‘Yuck factor': eating insects rather than meat to help the planet is failing, study finds
Recent efforts to encourage people to eat insects are doomed to fail because of widespread public disgust at the idea, making it unlikely insects will help people switch from the environmentally ruinous habit of meat consumption, a new study has found.
Farming and eating insects has been touted in recent years as a greener alternative to eating traditional meat due to the heavy environmental toll of raising livestock, which is a leading driver of deforestation, responsible for more than half of global water pollution, and may cause more than a third of all greenhouse gases that can be allowed if the world is to avoid disastrous climate change, the new research finds.
Despite this, the much lighter planetary cost of breeding and eating insects such as crickets, grasshoppers and ants is unlikely to be realized because people, particularly in western countries, remain repulsed at the idea of eating them, the researchers found.
Public polling in the US and Europe has found that while as many as 91% of respondents would be willing to try plant-based 'alternative meats', only about 20% would consider eating insects.
As well as a cultural 'yuck' factor, there are also economic barriers, the paper found, with most companies – the exception being a few protein bar startups – deciding to focus on raising species such as black soldier flies for animal, rather than human, consumption.
'Given these challenges, it is difficult to see how insect-based foods could significantly replace traditional meat options,' the paper, published in the Nature journal npj Sustainable Agriculture, states.
While many people express a desire to eat food that is raised sustainably, relatively few in western countries have embraced vegetarianism and veganism. Meanwhile, global meat consumption is expected to increase in the coming decades amid rising demand from a newly wealthy cohort in countries such as China, placing additional stresses upon the land, waterways and the climate.
'We have limited resources and we need to devote them to the most promising alternatives,' said Dustin Crummett, the co-author of the study and executive director of the Insect Institute. 'It turns out that farmed insects consistently score the lowest of any of the meat substitutes and the actual market for them is incredibly small, even in places that have a tradition of eating insects.'
Crummett said that while some efforts have been made to put insects into items such as snack bars and bread, they aren't being made into products that would actually dislodge meat consumption.
'All the talk about eating insects has not made a big difference. People still have a strong adverse reaction to insects and there is no cultural history of that,' he said. 'Changing longstanding culinary traditions and deep-seated disgust reactions is hard to do from the top down. If it were easy, more people would be eating plant-based foods.'
Few governments have made any significant moves to curb meat consumption, despite its enormous impact upon the environment, fearing political backlash. Denmark, however, has provided a possible model of how to do this, unveiling a plan in 2023 to reduce meat eating and bolster the supply of plant-based foods.
'Plant-based foods are the future,' Jacob Jensen, Denmark's minister for food, agriculture and fisheries, said at the time. 'If we want to reduce the climate footprint within the agricultural sector, then we all have to eat more plant-based foods.'
Crummett said that the Danish plan was a good starting point to craft an alternative to simply hoping that people will switch to insects.
'You have to meet people where they are,' he said. 'You need to make things easy and tasty, not just moralize and hector people. Once there are alternative products that are better based on taste, price and convenience, we will get some traction in reducing the impact of livestock.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Observer
6 days ago
- National Observer
New study surfaces explosive risk hidden beneath Antarctic ice
This story was originally published by The Guardian and appears here as part of the Climate Desk collaboration The melting of glaciers and ice caps by the climate crisis could unleash a barrage of explosive volcanic eruptions, a study suggests. The loss of ice releases the pressure on underground magma chambers and makes eruptions more likely. This process has been seen in Iceland, an unusual island that sits on a mid-ocean tectonic plate boundary. But the research in Chile is one of the first studies to show a surge in volcanism on a continent in the past, after the last ice age ended. Global heating caused by the burning of fossil fuels is now melting ice caps and glaciers across the world. The biggest risk of a resurgence of volcanic eruptions is in west Antarctica, the researchers said, where at least 100 volcanoes lie under the thick ice. This ice is very likely to be lost in the coming decades and centuries as the world warms. Volcanic eruptions can cool the planet temporarily by shooting sunlight-reflecting particles into the atmosphere. However, sustained eruptions would pump significant greenhouse gases into the atmosphere, including carbon dioxide and methane. This would further heat the planet and potentially create a vicious circle, in which rising temperatures melt ice that leads to further eruptions and more global heating. Pablo Moreno-Yaeger, at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, US, who led the research, said: 'As glaciers retreat due to climate change, our findings suggest these volcanoes go on to erupt more frequently and more explosively.' The research, which was presented at the Goldschmidt geochemistry conference in Prague, and is in the final stages of review with an academic journal, involved camping high in the Andes, among active and dormant volcanoes. As ice caps and glaciers melt, the pressure they put on volcanoes is released — and the magma that has built up beneath them is more likely to erupt, leading to a vicious circle of heating. Detailed work on one volcano, called Mocho-Choshuenco, used radioisotope dating to estimate the age of volcanic rocks produced before, during and after the last ice age, when the 1,500-metre-thick Patagonian ice sheet covered the area. Analysis of the minerals in the rocks also revealed the depth and temperature at which the rocks formed. This data revealed that thick ice cover had suppressed the volume of eruptions between 26,000 and 18,000 years ago, allowing a large reservoir of magma to build up 10-15km (6.2-9.3 miles) below the surface. After the ice melted, from about 13,000 years ago, the pressure on the magma chamber was released, gasses in the liquid or molten rock expanded and explosive eruptions followed. 'We found that following deglaciation, the volcano starts to erupt way more, and also changes composition,' said Moreno-Yaeger. The composition changed as the magma melted crustal rocks while eruptions were suppressed. This made the molten rock more viscous and more explosive on eruption. 'Our study suggests this phenomenon isn't limited to Iceland, where increased volcanicity has been observed, but could also occur in Antarctica,' he said. 'Other continental regions, like parts of North America, New Zealand and Russia, also now warrant closer scientific attention.' Previous research has shown volcanic activity increased globally by two to six times after the last ice age, but the Chilean study was one of the first to show how this happened. A similar phenomenon was reported via the analysis of rocks in eastern California in 2004. A recent review by scientists found there had been relatively little study on how the climate crisis had been affecting volcanic activity. They said more research was 'critically important' in order to be better prepared for the damage caused by volcanic eruptions to people and their livelihoods and for possible climate-volcano feedback loops that could amplify the climate crisis. For example, more extreme rainfall is also expected to increase violent explosive eruptions.
National Observer
15-07-2025
- National Observer
Sea ice can be ‘early warning system' for global heating — but the US is halting data sharing
This story was originally published by The Guardian and appears here as part of the Climate Desk collaboration Scientists analysing the cascading impacts of record low levels of Antarctic sea ice fear a loss of critical US government satellite data will make it harder to track the rapid changes taking place at both poles. Researchers around the globe were told last week the US Department of Defence will stop processing and providing the data, used in studies on the state of Arctic and Antarctic sea ice, at the end of this month. Tracking the state of sea ice is crucial for scientists to understand how global heating is affecting the planet. Sea ice reflects the sun's energy back out to space but, as long-term losses have been recorded, more of the planet's ocean is exposed to the sun's energy, causing more heating. The National Snow and Ice Data Center, based at the University of Colorado, maintains a Sea Ice Index used around the world to track in near real-time the extent of sea ice around the globe. In two updates in the past week, the centre said the US government's Department of Defence, which owns the satellites that contain onboard instruments used to track sea ice, would stop 'processing and delivering' the data on 31 July. The US Department of Defense's decision to halt sharing of critical sea ice data "couldn't come at a worse time," according to researchers. Climate scientists have been warning that Trump administration cuts have targeted climate functions across government, and there has been fears the sea ice data could be targeted. The news comes as new research, some of which relied on the data, found that record low amounts of sea ice around Antarctica in recent years had seen more icebergs splintering off the continent's ice shelves in a process scientists warned could push up global sea levels faster than current modelling has predicted. Dr Alex Fraser, a co-author of the research at the Australian Antarctic Program Partnership (AAPP), said NSIDC's sea ice data was 'our number one heart rate monitor' for the state of the planet's ice. 'It's our early warning system and tells us if the patient is about to flatline. We need this data and now [the scientific community] will be forced to put together a record from a different instrument. We won't have that continued context that we have had previously.' NSIDC has said it is working with alternative and higher-resolution instruments from a different satellite, but has warned that data may not be directly comparable with the current instruments. Fraser said: 'We are seeing records now year on year in Antarctica, so from that perspective this could not have come at a worse time.' Dr Walt Meier, a senior scientist at NSIDC, said there were other 'passive microwave instruments' that could keep the long-term record going, but he said differences with older sensors created a 'a challenge to make the long-term record consistent and there will be some degradation in the consistency of the long-term record.' 'I think we will end up with a robust and quality record that users can have confidence in,' Meier said, but said this would add to uncertainty to estimates of trends. Asked why the government was stopping the data, he said because 'everything is old and resources are limited, my guess is that it is not worth the time and effort to upgrade the systems for such old sensors, which may fail at any time.' The research, published in the journal PNAS Nexus, found a link between increasing numbers of icebergs calving from floating ice shelves and the loss of sea ice. While the loss of sea ice does not directly raise sea levels, the research said it exposed more ice shelves to wave action, causing them to break apart and release icebergs faster. Glaciologist Dr Sue Cook, also from AAPP, said 'like a cork in a bottle' those shelves help to slow down the advance of land-based ice that does raise sea levels if it breaks off into the ocean. She said the higher rates of iceberg calving seen in Antarctica were not accounted for in calculations of how quickly the ice sheet might break apart and contribute global sea levels. 'If we shift to this state where summer sea ice is very low but we continue using models based on previous periods, then we will definitely underestimate how quickly Antarctica will contribute to sea level rise,' she said. The study also outlined other knock-on effects from the record low sea ice levels in the Antarctic, including the loss of more seals and penguins if trends continued. As many as 7,000 emperor penguin chicks died in late 2022 after the early break-up of the stable ice they used for shelter while they grow their waterproof plumage. A US Navy spokesperson confirmed the data processing from its defence meteorological satellite program (DMSP) would stop on 31 July 'in accordance with Department of Defense policy.' DMSP is a joint program owned by the US Space Force, the spokesperson said, and was scheduled for discontinuation in September 2026. 'The Navy is discontinuing contributions to DMSP given the program no longer meets our information technology modernization requirements.'
National Observer
10-07-2025
- National Observer
‘Yuck factor': eating insects rather than meat to help the planet is failing, study finds
This story was originally published by The Guardian and appears here as part of the Climate Desk collaboration. Recent efforts to encourage people to eat insects are doomed to fail because of widespread public disgust at the idea, making it unlikely insects will help people switch from the environmentally ruinous habit of meat consumption, a new study has found. Farming and eating insects has been touted in recent years as a greener alternative to eating traditional meat due to the heavy environmental toll of raising livestock, which is a leading driver of deforestation, responsible for more than half of global water pollution, and may cause more than a third of all greenhouse gases that can be allowed if the world is to avoid disastrous climate change, the new research finds. Despite this, the much lighter planetary cost of breeding and eating insects such as crickets, grasshoppers and ants is unlikely to be realized because people, particularly in western countries, remain repulsed at the idea of eating them, the researchers found. Public polling in the US and Europe has found that while as many as 91% of respondents would be willing to try plant-based 'alternative meats', only about 20% would consider eating insects. As well as a cultural 'yuck' factor, there are also economic barriers, the paper found, with most companies – the exception being a few protein bar startups – deciding to focus on raising species such as black soldier flies for animal, rather than human, consumption. 'Given these challenges, it is difficult to see how insect-based foods could significantly replace traditional meat options,' the paper, published in the Nature journal npj Sustainable Agriculture, states. While many people express a desire to eat food that is raised sustainably, relatively few in western countries have embraced vegetarianism and veganism. Meanwhile, global meat consumption is expected to increase in the coming decades amid rising demand from a newly wealthy cohort in countries such as China, placing additional stresses upon the land, waterways and the climate. 'We have limited resources and we need to devote them to the most promising alternatives,' said Dustin Crummett, the co-author of the study and executive director of the Insect Institute. 'It turns out that farmed insects consistently score the lowest of any of the meat substitutes and the actual market for them is incredibly small, even in places that have a tradition of eating insects.' Crummett said that while some efforts have been made to put insects into items such as snack bars and bread, they aren't being made into products that would actually dislodge meat consumption. 'All the talk about eating insects has not made a big difference. People still have a strong adverse reaction to insects and there is no cultural history of that,' he said. 'Changing longstanding culinary traditions and deep-seated disgust reactions is hard to do from the top down. If it were easy, more people would be eating plant-based foods.' Few governments have made any significant moves to curb meat consumption, despite its enormous impact upon the environment, fearing political backlash. Denmark, however, has provided a possible model of how to do this, unveiling a plan in 2023 to reduce meat eating and bolster the supply of plant-based foods. 'Plant-based foods are the future,' Jacob Jensen, Denmark's minister for food, agriculture and fisheries, said at the time. 'If we want to reduce the climate footprint within the agricultural sector, then we all have to eat more plant-based foods.' Crummett said that the Danish plan was a good starting point to craft an alternative to simply hoping that people will switch to insects. 'You have to meet people where they are,' he said. 'You need to make things easy and tasty, not just moralize and hector people. Once there are alternative products that are better based on taste, price and convenience, we will get some traction in reducing the impact of livestock.'
