May 9 trials: PTI seeks SC review
In a detailed letter addressed to the Chief Justice of Pakistan, Ayub, who is also a senior leader of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), framed his appeal both as a political leader and as an individual directly affected by the legal proceedings.
He characterised the trials, which are taking place in multiple cities including Lahore, Faisalabad, and Sargodha, as 'rushed' and 'unfair,' warning that such processes undermine public trust in the country's judiciary.
'The integrity of the country's judicial process is under grave threat,' he wrote, alleging that Anti-Terrorism Courts (ATCs) were holding sessions late into the night, sometimes until 2 or 3 am.
'This is neither justice delayed nor justice served – this is justice crushed and buried under the weight of exhaustion, coercion, and haste,' he lamented.
Ayub cited numerous Supreme Court verdicts underscoring the necessity of transparency, fairness, and due process.
Quoting the landmark ruling in State vs Ziaul Haq (1975), he emphasised, 'Justice must not only be done, it must manifestly and undoubtedly be seen to be done.'
The opposition leader expressed deep concern over what he described as a 'systematic' erosion of legal rights for PTI members, accusing authorities of prosecutorial overreach, filing fabricated complaints, and using coercive tactics.
He also raised alarms about restrictions placed on defendants' access to legal counsel of their choice, citing Article 10A of the Constitution, and alleged that courts were frequently denying adjournments and appointing state lawyers without consent.
Highlighting violations of constitutional protections, including Articles 4, 10A, 14, 19A, and 25, Ayub warned that such practices contravened not only national law but also international standards, including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
He likened the secretive nature of the trials to the notorious 'Star Chambers' of 17th-century England, underscoring the opacity and lack of public scrutiny.
He called on Justice Afridi to take urgent corrective action, including a comprehensive review of all May 9 trials to ensure adherence to fair trial norms and enforcing reasonable court hours.
He also urged safeguarding the right to counsel, expanding media access, and investigating allegations of prosecutorial and police misconduct.
He also urged reopening trials concluded under questionable conditions.
Concluding his letter, Ayub invoked a famous quote from former US Chief Justice Earl Warren: 'The treatment a government gives its citizens when accused of crime reveals the very essence of justice in that society.'
He reminded the Chief Justice Afridi of his constitutional duty as the 'guardian of the Constitution' to ensure that courts serve justice rather than political interests.
'The public is watching closely,' he warned. 'And history is being written every day.'
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
an hour ago
- Express Tribune
First lady backs women in housing, motherhood
First Lady and Member of the National Assembly Bibi Aseefa Bhutto Zardari said that home ownership is not merely a legal entitlement, but a lasting symbol of security and dignity for families. Speaking at the distribution ceremony of ownership rights under the Sindh People's Housing for Flood-Affected (SPHF) Project, she announced that under the SPHF initiative, the govt is constructing 2.1 million homes to rebuild lives affected by catastrophic flooding. A distinctive and empowering feature of the project, she noted, is that each plot of land is being registered in the name of the woman of the household. This, she said, reflects a commitment to gender equality and lasting empowerment. Calling the SPHF Project a testament to Chairman Bilawal's vision and dedication to public service, Aseefa linked the initiative to the legacy of her grandfather, Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. "He promised land, shelter, and dignity to every citizen. Our chairman is fulfilling that promise today." World Breastfeeding Week As World Breastfeeding Week 2025 begins, Aseefa Bhutto Zardari also urged Pakistan to strengthen its national support system for all mothers - whether they breastfeed, use formula, or combine both. She said that exclusive breastfeeding for the first six months, followed by continued breastfeeding with complementary foods up to two years, offers critical health benefits, including stronger immunity and enhanced cognitive development for children, as well as reduced risks of breast and ovarian cancer for mothers. However, she stressed that no mother should ever feel judged or unsupported if she is unable to breastfeed exclusively. "Some women face medical complications, such as premature births, surgeries, or health conditions, that make breastfeeding unsafe. These mothers deserve care, clear guidance on safe supplementation, and the same dignity and respect we offer to breastfeeding mothers," she said. Aseefa called for a national approach that empowers every mother with accurate information, expert counselling, and full access to appropriate feeding options. She urged policymakers to implement and enforce strong regulations on the marketing of breast-milk substitutes so that mothers receive impartial, science-based advice. She also called on employers to provide paid maternity leave, flexible working hours, and designated lactation spaces, noting that such policies not only support breastfeeding but also reduce stress for mothers who rely on formula.
Express Tribune
an hour ago
- Express Tribune
Independence Day celebrations start
Political, religious parties and social organisations besides the government departments kicjed off a 15-day celebration of Independence titled the Battle for Truth as a tribute to the founders as well as the defenders of the country. Rallies were held across the city by PPP, MQM-P and other political parties while the city's administration was busy in ramping up security for the festive occasion. Exclusive ceremonies were held at the CM House and the Governor House. MQM-P staged a rally at the Quaid's Mazaar with a vow that as the heirs of the founders of the country they would continue to defend its ideological and geographical boundaries. Sindh Minister for Energy, Planning, and Development, Syed Nasir Hussain Shah has said that the month of August reminds us of the sacrifices of the martyrs who laid down their lives for the creation and protection of Pakistan. In the Ma'arka-e-Haq (Battle for Truth) our armed forces displayed remarkable bravery, valor, and resilience, which not only brought the honour to the country and pride for the Pakistani nation. This instilled a strong sense among the people that Pakistan is an invincible nation and that its defence lies in capable hands. He expressed these views while addressing a ceremony held on Friday at the Department of Energy, organised under the auspices of the Sindh Transmission & Dispatch Company (STDC), as part of the Independence Day and Ma'arka-e-Haq celebrations. The event was hosted by STDC CEO Saleem Sheikh and attended by Secretary of Sindh Energy Department Mushtaq Soomro, MD of Thar Coal Energy Board Tariq Shah, Project Director of SSEPP Mahfooz Ahmed Qazi, Secretary of Sindh Transmission Dispatch Company Umar Nawaz Sheikh, CFO Sajjad Ahmed Junejo, Senior GM Technical Tariq Saeed, along with other senior officials. On this occasion, the energy minister cut a cake to mark the celebration and shared it with attendees. Additionally, commemorative badges were distributed at the event by STDC CEO.
Express Tribune
an hour ago
- Express Tribune
Curriculum reforms urged
Minority MPA Mahesh Kumar Malani, in a separate call-attention notice, objected to the ethics subject being exclusively assigned to non-Muslim students. "Ethics should be part of the curriculum for all students," he argued. "Non-Muslim students, including Christians, do not object to learning Islamiat, so why single them out?" He also demanded a separate educational board for the Christian community. In reply, Education Minister Sardar Shah stated that the current policy stems from the PTI government's Single National Curriculum, which the Sindh government had opposed. "Muslim students are taught Islamiat, and non-Muslims are taught Ethics. We reviewed the curriculum in 2022 and agree that further improvements are necessary," he said. He added that curriculum changes are a continual process globally, and since Hinduism originated in Sindh, the majority of non-Muslim students are Hindu. Responding to another call-attention notice from MQM MPA Najam Mirza regarding the Sindh Electronic Centralized College Admission Program (SECAP), Education Minister Sardar Shah said the policy has now been extended to the entire province. "Admissions are computerized and automatic, with no human interference," he clarified. He explained that priority is given to students with A-1 and A grades, particularly in high-demand colleges such as PECHS. "Previously, recommendations played a role in admissions, but that is no longer the case. People now request admissions in specific colleges, but not everyone can be accommodated," he said.
