![[UPDATED] Govt's Pre-Q procurement method lacks transparency, Auditor General finds](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fassets.nst.com.my%2Fimages%2Farticles%2FGovtProcurement21_NSTfield_image_socialmedia.var_1753070913.jpg&w=3840&q=100)
[UPDATED] Govt's Pre-Q procurement method lacks transparency, Auditor General finds
Auditor-General Datuk Wan Suraya Wan Mohd Radzi said open tenders were better to ensure transparency and accountability in procurement.
The recommendation was made following findings in the Auditor-General's Report 2/2025, which uncovered manipulation and a lack of transparency in the Pre-Q process introduced by the Finance Ministry in 2023 and 2024.
"Some companies that failed to meet the initial evaluation criteria were still invited to participate and were even selected during the final round," she said in a statement.
The report audited the use of the Pre-Q method in several ministries, including the Energy Transition and Water Transformation Ministry, the Rural and Regional Development Ministry, and the Works Ministry.
At the Energy Transition and Water Transformation Ministry, a tender process involving the procurement of a government office building project saw the selection of a contractor who had failed to meet the requirements in the first stage of screening.
The audit found that a company which had not completed its Pre-Q application properly, including failing to provide mandatory supporting documents, was still allowed to advance to the second stage of evaluation.
Despite receiving a "Not Recommended" status from the technical evaluation committee, the company was still invited to participate in the second stage and was eventually awarded the project.
At the Rural and Regional Development Ministry, a tender process involving the procurement of a government office building project saw the selection of a contractor who had failed to meet technical requirements in the first stage of screening.
Despite not complying with the technical capability criteria, the project was still allowed to advance to the second stage of evaluation.
The ministry's internal justifications for allowing this were not in line with the Treasury's Pre-Q procurement circulars.
Wan Suraya warned that such deviations could result in "non-compliant decisions that jeopardise the credibility of procurement exercises."
The auditor-general concluded that the Pre-Q procurement method, as implemented, had failed to meet its original objectives of screening for quality and improving competition.
"Some companies that failed to meet the initial evaluation criteria were still invited to participate and were even selected during the final round," said Wan Suraya.
She recommended that the Finance Ministry consider abolishing the method altogether and reverting to the open tender approach to safeguard the integrity of government procurement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malaysiakini
2 hours ago
- Malaysiakini
Don't insult rakyat by saying PM trying to buy votes
MP SPEAKS | It seems to me that some people are determined to find fault with whatever initiatives that Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim and the government carry out for the benefit of the people. This is clear after the several major initiatives including the one-off RM100 grant under the Rahmah Necessities Aid (Sara) programme, the delay in toll hikes for 10 highways, and the lower RON95 petrol price subsidy at RM1.99 per litre. We have stable growth, inflation, low unemployment rates, high foreign investment volume, and good EPF rates. We are bouncing back from Covid-19 and the economic mismanagement of previous administrations, such as the recession-ridden days of Muhyiddin Yassin. Just imagine my annoyance at reading false claims that the latest initiatives are ill-advised handouts and wastage designed to buy the people's votes at the next election. I wonder if the critics would be happier if the government did not try to help the people at all! Despite the good figures, these are difficult and unpredictable times with international tariffs and sales and services tax (SST), electricity tariffs also making possible impacts on the economy. There are difficult decisions that have to be made, because of the corruption and economic mismanagement of the past. So, when the government tries to give the people a buffer, why complain? Elite entitlement We are trying and have succeeded in combating the fiscal deficit, improving governance, and restoring investor confidence over the past two and a half years. One of the main initiatives is the expansion of the Sara programme, which will benefit 22 million citizens aged 18 and above, with an allocation of RM2bil. This is across the board and eligible Malaysians can redeem the one-off RM100 Sara aid credited to their MyKad at over 4,000 participating outlets nationwide to purchase essential goods, such as rice and eggs. So, the critics are upset, saying that this is nothing. To me it reflects the privilege and entitlement of the elite to fail to recognise that these contributions will mean something, especially to those in the B40. Let's not forget that aside from the expanded Sara programme, the government is also doubling the allocation for the Rahmah Sales programme from RM300mil to RM600 mil. Then how about the reduced RON95 petrol price, from the current rate to RM1.99 per litre, with the mechanism to be detailed by the Finance Ministry. Surely this will help us all, by easing the burden on the people and increasing the cash flow in the economy. Reducing fuel prices shows the government is committed to inducing growth and restoring some imbalances, particularly as in the long term the strategy is to have targeted subsidies on fuel prices. Greater economic programme All this is part of a greater economic programme with the 13th Malaysia Plan scheduled to be tabled on July 31, followed by Budget 2026 in October. So, we know that the opposition wants to disrupt the progress, but we don't mind, we are committed to peaceful assembly for rallies like 'Turun Anwar'. We know that some columnists and cybertroopers are being paid to attack our initiatives and confuse the people, but we are committed to freedom of speech. We know that some try to divide us on the basis of race and religion, but we remain committed to a progressive and prosperous Malaysia for all. R YUNESWARAN is the Segamat MP. The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of Malaysiakini.
Focus Malaysia
3 hours ago
- Focus Malaysia
How would a tycoon spend his RM100 'extraordinary tribute for Malaysians' gift from PMX?
Editor's Note: Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim has reminded all parties not to belittle the RM100 additional cash aid for Malaysian citizens aged 18 and above under the Sumbangan Asas Rahmah (Sara) programme. '(Critics say) it's just RM100 but you're earning RM40,000 or RM20,000 a month. Of course, RM100 means nothing to you but I know its value when we go to the villages,' PMX who is also Finance Minister said told the Finance Ministry's assembly in Putrajaya yesterday (July 24). He went on to explain that for a poor household with two adult children and a married couple, the cash assistance would total RM400 which when combined with the existing Sumbangan Tunai Rahmah (STR), the amount could increase to as much as RM700. '… so don't trivialise these efforts because this is what we (the government) can do to add to the existing allocation from RM13bil to RM15bil,' added PMX. I ASKED a billionaire Tan Sri through WhatsApp the following question: 'Apologies. Seriously what do you plan to do with the RM100 SARA (Sumbangan Asas Rahmah) cash aid the Prime Minister gave?' He answered with two emojis; a thumbs up and thank you. RM100 isn't much considering that he is worth more than RM3 bil, according to Forbes. The richest of them all – Robert Kuok Hock Nien – is worth RM48.8 bil. Love to see media coverage of Robert Kuok Hock Nien and other billionaires, pushing shopping carts to buy RM100 worth of groceries – either for themselves or to be donated to the poor. This would certainly be an award-winning media coverage. I'm not sure if a recipient is allowed to give his or her MyKad to a trustee to shop on his or her behalf. If this is allowed, the rich who are too bashful to be seen shopping for RM100 worth of groceries at Mydin or Econsave can get their bodyguards or amah (house helpers) to do the shopping for them. This would also be helpful to the old and the invalid who cannot do the shopping themselves. These are the people who are truly entitled to this state-funded sadaqah (voluntary charitable giving in Islam). It would also be beneficial in the long term if recipients are given an option to credit the RM100 into their government-sponsored unit trust like the Amanah Saham Bumiputera (ASB) and Amanah Saham Malaysia (ASM). A digital facility should also be established to enable overseas Malaysians to benefit from this Madani generosity. They can use their RM100 Madani SARA to buy groceries for donation. Or the unclaimed SARA be put in a pool for the benefit of the needy such as residents of charity homes and the homeless. An AI search points to reports indicating an increasing trend of elderly parents being abandoned by their children in our country. This includes cases of parents being left at hospitals, care centres or even religious institutions with little to no support from their families. The case of anak derhaka (disobedient children). – July 25, 2025 National journalism laureate Datuk A. Kadir Jasin was formerly the group editor-in-chief of mainstream New Straits Times. The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia.
![BTH: Auditor General's Report, PAC action & pro-rakyat relief [WATCH]](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fassets.nst.com.my%2Fassets%2FNST-Logo%402x.png%3Fid%3Db37a17055cb1ffea01f5&w=48&q=75){kind=small}
New Straits Times
6 hours ago
- New Straits Times
BTH: Auditor General's Report, PAC action & pro-rakyat relief [WATCH]
KUALA LUMPUR: The latest Auditor-General's Report 2/2025 has reignited debate over public sector accountability, with findings highlighting recurring issues of financial mismanagement, procurement irregularities, and enforcement lapses across several ministries and agencies. The latest episode Beyond the Headlines, discussed how the report has triggered swift responses from the government, with Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim instructing all ministers to thoroughly act on the audit findings. Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Law and Institutional Reform), Datuk Seri Azalina Othman Said, stated the administration takes the matter seriously, citing leakages, regulatory non-compliance, and weak planning as issues that "must be corrected and not repeated." Transparency International Malaysia (TI-M) also weighed in, warning that the recurrence of such failures signals deep-rooted governance breakdowns. While TI-M welcomed recent amendments to the Audit Act 1957 — including real-time monitoring through the Auditor General's Dashboard — they cautioned that structural reform must go beyond dashboards and enforcement. Public Accounts Committee (PAC) deputy chairmanTeresa Kok joined us on set to address the PAC's role in prioritising cases for review, ensuring accountability, and proposing long-term reforms. More in the latest episode of Beyond the Headlines. Watch on NST Online's YouTube Channel
