Makabayan: COA, not DPWH, should audit flood control projects
House Deputy Minority Leader Representative Antonio Tinio of ACT Teachers party-list and House Assistant Minority Leader Renee Co of Kabataan party-list made the statement in the aftermath of Public Works chief Manuel Bonoan's comments that the DPWH does not have enough monitoring mechanisms for flood control projects included and approved by the lawmakers in the national budget.
'We welcome the call to probe and audit flood control projects following the massive flooding that hit Metro Manila and surrounding areas despite the billions allocated for flood mitigation. However, we strongly oppose any move to let the Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) conduct its own investigation,' Tinio said.
"COA has the technical expertise, independence, and constitutional mandate to conduct thorough audits. They exposed the PDAF (Priority Development Assistance Fund) scam, they questioned the confidential funds—they can certainly uncover the truth behind these flood control failures even by just basing from their previous audit reports," Tinio added.
Co, for her part, said the DPWH cannot probe itself as the chief implementor of these flood control projects given that the COA has flagged DPWH many times for its failure to implement infrastructure projects.
Co cited that based on the 2023 Annual Audit Report (AAR) on DPWH alone which is the latest available AAR, the DPWH was not able to efficiently implement P131 billion worth of locally funded projects due to inadequate planning, detailed engineering, supervision, and monitoring, resulting in delayed completion and non-implementation of various projects.
Likewise, the same COA report showed that the DPWH only completed 450 out of the 905 flood mitigation structures and drainage systems.
"Ang DPWH ay kasama sa problema, hindi bahagi ng solusyon. Paano nila i-audit ang sarili nilang kapalpakan? It would be a whitewash, pure and simple," Co, a lawyer, pointed out.
(DPWH is part of the problem, not the solution. How can they audit their own failings?)
'We call on the COA to conduct a comprehensive audit of all flood control projects, similar to their work on the pork barrel scam and Vice President Sara Duterte's confidential funds. COA has proven its independence and capability in exposing government anomalies,' Co added.
The prevailing inefficiency of DPWH, the lawmakers said, must end.
"The people deserve answers, and only an independent body like COA can provide them," We urge Congress to pass a resolution directing COA to conduct an immediate and comprehensive audit of all DPWH flood control projects from 2016 to the present,' they added.
GMA News Online has reached out to DPWH and the COA for comment. — BM, GMA Integrated News
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
GMA Network
5 hours ago
- GMA Network
Bonoan urged to take leave of absence amid probe on DPWH flood projects
Bacolod Lone District Representative Albee Benitez called on Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) Secretary Manuel Bonoan to take a leave of absence amid an investigation into "failed" flooding projects. "Out of delicadeza, and to help preserve the integrity of any inquiry, I respectfully urge the DPWH Secretary to take a leave of absence while the investigation is ongoing," Benitez said in a statement, according to a 24 Oras Weekend report by Nico Waje on Saturday. In response, Bonoan said he is ready to take on a leave of absence. 'Okay lang. If it is necessary, bakit hindi po? (It's okay. If it is necessary, why not?),' Bonoan said. Bonoan also responded to Manila Mayor Isko Moreno's comment that flood control projects should be turned over to local government units. 'If they have the resources, bakit hindi? I think talaga naman dapat tulong-tulong lang po ng local government, (Why not? I think local government units should also help),' he said. Probe Meanwhile, House Committee on Public Accounts Chairman Terry Ridon said they are already preparing a probe on the sloppy flood control projects. 'As soon as we organize po 'yung House Public Accounts Committee, magkakaroon na po ito ng pagdinig sa mga lahat ng infrastructure projects including flood control and drainage projects sa ating bansa,' Ridon said. (As soon as we organize the House Public Accounts Committee, it will hold hearings on all infrastructure projects including flood control and drainage projects in the country.) Ridon added they will immediately summon DPWH officials for investigation. During his fourth State of the Nation Address, President Ferdinand 'Bongbong' Marcos Jr. served notice to government personnel who steal public funds, such as those for flood control projects, that they will be dealt with under the law. 'Kitang-kita ko na maraming proyekto para sa flood control ay palpak at gumuho. At 'yung iba, guni-guni lang (I saw that many flood control projects were sloppy and have collapsed. Even some are just imaginary),' Marcos said. He tasked the DPWH to submit a list of all flood control projects in the last three years and publish it in order for the public to know who should be held accountable. —Jamil Santos/ VAL, GMA Integrated News
GMA Network
a day ago
- GMA Network
Palace asks public to keep eye on bicam over 2026 budget
Malacañang on Friday called on the public to be vigilant about the bicameral conference committee with regard to the 2026 national budget. At a press conference, Palace Press Officer Undersecretary Atty. Claire Castro said the committee still has yet provide specific details with regard to flood control projects, some of which may be anomalous. Castro said these projects are still under investigation. "Ngayon, hindi pa natin masasabi in details kung sino at kung anong proyekto ito, mas maganda po kasi kung mag-uulat kami ng verified. Mahirap po kasing magsabi at sabihin kong malamang itong lugar na ito, nakita ng Pangulo, sira ito at isipin niya na nagkaroon dito ng anomalya. So, bubuuin muna po ang karampatang pagiimbestiga rito, para po ang maiiulat namin sa bayan ay iyong verified facts," Castro said. (We can't say in detail what these projects are. It's better if we report with verified data. It's hard to mention a place, and then the President will see it and think that there has been an anomaly with the project. We will complete our investigation to report verified facts.) "Kaya po sa tulong po ng taumbayan, sa tulong po ninyong lahat, bantayan po natin itong gagawing bicam conference pagdating sa 2026 budget. At ayaw pong maulit ng Pangulo itong nangyaring ganyan," Castro added. (Through the help of the public, let's monitor the bicam conference for the 2026 budget. The President doesn't want this to happen again.) In his fourth State of the Nation Address, President Ferdinand "Bongbong" Marcos Jr. expressed dismay with government personnel who steal public funds, including those earmarked for flood control projects. Marcos said these officials would be dealt with under the law, noting that they should be ashamed of their actions. The President said a regional monitoring committee that will examine the projects to check on their progress, and if they exist at all. "We will publish this list so that the public can see it," Marcos said. "At the same time, there will be an audit and performance review of these projects to check and make sure and to know how your money was spent." The Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) earlier admitted that it has no monitoring system in place for some flood control projects, specifically those inserted by lawmakers into the national budget without undergoing technical vetting. DPWH Secretary Manuel "Manny" Bonoan said the agency is seeing some of the projects for the first time only after these appeared in the final version of the General Appropriations Act. Speaker Ferdinand Martin Romualdez has said the presence of watchdogs and other civil society observers will be allowed at the proposed national budget deliberations, from the committee and plenary level to the bicameral conference committee. Romualdez also vowed to strengthen the House of Representative's authority to investigate by conducting midyear performance reviews of agencies, and review of infrastructure projects. — VDV, GMA Integrated News
GMA Network
2 days ago
- GMA Network
Makabayan: COA, not DPWH, should audit flood control projects
The Commission on Audit (COA) should be the one to probe and audit the flood control projects, opposition lawmakers said Thursday. House Deputy Minority Leader Representative Antonio Tinio of ACT Teachers party-list and House Assistant Minority Leader Renee Co of Kabataan party-list made the statement in the aftermath of Public Works chief Manuel Bonoan's comments that the DPWH does not have enough monitoring mechanisms for flood control projects included and approved by the lawmakers in the national budget. 'We welcome the call to probe and audit flood control projects following the massive flooding that hit Metro Manila and surrounding areas despite the billions allocated for flood mitigation. However, we strongly oppose any move to let the Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) conduct its own investigation,' Tinio said. "COA has the technical expertise, independence, and constitutional mandate to conduct thorough audits. They exposed the PDAF (Priority Development Assistance Fund) scam, they questioned the confidential funds—they can certainly uncover the truth behind these flood control failures even by just basing from their previous audit reports," Tinio added. Co, for her part, said the DPWH cannot probe itself as the chief implementor of these flood control projects given that the COA has flagged DPWH many times for its failure to implement infrastructure projects. Co cited that based on the 2023 Annual Audit Report (AAR) on DPWH alone which is the latest available AAR, the DPWH was not able to efficiently implement P131 billion worth of locally funded projects due to inadequate planning, detailed engineering, supervision, and monitoring, resulting in delayed completion and non-implementation of various projects. Likewise, the same COA report showed that the DPWH only completed 450 out of the 905 flood mitigation structures and drainage systems. "Ang DPWH ay kasama sa problema, hindi bahagi ng solusyon. Paano nila i-audit ang sarili nilang kapalpakan? It would be a whitewash, pure and simple," Co, a lawyer, pointed out. (DPWH is part of the problem, not the solution. How can they audit their own failings?) 'We call on the COA to conduct a comprehensive audit of all flood control projects, similar to their work on the pork barrel scam and Vice President Sara Duterte's confidential funds. COA has proven its independence and capability in exposing government anomalies,' Co added. The prevailing inefficiency of DPWH, the lawmakers said, must end. "The people deserve answers, and only an independent body like COA can provide them," We urge Congress to pass a resolution directing COA to conduct an immediate and comprehensive audit of all DPWH flood control projects from 2016 to the present,' they added. GMA News Online has reached out to DPWH and the COA for comment. — BM, GMA Integrated News
