferably reusable, dry recycling containers" to keep recyclables separate. Local councils are also encouraged to establish repair and reuse shops to promote recycling. Furthermore, council recycling centres, according to the document, should aim for "at least 85% recycling and reuse". Wales boasts an impressive record in recycling, leading the UK and ranking second globally, just behind Austria. "An increasing proportion of waste managed by local authorities in Wales is being sent for preparing for reuse, recycling, or composting," the document states. The document indicates that 15 of Wales' 22 councils offer the recommended collection service and two additional councils are transitioning to it. Moreover, the document advises that councils ought to provide segregated litter bins to facilitate public recycling on-the-go and implement clear signage to indicate the correct disposal methods. Welsh Conservative MS Janet Finch-Saunders said: "We want the most straightforward waste collection service in the world for Wales. We need regulations brought forward to simplify waste collection for residents and businesses in Wales. 'With council tax rising year after year while services are being cut, people in Wales are right to question where their money is going and why they're being asked to do more with less." Article continues below A Welsh Government spokesman said: "The collections blueprint guidance to our local authorities has been a core part of our success in reaching second in the world for recycling. This version updates the blueprint in line with best practice and to cover the further enhancement of services, including the roll-out of repair and reuse. "As our local authority recycling services have improved and expanded, it increases the amount of household material recycled and collected as a valuable resource to go back into the economy, whilst reducing the amount of material needing costly disposal in black bins or bags which is wasted.' 'As a result, our environment benefits from a reduction in emissions and the use of raw materials, our economy benefits from the recycled materials collected, and our local authorities benefit from a reduction in the costly disposal of black bag waste.'
Metro
12 hours ago
- Metro
Rare new statue of black woman unveiled in London - who is she?
A rare new statue of a black woman who has been 'hidden in history' has been unveiled for Londoners to make wishes at. The statue of Mary Woolaston has been erected after it was found there were only three permanent statues of black women in London. She was said to be a 17th century woman in King's Cross, who kept a well with the ability to people's eyes. Now, made from St Bees sandstone and carved by Marcia Bennett-Male, the only black female stone carver in the UK, Mary has been brought back to he heart of London in Cowthorpe Community Gardens. Lead artist Gaylene Gould told Metro: 'There are glimpses of Mary in the history books, but some people still deny she exists. 'There is one argument suggesting she was actually a black cow, or a nun just wearing a habit, but we want to breathe life into her. 'But she now stands to represent working class women, particuarly those of colour, who have never had history written properly about her.' The statue has been placed in Cowthorpe, next to a stream which runs through a small community garden in the middle of high rises. Around her, the previously disused area has been transformed into a pleasure garden to try and create a space which Mary would have thrived in. 'As I was walking through the area, I just immediately knew, 'this is Mary's well',' Gaylene said. 'We want Londoners to be able to pause just for a moment, offer wishes, prayers.' The idea to create a statue of Mary has been in the back of Gaylene's mind for years. But after the Covid pandemic erupted and people were ordered to keep to a more solitary existence, plans were put into action. She said: 'All of a sudden there was a big threat to our survival, and people were without a community. 'But there were people who were voluntarily still trying to keep their areas alive and connected, such as gardeners and keepers. We want to honour them.' Funding to create the statue was granted by the Mayor of London's office who started a project to increase diversity in the public realm. It was commissioned in 2020 to highlight previously untold stories for London's diverse histories. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: Why 'big hairy' Welsh miners led London Pride in 1985 MORE: Patient who threw bricks at paramedics and smashed ambulance avoids jail MORE: I'm a shopping writer and here's what I'm buying this week – from Berghaus to Skin Rocks
Wales Online
20 hours ago
- Wales Online
Confidence that Llanharan bypass work will start as soon as possible
Confidence that Llanharan bypass work will start as soon as possible The council leader says it is a priority and that he is confident it will start in earnest once it gets planning permission Cold and frosty weather in Llanharan, as all of Wales will be feeling colder (Image: WalesOnline/Rob Browne ) The Llanharan bypass is a 'priority' for RCT council with the leader saying he's confident work will start in earnest once it gets planning permission and a contractor is appointed. Councillor Andrew Morgan was responding to a question from Brynna and Llanharan councillor Janine Turner at Rhondda Cynon Taf full council on Wednesday, June 25 who said that the statement earlier this year that the Llanharan Sustainable Transport Corridor had been given the go-ahead following a redesign was very welcome news. She asked the leader for update on the progress made since then and to outline some of the key steps for the scheme to be delivered. Cllr Morgan said the scheme was a priority for the council and that there had been a lot of work going on in the background to take it forward. The council has allocated £5.05m in the capital programme towards the project. He said the scheme had been 'redefined' in terms of embedding sustainable transport policies while still seeking to take the bulk of the traffic out of Llanharan. Article continues below The scheme was delayed because of the roads review by Welsh Government but the council has now had the green light to take it forward. To get all the latest politics, health and education news, sign up to our Wales Matters newsletter. The council is working on a funding package but the next key stage is that the pre-planning application consultation is expected to start during September and October. All the consultation documents will be made available online and in person at Llantrisant Leisure Centre from September 19 to October 17 with consultation days to be organised in Llanharan itself in October. Cllr Morgan said the road scheme is very much in line with what they previously looked at in terms of the corridor and it doesn't deviate much from that but has just been redesigned in terms of things like landscaping and drainage. He said 'what that does mean is that we substantially reduce in-built carbon' which will be close to 20,000 tonnes and the ancient woodland has been protected. They've also looked at junctions and making sure there's a good flow of buses and that they don't get caught up in traffic. 'There's an awful lot of small changes but the primary thing is the scheme is going ahead as far as we're concerned. We will need to get planning permission. 'We are in conversation with Welsh Government. We are committed to this in terms of using some CIL (community infrastructure levy) funding from the housing development down there and committing our own funds.' He also said they'd secured some further money around the active travel element. Article continues below Cllr Morgan said that once they do get planning and appoint a contractor 'I am confident the scheme will start in earnest'.
