Doctors striking without warning ‘shockingly irresponsible', says Streeting
Wes Streeting said that if it goes ahead, the strike would be a 'catastrophic mistake' and that any decision by resident doctors not to tell their employers about their intention to strike would be 'shockingly irresponsible'.
Streeting told MPs that BMA leaders seemed to be telling their members 'not to inform their trusts or their employers if they're going out on strike' and that he could not fathom 'how any doctor in good conscience would make it harder for managers to make sure we have safe staffing levels'.
Streeting is due to meet representatives of the BMA on Tuesday ahead of their planned five-day strike starting on 25 July. Resident doctors, formerly known as junior doctors, voted to take the action in pursuit of a 29% pay rise that the union has said was needed to replace lost pay over years of cuts.
Labour has offered resident doctors a 5.4% pay rise this year, after a 22% rise agreed for the previous two years. Speaking at the health and social care select committee on Monday, Streeting said that 'going on strike having received a 28.9% pay increase is not only unreasonable and unnecessary given the progress that we've been making on pay and other issues, it's also self-defeating'.
The figure is based on government calculations that resident doctors have received a 28.9% pay rise over the last three years.
Streeting said there was 'no more room for manoeuvre' on residents doctors' pay but that he was willing to engage on several other union demands including on unemployment and progression into speciality posts.
He warned that any decision by resident doctors not to inform their trusts that they will strike 'would make it harder for other staff who are going to be turning up to work that day, not least the staff who have not had a higher percentage pay rise, many of whom are paid less than resident doctors'.
Streeting warned that while he accepted doctors' right to strike, the 'idea that doctors would go on strike without informing their employer, not allowing planning for safe staffing, I think, is unconscionable, and I would urge resident doctors who are taking part in strike actions to do the right thing'.
He warned the strike would lead to cancellations and delays in patient treatment, and spoke of a family member who was waiting for the 'inevitable' phone call informing them that their procedure would be postponed.
'We can mitigate against the impact of strikes, and we will, but what we cannot do is promise that there will be no consequence and no delay, no further suffering, because there are lots of people whose procedures are scheduled over that weekend period and in the period subsequently, where the NHS has to recover from the industrial action, who will see their operations and appointments delayed,' he said.
'I have a relative in that position. My family are currently dreading what I fear is an inevitable phone call saying that there is going to be a delay to this procedure. And I just think this is an unconscionable thing to do to the public, not least given the 28.9% pay rise.'
The BMA defended resident doctors' pay claim on Monday, saying they did not work through the Covid pandemic only to end up with a real-terms pay cut. 'We are still down compared to even the pandemic in 2020,' Emma Runswick, a resident doctor in Greater Manchester and deputy chair of the BMA council, told BBC Radio 4's Today programme.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
3 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Doctors regulator failing ‘abysmally' to protect Jewish patients, says Streeting
The doctors' regulator is 'failing abysmally to protect Jewish patients', Wes Streeting has said. The Health Secretary said he would be 'hauling in' the General Medical Council's (GMC) leaders to explain themselves, during a Government summit on anti-Semitism in the health sector on Tuesday. Mr Streeting said the regulator's chief executive and chairman would need to explain 'why they are failing so publicly and abysmally in their responsibility to protect Jewish staff and Jewish patients '. The summit was hosted by the All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on anti-Semitism and Lord Mann, the Government's independent adviser on Anti-Semitism. In a speech, first reported by Jewish News, Mr Streeting said there had been 'cases of medics who've said things that would make me feel uncomfortable [to be] treated by those medics and even unsafe being treated by the[m] and I am not Jewish.' 'There are cases that our country's medical regulator should be taking seriously, and they should be taking all steps necessary to keep patients safe and I do not see the evidence that this is the case.' He said the Board of Deputies' newly published Commission on Anti-Semitism, which was co-chaired by Lord Mann and Penny Mordaunt, the former defence secretary, had made for 'pretty sobering reading'. 'It concludes that anti-Semitism has crept into our country's civil society in a way that hasn't happened before, including our National Health Service,' he said, adding that he takes that finding 'with the utmost seriousness'. He said he just 'cannot understand how there have been so many high-profile cases where the GMC doesn't take action' and that it was a 'shameful and sorry state of affairs'. 'I'm frankly sick and tired as the person who has a responsibility to the public, as a democratically elected representative of the people, of being told by the people who are charged with regulating a life and death service, that it's all too complicated and all too difficult,' he said. There have been 454 complaints of antis-Semitism made to the GMC about 131 doctors, data released to Jewish News found. A number of doctors have been allowed to continue practising medicine or working for the NHS, either by the GMC or its independent tribunal, despite allegations of anti-Semitism, and in the face of attempted crackdowns by Mr Streeting and his predecessor, the former Tory health secretary, Victoria Atkins. The GMC cannot suspend or strike doctors off the register itself, but refers cases it believes warranting such action to an independent tribunal. Dr Wahid Shaida, who ran the Islamist extremist group Hizb ut-Tahrir until its ban last year, never lost his licence to practice, despite being revealed as the group's UK leader when it emerged that he celebrated the Oct 7 massacre by Hamas as a 'very welcome punch on the nose' to Israel. Dr Martin Whyte, a paediatrician who was removed as deputy chairman of the British Medical Association's junior doctors' committee in April 2023 after writing on social media 'Hahaha zeig heil hahaha gas the Jews', similarly faced no reprimand. A doctor who said Hammersmith would be better if it was 'Jew free' was found not to be racist but 'comfortable with discriminatory language' by the General Medical Council's independent tribunal. Dr Dimitrios Psaroudakis, a consultant gynaecologist, was only given a three month suspension after saying Hammersmith in London would be better if it was 'Jew free'. The Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service (MPTS) found he was not racist but 'comfortable with discriminatory language' This week, it has emerged that Dr Rehiana Ali, an NHS neurologist that described the former leader of Hamas as a 'legend' has had a temporary suspension from the medical register lifted by the MPTS, which is independent of the GMC and makes the final judgement. Dr Ali had previously said Israel's killing of Yahya Sinwar had turned the Oct 7 mastermind into a 'legend' and 'male role model'. In separate posts, the consultant neurologist also said the assassination of Hassan Nasrallah, the Hezbollah leader, had turned him into a 'legend' who was 'completely untouchable'.
Telegraph
3 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Why depression increases your risk of dementia and how to deal with it
For the past four decades, my family has grappled with a mystery – can midlife mental health problems actually precipitate the onset of dementia? Back in the early 1960s, my grandfather suffered the sudden, unexpected loss of his twin brother, a deeply traumatic event from which he never fully recovered. Of course, at that time bereavement counselling or therapy did not really exist, and by all accounts, it left a marked change on his personality. He began suffering from mood swings, unable to maintain friendships or working relationships. Having previously held a stable job as an architect for more than 20 years, he moved from company to company in a nomadic fashion before eventually being forced to take early retirement. A decade later, he was diagnosed in his mid 60s with Alzheimer's disease. While I was growing up, my own father described his belief that 'Dad essentially had a nervous breakdown' and would repeatedly wonder aloud as to whether such trauma and the subsequent mental health difficulties had instigated his cognitive decline. Now, according to a growing number of studies, there is a definite connection between midlife mental health disturbances and the development of dementia. In late May, researchers at the University of Nottingham published a paper which found that depressive episodes across the life course can increase dementia risk, while last year, the prestigious Lancet Commission, which publishes scientific reviews into public health issues, released a new report including depression as one of 14 modifiable risk factors which account for half of all dementia cases. When I relayed my family's story to Peter Garrard, a consultant neurologist and a professor at St George's University of London, he said that over the years he had seen many cases of people in their 70s and 80s now displaying symptoms of dementia, who had suffered a serious mental health deterioration at some point in midlife. 'A proportion of these people declare absolutely no past history whatsoever of any medical condition,' says Garrard. 'It may have been that they were ashamed of it, they wanted to hide it, and they never went to their doctor in the first place. But if the spouse is there, you can sometimes uncover this past history of five to 10 years of a really deep depression, what they would refer to as a mental or nervous breakdown, typically in their 30s or 40s. I've seen this dozens of times, and I think there must be something biological linking the two.' So how is depression related to dementia? It turns out that it's a complex picture and one that we're only just starting to understand. How depression increases dementia risk As a psychology researcher at the University of Liverpool, and a current research fellow for Alzheimer's Research UK, Amber John has carried out a number of projects in this area. One of her most interesting findings to date has been that the people more likely to develop dementia in later life tend to be those who have suffered from persistent mental health problems. In contrast, people who have experienced the odd isolated episode of depression are less at risk. 'It's more the chronic problems with depression that seem to be detrimental, especially if they aren't managed,' says John. There are several reasons why this might be the case. For example, John points out that people who are severely depressed are more likely to struggle to lead a healthy lifestyle in terms of being physically active, sleeping well and maintaining social networks, things which are all known to be generally protective for brain health. At the same time, the biology of chronic depression itself could also prove toxic to the brain in various ways, with research studies showing for example, that people who suffer from persistent depression tend to have higher levels of neuroinflammation, which can have a toxic effect on brain cells. Another idea relates to the stress hormone cortisol, which is chronically elevated in people with depression, something which John and others say is thought to be driving atrophy or shrinkage of the hippocampus, an area of the brain which is commonly linked with dementia. 'In the long term, high levels of cortisol have been linked to brain shrinkage and cognitive decline,' says Julia Dudley, the head of research at Alzheimer's Research UK. 'But researchers still aren't quite sure and there's more studies going on to look at what's happening, and at what point in our lives this most affects us.' Why depression or anxiety can sometimes be an early warning sign In over 65s with no previous history of mental health problems, the sudden onset of depression and anxiety may actually be an early sign that someone is already developing dementia. Garrard can recall various cases of patients in their 80s, later diagnosed with dementia, who initially presented at his clinic with depressive symptoms. Earlier this year, researchers found that the likelihood of someone experiencing depression steadily increased in the decade prior to a dementia diagnosis, and Jonathan Schott, a neurology professor at University College London, says that in clinics, neurologists now flag sudden-onset cases of anxiety and depression over the age of 65 as a potential warning sign that dementia is brewing. 'It's by no means certain,' he says. 'Clearly there are many reasons for becoming depressed or anxious in later life. But in some cases, it could be related to brain changes occurring in the run-up to dementia. There are two broad causes of dementia – disease of the blood vessels, and then the build-up of abnormal proteins which leads to changes in how brain cells communicate. Basically, the brain is beginning to fail, and one of the manifestations of that is these alterations in mood.' Because of this, John says that there is a need for better tests which can allow doctors to distinguish cases of late-life depression or anxiety which are solely mood disorders, from instances where it's a more sinister reflection of underlying brain damage. If someone is experiencing early symptoms of dementia, they could be potential targets for future clinical trials of disease-modifying drugs such as the Alzheimer's therapies lecanemab and donanemab, or other experimental medications. How to deal with midlife depression/anxiety With mounting evidence linking prolonged midlife mental health problems with later life cognitive decline, experts now feel that addressing these conditions early on might represent a new pathway for reducing dementia risk. So what can you do if you or a family member are concerned about your mental health and the potential long-term impact on your cognition? One possibility is antidepressant medication, although the evidence for this when it comes to dementia is currently mixed, and depends on the type of antidepressants. Some research in lab animals has suggested that SSRI drugs may reduce the build-up of the toxic amyloid protein in the brain, a key factor in the progression of Alzheimer's disease. However, another study funded by the Alzheimer's Society found that certain anticholinergic drugs – another class of antidepressants which work by blocking the actions of a particular brain chemical called acetylcholine – may worsen dementia risk, although we still need to learn more. 'It's unclear at the moment whether that's due to the changes in the brain that have already happened before the treatment or the treatment itself,' says Dudley. John is particularly interested in the potential benefits of midlife psychological therapies for reducing the risk of dementia in the long run. She points to one study she carried out using NHS data from across the country which found that improving symptoms of depression and anxiety in midlifers through psychological therapies seemed to be linked with lower rates of future dementia. 'It provides really encouraging early evidence to suggest that seeking help for mental health symptoms could potentially be a powerful step in terms of protecting our future cognitive health,' she says. It's impossible to know if modern psychotherapies, had they existed 50 years ago, would have helped my grandfather, and prevented him from ultimately developing Alzheimer's, but there's a chance that they may well have made a difference. Overall, Dudley says the message is that if anyone is worried they have had depression for a sustained period of time, it's never too late to take action. 'Some people still think that dementia is an inevitable consequence of ageing,' she says. 'But we're learning more and more that's not the case, and it's possible to intervene and reduce your risk.'
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Labour voters back doctors over five-day strike and think Wes Streeting should meet pay demands
Labour voters support junior doctors' plans to stage a five-day walkout next week, even as public support for the strike collapses, according to a new poll. Overall people oppose the industrial action due to start next Friday by a margin of 44 per cent to 34 per cent, pollsters More in Common found. However, Labour voters support the strikes, with 47 per cent in favour and 35 per cent against, in a major challenge to the stance taken by the health secretary Wes Streeting who has vociferously pressed doctors' leaders to ditch their plans. Green voters also back the strike with 49 per cent in support, while others oppose it. Some 69 per cent of Tory voters are against the walkouts, followed by Reform voters (63 per cent) and Lib Dem voters (55 per cent). Mr Streeting is set to hold last-ditch talks with doctors ' union leaders on Thursday in an effort to avoid the action, which he has warned could break the NHS. Resident doctors, previously known as junior doctors, in England are set to strike from 7am on 25 July as part of a pay dispute with the government. Professor Robert Winston, a Labour peer who became a household name through his documentaries on child development, has warned that the 'highly dangerous' industrial action risks harming the public's trust in the profession. But the new leader of the British Medical Association (BMA), whose members voted in favour of strike action, has said that the doctors' 29 per cent pay demand is 'non-negotiable' and warned strikes could go on for years if the dispute is not resolved. Mr Streeting has previously told the union that, after junior doctors received a 28.9 per cent pay rise last year when Labour entered government, the public would not understand why 'you would still walk out on strike, and neither do I'. The More in Common poll of more than 3,000 adults conducted between July 11 and 14, also found that many voters feel resident doctors are not paid enough, yet most think the pay rises in recent years have been fair. The survey found 38 per cent think junior doctors are paid too little, 34 per cent think the right amount, and only 10 per cent think they are paid too much. However, asked about the pay rises awarded over the past three years, overall 45 per cent said they have increased by the right amount, compared to 23 per cent who said they have not been generous enough. Some 19 per cent of people said they had been too generous. However, such is the level of concern about the health service, the public may accept a further increase in junior doctors' pay in order to prevent strikes. The majority of voters (58 per cent) of the public believes that preventing strikes later this month should be prioritised, even if it means spending more on doctors' pay. Luke Tryl, from More in Common, said: 'When it comes to the prospect of resident doctor strikes, it looks to be lose-lose for everyone involved. 'The public tend to oppose the strikes, though trickily for the government, Labour's own voters are far more supportive. 'Britons also tend to think the settlement the doctors have received is fair, and they risk ending up on the wrong side of a public who are themselves still struggling with the cost of living. But above all, the public don't want strikes to further disrupt the NHS and grow waiting lists.'
