2025 Fantasy Baseball rest-of-season rankings: Starting Pitchers
Pitchers are the sirens of fantasy baseball, forever teasing us and misleading us. Most pitchers, even the best of them, are constantly tinkering with their approach, their arsenal, their mechanics. And of course, throwing a baseball is a very unnatural act, so you never know who's the next pitcher to need downtime — or a lost season.
You want to make the fantasy baseball gods laugh? Rank the pitchers.
ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
And that's what the Shuffle Up series aims to do. What's below is a set of salaries that reflect how I would price the starting pitching market if I were entering a fresh draft today, or considering pickups or trades. What's happened to this point is merely an audition.
[Smarter waivers, better trades, optimized lineups — Yahoo Fantasy Plus unlocks it all]
The salaries are a combination of stats to this point, observations, gut feel and special sauce. You'll have many disagreements, of course, because that's why we have a game. I did a courtesy rank of the currently-injured pitchers at the bottom, but I will not discuss or debate that part of the list. Everyone can decide for themselves what a hurt pitcher is worth.
In the weeks to follow, we will shuffle other positions. Assume a 5x5 scoring system, and away we go.
The Big Tickets
$29 Tarik Skubal
$27 Paul Skenes
$25 Zack Wheeler
$24 Michael King
$24 Garrett Crochet
$23 Hunter Brown
$23 Yoshinobu Yamamoto
$23 Bryan Woo
$22 Hunter Greene
$22 Cole Ragans
$21 Logan Webb
$21 Jacob deGrom
$20 Max Fried
$20 Joe Ryan
$20 Chris Sale
ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
So far, so good with the new version of deGrom, the so-called "dial it back" ace. His fastball is down a tick to 96.9 mph, which is intentional. The Rangers have been proactive in getting deGrom out of games, only pushing him past 90 pitches once.
I know there's no universal way to save the pitcher in the modern game, but when Texas quickly lifted deGrom with huge leads in his last two starts, I nodded my head. It's prudent. The strikeout rate has dropped and the walk rate is up, though 2.13 BB/9 is still excellent. There's also been an uptick in ground balls.
If this is the trade-off that has to happen, and we merely accept deGrom as a strong pitcher and not a demigod who separates himself, I can live with that. I'm just glad we can watch him every five days, and he hasn't had any setbacks.
ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Fried has been a godsend for the Yankees thus far, but see the story for what it is. His expected ERA is 3.27, much higher than the 1.01 on the back of the card. His ground-ball rate bails him out of trouble and he doesn't walk many batters, but the strikeout rate is merely average. He's getting positive results from his four primary pitches, with the cutter notably improved this year. His ratios from his last two Atlanta years are still the way to bet.
Legitimate Building Blocks
$19 Freddy Peralta
$18 Nick Pivetta
$18 Carlos Rodón
$18 Framber Valdez
$17 Nathan Eovaldi
$17 Dylan Cease
$17 MacKenzie Gore
$16 Jesús Luzardo
$16 Seth Lugo
$15 Kodai Senga
$15 Luis Castillo
$15 Pablo López
$14 Bailey Ober
$14 Kris Bubic
$13 Spencer Schwellenbach
$13 Zac Gallen
Gore has long been viewed as a future ace; maybe that future is now. His walk and strikeout rates are moving in the right direction. The batted-ball profile validates his early ratios, and his Savant page is a glorious display of red sliders pushed to the right. It's interesting that, for his career, he has reverse splits — lefties hit him better than righties — but it's nothing to be alarmed about. I wish the Washington defense were better, but Gore misses so many bats, he doesn't need as much help as the average pitcher. He's occupying a slot much higher than whatever you projected in March. This feels legit.
ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Is Lugo the most underrated starting pitcher in baseball? He's been a full-time rotation guy since 2023, with these returns: 3.57/1.20 in 2023, 3.00/1.09 last year (where he was quietly Cy Young runner-up) and a 3.07/1.05 push to this season. The K/BB rate isn't as tidy this year as what we're used to, and the batted-ball profile says he's about a run fortunate on the ERA. I'm not sweating any of that. This breakout story is 66 starts deep now, I'm trusting the results.
Talk Them Up, Talk Them Down
$12 Aaron Nola
$12 Sonny Gray
$12 Jack Flaherty
$11 Tyler Mahle
$11 Tanner Bibee
$11 Drew Rasmussen
$11 Bryce Miller
$10 Casey Mize
$10 Robbie Ray
$10 Clay Holmes
$10 Kevin Gausman
$10 Tony Gonsolin
$9 Tylor Megill
$9 Reese Olson
$9 Brady Singer
$9 Nick Lodolo
$9 Matt Liberatore
$9 Chris Bassitt
$9 Brandon Pfaadt
$9 Cristopher Sánchez
$9 Shane Baz
$9 Taj Bradley
ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Maybe we're firmly in "what you see is what you get" territory with Nola. His fastball has dropped down to 90.9 mph, after living in the 92s for eight straight years (for what it's worth, velocity often lags in the early part of a season and Nola feels that's the case here). His 4.61 ERA is basically what he's earned from his batted-ball profile. The Phillies might have the worst defense in the National League, so Nola pitching to contact comes at a price. He should be good enough to start for a mixed-league contender, but I've stopped expecting ace things from Nola.
Because Mize is a sturdy 6-foot-3 and 212 pounds and he was the top pick in his draft class, it's easy to imagine we're looking at a horse in the Roger Clemens/Zack Wheeler mode. That's never going to be Mize. He's not a strikeout guy. Plus control and a decent ground-ball rate have sparked his quasi-breakout so far, and his expected ERA (2.91) is right in line with the front-door 2.70. Detroit's defense isn't exactly airtight, but it's better than average. Stay grounded with the upside dreams, but Mize has shown enough to be considered a full-season story.
Some Plausible Upside
$8 Roki Sasaki
$9 Griffin Canning
$8 José Berríos
$8 Max Meyer
$8 Yusei Kikuchi
$7 JP Sears
$7 *Ben Casparius
$7 Dustin May
$6 Jackson Jobe
$6 José Quintana
$6 Gunnar Hoglund
$6 Sandy Alcantara
$6 Ryan Pepiot
$6 Luis Severino
$6 Matt Boyd
$5 Tyler Anderson
$5 Andrew Heaney
$5 David Peterson
$5 Hayden Wesneski
ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
The Dodgers are looking to stretch out Casparius; he was the secondary pitcher Monday (four innings, one run) after a one-inning opener. That gloriously K/BB rate speaks for itself (28 punch outs, five walks) and the fastball pops at 96.0 mph. The Chavez Ravine infrastructure is a plus, too.
So many Japanese pitchers have seamlessly onboarded to the majors, perhaps I was unrealistic with my initial Sasaki expectations. The strikeout rate is low, the walk rate a screaming problem at the moment. Remember: the ball is different in America, not to mention the cadence of a rotation. His NPB success is what's keeping me from collapsing his salary completely.
I wish I had a good theory for Alcantra's struggles. Walks are way up, of course, and the strikeout rate is low — and he was never a strikeout dominator anyway, even in his Cy Young season. Miami wants to trade Alcantara at some point this year, but you need something to sell. Maybe drawing the White Sox on the weekend and Tampa Bay next week will improve the story, but whatever ceiling we might have dreamt about in March, it's long gone now. I would not be averse to selling low.
Bargain Bin
$4 Shane Smith
$4 Andrew Abbott
$4 Tomoyuki Sugano
$4 Brayan Bello
$4 Ronel Blanco
$4 Merrill Kelly
$4 Justin Verlander
$4 Gavin Williams
$4 Mitch Keller
$4 Jameson Taillon
$4 Michael Wacha
$3 Tanner Houck
$3 Grant Holmes
$3 Jake Irvin
$3 Mitchell Parker
$3 Jeffrey Springs
$3 Lance McCullers
$3 Nick Martinez
$3 AJ Smith-Shawver
$3 José Soriano
$2 Clarke Schmidt
$2 Bowden Francis
$2 Jack Leiter
$2 Lucas Giolito
$2 Erick Fedde
$2 Michael Lorenzen
$2 Zack Littell
$2 Ben Lively
$2 Taijuan Walker
$1 Stephen Kolek
$1 Luis L. Ortiz
$1 Landen Roupp
$1 Jordan Hicks
$1 Logan Allen
$1 Osvaldo Bido
$0 Eduardo Rodríguez
$0 Ben Brown
$0 Miles Mikolas
$0 Will Warren
$0 Tobias Myers
$0 Sean Burke
$0 Andre Pallante
$0 David Festa
$0 Dean Kremer
-$1 Chase Dollander
-$1 Patrick Corbin
ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Burke and Sugano are near the top of the good luck leaderboard, with ERAs that should be a couple of runs higher. Burke is also supported by the worst set of teammates in the American League, of course, and Sugano's Baltimore club is probably the biggest disappointment in the A.L. this year.
It will be interesting to see how patient the Giants are with Hicks — he has an ERA over six, but the expected number is a reasonable 3.51. Hayden Birdsong has been excellent in long relief — Monday's hiccup to the side — and is ready if anyone in the rotation has an extended slump or an injury. Landen Roupp, the team's No. 5 starter, could be on notice, too.
Courtesy Injury Ranks — Not for Debate
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Times
2 hours ago
- New York Times
Giants to promote pitching prospect Carson Whisenhunt for debut Monday vs. Pirates
SAN FRANCISCO — With their rotation in a bind and the losses beginning to pile up, the San Francisco Giants will seek a boost from their top pitching prospect on Monday. The team will promote left-hander Carson Whisenhunt from Triple-A Sacramento to make his major-league debut with a home start against the Pittsburgh Pirates. Advertisement 'We've been waiting for this for a little bit now,' Giants manager Bob Melvin said following the Giants' 5-3 loss on Sunday that capped the New York Mets' three-game sweep. 'We thought maybe he'd be here last year, too. With what's gone on here … there's a need for it. It'll be exciting to see him pitch.' What's gone on will have to change quickly for the Giants to stay in the National League playoff picture. They've lost nine of 11, and their rotation is down to three healthy and established pitchers — All-Star right-hander Logan Webb, All-Star left-hander Robbie Ray and 42-year-old right-hander Justin Verlander — after right-hander Landen Roupp was placed on the 15-day injured list with elbow inflammation and erratic right-hander Hayden Birdsong LaLooshed himself to Triple-A Sacramento. So the Giants will turn to Whisenhunt, a fringe top-100 prospect who was widely considered the best collegiate left-hander in his 2022 MLB Draft class before a positive test for a performance-enhancing substance resulted in a suspension that caused him to miss his junior season at East Carolina University. The Giants thought they got a steal when they selected Whisenhunt in the second round, and although he didn't post overpowering numbers in the upper minors, his changeup consistently grades out as a plus major-league pitch. Whisenhunt, 24, compiled a 4.42 ERA in 18 starts while spending his second season in the Pacific Coast League, which tends to warp most pitching statistics. His progress could be measured in a walk rate (2.6 per nine innings) that he nearly halved from the previous year. He's also striking out fewer batters, though (7.9 per nine innings, down from 11.6 in 2024). The Giants won't expect Whisenhunt to dominate. They'll be happy to receive five or six competitive innings one day after relying on a bullpen game against the Mets. Giants catcher Patrick Bailey, a fellow North Carolina native, said he's confident Whisenhunt will have what it takes to compete. Advertisement 'I'm very excited for him,' Bailey said. 'Awesome dude, awesome player. I think he'll be ready. He's got really good stuff. Obviously, he's got the plus-plus changeup, and I hear the fastball command is getting better and he's throwing some different breaking balls. It's well deserved.' The Giants could air a Carson special Monday night. They didn't use Whisenhunt's former Sacramento rotation mate, right-hander Carson Seymour, in Sunday's bullpen game. So he'd be available to back up Whisenhunt. 'It just depends on how efficient he is,' Melvin said. The bullpen game — which included two home runs off right-hander Randy Rodríguez after he'd allowed just one in his first 43 appearances — wasn't the reason the Giants dropped their series finale against the Mets. The Giants didn't get any offensive production outside of two home runs from third baseman Matt Chapman and, continuing a cruel theme, went hitless in seven at-bats with runners in scoring position. Mets closer Edwin Diaz struck out Willy Adames and Chapman to strand the bases loaded in the ninth, concluding a series in which the Giants went 0-for-23 with runners in scoring position. According to research by NBC Sports Bay Area, it was the first time since 1931 that the Giants played a series in which they had at least 20 at-bats with runners in scoring position and failed to get a hit in any of them. The tragicomic detail: They would've been credited with one in the third inning Sunday when Adames failed to check his swing and sent a roller up the third-base line. But Heliot Ramos' base-running foibles continued. He got hung up between second and third, and Mets third baseman Ronny Mauricio tagged him to complete a fielder's choice. Of course, there isn't much Whisenhunt can do to alleviate the Giants' most persistent problem this season. The best he can do is keep the team in the game. He's coming off a shortened outing last Sunday against Oklahoma City in which he threw 68 pitches while allowing a run in 3 2/3 innings, but he had an earlier run of four consecutive seven-inning starts and twice earned PCL pitcher of the week honors. On July 12, Whisenhunt represented the Giants in the All-Star Futures Game in Atlanta and retired both batters he faced. Advertisement The Giants must make space on the 40-man and active roster for Whisenhunt, who was scratched from his start for Sacramento on Saturday night and added to the major-league taxi squad. After Sunday's game, there was a locker in the Giants clubhouse with a No. 88 jersey hanging in it. A duffel bag and a pair of dimpled, ostrich leather boots signified Whisenhunt's arrival. Roupp, another fellow North Carolina native who brings a strong boot game to the clubhouse, has competition now. 'I've seen him since we competed against each other in college,' Roupp said. 'I'm excited. I think it's past due. He's been throwing pretty well this year and threw well last year. 'Everybody knows his changeup is really good, but the other pitches are coming around, too.' The Giants need their offense to come around if they hope to remain relevant in September and beyond. But they also need to stabilize a pitching staff that has thrown the most bullpen innings of any team since the All-Star break. Chapman said he has no doubt that club president Buster Posey will remain an active buyer as Thursday's trade deadline approaches. 'It sucks to lose 9 of 11 and slip out of the standings a little bit, but we're still right there,' Chapman said. 'We'll play a lot of the teams that are right in front of us and right in the thick of it with us. Buster has made it clear: We go out and get Rafi (Rafael Devers), and it makes sense to continue to try to improve this team for this year and the foreseeable future. So I think we expect to add and to continue to get better and to continue to make a push to make the playoffs.'
Washington Post
3 hours ago
- Washington Post
The Kansas City Royals and pitcher Seth Lugo agree to 2-year extension, AP source says
KANSAS CITY, Mo. — The Kansas City Royals and right-hander Seth Lugo have agreed to a two-year extension that includes a vesting option for the 2028 season, a person familiar with the negotiations told The Associated Press on Sunday night. The person spoke on condition of anonymity because the deal, which presumably takes one of the most talked-about names on the trade market off the table ahead of this week's deadline, had not been officially announced. The 35-year-old Lugo made his first All-Star Game and won his first Gold Glove last season, when he went 16-9 with a 3.00 ERA in the first year of a two-year, $30 million deal that included a player option for next season. Lugo has followed that up with an even better start to this season, going 7-5 with a 2.95 ERA through 19 outings for Kansas City. Rumors surfaced of several contenders interested in trading for Lugo ahead of Thursday's deadline, and the fact that the Royals have been hanging on the fringe of contention themselves left many wondering whether they would be buyers or sellers. It appears that they are going to make a push for a second consecutive playoff appearance. The Royals acquired outfielder Randal Grichuk from the Diamondbacks for reliever Andrew Hoffmann late Saturday, shoring up a weakness in the lineup by adding a right-handed bat. Now, they have indicated that Lugo remains big a part of their future with his extension — an especially timely one given it came the same day that All-Star pitcher Kris Bubic went on the injured list. Kansas City also is missing starters Cole Ragans and Michael Lorenzen due to injuries. Both are expected back at some point in August, and the Royals are hopeful that their return to the rotation will propel them down the stretch run. After beating the Guardians on Sunday, the Royals were four games back of the final American League wild-card spot. ___ AP MLB:
USA Today
3 hours ago
- USA Today
Arizona Diamondbacks at Detroit Tigers odds, picks and predictions
The Arizona Diamondbacks (51-55) and Detroit Tigers (61-46) begin a 3-game series Monday. First pitch from Comerica Park in Detroit is set for 6:40 p.m. Let's analyze BetMGM Sportsbook's MLB odds around the Diamondbacks vs. Tigers odds and make our expert MLB picks and predictions for the best bets. Season series: First meeting; Tigers won 2 of 3 last season The Diamondbacks opened their 9-game road trip with a rough series loss in Pittsburgh, managing just 1 run total across the 3-game set against the Pirates. They won the opener 1-0, but were shut out 2-0 Saturday and 6-0 Sunday. Arizona lost the finale as +134 underdogs as the Under (7.5) cashed. The Tigers ended their 6-game skid Sunday with a 10-4 win over the Toronto Blue Jays as -113 home favorites as the Over (8.5) cashed. Starter Jack Flaherty delivered 6 shutout innings with 7 strikeouts and 2B Gleyber Torres powered the offense, going 2-for-4 with a home run and 4 RBIs. Diamondbacks at Tigers projected starters LHP Eduardo Rodriguez vs. RHP Troy Melton Rodriguez (3-6, 5.50 ERA) is making his 18th start. He has a 1.65 WHIP, 3.3 BB/9 and 9.7 K/9 through 86 2/3 innings. Melton (0-1, 10.80 ERA) is making his second career start. The 24-year-old fourth-round draft pick (2022) was called up on July 21 Win your fantasy baseball league with For decades, BHQ has been helping players just like you win! BHQ offers full-season subscriptions. Sign up today and start winning! Diamondbacks at Tigers odds Provided by BetMGM Sportsbook; access USA TODAY Sports Scores and Sports Betting Odds hub for a full list. Lines last updated at 12:04 a.m. ET. Diamondbacks at Tigers picks and predictions Diamondbacks 7, Tigers 5 Moneyline BET DIAMONDBACKS (+110). The Diamondbacks are in a favorable spot to take Monday's series opener in Detroit. Arizona sends Rodriguez to the mound, who's been solid on the road, allowing just 5 earned runs over his last 3 road starts (14 2/3 IP). He's coming off a strong outing, holding Houston scoreless through 6 1/3 innings. On the other side, Detroit rookie Melton makes his second career start—and first at Comerica Park—after giving up 6 earned runs in 5 innings in his debut. That home crowd pressure won't make things easier. The Tigers have dropped 7 of their last 10 games at home and enter the week struggling at the plate, hitting an MLB-worst .197 over the last 15 days. While Detroit looked better on Sunday, it's tough to trust this offense to stay hot. At plus odds, the value lies with Arizona to grab the series opener on the road. Run line/Against the spread PASS. I'm going to keep my wager to the run line. Over/Under BET OVER 9 (+100). The Over has hit in 7 of the last 8 games between the Tigers and Diamondbacks, and recent trends support more scoring Monday. The Over is 3-2-1 in Detroit's last 6 games and has cashed in 4 of Rodriguez's last 6 starts. Expect another high-scoring affair in this series opener. Play our free daily Pick'em Challenge and win! Play now! For more sports betting picks and tips, check out and BetFTW. Follow @DrewPhelps05 on Twitter/X. Follow SportsbookWire on Twitter/X and like us on Facebook.
