Late Arizona man forgives killer during trial in AI-generated video
'In another life we probably could have been friends,' a replica of Pelkey said in the AI-generated video played earlier this month in a Phoenix courtroom.
This victim recreation is believed to be the first time AI has been used for a victim impact statement during a trial. The statements are a chance for victims and families to say their peace, but sometimes the victims aren't alive to do so.
'To Gabriel Horcasitas, the man who shot me, it is a shame we encountered each other that day in those circumstances,' the video said. 'I believe in forgiveness and in God, who forgives. I always have and I still do.'
The victim's sister, Stacey Wales, said she struggled to find the right words to say in a victim impact statement, so she turned to AI.
'I turned to my husband one night and I asked him, I said, 'Tim, I want you to help me have Chris make his own impact statement at sentencing next week. I know you can do it. I've seen your work,'' Wales told NewsNation. 'And he says, 'Stacy, do you know what you're asking me? This is my best friend.''
The couple works in tech, and they had just a few days to come up with the 4 and a half-minute video using photos and voice recordings with the script of what they believed Pelkey would have said.
The result was realistic. The man charged with shooting Pelkey to death could be seen wiping away tears at the hearing.
Horcasitas, 54, was convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to more than 10 years in prison.
'I love that AI. Thank you for that,' Judge Todd Lang said at the hearing. 'And as angry as you are, and justifiably angry as the family is, I heard the forgiveness, and I know Mr. Horcasitas could appreciate it, but so did I.'
Within hours of the hearing, the defense filed a notice to appeal, pointing to the impact AI may have had on the judge's sentencing decision.
Although AI has been used before in legal research and preparing cases, using it to deliver a deceased person's victim impact statement is unprecedented.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Washington Post
36 minutes ago
- Washington Post
Trump's MAGA allies zero in on Ghislaine Maxwell as Epstein furor persists
As President Donald Trump has struggled to contain the stubborn fallout of the Jeffrey Epstein scandal, several of his staunchest supporters and conservative media allies think they have finally found the key to exposing a secret cabal of rich and powerful pedophiles. Some of MAGA's most prominent voices say without evidence that Ghislaine Maxwell, who was sentenced to 20 years for sex trafficking girls for Epstein, has inside knowledge that would help law enforcement bring untold elites to justice.
New York Times
36 minutes ago
- New York Times
How Hulk Hogan Leg-Dropped the Digital Media Industry
Among the 99.99 percent of Americans who are not journalists, Hulk Hogan's name most likely summons a charming and patriotic cloud of associations: vitamins, 'real American,' ripped shirts, leg drops, mustache, pectorals, 'brother.' But among our diminishing tribe, Hogan's wrestling persona falls away, and the man, Terry Bollea, looms larger. Because he — not Hogan — was the plaintiff in an invasion of privacy lawsuit, Bollea v. Gawker, that reshaped the whole landscape of the media business. The tawdry story begins at some point in or around 2006. Bollea was having trouble in his marriage and was, by his own account, severely depressed. One day, he visited the home of his friend, a Tampa shock jock named Bubba the Love Sponge Clem. Clem invited Bollea to have sex with his wife, Heather. The two apparently had an arrangement. But Clem also had a hidden camera in his bedroom — and what he probably didn't mention that day was that he was going to burn the footage onto a DVD, label it 'HOGAN' with a Sharpie, and leave it in an unlocked drawer. It took that tape somewhere around six years to reach the Manhattan offices of Gawker Media, in 2012. At the time, Gawker was no longer a gossipy blog for the media elite and those just outside the walls. It was that, plus a news aggregator, plus a tabloid, plus an occasional source of literary essays. It was, without question, the most interesting and unpredictable of the rising class of digital media properties. According to a later report by BuzzFeed News, Gawker's editor in chief, A.J. Daulerio, used a somewhat circular logic to determine the video had news value: A Hulk Hogan sex tape was fair game because there had previously been reported rumors about a Hulk Hogan sex tape. Consequentially, Daulerio made the decision not just to confirm the tape's existence and summarize its lurid contents but also to publish a roughly two-minute excerpt from it. Bollea's lawyers tried to have Gawker take the video down, but the site refused. In 2013, Bollea sued Gawker — as well as Daulerio and Gawker's founder, Nick Denton — for invasion of privacy, seeking damages of $100 million. Then, rather than settle the suit, as Gawker seemed to expect he would, Bollea spent years pursuing justice through the courts before finally winning at trial in 2016. In the end, the court ordered Gawker to pay $140 million in damages, forcing the company into bankruptcy. Its flagship site was eventually revived under different ownership, then shuttered again in 2023. (Daulerio's inciting post no longer exists, not even in the Internet Archive; the one apparently faithful copy I could find had been pasted contemporaneously on a message board connected to a boating lifestyle brand in Lake Havasu City, Ariz.) As Ben Smith recounts in 'Traffic,' his recent history of the rise of digital media, Daulerio was a creature of the earlier, meaner Gawker days. As editor of another Gawker property, Deadspin, he published questionably obtained pictures of athletes' penises, posted a link to peeping Tom footage of the ESPN reporter Erin Andrews changing in a hotel room, and published a video of a visibly drunk female college student having sex in a bar bathroom. According to a 2011 profile in GQ, Daulerio heard directly from a woman he took to be the person in the video, begging him to take it down; he initially refused, but relented the next day, admitting to the magazine that what the video depicted 'was possibly rape.' The Gawker that published the Hogan tape wasn't yet the website that it would become in the public imagination; digital media hadn't yet taken the crusading and moralizing form it would later that decade. In 2012, the site — and maybe the whole country — was on the other side of a fulcrum that was hard to see at the time. Just one year later, another Gawker site, Valleywag, would post the news that a completely unknown communications professional, Justine Sacco, had made a racially insensitive joke on Twitter, which led to her firing — and inaugurated a tumultuous new era in American life. The signals from the commingling worlds of digital and social media were clear: Not even a non-wrestling civilian could be totally sure that the beam would never be turned on them. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
New York Times
36 minutes ago
- New York Times
Competing Conspiracy Theories Consume Trump's Washington
OK, so President Trump's name is in the Jeffrey Epstein files. But who put it there? Could it possibly have been Barack Obama from his prison cell? Or a tranquilized Hillary Clinton? Oh wait, maybe it was etched onto the documents by Joe Biden's magical autopen. Or wait, is that mixing up different scandals? It's so hard to keep up with the latest wild notions circulating in the capital and beyond. Washington is awash in conspiracy theories these days, a cascade of suspicion and intrigue promoted or denied in the Oval Office, ricocheting around Capitol Hill and cable news and propelled at warp speed across social media. No commander in chief in his lifetime has been as consumed by conspiracy theories as President Trump and now they seem to be consuming him. They have been the rocket fuel for his political career since the days when he spread the lie that Mr. Obama was secretly born overseas and therefore not eligible to be president. More than a decade later, Mr. Trump is coming full circle by trying to divert attention from the Epstein conspiracy theory with a new-and-improved one about Mr. Obama supposedly committing treason. The harmonic convergence of competing conspiracies has overshadowed critical policy issues facing America's leaders at the moment, whether it's new tariffs that could dramatically reshape the global economy or the collapse of cease-fire talks meant to end the war in Gaza. The Epstein matter so spooked Speaker Mike Johnson that he abruptly recessed the House for the summer rather than confront it. The allegations lodged against Mr. Obama so outraged the former president that he emerged from political hibernation to express his indignation at even having to address them. The whispers and questions — 'this nonsense,' as Mr. Trump put it — followed the president all the way to Scotland, where he landed Friday for a visit to his golf club. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
